Comment Re: Alternatives (Score 1) 7
It's the other way around, re: having so many users: when you have a good, small community that has effective moderation, you can cover anything in depth. When you have a morass of uninformed opinions, ignorant nonsense, and off-topic jokes that are made just for karma, then your signal-to-noise ratio gets very, very low. This is why one big messageboard is a bad idea and many specialized ones is a good idea. This is just how the Web is supposed to work anyway: it's not supposed to be five websites made up of screenshots of the other four. As you point out, it is by having a relatively small group that has clear and consistent moderation that keeps an individual subreddit good. What would be best is if these were separate websites using their own domains and built on the best free/open code, but Reddit closed source the backend in 2013 in an act of hostility toward the open web. A decade later, they've made it even more hostile as they've also sought very stupid attempts to be TikTok and Clubhouse and NFTs and every other stupid trend in the past few years.