SCC deems Shura Council and Constituent Assembly unconstitutional
The Council will remain until parliamentary elections
Nouran El-Behairy June 2, 2013 3 Comments


The Supreme Constitutional Court has ruled that the Shura Council and Constituent Assembly unconstitutional.
(DNE File Photo/ Hassan Ibrahim)
The Shura Council and the Constituent Assembly were formed unconstitutionally according to a ruling of the Supreme Constitutional Court (SCC) on Sunday.
The SCC, headed by Judge Maher El-Beheiry, postponed the dissolution of the Shura Council until after elections for the House of Representatives.
The decision to postpone the dissolution was based upon article 230 of the new constitution, which states that the Shura Council is to remain in its current formation as acting legislature until a new House of Representatives is elected.
The verdict was based on the unconstitutionality of the election law for the independent members who form one third of the Shura Council.
The SCC also ruled unconstitutional the first article of law 79 for 2012, concerned with elections to the Constituent Assembly, the body responsible for drafting the new constitution.
The SCC earlier referred the case to the Commissioners Authority of the court, for a legal opinion from the advisory body. The authority recommended against ruling on the case because the new constitution safeguarded the Shura Council and gave it legislative powers.
The challenges to the Shura Council and the Constituent Assembly were referred to the SCC by the Supreme Administrative Court. The SCC found the People’s Assembly unconstitutional last June for the same reason related to the election of independent members.
The People’s Assembly was dissolved following the ruling.
Topics: Constituent Assembly constitutionConstitutional court House of Representatives​Independent Morsi parliament presidentrule ruling shura council Supremeunconstitutional
Nouran El-Behairy
News Reporter
MORE IN EGYPT
MORE IN NOURAN EL-BEHAIRY
Featured Video
Video| Egypt’s President Al-Sisi weighs in on freedom of expression, Islamic extremism
Editorial Pick
Egypt’s Sovereign Fund to decide on private sector bids for stakes at Safi, Wataniya before 2021-end
Nile for Peace Initiative calls for legally-binding deal on Ethiopia’s dam
Egypt’s infrastructure investments recorded EGP 1.7trn over 7 years: Planning Minister
Egypt’s Al-Sisi arrives in Djibouti on 1st presidential visit since 1977
Latest News
Egypt, EU agree on reviving peace negotiations in Middle East
Al-Sisi highlights Egypt’s historic relations with Dawoodi Bohra sect
Egypt, Malaysia discuss bilateral, international issues of common interest
OPINION
Opinion| Shaw Festival raises issue of silent racism in Canada
opinion| Havana Syndrome and the coming wars
Opinion| Historic decisions to empower women in Egypt
Opinion| Success comes from the ground up, empowering entrepreneurs is key to a better future
MORE OPINION
Receive our daily newsletter
Subscribe