DONATE
The Utterly Predictable And Completely Mindless Attacks On Hagel
DECEMBER 14, 2012|6:13 PM
DANIEL LARISON
Michael Rubin does his part to discredit critics of Hagel (via Robert Golan-Vilella):
I think his vision of foreign affairs and defense goes beyond naïve and actually is malign. . . . The man really does seem to be an isolationist.
This is remarkable in several ways. First, it shows that the hawks’ arsenal of epithets and insults is now so limited that they are reduced to the oldest, laziest, most baseless canards available: Hagel is an “isolationist,” Hagel is an anti-Semite, etc. It’s as if they’re not even really trying. Second, the hawkish reaction to Hagel is even more deranged than I thought it would be. Hagel is no more of an “isolationist” than Obama is, but then I suppose that’s the point. If one can’t stand someone as conventionally hawkish as Obama because he is not hawkish enough, Hagel would be even more infuriating. It’s impossible to portray Hagel as a would-be McGovernite, and the fact that he and Obama are frequently in agreement exposes how absurd most hawkish complaints against Obama are.
Hagel has not been a maximally hawkish supporter of Israel, but the smear against Hagel on this point is particularly loathsome and of course has absolutely no merit. If Hagel criticized Israel’s 2006 Lebanon war, that’s because the overkill and folly that war represented deserved to be criticized. If he believes that attacking Iran would have disastrous consequences and war ought to be avoided, that makes him unusually sane for a member of the political class. The fact that such a despicable smear is already being thrown around (albeit by an anonymous aide who won’t attach his name to the slur) reeks of desperation. The “isolationist” charge is much more amusing because Hagel has often warned against the dangers of so-called “isolationism” (and occasionally insulationism), and has been happy to fling that charge at others as all internationalists do from time to time. Being a thoroughly conventional and generally hawkish internationalist in his own right, Hagel has indulged in chasing away the non-existent bogeyman of “isolationism” almost as often as the people now attacking him. Hawks fling these charges so often at so many people that they have lost almost all of their power, and at the same time they serve to discredit the positions of the people lobbing the accusations.
We can hope that Hagel is now less inclined to support the use of force overseas than he was ten years ago, but that remains to be seen. I would like to think that Hagel truly has learned something from his previous mistakes, since it suggests that it is possible even for largely conventional Republican hawks to change. Even if that is the case, it won’t ever make him an “isolationist,” since there aren’t any real isolationists in America today. The label doesn’t even apply to advocates for a foreign policy of restraint and peace, but anyone so labeled by hawkish critics has to be getting something right.
P.S. Rubin went on to say:
Hagel’s non-interventionist views make him “like Ron Paul separated at birth.”
That would be welcome news for non-interventionists, but it’s completely absurd. Hagel has never been and will not be a non-interventionist. That’s simply the wrong way to describe Hagel’s views, as I suspect his enemies understand.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Daniel Larison is a senior editor at TAC, where he also keeps a solo blog. He has been published in the New York Times Book Review, Dallas Morning News, World Politics Review, Politico Magazine, Orthodox Life, Front Porch Republic, The American Scene, and Culture11, and was a columnist for The Week. He holds a PhD in history from the University of Chicago, and resides in Lancaster, PA. Follow him on Twitter.
email
LEAVE A COMMENT
LATEST ARTICLES
The ‘Cost-Effective’ Coup and Other Myths
Engineering the overthrow of a foreign government that poses absolutely no threat to the U.S. is the definition of gratuitous.
DANIEL LARISON MAY 13, 2020
No One Should Be Missing Kissinger
Our government usually listens to and employs the Kissingers to make our foreign policy, and it ignores and marginalizes the Kennans once they start saying inconvenient things.
DANIEL LARISON MAY 11, 2020
Trump’s Contemptible War Powers Veto
The president once again showed his contempt for the Constitution with his veto of another war powers resolution.
DANIEL LARISON MAY 7, 2020
McMaster and the Myths of Empire
McMaster uses the same "paper tiger image" to portray China as an unstoppable aggressor that can nonetheless be stopped at minimal risk.
DANIEL LARISON MAY 6, 2020
New START and the China Diversion
It is obvious that the administration has never been serious about extending New START.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 29, 2020
Pompeo’s Cynical Attack on the Nuclear Deal
It reeks of bad faith and contempt for international law, and all other governments will be able to see right through it.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 27, 2020
Trump Draws a Reckless ‘Red Line’ in the Sea
Once again, Trump is choosing escalation when he doesn't have to.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 22, 2020
Even a Pandemic Can’t Kill Threat Inflation
The U.S. is wasting its time and resources on operations that serve no purpose.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 20, 2020
Iran Is Not Ours to ‘Steer’
The U.S. does not know how to "steer" other countries, and we have no right to try.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 14, 2020
Regime Change Is Wrong
It is very unlikely that the U.S. can bring about regime change in Iran short of an invasion, but it would be a terrible idea even if it could.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 14, 2020
The Shakedown of South Korea Has Failed
The Trump administration's inflexible maximalism always leads to diplomatic failure.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 13, 2020
Crozier Should Be Reinstated
If you wanted a better example of outstanding leadership, you would be hard-pressed to find it.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 12, 2020
Blessed Is He That Cometh in the Name of the Lord
By raising Lazarus from the dead before Thy passion, Thou didst confirm the common resurrection, 0 Christ God! Wherefore,…
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 12, 2020
The Week’s Most Interesting Reads
Captain Crozier was right, and his sailors knew it. Andrew Bacevich responds to Crozier’s removal and the crew’s reaction.…
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 10, 2020
Contesting the Iranian Revolution: Understanding the Green Movement
This is an outstanding study of the uprisings of 2009 and 2010.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 9, 2020
Restraint and Reorienting U.S. National Security
We have been straining at gnats for at least half of my lifetime, and when the real danger appeared many of us were oblivious to it.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 8, 2020
The TR’s Cleanup Crews Need Protective Equipment Now
Getting protective equipment to the sailors remaining on the carrier ought to be a top priority for the Navy.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 8, 2020
The U.S. Is Wrong to Block Iran’s Loan
Opposition to the IMF loan is consistent with the administration's ghoulish opposition to sanctions relief.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 8, 2020
Modly Has Resigned
The Navy was being harmed by his poor leadership, and it will be much better off without him in this role.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 7, 2020
A Pandemic Is Not a War
The right response to a pandemic is to do all we can to protect the most vulnerable. Few things are less like war than this.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 7, 2020
After Crozier Comments, Navy Secretary Modly Must Resign
He has handled the removal of the captain as badly as he could have. Time to go.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 6, 2020
The Open Skies Treaty Is Worth Keeping
Abandoning the treaty doesn't serve any American interests, and the only people that want to abandon it are ideologues that have never seen a treaty they didn't want to kill.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 6, 2020
Crozier Was Punished for Doing His Duty
Crozier's willingness to risk his command for his crew demonstrated precisely why he is an excellent commander.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 5, 2020
The Week’s Most Interesting Reads
COVID-19 outbreak in Iran exposes the twisted aims of Iran hawks. Ryan Costello takes leading Iran hawks to task…
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 3, 2020
The Intense Backlash to Firing Crozier
Crozier's punishment sends a chilling message to other officers that they shouldn't rock the boat even when lives are on the line.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 2, 2020
Captain Crozier Has Been Relieved of Command
It is a disgrace that he is being penalized for speaking out on behalf of his crew.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 2, 2020
One War at a Time Is More Than Enough
If one goes looking for excuses to intervene all over the world, it will be difficult to avoid fighting multiple wars at once.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 2, 2020
Endless War Makes America Less Safe
This is the lament of every war supporter when confronted with evidence of failed wars: if only we were "trying to win," then victory would follow.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 1, 2020
Why the U.S. Should Scrap the Useless, Noxious Saudi Relationship
Now there are only costs and risks, and they continue to increase as the reckless Mohammed bin Salman consolidates his hold on power.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 1, 2020
‘The Letter Worked’: Carrier Crew to Be Quarantined on Guam
The captain deserves enormous credit for making sure that this happened, and he has saved the lives of many of his sailors.
DANIEL LARISON APRIL 1, 2020
Trump’s Baffling Lack of Urgency
Trump's frequent uses of the DPA show that he doesn't even believe his own absurd rhetoric.
DANIEL LARISON MARCH 31, 2020
Carrier Captain Pleads for the Lives of His Sailors
This is an extraordinary letter, and it is to the captain's credit that he is putting the welfare of his crew ahead of any other considerations.
DANIEL LARISON MARCH 31, 2020
Muzzling Doctors and Nurses Is Dangerous
Health care workers are being put at unacceptable risk, and in many cases their employers seem more concerned with avoiding bad press than they are with providing the protection that these workers need.
DANIEL LARISON MARCH 31, 2020
Failing the Pandemic Test
The "indispensable nation" that presumes to dictate the affairs of nations on the other side of the planet can't even take care of its own people in an emergency.
DANIEL LARISON MARCH 30, 2020
Saudi Arabia’s Dwindling Influence
The Saudi government under Mohammed bin Salman and his father has managed to burn its bridges with most members of Congress and many of its other erstwhile supporters in Washington.
DANIEL LARISON MARCH 30, 2020
The Sanctions Minefield
For the sake of preserving innocent life and for the sake of bringing the pandemic under control, the economic wars have to end.
DANIEL LARISON MARCH 30, 2020
A Failed Secretary of State
Diplomatic failure and sabre-rattling have been the hallmarks of Pompeo's time running the State Department, and he has responded to the pandemic by doing more of the same.
DANIEL LARISON MARCH 29, 2020
Escalation in Iraq Would Be Insane
The U.S. would be going to war in Iraq for the sake of keeping troops in Iraq indefinitely over the objections of the Iraqi government, which is one of the dumbest reasons for escalation imaginable.
DANIEL LARISON MARCH 29, 2020
The Week’s Most Interesting Reads
Collective punishment has always been Iran hawks’ stated goal. Eli Clifton reminds us that attacking the Iranian people has…
DANIEL LARISON MARCH 27, 2020
Farewell to Sanctions
Economic warfare isn't just an abhorrent and immoral policy, but right now it also represents a threat to global health and safety as well.
DANIEL LARISON MARCH 26, 2020
RECOMMENDED
FOREIGN AFFAIRS
POLITICS
Another Opinion Columnist Pushing War With Iran Who Doesn’t Actually Exist
The fake opinion columnists primarily targeted right-of-center outlets receptive to a hawkish line against Iran
PAUL BRIAN AND ARTHUR BLOOM SEPTEMBER 2, 2020
GET OUR NEW DIGITAL EDITION
Get a roundup of the most important and intriguing stories from around the world, delivered to your inbox every weekday.
SUBSCRIBE
1. Make a Donation
2. Join our Newsletter
Email Address

3. Subscribe to our Magazine
BLOGS
Rod Dreher
Daniel Larison
New Urbs
Prufrock
State of the Union
CATEGORIES
Politics
World
Culture
Arts & Letters
New Urbanism
Crony Capitalism
Realism & Restraint
HELP & INFO
Who We Are
FAQ
Comments Policy
Jobs/Internships
Masthead
Contact TAC
THE MAGAZINE
Subscribe
Customer Service
Change Address
Donate
Advertise
© 2021 The American Conservative
Advertising Guidelines
Privacy Policy
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. to find out more, read our Privacy Policy.
ACCEPT