Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-wq2xx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-17T20:48:29.875Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Army, Regime, And Society In Fatimid Egypt, 358–487/968–1094

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 January 2009

Yaacov Lev
Yaacov Lev
Affiliation:
Department Of Middle East History University Of Haifa
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Tensions between the regime and the army are a crucial component for the understanding of Fatimid history and, as will be shown, they had a mostly destabilizing impact on society and the economy. A host of factors shaped the relationship between the regime, the army, and society. Among these factors, the socio-military composition of the army was especially important. The composition of the army was partly an outcome of deliberate policies of the regime, partly a consequence of local conditions, and partly a reflection of wider Islamic practices. In the case of the Fatimids, the local conditions of Ifrīqiya (Tunisia) and Egypt and the military traditions of the deposed regimes of the Aghlabids and the Ikhshidids must be taken into consideration. Fatimid reliance on the Berbers of Kutāma was not much a matter of a choice; they were the first adherents of the Fatimids and had helped bring them to power in Ifrīqiya. However, from the earliest years of Fatimid rule the Aghlabid military traditions and local conditions were reflected in the composition of the Fatimid army and had an influence on Fatimid policies. Conditions in Egypt played a smaller role in shaping the Fatimid army. Certain elements of the defeated Egyptian army (the lkhshīdiyya and the Kāfūriyya) were incorporated into the Fatimid army while others were disbanded. The Fatimid drive into Palestine and Syria, whose ultimate goal was Baghdad, confronted the Fatimids with militarily superior armies built on the model of the Buyid-'Abbasid and the Byzantines.

Type
Articles
Information
International Journal of Middle East Studies , Volume 19 , Issue 3 , August 1987 , pp. 337 - 366
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1987

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

NOTES

Author's note: I Would like to thank my friend and colleague Dr. R. Talman of the Department of Arabic (University of Haifa) for his valuable suggestions and criticisum.

1 On Fatimid army see Beshir, B. J., “Fatimid Military Organization” Der Islam, 55 (1978), 37–56;CrossRefGoogle ScholarAssaad, S. I., The Reign of al-Hākim bi-.Amr Allah (386/996–411/1021): A Political Study (Beirut, 1974), pp. 44–49;Google ScholarLev, Y., “The Fatimid Army, A. H. 358–427/968–1036 C.E.: Military and Social Aspects,” Asian and African Studies, 14 (1980), 165–92.Google Scholar

2 al-Dīn, Idrīs 'Imād, 'Uyūn al-akhbār, Ghālib, M., ed. (Beirut, 1975), vol. V, p. 114;Google Scholar and al-Nu'mān, al-Qādī, Risālat iftitāh al-da'wa, al-Qādī, Wadād, ed. (Beirut, 1970), p. 257.Google Scholar

3 Lev, Y., “Fatimid Policy Towards Damascus (358/968–386/996)—Military, Political and Social Aspects,” Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam, 3 (1981–1982), 170;Google ScholarBacharach, J. L., “African Military Slaves in the Medieval Middle East: The Cases of Iraq (869–955) and Egypt (868–1171),” International Journal of Middle East Studies, 13 (1981), 477–78.Google Scholar

4 Khallikān, Ibn, Wafayāt al-a'yān, I. 'Abbās, , ed. (Beirut, 1968–1971), vol. IV, pp. 21–22;Google ScholarDhahabī, , Kitāb al-'ibar, Sayyid, F., ed. (Kuwait, 1960–1965), vol. II, pp. 287–88;Google Scholar'l-Fidā', Abū, Abulfedae annales Muslemici, Riskius, J. J., ed. (Hafniae, 1789–1794), vol. II, p. 472.Google Scholar Fātik al-Rūmī became widely known through panegyric and elegies written about him by Mutanabbi, see Winter, M., “Content and Form in the Elegies of al-Mutanabbī,” in Studia orientalia memoriae D. H. Baneth dedicata (Jerusalem, 1979), pp. 327–65, esp. pp. 328, 334–40.Google Scholar See also Issawi, C., “Al-Mutanabbī in Egypt (957–962),” in Hanna, S., ed., Medieval and Middle Eastern Studies in Honor of Aziz Suryal Atiya (Leiden, 1972), pp. 236–39.Google Scholar For the North Syrian frontier see: von Sivers, P., “Taxes and Trade in the 'Abbāsid Thughūr, 750–962,” Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient, 25 (1982), 71–99.Google Scholar

5 Al-Antākī, (Yahyā ibn Sa'īd), Tā'rīkh, Shaykhū, L., ed. (Beirut, 1909), p. 221.Google Scholar

6 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz al-hunafā', Ahmad, M. H. M., ed. (Cairo, 1971), vol. II, p. 56.Google Scholar

7 Musabbihī, , Akhbār Mişr, Sayyid, A. F. and Bianquis, Th., eds. (Cairo, 1978), p. 109.Google Scholar nother edition is by Millward, W. G. (Cairo, 1980). Hereafter all references are to Cairo, 1978 edition.Google Scholar

8 Ayalon, D., “On the Eunuchs in Islam,” Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam, 1 (1979), 92–124.Google Scholar

9 al-Dīn, 'lmād, 'Uyūn, p. 84;Google Scholaral-Nu'mān, Iftitāh, p. 207.Google Scholar

10 On him see: Sīrat al-Ustādh Jawdhar, al-Husayn, M. K. and Sha'īra, M. A. H., eds. (n.d., n.p.). The text was translated by Canard, M., Vie de l'ustādh Jaudhar (Algiers, 1958).Google Scholar

11 'lmād al-Dīn, 'Uyūn pp. 150, 151, 328;Google Scholar Ibn 'ldhārī, Amari, A., ed., in his Biblioteca AraboSicula, reprint (Baghdad, n.d.), pp. 366–67, 378;Google ScholarNuwayrī, , Amari, A., ed., Arabo-Sicula, p. 436;Google ScholarVasiliev, A. and Canard, M., Byzance et les Arabes (Bruxelles, 1950), vol. 11, pp. 223, 231.Google Scholar

12 On them see respectively 'lmād al-Dīn, 'Uyūn, pp. 171–72, 184, 186, 195–96, 242, 244–45, 263, 267.Google Scholar See also Sīrat al-Ustādh Jawdhar, 96, 147, 242, 244, 280.Google Scholar

13 al-Maghribī, lbn Sa'īd, al-Maghrib fī hulā al-Maghrib, Hasan, Z. M., Dayq, M. and Kāshif, I., eds. (Cairo, 1953), pp. 165, 184–85.Google Scholar

14 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz al-hunafā', al-Shayyāl, J. D., ed. (Cairo, 1967), vol. 1, p. 223.Google Scholar

15 For Saqliba in the service of the Fatimids see Hrbek, I., “Die Slawen im Dienste der Fatimiden,” Archiv Orientalny, 21 (1953), 543–81. He covers the North African and the Egyptian period until al-Mustansir's reign.Google Scholar

16 Maqrīzī, , Kitāb almawā'īz Wa- 'li'tibār bi-dhikr al-khitat Wa- 'l-athār, Wiet, G., ed., in Mémoires de l'lnstitut français d'archéologie orientale du Caire, 46 (1922), 44.Google Scholar

17 Maqrīzī, , Khiat (Bulaq, 1323), vol. III, p. 68.Google Scholar

18 Iyās, lbn, Badā'i' al-zuhūr fī waqā'i' al-duhūr (Bulaq, 1311–1312), vol. 1, p. 57;Google Scholar cf. however vol. 1, p. 48.

19 Martin, B. O., “Kanem, Bornu and Fazzān: Notes on the Political History of a Trade Route,” Journal of African History, 10 (1969), 15–27;CrossRefGoogle ScholarTrimingham, J. S., A History of Islam in West Africa (London, 1968), p. 107;Google ScholarCorpus of Early Arabic Sources for West African History, Hopkins, J. F. P., trans., Levtzion, N. and Hopkins, J. F. P., eds. (Cambridge, 1981), pp. 22, 41, 46.Google Scholar

20 Martin, , “Kanem,” p. 18.Google Scholar

21 Trimingham, A History, p. 107;Google ScholarCorpus, pp. 24, 42, 64. Ayalon, , “On Eunuchs,” p. 76, section Va.Google Scholar

22 Norris, H. T., The Berbers in Arabic Literature (London, 1982), pp. 8, 37, 76–77;Google ScholarDespois, J., “Fazzān,” El2, vol. II, p. 875.Google Scholar

23 Canard, M. considers them as blacks: see Vie, p. 104.Google Scholar In the text they are referred to as 'abid. Brett, M. remarks however: “'abīd at this period was a technical military term without color connotation” and gives the following examples: 'abīd al-saqāliba and 'abīd wa-ajnād (“lfrīqiya as a Market for Saharan Trade from the Tenth to the Twelfth Century AD.,” Journal of African History, 10 [1969], 354, n. 31).Google Scholar However, the term had a technical military meaning indicating black slave troops, usually infantry. (See Brett, M., “The Military Interest of the Battle of Haydaran,” in Parry, V. and Yapp, M. E., eds., War, Technology and Society in the Middle East [London, 1975], pp. 78–89.Google Scholar) Sometimes, as the first of Brett's examples show (the second does not support his claim), the meaning can be ascertained only from the context. Regarding Canard's translation, it must taken into consideration that in Fatimid sources (such as the Vie) the term has a well defined military meaning but also the meaning of “loyal servants.” The most striking example is Musabbihī's passage (p. 54) where both meanings appear in the same account.

24 al-Bekri, Abou Obeid, Dé;scription de l'Afrique seplentrionale, Slane, D., ed. (Algier, 1857, rep. Baghdad, n.d.), pp. 29–30.Google Scholar

25 Idris, H. R., Contribution à l'histoire de l'Ifrikiya, reprint of Revue des Études islamiques 1935–1936 (n.p., n.d.), pp. 169–70.Google Scholar

26 Al-Kindī, , The Governors and Judges of Egypt, Guest, R., ed. (Leiden-London, 1912), p. 276;Google Scholar Eutychius Patriarch of Alexandria (Sa'īd ibn al-Batrīq), Annales, Cheiko, L. et al. , eds. (Beirut, 1906–1909), vol. II, pp. 80–81.Google Scholar

27 'lmād al-Dīn, 'Uyūn, pp. 185, 210, 224.Google Scholar

28 Maqrīzī, , Ittic'āz, vol. II, p. 56.Google Scholar

29 Lev, , “The Fatimid Army,” p. 179.Google Scholar

30 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 137;Google ScholarMusabbihī, Akhbār, p. 21.Google Scholar

31 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. Il, p. 155;Google ScholarMusabbihī, Akhbār, pp. 54, 61.Google Scholar

32 Khusrau, Nāsir-i, Relation du voyage, Shefer, C., ed. (Paris, 1881), pp. 138, 145.Google Scholar

33 For the Aghlabids see Talbī, M., L'émirat aghiabide (Paris, 1966),Google Scholar index “'abīd,” esp. 136. For Tulunids and the lkhshidids see: Hasan, Z. M., Les Tūlūnides (Paris, 1933), pp. 165–73, esp. p. 167;Google ScholarHasan, Y. F., The Arabs and the Sudan (Edinburgh, 1967), pp. 44, 47;Google ScholarBacharach, , “African Military Slaves,” pp. 477–80;Google ScholarLev, , “Fatimid Policy Toward Damascus,” p. 170.Google Scholar

34 See the sources quoted in note 2. However, other al-sūdān mm mawālī Banī Aghlab were massacred following the fall of Raqqāda. See Hammād, lbn, Akhbār mulūk banī 'Ubayd Vonderheyden, M., ed. and trans. (Paris-Algier, 1927), p. 8.Google Scholar For opposite version see al-Nuc'maā, , Ifritāh, pp. 214–15.Google Scholar

35 'mād al-Dīn, , 'Uyūn pp. 114, 118, 128, 184, 194, 195, 202, 214, 233, 258, 276, 311.Google Scholar

36 Nuwayrī, , Nihāyat al-'arab fī funūn al-adāb, ms. Leiden, Leiden University Library, Or. 2k, f. 178A;Google Scholaral-Qalānisī, lbn, Dhayltā'rīkh Dimashq, Amedroz, H. F., ed. (Leyden, 1908), p. 50;Google Scholaral-Antākī, , Tā'rikh. p. 181.Google Scholar

37 al-Maghribī, Ibn Sa'īd, al-Nujūm al-zāhira fī hulā hadra al-Qāhira, Nasār, H., ed. (Cairo, 1969), p. 67;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. 11, p. 100.Google Scholar

38 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 121;Google ScholarSa'īd, Ibn, Nujūm, p. 58.Google Scholar

39 Nawayrī, Nihāyat, Or. 2k, ff. 184B–85B, esp. 185B; see also f. 183A; al-Antākī, , Tā'rīkh, pp. 225–26.Google Scholar On the activity of foreign da's see: Bryer, D., “The Origin of the Druze Religion,” Der Islam, 52 (1975), 66–76;Google Scholarvan Ess, J., Chiliastische Erwartungen und die Versuchung der Göttlichkeit. Der Kalif al-Hākim (386–411 H.) (Heidelberg, 1977), pp. 63–85.Google Scholar

40 al-Dawādāri, lbn, Kanz al-durar wa-jāmic al-ghurar, al-Munajjid, S. al-Dīn, ed. (Cairo, 1961), vol. VI, p. 298;Google ScholarSa'īd, lbn, Nujūm, p. 54.Google Scholar

41 Al-Antāki, , Tārīkh, pp. 195, 197.Google Scholar

42 Bianquis, T., “Une crise frumentaire dans l'Éypte Fatimide,” Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient, 23 (1980), 67–101.Google Scholar

43 Musabbihī, , Akhbār, p. 80.Google Scholar

44 Ibid., pp. 87–88; Nuwayrī, , Nihāyat, Or. 2k, f. 187A.Google Scholar

45 Musabbihī, , Akhbār, p. 57.Google Scholar

46 lbid., p. 82.

47 Ibid., pp. 20, 22, 50.

48 Ibid., p. 21.

49 Ibid., p. 74. See also; Shoshan, B., “Fatimid Grain Policy and the Post of the Muhtasib,” International Journal of Middle East Studies, 13 (1981), 181–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

50 Lev, , ‘Fatimid Army,’ p. 180.Google Scholar See in addition to sources given there (n. 60) also Maqrīzī, , Khitat (Bulaq), vol. III, pp. 20–21.Google Scholar

51 Maqrīzī, , Khitat (Bulaq), vol. III, pp. 21–22, 32–33.Google Scholar

52 Sibt ibn Jawzī, Mir'at al-zamān, ms. Oxford, Bodleian Library, Poc. 370, f. 144A;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 121, 127;Google ScholarSa'īd, Ibn, Nujūm, p. 67;Google Scholaral-Antākī, , Tā'rīkh, pp. 205, 217.Google Scholar

53 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. 11, pp. 107–8.Google Scholar

54 Ibid., p. 57; al-Antākī, , Tārīkh, pp. 208, 209;Google ScholarSa'īd, Ibn, Nujūm, pp. 58, 59, 61, 67;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Khitat, Wiet, ed., (see n. 16).Google Scholar

55 Khusrau, Nātir-i, Relation, p. 138.Google Scholar

56 Ibid., pp. 124, 138; al-AntAkī, , Tārīkh, pp. 247, 248.Google Scholar

57 lyās, lbn, Badāi', vol. 1, pp. 48, 57;Google Scholaral-Qalqashandī, , Subh al-a'shā (Cairo, 1913–1919), vol. III, p. 478;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Khitat (Bulaq), vol. III, pp. 30–31.Google Scholar

58 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. I, pp. 242–43.Google Scholar

59 al-Qalānisī, lbn, Dhayl, p. 31.Google Scholar

60 Khusrau, Nātir-i, Relation, p. 138.Google Scholar

61 Maqrīzī, , Iui'z, vol. II, p. 27.Google Scholar

62 Lev, , ‘Fatimid Army,” pp. 168–69.Google Scholar

63 Maqrīzī, , Itt'āz, vol. II, p. 177.Google Scholar

64 al-Qalānisī, lbn, Dhayl, p. 51;Google ScholarLev, , “Fatimid Army,” p. 174, n. 32.Google Scholar

65 al-Qalānisī, Ibn, Dhayl, pp. 45, 49, 51, 71.Google Scholar

66 Maqrīzī, , Iui'āz, vol. II, pp. 55, 150;Google ScholarMusabbihī, , Akhbār, p. 61.Google Scholar

67 Bosworth, C. E., ‘Military Organization under the Būyids of Persia and Iraq,” Oriens, 18–19 (1965–1966), 158–59.Google Scholar

68 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 9, 154;Google ScholarMusabbihī, , Akhbār, p. 51;Google ScholarTaghrībirdī, Ibn, A1-Nujūm al-zāhira fi mulūk Mitr Wa- 'l-Qāhira (Cairo, 1932–1950). vol. IV, p. 216.Google Scholar

69 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. 1, p. 260;Google Scholaral-Qalānisī, lbn, Dhayl, p. 31.Google Scholar

70 Maqrīzī, , lttt'ā, vol. II, p. 55.Google Scholar

71 Musabbihī, , Akhbār, p. 104.Google Scholar

72 Lev, Y., “The Fatimid vizier Ya'qūb ibn Killis and the Beginning of the Fatimid Administration Egypt,” Der Islam, 58 (1981), 242, 248.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

73 Maqrīzī, , Khitai (Bulaq), vol. II, 278;Google Scholar cf. Beshir, , “Fatimid Military Organization,” p. 47.Google Scholar See also Stern, S. M., Fatimid Decrees (London, 1964), pp. 17, 170.Google Scholar

74 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 55–56;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Khitat (Būlāq), vol. III, pp. 32–33.Google Scholar

75 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 9, 13;Google Scholaral-Qalānisī, Ibn, Dhayl, p. 49.Google Scholar

76 Al-Antgkī, , Tā'rīkh, pp. 222, 223;Google ScholarNuwayrī, Nihāyat, Or. 2k, ff. 184B–185A, says that shabāb min niuwalladī 'l-Atrāk were Hamza ibn 'Alt's followers.Google Scholar

77 Musabbihī, , Akhbāi, p. 36.Google Scholar

78 Maqrīzī, , Khitai (Bulaq), vol. II, p. 332.Google Scholar

79 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. I, p. 291;Google ScholarSa'īd, Ibn, Nujūm, p. 54.Google Scholar

80 al-Dawādāri, lbn, Kanz, vol. VI, 298;Google ScholarSa'īd, lbn, Nujūm, p. 54.Google Scholar

81 Musabbihī, , Akhbār, pp. 20, 43, 46, 53, 74, 92, 96;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 165.Google Scholar

82 Khusrau, Nāsir-i, Relation, p. 138.Google Scholar

83 Musabbihi, , Akhbār, p. 53;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Iui'āz, vol. II, p. 154.Google Scholar

84 Tyan, E., Institutions du droit public musulman (Paris, 1956), vol. II, p. 529.Google ScholarStern, , Fatimid Decrees, p. 128.Google Scholar

85 Maqrīzī, , Khitat (Bulaq), vol. III, pp. 17–18.Google Scholar

86 AlNu'mān, Al-Qādī, Kitāb al-majālis wa-'l-musāyarāt, al-Faqī, H., Mashabūh, I. and al-Ya'lāwī, M., eds. (Tunis, 1978), p. 246.Google Scholar

87 Al-Nu'mān, , lftitāh, pp. 257–58.Google Scholar

88 Al-Nu'mān, , Majālis, pp. 245, 322;Google Scholar'lmād al-Dīn, , 'Uyān, pp. 53, 65, 66, 70, 130, 194, 209, 223.Google Scholar

89 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. I, pp. 97–98.Google Scholar

90 Al-Nu'mān, , Majālis, pp. 321, 486.Google Scholar In al'Azīz's period the term was also applied to the Turks and blacks: awlīyā al-dawla mm al-Atrāk wa-'l-'abīd. See Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 12.Google Scholar Cf. Stern, Fatimid Decrees, pp. 16, 20, 21, 169.Google Scholar

91 Al-Nu'mān, , Majālis, pp. 239, 245, 321, 526.Google Scholar On the term sanā'i' see Sourdel, D., Le vizirat abbasside (Damascus, 1956–1960), vol. II, pp. 520, 651.Google ScholarForand, P. G., “The Relation of the Slave and the Client to the Master or Patron in Medieval Islam,” International Journal of Middle East Studies, 2 (1971), 63–64.Google Scholar On the institution of patronage (istinā) see Mottahedeh, R. P., Loyalty and Leadership in an Early Islamic Society (Princeton, 1980),Google Scholar index; Lev, “Fatimid Army,’ passim; Lassner, J., Shaping of 'Abbāsid Rule (Princeton, 1980),CrossRefGoogle Scholar index mawālī For earlier periods see Crone, P., Slaves on Horses (Cambridge, 1981),Google Scholar index “clientage,” “clients”; and Pipes, D., “Mawlas: Freed Slaves and Converts in Early Islam,” Slavery and Abolition, 1 (1980), 132–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

92 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. I, pp. 128, 130.Google Scholar

93 Lev, , “Fatimid Army,” pp. 169–73;Google Scholaridem, “Fatimid Policy Toward Damascus,” pp. 172–73.

94 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. I, p. 263;Google Scholar'Idhārī, Ibn, Kitāb al-bayān al-Mughrib, Cohn, G. S. and Lévi-Provençal, E. (Leiden, 1948), vol. I, pp. 241–43.Google Scholar

95 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. I, pp. 132, 133, 146, 229, 277;Google Scholaral-Qalānisī, lbn, Dhayl, p. 44.Google Scholar

96 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 12–13;Google Scholaral-Qalānisī, lbn, Dhayl, pp. 44–46;Google ScholarMuyassar, lbn, Akhbār Mitr, Massé, H., ed. (Cairo, 1919), P. 55.Google Scholar

97 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 12–13;Google ScholarSa'īd, lbn, Nujūm, pp. 54, 55.Google Scholar

98 Sa'īd, Ibn, Nujūm, p. 55;Google Scholaral-Qalānisī, Ibn, Dhayl, pp. 49–50, 54, 59;Google Scholaral-Dawādārī, lbn, Kanz, vol. VI, p. 257;Google Scholaral-Sayrafī, Ibn, al-lshāra man nāla al-wizāra, Mukhlis, 'Abd Allāh, ed. (Cairo, 1924–1925), pp. 86–87.Google Scholar

99 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, 47;Google ScholarTaghrībirdī, Ibn, Nujūm, vol. IV, p. 216.Google Scholar

100 Taghrībirdī, lbn, Nujūm, vol. IV, p. 216;Google Scholaral-Athīr, Ibn, al-Kāmilfī‘l-tā’rīkh, Tornberg, C. J., ed. (Leyden, 1863), vol. IX, p. 141.Google Scholar

101 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 115–17;Google ScholarTaghrībirdī, lbn, Nujūm, vol. IV, pp. 185–92, 194–95, 248;Google Scholar'idhārī, lbn, al-Bayān, vol. I, p. 271;Google Scholaral-Qalānisī, Ibn, Dhayl, pp. 79–80;Google Scholaral-Athīr, Ibn, Kāmil, vol. IX, pp. 222–23, 235;Google ScholarZāfir, Ibn, Kitāb akhbār al-duwal al-munqati'a, Ferré, A., ed. (Cairo, 1972), pp. 57–60.Google Scholar Cf. Tyan, , Institutions, vol. II, pp. 544–45;Google Scholar'lnān, M. 'Abd Allāh, A1-Hākim bi-Amr Allāh wa-asrār alda'wa al-Fātimiyya (Cairo, 1959), pp. 223–27.Google Scholar

102 Musabbihī, , Akhbār, pp. 60–61.Google Scholar

103 Ibid., p. 76.

104 Sourdel, D., ‘Al-Djardjarā'ī,” El2, vol. II, pp. 461–62;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 184–85;Google Scholar Nuwayrī, Nihāyat, Or. 2k, anno 427 and the beginning of anno 428; lbn Jawzī, Mir'at, Poc. 370, anno 427. For the political history of al-Mustansir's reign see Quatremére, M., “Mémoire historique sur Ia vie du Khalife fatimite Mostanser-Billah” in idem, Mémoires géographiques et historiques sur l'Égypte et sur quelques contrées voisines (Paris, 1811), vol. II, pp. 296–485;Google ScholarWustenfeld, F., Geschichte der Fatimiden-Chalifen nach dem arabischen Quellen (Göttingen, 1881; reprint, 1976), Part 3, pp. 245;Google ScholarLane-Pool, S., A History of Egypt in the Middle Ages (reprint, London, 1968), pp. 136–54;Google ScholarO'Leary, De Lacy, A Short History of the Fatimid Kha1fate (London, 1932), pp. 193–211;Google ScholarWiet, G., L'Égypte arabe de la conquéte arabe à la conquête ottomane, 642–1517 de l'ère chrétienne, vol. IV of Histoire de la nation égyptienne, Hanotaux, G., ed. (Paris, n.d.), pp. 219–54;Google ScholarGibb, H. A. R. and Kraus, P., “Al-Mustansir Bi'llāh,” El1, vol. III, pp. 768–71;Google ScholarHamdani, A., The Fatimids (Karachi, 1962), was not available to me.Google Scholar

105 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 190.Google Scholar

106 Ibid., p. 191; Muyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, pp. 1–2.Google Scholar On the Tustari brothers see Fischel, W. J., Jews in the Economic and Political Life of Medieval Islam (London, 1937), pp. 68–89;Google ScholarGil, M., The Tustaris, Family and Sect (Tel-Aviv, 1981) (in Hebrew).Google Scholar

107 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 191, 195;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 1.Google Scholar

108 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 195;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, pp. 1–2.Google Scholar

109 Musabbihī, , Akhbār, pp. 29–30;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 152;Google Scholar cf. Gil, , The Tustaris, p. 39, n. 52.Google Scholar See also al-Qalānisī, Ibn, Dhayl, p. 73.Google Scholar

110 Nuwayrī, , Nihāyat, Or. 2k, anno 439;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 195;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, pp. 1–2;Google Scholaral-Athīr, Ibn, Kāmil (Beirut, 1966), vol. X, p. 81;Google ScholarKhusrau, Nāsir-i, Relation, p. 159.Google Scholar

111 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 196.Google Scholar

112 al-Mulk, Nizām, The Book of Government, Darke, H., trans. (London, 1960), pp. 103–4;Google Scholar cf. Bosworth, C. E., The Ghaznavids: Their Empire in Afghanistan and Eastern Iran, 994–1040 (Edinburgh, 1963), pp. 98–99, 107–9.Google Scholar

113 Nu'mān, Al, Majālis, pp. 256–57, 258.Google Scholar

114 Maqrīzī, Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 214, 216, 223.Google Scholar Cf. Idris, H. R., La Berbérie orientate sous les Zirides (X–XlI siècles) (Paris, 1962), vol. I, pp. 181–203;Google ScholarBrett, M., “Fatimid Historiography: A Case Study—The Quarrel with the Zīrids, 1048–58,” in Morgan, D. O., ed., Medieval Historical Writing in the Christian and Islamic Worlds (London, 1982), pp. 47–59.Google Scholar

115 Taghrībirdī, Ibn, Nujūm, vol. V, p. 40;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 202.Google Scholar For the situation in Syria see Zakkār, S., The Emirate of Aleppo 1004–1096 (Beirut, 1971), pp. 134–38;Google Scholar and Salibi, K. S., Syria under Islam (New York, 1977), pp. 84–122.Google Scholar

116 Taghrībirdī, Ibn, Nujām, vol. V, pp. 11–20;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 232.Google Scholar

117 Zāfir, Ibn, Akhbar, p. 69;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 8;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itticāz, vol. II, p. 233.Google Scholar

118 Nuwayrī, , Nihāyat, Or. 2k, anno 443;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 8.Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itticāz, vol. II, pp. 218, 220, 224, 240;Google ScholarMqrīzī, , Khitat (Būlāq), vol. II, p. 170;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Ighāthat al-umma bi-kashf al-ghumma (n.p., n.d.), pp. 17, 19–20,Google Scholar translated into French by Wiet, G., “Le traité des famines de Maqrīzī,” Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient, 5 (1962), 18–24.Google Scholar For the economic crisis under al-Mustansir see Cohen, M., Jewish Self-Government in Medieval Egypt (Princeton, 1980), pp. 54–60.Google Scholar

119 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 227–29, 230–31;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Muqaffā,Google Scholar S. Zakkār, ed., in idem, Madkhal itā tā'rikh al-surūb al-talībiyya (Beirut, 1973), pp. 374–75.Google Scholar See also Felix, W., Byzanz und die islamische Welt im frühen II. Jarhundert (Vienna, 1981), pp. 119–23.Google Scholar

120 Taghrībirdī, Ibn, Nujūm, vol. V, p. 59;Google Scholaral-Dawādāzī, Ibn, Kanz, vol. VI, pp. 369, 371.Google Scholar

121 Maqrīzī, , Khitat (Bulaq), vol. II, p. 171;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itti'āzz, vol. II, pp. 236, 247, 251.Google Scholar

122 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 199–200.Google Scholar

123 Ibid., pp. 265–67; Muyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, pp. 13–14;Google ScholarZāfir, Ibn, Akhbār, pp. 73–74.Google Scholar

124 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 226–27.Google Scholar

125 Ibid., pp. 268–69, 270, 271, 272.

126 Ibid., p. 272.

127 Ibid., p. 273; Muyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, pp. 16–17.Google Scholar

128 Maqrīzī, Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 273;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 17;Google ScholarAthir, IbnKāmil (Beirut, 1966), vol. X, p. 81.Google Scholar

129 Bacharach, , “African Military Slaves,” pp. 471, 484–85, 490.Google Scholar

130 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 275;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 17;Google Scholaral-Athīr, Ibn, Kāmil (Beirut, 1966), vol. X, p. 83.Google Scholar

131 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 275–76;Google ScholarTaghrībirdī, Ibn, Nujūm, vol. V, p. 81;Google Scholaral-Qalānisī, Ibn, Dhayl, p. 95.Google Scholar

132 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 276;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbär, p. 18.Google Scholar

133 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 278.Google Scholar

134 Ibid., p. 279.

135 Ibid.; Muyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 19;Google Scholaral-Muqaffa', Sawīrus ibn, History of the Patriarchs of the Egyptian Church, 'Atiya, A. Z., al-Masīh, Y. 'Abd and Burmester, O. H. E. K., eds. and trans. (Cairo, 1959), vol. II, p. 182;Google ScholarTaghrībirdī, Ibn, Nujūm, vol. V, pp. 13–14;Google Scholaral-Athīr, Ibn, Kāmil (Beirut, 1966), vol. X, p. 84.Google Scholar

136 Maqrīzī, , Itti'az, vol. II, pp. 279, 280–300, esp. 296–98.Google Scholar

137 Ibid., pp. 299–300.

138 al-Muqaffa', Sawīrus ibn, History, p. 183;Google Scholaral-Athīr, Ibn, Kāmil (Beirut, 1966), vol. X, p. 85;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 20.Google Scholar

139 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 302;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Muqaffā, pp. 265–66, see also p. 281;Google ScholarTaghrībirdī, lbn, Nujūm, vol. V, pp. 13–14.Google Scholar

140 Maqrīzī, , Itt'āz, vol. II, pp. 305–7;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbar, p. 21;Google Scholaral-Athīr, Ibn, Kāmil (Beirut, 1966), vol. X, p. 85.Google Scholar

141 Maqrīzī, , Itticāz, vol. II, pp. 309–10;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 22;Google Scholaral-Athīr, Ibn, Kāmil (Beirut, 1966), vol. X, p. 85;Google ScholarTaghrībirdī, Ibn, Nujūm, vol. V, pp. 9, 21.Google Scholar

142 Maqrīzī, , Muqaffā, pp. 299, 301;Google Scholar and al-Muqaffa', Sawīrus ibn, History, pp. 218–19.Google Scholar

143 Maqrīzī, , Muqaffā, pp. 300, 301, 302, esp. 303–4.Google Scholar

144 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āāz, vol. II, pp. 311–16;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Khitat (Bulaq), vol. II, pp. 211–12;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, pp. 22–23;Google Scholaral-Sayrafī, Ibn, Ishāra, pp. 57–58;Google ScholarZāfir, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 76;Google Scholaral-Qalānisī, Ibn, Dhayl, p. 109;Google Scholar and al-Dawādārī, Ibn, Kanz, vol. VI, pp. 399–400.Google Scholar

145 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 317–18;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Muqaffa, pp. 267–68;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 25;Google Scholaral-Qalānisī, Ibn, Dhayl, pp. 109, 110–11;Google Scholar Sibt ibn Jawzī on the margin of al-Qalānisī, lbn, pp. 109–10;Google Scholaridem, Sevim, Ali, ed. (Ankara, 1968), PP. 182–83;Google Scholar and al-Muqaffa', Sawīrus ibn, History, pp. 218, 219.Google Scholar A laudatory Hebrew poem composed to celebrate the Fatimid victory describes Atsiz's army as made up of Armenians, Bedouins, Turks, Greeks, and European mercenaries is not supported by other sources (Greenstone, J., “The Turkoman Defeat at Cairo by Solomon ben Joseph Ha-Kohen,” American Journal of Semitic Languages and Literatures, 22 [1905–1906], 160, 164).Google Scholar Sibt ibn Jawzi's account saying that Atsiz's army was composed of Bedouins, Kurds, and Turkomen, i.e., elements to be found in Syria, is more reliable (Sibt, op. cit.), cf. Fraenkel, Y., “The Seljuks in Palestine, 1071–1098,” Cathedra, 21 (1981), 63–72 (in Hebrew).Google Scholar

146 Maqrīzī, , Itticüt, vol. II, pp. 13, 30, 65, 167, 170, 172.Google ScholarMusabbihī, , Akhbār, pp. 82–89;Google ScholarJawzī, Ibn, Mir'at, Poc. 370, anno 411;Google ScholarDhahabī, , Tā'rīkh al-Islām, ms. London, British Library, Or. 49, f. 8A;Google ScholarNuwayrī, , Nihāyat, Or. 2k, f. 177A.Google Scholar

147 Muyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 53.Google Scholar This applies to other groups as well; see Musabbihī, , Akhbār, p. 80;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 167.Google Scholar

148 Musabbihī, Akhbār, index; Stern, Fatimid Decrees, index.Google Scholar

149 Sourdel, , Le vizirat abbasside, vol. II, P. 661.Google Scholar

150 Dhahabī, Tā'rikh, Or. 49, f. 28;Google Scholaridem, on the margin of Ibn al-Qalanīsī, Dhayl, p. 64.

151 al-Sayrafī, Ibn, Ishāra, p. 180;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itli'āz, vol. II, p. 128, see also p. 93.Google Scholar

152 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 55.Google Scholar

153 Musabbihi, , Akhbār, p. 87;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itticāz, vol. II, pp. 167, 170;Google Scholar and al-Antākī, , T¯'rīkh, Pp. 247, 248.Google Scholar Cf. Lev, , “Fatimid Army”, p. 183.Google Scholar What is said there must be modified in light of the remarks of lbn al-Sayrafī and Maqrīzī (n. 151, above). The distinction between the military and the non-military function of the zimam is blurred in Lev, op. cit.

154 al-Qalānisī, Ibn, Dhayl, pp. 25, 28, 30, 40, 41, esp. 58, 61–64 and 73.Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Iiti'āz, vol. I, p. 256; vol. II, p. 8, 46, 76, 157;Google Scholar and Musabbihī, , Akhbār, p. 57.Google Scholar

155 al-Qalānisī, Ibn, Dhayl, pp. 46, 59.Google Scholar

156 Bosworth, C. E., “Recruitment, Muster and Review in Medieval Islamic Armies,” in Parry, and Yapp, , eds., War, PP. 59–78.Google ScholarIdem, “Isti'rād,'Ard” El 2, vol. IV, pp. 265–69.

157 Maqrīzī, , Itticāz, vol. I, p. 202.Google Scholar

158 Ibid., p. 279.

159 Ibid., vol. 11, p. 117.

160 Ibid., vol. I, pp. 279, 283.

161 Musabbihī, , Akhbār, pp. 60–61, 83.Google Scholar See also Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 117.Google Scholar

162 Musabbihī, , Akhbār, pp. 60–61;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itticāz, vol. II, pp. 158–59.Google Scholar

163 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. I, pp. 202, 239, 269; and vol. II, P. 63.Google Scholar

164 al-Qalanisī, Ibn, Dhayl, p. 56.Google Scholar

165 Maqrīzī, , Ittfāz, vol. II, p. 93.Google Scholar

166 Musabbihī, , Akhbār, p. 74.Google Scholar

167 Maqrīzī, , Itticāz vol. II, p. 90.Google Scholar

168 Maqrīzī, , Khitat (Bulaq), vol. II, p. 278; vol. III, p. 305.Google Scholar

169 Ibid., vol. 1, p. 152; Maqrīzī, , Itticā, vol. I, pp. 287–88;Google Scholaral-Qalānisī, Ibn, Dhayl, p. 44;Google Scholaral-Zubayr, Ibn, Kitāb al-dhakha'ir wa-'l-ruhaf, Allah, M. Hamid and al-Munajjid, S. al-Dīn, eds. (Kuwait, 1959), p. 232.Google Scholar

170 Musabbihī, , Akhbār, p. 86.Google Scholar

171 Maqrīzī, , Itticāz, vol. I, pp. 252, 278, 281, 282, 283, 290; vol. Il, p. 43, 134, 141, 177;Google ScholarMusabbihī, , Akhbār, p. 12;Google Scholaral-Zubayr, IbnK. al-dhakhā'ir, p. 75.Google Scholar

172 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, p. 177;Google Scholaral-Zubayr, Ibn, K. al-dhakh'ir;, pp. 69, 70–71.Google Scholar

173 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. I, PP. 135, 287–88;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Khitat (Bulaq), vol. I, p. 152.Google Scholar

174 Maqrīzī, , Khitat (Bulaq), vol. II, pp. 236, 268–69, 270–71.Google Scholar On the Dhū 'l-Faqār sword see Zaky, A. R., “Medieval Arab Arms,” in Elgood, R., ed., Islamic Arms and Armour (London, 1979), p. 202.Google Scholar

175 A million dinar were spent on the army in Syria (Lev, , “Fatimid Policy Toward Damascus,” p. 172).Google Scholar 400,000 dinar and 700,000 dirham were spent on the army prepared to be transferred to Syria (Maqrīzī, , Itticāz, vol. II, p. 9).Google Scholar For lower sums see Maqrīzī, , Itticāz, vol. I, pp. 245, 287.Google Scholar Only 5,000 dinar were given to a general dispatched to Syria (al-Qalānisī, Ibn, Dhayl, p. 73).Google Scholar Payments of tens of dinar to soldiers mustered for campaigns are mentioned in the sources; for example. 40 dinar to each horseman (Musabbihī, , Akhbār, p. 49;Google ScholarMaqrīzī, , Itticāz, vol. II, p. 52),Google Scholar but only 5–10 dinar on other occasions (Lev, , “Fatimid Army,” p. 189)Google Scholar and 24 or 50 dinar to each soldier on the eve of a battle (Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 62, 63). The data are too scanty to justify the effort of correlating it with prices, incomes, and monetary fluctuations.Google Scholar

176 Muyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 53;Google Scholar cf. Lev, “Fatimid Army,” pp. 177–78. My description of the arrangement between lbn 'Ammār and the Kutāma there must be modified. It should not be 80 dinar in 8 installments but 8 dinar. The payment of 20 dinar was not the first installment but an extraordinary bonus (fadl) (for references see n. 177).Google Scholar

177 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 125, 284–85.Google Scholar

178 Morimoto, K., The Fiscal Administration of Egypt in the Early Islamic Period (Kyoto, 1981), pp. 255–57, 260, 261–63.Google Scholar

179 Cahen, C., “L'évolution de l'iqta' du lXe au XllIe siècle,” Annales. Économies, Sociéiés, Civilisations, 8 (1953), 37–38Google Scholar;, see also 45–48. For the system of iqta' in late Fatimid period see idem, “L'administration financière de l'armée fatimide d'apres al-Makhzūmī,” Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient, 15 (1972), 163–82, reprinted in idem, Makhzūmiyyāt (Leiden, 1977).

180 Rabie, H., The Financial System of Egypt A.H. 564–741/A.D. 1169–1341 (London, 1972), pp. 26–27.Google Scholar

181 Lev, , “Fatimid Army,” pp. 184–88.Google Scholar

182 Sa'īd, Ibn, Nujūm, p. 68.Google Scholar

183 Dhahabī, , Tā'rākh, Or. 48, f. 23B;Google Scholaral-Sayrafī, Ibn, Ishāra, p. 48;Google ScholarTaghrībirdī, Ibn, Nujūm, vol. IV, p. 217.Google Scholar

184 al-Athīr, Ibn, Kīmil (Leiden, 1865), vol. IX, pp. 222, 225.Google Scholar

185 Sa'īd, Ibn, Nujūm, p. 68.Google Scholar

186 Al-Antākī, , Tā'rīkh, p. 204.Google Scholar

187 Maqrīzī, , Muqaffā, p. 300.Google Scholar

188 Ayalon, D., “Aspects of the MamlOk Phenomenon,” Der Islam, 53 (1976), 196–97;CrossRefGoogle ScholarCrone, , Slaves on Horses, pp. 74–81, esp. 78–80;Google Scholar and Pipes, D., Slave Soldiers and Islam (New Haven and London, 1981), pp. Xlll–XV, esp. XV.Google Scholar

189 Pipes, , Slave Soldiers, pp. 46–50, esp. 47.Google Scholar

190 al-Muqaffa', Sawīrus ibn, History, pp. 203–4;Google ScholarMorimoto, , The Fiscal Administration, pp. 252– 53;Google Scholar and Cohen, , Jewish Self-Government, pp. 58, 61–63.Google Scholar

191 Maqrīzī, , ltti'āz, vol. II, pp. 312, 314, 330;Google ScholarMuyassar, Ibn, Akhbār, pp. 23–24.Google Scholar

192 Maqrīzī, , Itti'āz, vol. II, pp. 280–81, 282, 296;Google ScholarZāfir, Ibn, Akhbār, p. 75 (cf. editor's note 374);Google ScholarTaghrībirdī, Ibn, Nujūm, vol. V, p. 17;Google Scholaral-Zubayr, Ibn, K. al-dhakhā'ir, pp. 251–52.Google Scholar Maqrīzī's description of the looting of al-Mustansir's treasures (in Khitar) is translated into German by Kahle, P., “Die Schätze der Fatimiden”, Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft, 89( 1935), 329–62, esp. 338–62.Google Scholar

193 Taghrībirdī, Ibn, Nujūm, vol. V, p. 16;Google ScholarZubayr, Ibn, K. al-dhahkā'ir, p. 257.Google Scholar

194 Gibb, H. A. R., “The Caliphate and the Arab States,” in Baldwin, M. W., ed., History of the Crusades (Philadelphia, 1955), vol. I, p. 95;Google ScholarCohen, , Jewish Self-Government, pp. 64–.Google Scholar

195 Gibb admits that the Fatimid weakness was the reason for the failure to assist al-Baāasīrī effectively (Gibb, “The Caliphate,” p. 91), but does not see its wider implications.