An embedded civilian journalist taking photographs of US soldiers in Pana
2003 invasion of Iraq
At the start of the war in March 2003, as many as 775 reporters and photographers were traveling as embedded journalists.
These reporters signed contracts with the military promising not to report information that could compromise unit position, future missions, classified weapons, and information they might find.[clarification needed]
Joint training for war correspondents started in November 2002 in advance of start of the war.
When asked why the military decided to embed journalists with the troops, Lt. Col. Rick Long of the U.S. Marine Corps replied, "Frankly, our job is to win the war. Part of that is information warfare
. So we are going to attempt to dominate the information environment."
The first journalist to run afoul of U.S. military rules in Iraq was freelancer Philip Smucker, travelling on assignment for the Christian Science Monitor
with the 1st Marine Division
. Smucker was not officially embedded, but all reporters in the theater of war were deemed subject to Pentagon oversight. On March 26, 2003, during an interview with CNN
, Smucker disclosed the location of a Marine unit, as he'd also done during an interview with NPR
. He was thereafter expelled.
Just four days later, Fox News Channel
correspondent Geraldo Rivera
similarly broadcast details from Iraq of the position and plans of U.S. troops. "Let me draw a few lines here for you," he said, making on-camera marks in the sand. "First, I want to make some emphasis here that these hash marks here, this is us. We own that territory. It's 40%, maybe even a little more than that." At another point, complained a CENTCOM
spokesman, Rivera "actually revealed the time of an attack prior to its occurrence." Although Rivera—like Philip Smucker—was not officially embedded, he was swiftly escorted back to Kuwait.
A week later, Rivera apologized. "I'm sorry that it happened," he said on Fox News Channel, "and I assure you that it was inadvertent. Nobody was hurt by what I said. No mission was compromised." However, a network review, he admitted, "showed that I did indeed break one of the rules related to embedment."
In December 2005 the U.S. Coalition Forces Land Component Command in Kuwait pulled the credentials of two embedded journalists on a two-week assignment for the Virginian-Pilot newspaper in Norfolk, Virginia, claiming they violated a prohibition against photographing damaged vehicles.
We were a propaganda arm of our governments. At the start the censors enforced that, but by the end we were our own censors. We were cheerleaders.
Embed critics objected that the level of military oversight was too strict and that embedded journalists would make reports that were too sympathetic to the American side of the war, leading to use of the alternate term "inbedded journalist" or "inbeds". "Those correspondents who drive around in tanks and armored personnel carriers," said journalist Gay Talese
in an interview, "who are spoon-fed what the military gives them and they become mascots for the military, these journalists. I wouldn't have journalists embedded if I had any power!... There are stories you can do that aren't done. I've said that many times."
On June 14, 2014, The New York Times
published an opinion piece critical of embedded journalism during both the U.S. military occupation of Iraq
and the war in Afghanistan
. It was written by PVT Chelsea Manning
, the former U.S. Army intelligence analyst known for leaking the largest set of classified documents in American history. At no point during her 2009–10 deployment in Iraq, Manning wrote, were there more than a dozen American journalists covering military operations—in a country of 31 million people and 117,000 U.S. troops. Manning charged that vetting of reporters by military public affairs officials was used "to screen out those judged likely to produce critical coverage," and that once embedded, journalists tended "to avoid controversial reporting that could raise red flags" out of fear having their access terminated. "A result," wrote Manning, "is that the American public's access to the facts is gutted, which leaves them with no way to evaluate the conduct of American officials." Manning noted, "This program of limiting press access was challenged in court in 2013 by a freelance reporter, Wayne Anderson, who claimed to have followed his agreement but to have been terminated after publishing adverse reports about the conflict in Afghanistan. The ruling on his case upheld the military's position that there was no constitutionally protected right to be an embedded journalist."
, a reporter for the Army Times,
said, "They’re [the journalists] relying more on the military to get them where they want to go, and as a result, the military is getting smarter about getting its own story told." But, she added, "I don't necessarily consider that a bad thing."
During both the Iraq War
and War in Afghanistan
, improvised explosive devices
(IEDs) were used extensively against U.S.-led Coalition forces, and accounted for the majority of Coalition casualties. Journalists travelling with ground forces were at the same risk.
On January 29, 2006, while embedded with the U.S. Army's 4th Infantry Division
, ABC's World News Tonight
co-anchor Bob Woodruff
and cameraman Doug Vogt
were, together with an Iraqi soldier, seriously injured when their convoy was ambushed near Taji, Iraq
, and an IED detonated beneath them. At the time of the attack, Woodruff and Vogt were exposed, standing in the back hatch of their Iraqi mechanized vehicle taping a video log of the patrol.
- ^ Cockburn, Patrick (23 November 2010). "Embedded journalism: A distorted view of war". The Independent. The Independent. Retrieved 3 September 2020.
- ^ "Reporters, commentators conduct an in-depth postmortem of Iraq war's media coverage". www.berkeley.edu.
- ^ "Pros and Cons of Embedded Journalism". Archived from the original on 2003-04-21.
- ^ "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 2009-09-02. Retrieved 2010-03-24.
- ^ Borger, Julian (1 November 2002). "Flabby journalists sent to boot camp" – via www.theguardian.com.
- ^ "Postmortem: Iraq war media coverage both dazzled and obscured". www.berkeley.edu.
- ^ ": Silha Center : University of Minnesota". www.silha.umn.edu.
- ^ Carr, David (1 April 2003). "A NATION AT WAR: COVERAGE; Pentagon Says Geraldo Rivera Will Be Removed From Iraq" – via www.nytimes.com.
- ^ "Geraldo: I Messed Up, But 'Nobody Was Hurt'".
- ^ "MRE Criticizes Expelling of Embeds Over Pix of Shot-Up Humvee – Editor & Publisher". www.editorandpublisher.com.
- ^ Knightley, Phillip. The First Casualty, 1975. p. 333
- ^ Farrell, Stephen. "Embedistan".
- ^ Myers, Steven Lee. "Embedistan: Embedding in Iraq During the Invasion and the Drawdown".
- ^ Interview with Gay Talese, David Shankbone, Wikinews, October 27, 2007.
- ^ Manning, Chelsea (14 June 2014). "Opinion - Chelsea Manning on the U.S. Military and Media Freedom" – via www.nytimes.com.
- ^ "Embed Cavallaro sees war from the inside". 6 April 2005. Archived from the original on 6 April 2005.
- ^ Boone, Jon (10 January 2010). "How journalists embedded in Afghanistan are too close for comfort" – via www.theguardian.com.
- ^ Refugees, United Nations High Commissioner for. "Refworld - UNESCO deplores recent killing, abduction of journalists in Afghanistan".
- ^ "Woodruff, Cameraman Seriously Injured in Iraq". ABC News. 4 February 2006.
Last edited on 24 March 2021, at 11:48
Content is available under CC BY-SA 3.0
unless otherwise noted.