Wednesday, 08 December 2021
Why banning financing for fossil fuel projects in Africa isn't a climate solution: AP report
AP , Thursday 21 Oct 2021
Video gamers in California consume more electricity than entire nations. The average Tanzanian used only one-sixth the electricity consumed by a typical American refrigerator in 2014.

File Photo: Nigeria port Harcourt worker on an oil platform. AFP
Globally, the top 10% of countries consume 20 times more energy than the bottom 10%. And 1.1 billion sub-Saharan Africans share the same amount of power generation capacity as Germany's 83 million people. At least half have no access to electricity at all.
Related
EU lawmakers back green conditions for COVID-19 cash, critics eye fossil fuel loopholes
Davos financiers pump $1.4tn into fossil fuels: Greenpeace
These stark energy inequalities are fueling thorny debates around financing Africa's energy future as world leaders and their negotiators prepare for COP26, the United Nations climate conference in Glasgow, Scotland, in November.
One increasingly common theme from wealthy countries  including those responsible for the majority of greenhouse gas emissions over time is a vow that they will cease public funding for all (or nearly all) fossil fuel projects in less developed countries, even as they continuefinancing, and in many cases heavilysubsidizing, fossil fuels in their own.
It is generally easier for countries that offer overseas development finance for energy projects to make low-carbon rules for others, rather than for themselves. For example, China, Japan and South Korea . some of the world's highest coal-consuming nations  have each recently pledged to stop funding coal projects overseas and increase investments in renewables. But they have made no equivalent commitments at home.
The US Treasury and the United Kingdom's development finance institution, CDC Group, have taken a more nuanced approach. They are limiting all coal and oil-based power generation projects and leaving a narrow window available for natural gas projects in poor countries that pass a rigorous screening process. This is roughly similar to the approach of the World Bank.
As experiencedclean energy policy researchers, we believe the blunt exclusion of all nonrenewable energy projects from development finance is an inequitable and ineffective climate strategy that gaslights over 1 billion Africans.
Tiny climate gains, major development losses
Focusing on limiting the emissions of the world's poorest countries while emissions continue to rise in industrialized countries is clearly misdirected in our view. Given stark inequalities in energy use and emissions, this could instead entrench poverty and widen inequality induced by worsening climate change, while simultaneously accomplishing very little to reduce global greenhouse gas emissions.
Together, the US, UK, European Union, Japan and Russia have almost the same population  1.1 billion people as sub-Saharan Africa, but 35 times more gas-fired power plants in operation or under development, and 52 times more coal plants.
When it comes to carbon dioxide emissions, sub-Saharan Africa is collectively responsible for barely half a percent of all global emissions over time, while the US, UK, EU, Japan and Russia are responsible for more than 100 times that amount, or about 57%.
The upper bound for Africa's future growth in power sector emissions is also negligible. If the region's electricity demand hypothetically tripled tomorrow, rather than doubling by 2040 as the International Energy Agency recently forecast, and if only natural gas was used to meet the new demand, annual global emissions would increase by only 0.62%, according to one estimate. That's equivalent to the state of Louisiana's annual emissions today.
What's more, the share of renewable power in many sub-Saharan African national grids is already higher than for nearly all the big greenhouse gas emitters. In at least six countries Kenya, Ethiopia, Malawi, Mali, Mozambique and Uganda  renewables make up more than 50% of their annual generation. In 2018, hydropower, geothermal, solar and wind made up about 20% of the continent's total power generated.
Most of the region will find renewable power to be the fastest and cheapest way to expand their generation capacity, but some areas may still need to rely on some fossil fuels in various sectors of the economy as they develop.
It has been clear for decades that the world needs to rapidly and aggressively cut its greenhouse gas emissions to keep global warming below 1.5 degrees Celsius and avoid the worst impacts of climate change. Many regions in Africa, including the Sahel and Mozambique, are already facing the effects of climate change, including worsening droughts, food insecurity and severe storms. Adapting to climate change and building resilience requires the very energy, economic development and infrastructure currently lacking in some of the most affected regions and those least prepared to adapt.
Climate colonialism and legacies of colonization
Other experts agree that this direction of climate policy is not just ineffective, it's rooted in the historic inequities of colonialism.
The philosopher Olúfmi O. Táíwò defines climate colonialism as the "deepening or expansion of foreign domination through climate initiatives that exploit poorer nations' resources or otherwise compromises their sovereignty."
Colonialism's legacy is a contributing factor to a wide range of issues, from conflict to corruption, and to the poor state of electricity access across much of Africa today.
While industrializing nations in the 1900s were building electricity grids through massive public spending campaigns, like Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal in the United States and the Electricity Supply Act of 1926 in the UK, most of Africa was being actively pilfered of its rich natural resources. Much of the infrastructure built in colonial Africa during that time was built only to facilitate resource extraction operations, such as mined commodities, oil, timber, rubber, tea, coffee and spices.
In 1992, a coalition of low-income nations successfully advocated for the UN's climate mitigation pathways to include their right to development, and a "common but differentiated responsibility" to address the dual problems of development and climate change. This language has long been the basis of equity considerations in climate policy, including in the 2015 Paris Agreement, which expects deeper emissions cuts from developed countries based on their "respective capabilities".
A transition from what?
Nigerian Vice President Yemi Osinbajo recently described "energy transition" as "a curious term" when applied universally, given the energy shortfalls in countries like Nigeria. He has argued for an energy transition in which Africa can develop quickly and grow. Increasing electricity in industrializing regions of sub-Saharan Africa would first power income-generating activities and public services, both drivers of economic growth.
Equitable and effective climate negotiations will require nuanced policy considerations that balance the priorities of alleviating energy poverty with urgent climate change mitigation and adaptation. A just energy transition would leave African governments to make and implement policies and deliver on their own national climate commitments under the Paris Agreement rather than shouldering the West's.
Search Keywords:
Africa
fossil fuel
climate solution
Short link:

 
Latest News
Real Madrid dispatch 10-man Inter to go through top of the group
Keeper El-Shennawi hails team spirit as Egypt draw with Algeria
Salah continues remarkable goal spree as Liverpool knock AC Milan out of Champions.....
PHOTO GALLERY : Check today's highlights of the UEFA Champions League games
Qatar sees budget outlay up 5% for World Cup
UEFA Champions League fixtures & results (6th round, group stage)
Match facts: AC Milan v Liverpool (UEFA Champions League)
Early eight
PHOTO GALLERY: North African rivals Egypt, Algeria deliver entertaining show.....
Iran nuclear deal required
Most Viewed
PHOTO GALLERY: North African rivals Egypt, Algeria deliver entertaining show.....
PHOTO GALLERY : Check today's highlights of the UEFA Champions League games
Egypt closes two ports, to suspend schools in Alexandria, Matrouh Wednesday.....
Qatar sees budget outlay up 5% for World Cup
Rangnick appoints sports psychologist to help Man Utd players
Omicron variant 'almost certainly' not more severe than Delta, Fauci.....
Economic crisis deepens in Lebanon
Fears for the Libyan elections
More adversity in Ethiopia
From Sanaa to Vienna
Also In Africa
Mozambique jihadists kidnap 600 women, girls since 2018: HRW
Ethiopia accuses US, allies of 'destructive' approach
Africa's COVID-19 fight is vital for world security: Leaders
Ethiopia govt claims recapture of towns on key road to capital
21 begin trial in Madagascar over alleged coup plot
Gambia incumbent leads in partial results, opposition cries foul
Ethiopia's war in uncertain phase after Abiy's advance
Protesters hit S.Africa beaches to oppose oil exploration
Egypt Business Opinion WorldArts & Culture Sports Life & StyleAntiquities Books AnalysisHeritage Multimedia​Al-Ahram Weekly About us
© 2020 All Rights Reserved Ahram Online.
HomeEgyptEgypt Home Politics Courts & LawForeign AffairsSocietyHealthUrban & TransportDefenceTourismBusinessBusiness Home EconomyMarkets & CompaniesEnergyTechOpinionWorldWorld Home RegionInternationalAfricaArts & CultureArts & Culture Home FilmMusicVisual ArtStage & StreetEntertainmentArt AlertSportsSports Home Egyptian FootballTalents AbroadWorldNational TeamsAfricaOmni sportsMultimediaLife & StyleLife & Style Home StyleHealthFoodCity LightsAntiquitiesAntiquities Home Ancient EgyptGreco-RomanCopticIslamicMuseumsBooksBooks Home ReviewsNewsAnalysisHeritageHeritage Home WalksFolk ArtsHeritage specialPhoto HeritageInspiring MindsMultimediaAl-Ahram WeeklyAl-Ahram Weekly Home EgyptEconomyWorldOpinionCultureLimelightHeritageFeaturesFocusLivingSufra DaymaEntre nousAutosTravelInterviewsSpecialArtCinemaExhibitionsLecturesTheaterMusic and danceSports