UNESCO removes Liverpool waterfront from world heritage list, UK government 'extremely disappointed' at the ruling
The government believes that 'Liverpool still deserves its world heritage status given the significant role the historic docks and the wider city have played throughout history', a spokeswoman said
AFP , Wednesday 21 Jul 2021

File Photo: buildings on Liverpool's waterfront, including the Liver Building, are pictured across the River Mersey taken on October 13, 2020. AFP
The UN's cultural agency UNESCO on Wednesday voted narrowly to remove Liverpool's waterfront from its list of world heritage sites, citing concerns about overdevelopment including plans for a new football stadium.
At committee talks chaired by China, 13 delegates voted in favour of the proposal and five against -- just one more than the two-thirds majority required to delete a site from the global list.
"It means that the site of Liverpool Maritime Mercantile City is deleted from the World Heritage List," Tian Xuejun, chairman of UNESCO's World Heritage Committee, declared.
It is only the third such removal, after previous decisions affecting Oman and Germany, and followed two days of committee discussions that exposed tensions about how cities around the world can preserve their past while also moving forward.
Liverpool City Region Mayor Steve Rotheram called it "a retrograde step" taken by officials "on the other side of the world".
"Places like Liverpool should not be faced with the binary choice between maintaining heritage status or regenerating left-behind communities -- and the wealth of jobs and opportunities that come with it," he said.
The UK government said it was "extremely disappointed" in the decision.
The government believes that "Liverpool still deserves its world heritage status given the significant role the historic docks and the wider city have played throughout history", a spokeswoman said.
But UNESCO delegates heard that the redevelopment plans, including high-rise buildings, would "irreversibly damage" the heritage of the port in northwest England.
The International Council on Monuments and Sites, which advises UNESCO on the heritage list, said the UK government had been "repeatedly requested" to come up with stronger assurances about the city's future.
The planned new stadium for Everton football club was approved by the government without any public enquiry, and "is the most recent example of a major project that is completely contrary" to UNESCO goals, it said.
From Shipping To Music 
Several countries had backed the UK, agreeing it would be a "radical" step in the midst of the coronavirus pandemic, and urging more time for a new city council elected in May.
A corruption scandal linked to regeneration funding had engulfed the old city leadership, prompting the national government to step in temporarily before the May local elections.
Those who argued against delisting Liverpool included Australia, whose own listing for the Great Barrier Reef is threatened in this year's UNESCO deliberations.
Norway in contrast said that while it was "painfully aware" of conflicts between development and heritage conservation, a "delicate balance" was possible, which was lacking in Liverpool.
The prestigious World Heritage label can be a boon for tourism, while encouraging governments to protect cultural or environmental treasures.
But addition is not permanent, and sites can also be stripped of their status or be warned they are at risk.
The waterfront and docks of Liverpool were listed by UNESCO in 2004, after an ambitious regeneration following decades of decline in one of the cradles of Britain's Industrial Revolution.
The city also saw the departure of millions of Irish and British emigrants -- as well as African slaves -- to the United States and elsewhere, a history that forged what UNESCO deemed Liverpool's "distinctive character and unique spirit".
But since 2012 the agency has locked horns with UK officials over development that has seen extensive restorations but also new construction that UNESCO inspectors say is overwhelming the district.
It had urged the city to limit building heights and reconsider the proposed new stadium for Everton at a derelict dock site, warning of "significant loss to its authenticity and integrity".
The waterfront is also the site of a statue honouring the four members of The Beatles, the most famous cultural export from a city rich in musical history.
Search Keywords:
World Heritage-
Short link:
China denies politics behind UNESCO move on Barrier Reef
Sisi says Egypt keen on developing relations with UNESCO
UNESCO chief arrives in Cairo to attend parade of royal mummies
Egyptian handmade weaving enlisted in UNESCO
Upper Egypt's handmade weaving enters UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage list
18:09 Spain La Liga fixtures & results (5th matchday)
18:01 Lewandowski scores again as Bayern Munich rout Bochum 7-0
17:55 Egyptian players abroad: Salah nets 4th Premier League goal as Liverpool win.....
17:52 English Premier League fixtures & results (5th matchday)
17:51 Match facts: Liverpool v Crystal Palace (English Premier League)
17:50 Taliban replace ministry for women with one restricting them
17:43 France recalls ambassadors to Australia, US in escalating row
17:25 UN Council urges restraint, dialogue in Somalia's leadership feud
17:25 Germany Bundesliga fixtures & results (5th matchday)
17:12 Lebanon seizes dangerous fertiliser in country's east
17:04 Italy Serie A fixtures & results (4th matchday)
17:01 Afghan survivors of US drone strike: Sorry 'is not enough'
16:42 Greece inaugurates its first 'closed' camp for asylum seekers
16:41 Toney shines in Brentford's 2-0 win at Wolves in EPL
15:09 France's Notre Dame cathedral secured at last. Next: Rebuild
15:06 Algeria: Big, volatile and oil dependent
14:57 Russia claims foreign interference in parliamentary vote
13:42 In the footsteps of Hathor: She Arts festival promotes artistic spirit of women
13:16 'What a player, what a professional, what a person': Liverpool boss Klopp about.....
12:58 Yemen rebels say nine executed over political leader's killing
11:09 Bombs kill at least 3 in eastern Afghanistan
10:20 UN concerned about detained migrants vanishing in Libya
10:04 Brazilian great Pele in semi-intensive care, says daughter
09:42 Egypt reports 588 new coronavirus cases, 14 deaths on Friday
20:28 AC Milan files complaint over racist chants from Lazio fans
18:43 Death of IS Sahel leader won't end jihadist group: French general
18:43 Apple, Google remove opposition app as Russian voting begins
17:59 Milley: Calls to China were ‘perfectly’ within scope of job
17:58 Biden, other leaders meet to push for more action on climate
17:33 Man Utd on 'right track' despite financial hit from virus
Readers Picks
Most Viewed
1. UK removes Egypt from red list of travel
2. Libya's PM Dbeibah praises projects in Egypt’s New Administrative Capital
3. English Premier League fixtures & results (5th matchday)
4. Spain La Liga fixtures & results (5th matchday)
5. Match facts: Liverpool v Crystal Palace (English Premier League)
6. Egyptian players abroad: Salah nets 4th Premier League goal as Liverpool win
7. Algeria's ex-president Abdelaziz Bouteflika dies aged 84
8. Italy Serie A fixtures & results (4th matchday)
Ahram online
© 2010 Ahram Online.
Find us on Google+Find us on facebookFind us on twitter
HomeEgyptBusinessOpinionWorldArts & CultureTokyo 2020SportsLife & StyleHeritageBooksAnalysisFolkMultimedia