SECTION OPINION
OPINION
The 'Cold War' diplomacy behind Covid-19 vaccines
Our current system relies on transparency, collaboration, and credible institutions. A rewrite of these global health norms to match the Chinese and Russian governance models would have long-term consequences for Europe and the world (Photo: Wikimedia)
By ALLISON CARRAGHER
ZAGREB, 11. MAR, 07:02
The race is on to vaccinate Europeans, and it's a competition between East vs West. There's a reason the contest has been termed "a new Cold War". It just might not be the reason you think.
Most commentaries on the rivalry between vaccine-producing countries focus on influence and soft power.
The main goal of countries procuring vaccines is to save lives. But in a realpolitik world, relationships with source or donor countries also sustain alliances—which can be leveraged for other diplomatic priorities. This is the theory behind "vaccine diplomacy."
However, diplomatic leverage is only part of the story. Vaccine diplomacy is also about validating the underlying principles of those vaccine programs.
In other words, Russia and China aren't just selling vaccines—they're peddling a value set that undermines international norms. It is this ideological clash that makes the Cold War metaphor more apt than pundits realise.
The first principle endangered by the Russian and Chinese vaccination programs is transparency. In the case of Covid-19, this means openly sharing data within the medical community.
In contrast, Chinese state-run vaccine producers have failed to publish late-stage clinical trial data, and not a single one has allowed a scientific peer review of its vaccine.
Western leaders like Emmanuel Macron have criticised this lack of transparency, as have experts within China.
Leading Chinese drug researcher Ding Shen recently called for Chinese pharmaceutical companies to release original clinical trial data to allow experts to accurately assess the drugs' efficiency—and safety.
Transparency concerns are only one reason why worries remain about the safety of these vaccines.
China and Russia widely deployed homegrown vaccines before completing clinical trials, as researchers ran roughshod over established scientific protocols and ignored a WHO recommendation that all vaccines undergo full testing before distribution.
Russia registered the Sputnik V vaccine for public use after it was tested on just 76 individuals. At the time, some 40 scientists signed an open letter noting irregularities in even this small data set.
Gamble
Sputnik V has since been confirmed safe and 91.6 effective, according to a peer-reviewed paper published in British medical journal The Lancet in February.
However, about a dozen countries gambled with their citizens' lives by approving Sputnik V well before that paper's publication, including Serbia and Hungary.
Safety concerns also raise questions about the role (and credibility) of regulators.
Drug safety agencies like the European Medicines Agency are designed as bastions of public health. When member states bypass the EMA approval process, as Hungary did when it became the first EU country to approve both the Sputnik V and China's Sinopharm vaccines for emergency use, they undermine the existing health system.
And if they get it wrong, it can have devastating consequences on public health and trust, including fuelling the already potent anti-vaxxer movement.
While criticism that the EU's collective approach to vaccine procurement has been slow is justified, there can be no analogous critique of the EMA dragging its feet to approve non-Western vaccines.
No Chinese or Russian developer has yet sought EMA sign-off (though the EMA is beginning to review data on Sputnik V should an application be filed).
Nor should drug regulators in Western countries outsource the approval process to vaccine-producing countries.
This is precisely the case in Hungary, where a government decree permits emergency approval of any vaccine administered to at least one million people worldwide - without review by the EMA or even the domestic regulator.
However, millions of doses of both the Sinopharm and Sinovac shots were administered in China before the jabs received Chinese regulatory approval.
The credibility of China's regulator is further undermined by incidents like manufacturer Sinovac's bribing of Chinese authorities for vaccine approvals, and a 2018 scandal in which defective vaccines for childhood ailments were administered to hundreds of thousands of babies.
To the individual observer, debates about vaccine diplomacy may seem out of touch. Communities decimated by Covid-19 rationally prioritise the swiftest possible delivery of lifesaving jabs.
Czech president Miloš Zeman said "vaccines have no ideology." This is simply not true.
Selecting a vaccine equates to endorsing – and therefore perpetuating – the underlying values of vaccine programs. As such, choosing a Chinese or Russian vaccine directly undermines the international system constructed to protect global health.
Our current system relies on transparency, collaboration, and credible institutions. A rewrite of these global health norms to match the Chinese and Russian governance models would have long-term consequences for Europe and the world.
Delays based on production capacity or unfulfilled contracts must be righted.
The EU should deliver on its commitments to help vaccinate the citizens of the Western Balkans and to the COVAX scheme. But at the same time, a timeline that allows for the transparent, complete testing of vaccines for effectiveness and safety and full approval by regulators ought to be embraced.
AUTHOR BIO
Allison Carragher is a visiting scholar with the Carnegie Europe focussing on the Western Balkans.
DISCLAIMER
The views expressed in this opinion piece are the author's, not those of EUobserver.
SHARE ARTICLE
Twitter Facebook LinkedInReddit Mail
SITE SECTION
Opinion
RELATED STORIES
EU Commission casts doubt on Russian Sputnik vaccine
China and Russia abusing corona for geopolitics, Lithuania says
Hungary breaks with EU on Russia, China vaccines
Von der Leyen on vaccines: 'We're tired of being the scapegoat'
EU-UK vaccine 'nationalism' spat intensifies
Brussels silent on vaccinating undocumented migrants
EU Commission casts doubt on Russian Sputnik vaccine
China and Russia abusing corona for geopolitics, Lithuania says
ANALYSIS
Von der Leyen on vaccines: 'We're tired of being the scapegoat'
EU-UK vaccine 'nationalism' spat intensifies
Brussels silent on vaccinating undocumented migrants
NEWS IN BRIEF
TODAY, 07:13
Gay-rights activist storms pitch at Hungary's Euro game
TODAY, 07:13
UK defies Russian military over Crimea
TODAY, 07:08
Delta variant to be 'predominant in EU by end-August'
TODAY, 07:08
EU domestic banks need climate-risk plans
TODAY, 07:08
Report: France and Germany want EU-Russia summit
TODAY, 07:07
New EU rules on shipping fuels dubbed 'disastrous'
TODAY, 07:07
Japan government proposes four-day working week
TODAY, 07:07
US: Nord Stream 2 undermines Ukraine's security
Next week is time for EU to finally lead on rule of law
18. JUN, 07:09
The EU Commission still has to prove they are ready to stand up for the rights of every citizen in the EU. Throwing the towel in would send a terrible signal to European leaders tempted to emulate Hungary and Poland.
Why the EU renewables target needs to be (a lot) higher
17. JUN, 07:02
The revamped Renewable Energy Directive next month should set an EU binding renewable energy target of at least 50% by 2030, paving the way towards transition to a 100 percent renewable-energy based system by 2040.
STAKEHOLDERS' HIGHLIGHTS
NORDIC COUNCIL OF MINISTERS
Nineteen demands by Nordic young people to save biodiversity
NORDIC COUNCIL OF MINISTERS
Sustainable public procurement is an effective way to achieve global goals
NORDIC COUNCIL OF MINISTERS
Nordic Council enters into formal relations with European Parliament
NORDIC COUNCIL OF MINISTERS
Women more active in violent extremist circles than first assumed
NORDIC COUNCIL OF MINISTERS
Digitalisation can help us pick up the green pace
NORDIC COUNCIL OF MINISTERS
COVID19 is a wake-up call in the fight against antibiotic resistance
LATEST NEWS
TODAY, 07:18
EU talks migration over dinner, as NGO rescue-ship sets sail
TODAY, 07:12
EU enlargement still 'hopelessly stuck'
TODAY, 07:07
EU creates new cyber unit, after wave of online attacks
TODAY, 07:07
How NOT to frame debate about Hungary's toxic anti-gay law
TODAY, 07:06
What a post-Netanyahu Israel means for EU
23. JUN, 16:35
EU Commission warns Hungary over anti-LGBTIQ measures
23. JUN, 07:16
Fourteen EU countries condemn Hungary over anti-LGBTIQ law
23. JUN, 07:09
EU preparing to lift Burundi sanctions, despite warning
STAKEHOLDERS' HIGHLIGHTS
NORDIC COUNCIL OF MINISTERS
The Nordic Region can and should play a leading role in Europe’s digital development
NORDIC COUNCIL OF MINISTERS
Nordic Council to host EU webinars on energy, digitalisation and antibiotic resistance
UNESDA
EU Code of Conduct can showcase PPPs delivering healthier more sustainable society
NORDIC COUNCIL OF MINISTERS
Women benefit in the digitalised labour market
Support quality EU news
JOIN US