home subscribe about JTA contact support us resources
 Istanbul Jews bury dead
 U.S., Israel seek to help Qurei
 Turkish Jews: We’ll carry on
 Germany drops claim in restitution case
 France to get tough on anti-Semitism
 Muslim fundamentalist hero of anti-global crowd
 Iowa Jews: few but strong
 Santorum’s relations with the Jews
 Candidates vie for Iowa Jewish votes
 G.A. grapples with competing needs
 Tisch, former CBS and UJA chief, remembered
 G.A. delegates show solidarity
 Omar Sharif´s new film
 Nazi play stirs passions
 Portuguese vintners say l’chaim
  Jews wonder about Mahathir fallout
JFN
At the Nov. 5 conference held by the Jewish Funders Network, George Soros (second from left) poses with, from left, Mark Charendoff, Michael Steinhardt, Cheri Fox and David Friedman.
In rare Jewish appearance, George Soros
says Jews and Israel cause anti-Semitism
By Uriel Heilman
NEW YORK, Nov. 9 (JTA) — Itīs not often that George Soros, the billionaire financier and philanthropist, makes an appearance before a Jewish audience.

Itīs even rarer for him to use such an occasion to talk about Israel, Jews and his own role in effecting political change.

So when Soros stepped to the podium Nov. 5 to address those issues at a conference of the Jewish Funders Network, audience members were listening carefully.

Many were surprised by what they heard.

When asked about anti-Semitism in Europe, Soros, who is Jewish, said European anti-Semitism is the result of the policies of Israel and the United States.

"There is a resurgence of anti-Semitism in Europe. The policies of the Bush administration and the Sharon administration contribute to that," Soros said. "Itīs not specifically anti-Semitism, but it does manifest itself in anti- Semitism as well. Iīm critical of those policies."

"If we change that direction, then anti-Semitism also will diminish," he said. "I canīt see how one could confront it directly."

That is a point made by Israelīs most vociferous critics, whom some Jewish activists charge with using anti-Zionism as a guise for anti-Semitism.

The billionaire financier said he, too, bears some responsibility for the new anti-Semitism, citing last monthīs speech by Malaysiaīs outgoing prime minister, Mahathir Mohammad, who said, "Jews rule the world by proxy."

"Iīm also very concerned about my own role because the new anti-Semitism holds that the Jews rule the world," said Soros, whose projects and funding have influenced governments and promoted various political causes around the world.

"As an unintended consequence of my actions," he said, "I also contribute to that image."

In the past, Mahathir has singled out Soros and other "Jewish financiers" for financial pressure that Mahathir said has harmed Malaysiaīs economy.

After the conference, some Jewish leaders who heard about the speech reacted angrily to Sorosī remarks.

"Letīs understand things clearly: Anti-Semitism is not caused by Jews; itīs caused by anti-Semites," said Elan Steinberg, senior adviser at the World Jewish Congress. "One can certainly be critical of Bush policy or Sharon policy, but any deviation from the understanding of the real cause of anti-Semitism is not merely a disservice, but a historic lie."

Abraham Foxman, national director of the Anti-Defamation League, called Sorosī comments "absolutely obscene."

"He buys into the stereotype," Foxman said. "Itīs a simplistic, counterproductive, biased and bigoted perception of whatīs out there. Itīs blaming the victim for all of Israelīs and the Jewish peopleīs ills."

Furthermore, Foxman said, "If he sees that his position of being who he is may contribute to the perception of anti-Semitism, whatīs his solution to himself — that he give up his money? That he close his mouth?"

Associates said Sorosī appearance Nov. 5 was the first they could ever recall in which the billionaire, a Hungarian-born U.S. Jew who escaped the Holocaust by fleeing to London as a child, had spoken in front of a Jewish group or attended a Jewish function.

The one-day meeting on funding in Israel, which took place at the Harvard Club in New York, was limited mostly to representatives of Jewish philanthropic foundations.

After Sorosī speech, Michael Steinhardt, the real-estate magnate and Jewish philanthropist who arranged for Soros to address the group, said in an interview that Sorosī views do not reflect those of most Jewish millionaires or philanthropists.

He also pointed out that this was Sorosī first speech to a Jewish audience.

Steinhardt approached the lectern and interrupted Soros immediately after his remarks on anti-Semitism.

"George Soros does not think Jews should be hated any more than they deserve to be," Steinhardt said by way of clarification, eliciting chuckles from the audience.

Steinhardt then gave the lectern back to Soros, who said he had something to add to his remarks on the issue of anti-Semitism. Soros then paused to ask if there were any journalists in the room.

When he learned that there were, Soros withheld further comment.

Mark Charendoff, president of the group that hosted the conference, said he was pleased overall with the Soros event.

"We found him to be enormously frank, candid and generous with his time," Charendoff said. "I would be delighted if Mr. Soros would bring his passion, his brilliance and his resources to a range of different causes that are important to the Jewish community."

Charendoff is not alone.

Regardless of what they think of his politics, most Jewish activists likely would welcome Sorosī participation in the world of Jewish philanthropy.

Though heīs ranked as the 28th richest person in the United States by Forbes magazine — with a fortune valued at $7 billion — Soros has given relatively little money to Jewish causes.

Sorosī first known funding of a Jewish group came in 1997, when his Open Society Instituteīs Emma Lazarus Fund gave $1.3 million to the Council of Jewish Federations, and when Soros gave another $1.3 million to the Jewish Fund for Justice, an anti-poverty group.

As much as Jews may not like what Soros has to say — at the Nov. 5 meeting, he called for "regime change" in the United States and talked of funding projects in "Palestine" — they are eager to get Soros involved in giving to Jewish causes.

"In many ways, this was an introduction for Soros," Charendoff said. "He remarked to me how impressed he was with the quality of the people he met. We can only hope that this was a beginning of an engagement with the Jewish funding world."

Soros said he has not given much to Jewish or Israel-related causes because Jews take care of their own, so that his financial clout is better directed elsewhere.

Steinhardt tried to correct him on that point, saying the field of Jewish giving is not as crowded as Soros thinks.

"Even if we were a crowded field," Steinhardt told Soros, "Iīm sure we could make room for you."

During his speech, Soros announced that he would support the "Geneva accord," an unofficial Middle East peace plan proposed by two out-of-office politicians, Israelīs Yossi Beilin and Palestinian Yasser Abed Rabbo.

That plan envisions two states along pre-1967 borders and a shared Jerusalem, and is vague on the demand that Palestinian refugees from 1948 be allowed to return to Israel.

It was not clear whether Sorosī support of the plan would involve funding. Beilinīs office did not return a call seeking comment.

© JTA. Reproduction of material without written permission is strictly prohibited.
Send us feedback   Email this story   Print this page  
Back to top ^
Home | Mideast | Around the Globe | Washington | American Jewry | Features
Site Map | Free Daily Briefing | JTA To Go | Publications
How to Donate | Customer Service | Tell the Editors | Useful Links
JTA Today | History | Staff | Board | Clients | Funding

© JTA. Reproduction of material without written permission is strictly prohibited.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service