By Tammy Flanagan
September 8, 2006
One of the very nice things about federal retirement benefits is that they come with annual cost-of-living adjustments.
For many people, retirement means living on a fixed income. They no longer get pay raises, promotions, overtime pay, locality pay or bonuses. Retirement income often is a fixed percentage of salary. There is some flexibility in the way people manage their retirement investments, but let's face it, most of us aren't going to be adding much to those savings, so they are in essence fixed, too.
Most people are satisfied if they can maintain their lifestyle in retirement. One of the things that can derail that goal is inflation.
Here are some prices from 1980:
Postage stamp: 15 cents
Loaf of bread: 48 cents
Gallon of milk: $1.60
Gallon of gas: $1.03
Average new car: $7,600
Average house: $86,159
Now compare the same prices today:
Postage stamp: 39 cents
Loaf of bread: $1.48
Gallon of milk: $3.49
Gallon of gas: $2.50-$3.50, depending on the day
Average new car: $27,800
Average house: $264,000
Consider the case of Stella, who retired in 1979. After a 35-year career in government, her Civil Service Retirement System retirement benefit was $20,000 per year. Since then, Stella's retirement benefit has been adjusted by the following COLAs:
Those early 1980s were some high inflation years! Stella's retirement is now $54,134 per year, more than 2.5 times its original amount. But the prices of the things Stella needs to buy have gone up at the same rate.
If Stella had retired under the Federal Employees Retirement System at age 62, she would have received lesser annual COLAs and her retirement would have increased to only $45,150. Unlike CSRS annuitants, FERS retirees get Social Security benefits that are indexed to inflation. To compensate for the "diet COLA" of FERS, Stella would need to take a little more out of her retirement savings as she gets older.
A Tale of Two COLAs
Let's look at the difference between the regular and diet COLAs.
CSRS annuitants receive allowances based on the rise in the consumer price index for urban wage earners and clerical workers from the third quarter of one year to the third quarter of the next. FERS uses a somewhat more complicated formula to provide its smaller benefit. If the change in the CPI is between 2 percent and 3 percent, the FERS COLA is 2 percent. If the CPI increase is more than 3 percent, the FERS COLA is 1 percent less than the increase. COLAs under FERS are not provided until age 62, except under special circumstances.
The FERS basic annuity benefit is designed to be more like a private sector pension, providing a supplement to Social Security. Private sector pensions rarely receive any COLA adjustments. Social Security benefits receive the same adjustment annually as CSRS benefits.
Unlike FERS, CSRS was designed to provide full retirement benefits and not serve as a supplement to Social Security. CSRS employees are exempt from paying Social Security taxes during their federal careers. The lower FERS COLA seems to have been a compromise between the lack of COLAs in private sector pensions and the full COLA of CSRS benefits.
What You Get and When
The COLA is granted to retirees on Dec. 1 each year and is payable on Jan. 1. To get the full 2006 COLA on January 1, 2007, a retiree must have begun receiving benefits no later than Dec. 31, 2005. If not, the increase is prorated (under both CSRS and FERS). Annuitants with prorated accounts receive one-twelfth of the increase for each month they received benefits.
If an employee retires voluntarily, his or her retirement begins the first day of the month following retirement. Under CSRS, an employee may retire on the first, second or third day of the month and retirement officially will begin the next day. So, in order to have a retirement that began before Dec. 31, 2005, you would have had to voluntarily retire no later than Nov. 30, 2005, under FERS or by Dec. 3, 2005, under CSRS. There are exceptions for survivor annuities, disability retirements and involuntary separations.
Let's look at a couple of examples of how retirement dates affect COLAs:
Barney retired on Dec. 31, 2005. His retirement began on Jan. 1, 2006. He will receive eleven-twelfths of the COLA for 2006 on Jan. 1, 2007.
Lucy plans to retire under FERS at age 62 on Friday, Sept. 15, 2006. Her retirement will begin on Oct. 1, 2006. When the 2006 COLA is granted on Dec. 1, she will be entitled to 2/12 of it since she was a retiree for October and November.
For FERS annuitants who are not eligible to receive a COLA during their first year (or more) of retirement because they retired more than one year prior to age 62, the initial allowance they receive after reaching age 62 will be the full COLA. Some retirees under FERS receive immediate COLAs prior to age 62. These include employees retiring under the law enforcement, firefighter, and air traffic controller provisions of FERS. Survivor annuities under FERS also receive immediate COLAs.
So what will next year's COLA be? We will have to wait a few more weeks to find out. The 2006 COLA will be announced after Sept. 30 by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. If I were a betting person, I would wager that it will exceed the federal employee pay raise in January, whether that raise is 2.2 percent or 2.7 percent.
Tammy Flanagan is the senior benefits director for the National Institute of Transition Planning Inc., which conducts federal retirement planning workshops and seminars. She has spent 25 years helping federal employees take charge of their retirement by understanding their benefits.
Dear Tammy, Thank you, as always, for responding to my questions. I just didn't get the most important of them addressed. I'm not sure if I missed the information in some of the personnel literature and have been looking for it. Perhaps you could help me out? The questions are: 1. Is the COLA for FERS calculated only on the 1 percent? 2. Are the 1 percent basic FERS funds separated from the matching and participatory TSP contributions during the retirement process and the conversion to an annuity? Thanks again. Tip off.
This is in response to the comment: Stella's case would be even worse off since under FERS she would not have gotten the same starting basis of $20,000 for the same time in service worked and the salary earned. Additionally, the COLA would only be on her government contributed retirement (that FERS "basic" annuity) of 1 percent. Yes, I did make the FERS "Stella" with the same benefit as the CSRS "Stella." In reality, the FERS "Stella" would have had a FERS basic benefit about half as much as the CSRS retiree (2 percent versus 1 percent). But, if she was 62 or older, she would have also been entitled to Social Security retirement, which does receive full COLAs. In addition, she can manage her TSP withdrawals to take less out when she is younger, leaving more for her later years. You're right, it will take more planning!
This entire mess is so reminiscent of “Voodoo Economics.” Distinguishing between the 1 percent basic, the 4 percent matching, and our own TSP contributions has truly confounded me. As simple as this article was laid out, it’s left me with several questions that I’d appreciate if you (or anyone else out there) could answer for me. As always correct me if I’m wrong, but your scenario assumed equal amounts merely for the convenience example. Stella’s case would be even worse off since under FERS she would not have gotten the same starting basis of $20,000 for the same time in service worked and the salary earned. Additionally, the COLA would only be on her government contributed retirement (that FERS “basic” annuity) of 1 percent. Is that true? Is the COLA for FERS calculated only on the 1 percent? Are the 1 percent basic FERS funds separated from the matching and participatory TSP contributions during the retirement process and the conversion to an annuity? Without such information, I couldn’t even begin to crunch numbers and attempt to estimate my retirement. Once again, thanks for making me think. Tip off.
Life After Government
GovExec.com's special section provides retirement-related news updates, legislative updates, and links to Web resources.
(C) 2008 BY NATIONAL JOURNAL GROUP, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.