A pitch-perfect account of how hip-hop culture drew in the author and how his father drew him out again-with love, perseverance, and fifteen thousand books.
Into Williams's childhood home-a one-story ranch house-his father crammed more books than the local library could hold. "Pappy" used some of these volumes to run an academic prep service; the rest he used in his unending pursuit of wisdom. His son's pursuits were quite different-"money, hoes, and clothes." The teenage Williams wore Medusa- faced Versace sunglasses and a hefty gold medallion, dumbed down and thugged up his speech, and did whatever else he could to fit into the intoxicating hip-hop culture that surrounded him. Like all his friends, he knew exactly where he was the day Biggie Smalls died, he could recite the lyrics to any Nas or Tupac song, and he kept his woman in line, with force if necessary.
But Pappy, who grew up in the segregated South and hid in closets so he could read Aesop and Plato, had a different destiny in mind for his son. For years, Williams managed to juggle two disparate lifestyles- "keeping it real" in his friends' eyes and studying for the SATs under his father's strict tutelage. As college approached and the stakes of the thug lifestyle escalated, the revolving door between Williams's street life and home life threatened to spin out of control. Ultimately, Williams would have to decide between hip-hop and his future. Would he choose "street dreams" or a radically different dream- the one Martin Luther King spoke of or the one Pappy held out to him now?
Williams is the first of his generation to measure the seductive power of hip-hop against its restrictive worldview, which ultimately leaves those who live it powerless. Losing My Cool portrays the allure and the danger of hip-hop culture like no book has before. Even more remarkably, Williams evokes the subtle salvation that literature offers and recounts with breathtaking clarity a burgeoning bond between father and son.
Chapter One
The Discovery of What It Means
to Be a Black Boy
It was wintertime, early in the morning. I was in the third grade,
standing on the rectangular asphalt playground behind Holy
Trinity Interparochial School in Westfield, New Jersey, palming a
tennis ball, waiting. Ned, nearsighted and infamous for licking the
dusty soles of his penny loafers in the back of social studies class,
was splayed against the cold orange brick wall of the school building.
He had his head down and hands up, legs akimbo with his butt
out, like a South American mule bracing herself to be searched
by border patrol. “Not so hard!” he cried, glancing back over his
shoulder through smudged Coke-bottle lenses.
“Put your head down!” another boy yelled.
“Fine, just do it and get it over with, then,” Ned muttered.
“Head down!” the boy said. I wound my arm back and let fly a
fastball that seemed to hang in the air for a second before rico-
cheting from the small of Ned’s back like a Pete Sampras ace off
some hapless ball boy at Wimbledon. Ned jerked upright and
howled in pain. All my classmates screamed and high-fived me as
the bell rang and we rushed to grab our book bags and line up in
size order before our teachers came to lead us indoors. I was still
the undisputed king of Butts-Up, I thought to myself as I pulled my
Chicago Bulls Starter jacket over my uniform. Standing in line, waiting
for the younger grades to file past, I began mumbling to myself
bits of a song by Public Enemy, a song that my older brother had
been playing at home and that had gotten stuck in my head that
week like the times tables or the Holy Rosary. “Yo, nigga, yoooooo,
nigga, yoooo-oooooo, niiiigga . . .” I repeated the refrain over and
over under my breath, unthinkingly, as I relived in my mind’s eye
the glorious coup de grace, the deathblow I’d just dealt Ned from
over ten yards away—Blaow!
“But you’re a nigger, too,” a voice said from behind me, and I half
made out what I’d just heard, but not fully. I went on singing my
song, which I couldn’t claim to understand on any level, but which
somehow made me feel cool as hell, and that was all that mattered.
The voice repeated itself, louder this time: “But you’re a nigger,
too, Thomas, aren’t you?”
“Huh?” I said, pivoting to see Craig standing there, his dirtyblond
hair cut by his mother’s Flowbee into the shape of an upsidedown
serving bowl, like a medieval friar without the bald spot.
“What did you just say?”
“You’re a nigger, too, right, so how can you say that?”
“How can I say what?”
“‘Yo, nigga, yo, nigga’; how can you say that when you’re a nigger,
too, right?”
My mother is white, my father black. They met in San Diego in the
late 1960s. Both were entrenched on the West Coast front of what
at the time was called the War on Poverty. After San Diego, they
went up to Los Angeles. From L.A. they made their way north and
my father pursued doctoral studies in sociology at the University
of Oregon. In 1975, and over my maternal grandfather’s dead body,
they were married in Eugene at the county courthouse. They had
little money, fewer blessings, and plenty of love. Later, they moved
again to Spokane and my mother, Kathleen, gave birth to their first
child, Clarence, named for my father. From Spokane the family continually
moved east: first to Denver, then to Albany, then to Philadelphia,
and finally to New Jersey, where I was born in 1981.
When I was one year old, my father switched professions and
the family moved again, this time from Newark, where he had been
running antipoverty programs for the Episcopal Archdiocese and
my mother had been raising my brother and me, to Fanwood, a
small suburb thirty minutes to the west on U.S. Route 22. Fanwood,
like the space inside a horseshoe, is bordered on three sides by the
much larger township of Scotch Plains, and these two municipalities
by and large function as one. They share a train station and
public school system and together act as a kind of buffer ground
between wealthy Westfield to the east and poor Plainfield to the
west. Riots and waves of white flight long ago left Plainfield a
vexed cross between a legitimate inner-city ghetto—with all the
requisite crime, poverty, and hopelessness that go with that—and
an emergent middle-class suburb that in many ways resembles
Westfield, except for the condition of the houses and the color of
the residents. No such white flight occurred in Fanwood, Scotch
Plains, or Westfield, although like so many small towns in New
Jersey, they had their designated black pockets.
When my parents first began searching in the area, real estate
brokers only wanted to show them homes in Plainfield or on the
redlined black sides of town. They said families like ours tended
to prefer things this way, but my father, whom we call Pappy in a
nod to his Southern roots, had led a childhood that was boxed in
by formal segregation in Texas, and no longer could stand to be
told where to live. Out of principle he said to the brokers thank
you but no thank you, and insisted on seeing all listings. Reluctantly,
they caved and the four of us settled into a three-bedroom
ranch on Fanwood’s decidedly white side.
It was a neighborhood of well-kept homes with yards that were
flaired-up with inflatable IT’S A BOY! lawn signs, lighted holiday displays,
and the occasional life-size Virgin Mary shrine. There were
two main downtown areas in either direction of our house, with
more pizzerias than banks or dry cleaners and, to Pappy’s lament,
without a single bookstore between them. Our neighbors were
what my parents called “ethnic whites,” and they tended to grow
up, buy homes, have children, and die within a twenty-mile radius
of where they had been born—a fact that always seemed to strike
Mom and Pappy as bizarre. As a family, we did not fit in with these
people, who often didn’t know what to make of us. Once when I
was a very young boy, I was at the grocery store with my mother,
misbehaving as little children do, when an older white woman
walked by and said, “Ugh, it must be so tough adopting those kids
from the ghetto.”
Despite my mother’s being white, we were a black and not an
interracial family. Both of my parents stressed this distinction and
the result was that, growing up, race was not so complicated an
issue in our household. My brother and I were black, period. My
parents adhered to a strict and unified philosophy of race, the contents
of which boil down to the following: There is no such thing
as being half-white, for black, they explained, is less a biological
category than a social one. It is a condition of the mind that is
loosely linked to certain physical features, but more than anything
it is a culture, a challenge, and a discipline. We were taught from
the moment we could understand spoken words that we would be
treated by whites as though we were black whether we liked it or
not, and so we needed to know how to move in the world as black
men. And that was that.
Questions of the soul were less clear. My mother is Protestant,
the daughter of an evangelical Baptist minister. My father is what
he calls a Geopolitical-Existentialist-Secularist-Humanist-Realist,
which really is just his way of saying he doesn’t put much stock in
organized religion. Nevertheless, after very nearly being homeschooled,
Clarence and I were enrolled in private Catholic schools
for what my father described as “the superior levels of discipline”
they offered in relation to the public schools nearby.
Another factor in the decision was the day Clarence came
home from School One, about a half-block away from our front
door, dazed and unable to speak. He was in the second grade and
my father had given him an oxblood leather briefcase. Apparently,
this made him stand out among the other boys. So did his suntanned
skin, which after the long hot summer was the color of
maple honey; and his hair, which was styled in a large spherical
Afro and which in his childhood was light brown with strands of
blond and something like sherry in it: beautiful. My mother and
sometimes my father would comb my brother’s Afro in the mornings
with an orange tin can of Murray’s dressing grease and a black
plastic pick. “You look distinguished now, son,” Pappy would say,
and smile when he was finished with him, distinguished being the
rarest and highest compliment in his vocabulary.
Clarence was a quiet boy with thick hair, good muscle tone, and
intelligent almond-shaped eyes beneath bushy brown eyebrows.
That day at school a group of white children had cornered and
taunted him on the yard, asking what a fucking monkey had to do
with a briefcase. Either the other black students didn’t see this
happen or they chose not to intervene. Pappy yanked Clarence
from public school the next day. By the time I was old enough, being
in class with our neighbors was not even an option.
Unlike some children of mixed-race heritage, I didn’t ever wish to
be white. I wanted to be black. One of the first adult books my
parents gave to me, around age seven, was Alex Haley’s The Autobiography
of Malcolm X. Often my mother would come into my
room in the evening and discuss with me what I was reading. For
several nights, I lay awake long after she had turned out the lights,
haunted by the image of Malcolm’s father lying prone on the railroad
tracks, his body torn in two and his cranium cracked open
like a coconut husk. I didn’t want to resemble in any way whatsoever
those men who did things like that to other men.
It was a fortunate thing for me, too, that I didn’t want to be
white. It was fortunate because I really didn’t have much choice in
the matter. My parents were right: Around white kids, I simply was
not white. Whatever fantasies of passing may have threatened to
steal into my mulatto psyche and wreak havoc there were dispelled
early on, when Tina turned around in her chair, flipped her
bronze ponytail to the side, and asked me point-blank, and audibly
enough for the whole classroom to hear, “Hey, why doesn’t your
hair move like everyone else’s?”
“It’s because I’m black,” I told her, and I wasn’t angry or embarrassed.
It was just a fact, I felt, the way that she was husky or
big-boned.
Though we didn’t speak about it outright, I don’t think my
brother, Clarence, ever wanted to be white, either. He just didn’t
seem to see race everywhere around him like my parents and I did.
Or if he saw it, he fled from it and didn’t want to analyze it or have
to spend his time unraveling it. He didn’t want to be forced to
make a big deal out of it. He was forgiving and trusting and found
companions wherever they would be his. His two best friends
were black, and he dated a quiet Asian girl for a spell during high
school. Mostly, though, he fell in with a set of neighborhood white
boys with lots of vowels in their surnames and little in their heads.
These white boys were almost certainly the same ones who, years
earlier, had demeaned my brother with racial epithets on that
School One playground (the neighborhood is not that big). But
Clarence never knew how to hold a grudge, and that was ages ago
and these were his neighbors and they liked to do the things that
he liked to do: ride bikes, ride skateboards, talk cars, smoke cigarettes,
cut class, hang out. And they did take him in as one of their
own, that’s true, although I could see even as a child that they did
so without ever fully allowing him to rest his mind, to forget that
he was black and that he was somehow other. Still, I can’t fault my
brother for going the way he felt was most comfortable. He was a
child of the late ’70s and ’80s; hip-hop hadn’t completely circumscribed
the world he was formed in. I was a child of the late ’80s
and ’90s, on the other hand. I went the other route.
Not that it was always an easy route to go. It was not enough
simply to know and to accept that you were black—you had to look
and act that way, too. You were going to be judged by how convincingly
you could pull off the pose. One day when I was around nine
years old, my mother drove Clarence and me over to Unisex Hair
Creationz, a black barbershop in a working-class section of Plainfi
eld. Back then we had a metallic blue, used Mercedes-Benz sedan,
which from the outside seemed in good condition, though underneath
the hood it was anything but, as the countless repair bills
Pappy juggled would attest. While the three of us waited for the
light to change colors, I became transfixed by the jittery figure of a
long, thin black woman in a stained T-shirt and sweatpants, a greasy
scarf wrapped around her head. She was holding an inconsolable
baby in one hand and puffing on a long cigarette with the other,
stalking the second-floor balcony of a beat-up old Victorian mansion
that had been converted into apartments.
I must have really been staring at her, because all of a sudden I
noticed that she wasn’t aimlessly pacing back and forth anymore
but pointing and yelling specifically at our car. “What the fuck are
you staring at?” she howled. “You rich, white motherfuckers in your
Murr-say-deez, go the fuck home! You think you can just come and
watch us like you in a goddamn zoo?”
She was making a scene. Passersby in the street were taking
notice and looking at our car, too. That was a time when Benzes
were the shit and you had to be careful where you parked because
tough guys would pull off the little hood ornament and wear it
from a chain around their necks—ready-made jewelry. I was terribly
uncomfortable being the center of attention there in that backseat,
mentally pleading for the light to turn green. I was also
confused as hell. Who were these white people this woman kept
referring to? Was she talking about . . . us—was she talking about
me? Of course my mother was white, but I didn’t understand how
she could think I was white, too. After all, I was on the way that
very moment to have my hair cut at the only barbershop in the
area that would cut hair like mine—curly, nappy hair. The kind
that “didn’t move,” the kind of hair that disqualified me from getting
cuts at the white barbershop two blocks from my house. But this
woman was talking to me.
“Just ignore her,” my mother said, and finally we drove away. But
I couldn’t drive that woman’s angry face out of my head. She had
somehow stripped me of myself, taken something from me. I felt I
had to protect myself from ever feeling that kind of loss again.
When I stepped into the barbershop that day and every second
Saturday afterward, I was extra careful to pay attention to the other
black boys sitting inside, some with their uncles, some with their
fathers and brothers, some sitting all alone. These boys became
like models to me. I studied their postures and their screwfaces,
the unlaced purple and turquoise Filas on their feet, their mannerisms,
the way they slapped hands in the street. These boys would
never be singled out and dissed the way I had been. I decided I
wanted whatever it was that protected them.
Inside Unisex, it smelled deliciously of witch hazel and Barbasol,
and there were three long rows of cushioned seats facing five
swiveling barber’s chairs like bleachers in a gymnasium. There
was an old, fake-wood-paneled color television suspended from
the ceiling in the far back corner. If a bootlegged movie wasn’t
playing on the VCR, the TV stayed stuck on one channel in particular
the rest of the time, a channel I soon learned was called Black
Entertainment Television. At the time in the morning when I usually
came into the shop, the program Rap City would be showing.
These barbershop Rap City sessions were not my first exposure to
hip-hop music and culture, of course; I had been aware of it vaguely
through the tapes my brother brought home and played in his
bedroom. I don’t believe, though, that I had ever noticed BET before,
and in the strange, homogeneously black setting of Unisex
Hair Creationz and the city of Plainfield beyond it, the sight of this
all-black cable station mesmerized and awed me. Watching BET felt
cheap and even a little wrong on an intuitive level—my parents
wouldn’t admire most of what was shown; Pappy called it
minstrelsy—but the men and women in the videos didn’t just contend
for my attention, they demanded it, and I obliged them. They
were all so luridly sexual, so gaudily decked out, so physically confi
dent with an oh-I-wish-a-nigga-would air of defiance, so defensively
assertive, I couldn’t pry my eyes away.
One morning, Ice-T’s “New Jack Hustler” video came on, and
though I didn’t know the meaning behind the title—or even
whether I liked what I was hearing—I knew for sure that the other
boys in the shop didn’t seem to question any of it, and I sensed
that I shouldn’t, either. All of them knew the words to the song and
some rapped along to it convincingly. I paid attention to the slang
they were using and decided I had better learn it myself. Terms like
“nigga” and “bitch” were embedded in my thought process, and I
was consciously aware for the first time that it wasn’t enough just
to know the lexicon. There was also a certain way of moving and
gesticulating that went with whatever was being said, a silent body
language that everybody seemed to speak and understand, whether
rapping or chatting, which I would need to get down, too. Over the
weeks and months that followed, as I became more and more
adept at mimicking and projecting blackness the BET way, and
while it was all still fresh to me, what struck me most about this
new behavior was how far it veered not just from that of my white
classmates and friends at Holy Trinity, but also from that of my father
and the two older black barbers in the barbershop—sharp
men who looked out of place in Unisex and who held the door
and brushed parts on the sides of their heads.
One afternoon I came home from the barbershop sporting an
aerodynamic new hair creation of my own. “What on earth did you
let them do to you, son?” Pappy said as soon as he saw me. (Our
house was not spacious; the front door opened directly into Pappy’s
study, which he had converted from what ordinarily would
have been a living room. To enter the house was literally to step
into his scrutinizing gaze.)
“Huh?” I said, touching my hand to my head. The top was so flat
and cylindrical it resembled an unused No. 2 pencil eraser; the
sides and the back were shaved all the way down, revealing a shaft
of high-yellow scalp.
“What, they didn’t listen when you told them what you wanted?”
“No, they did,” I said. “This is what I wanted.”
“You wanted that?”
“Well, yeah, it’s what everyone is wearing, Babe; it’s what’s on
BET and in all the magazines.” (We call my father Babe when speaking
to him casually, kind of a tu to the vous of Pappy.)
“And you want to look like everyone else, son? Is that what you
want?” He was staring at me intently now.
I stood there before him, studying the Air Flights on my feet. I
didn’t have a response he would find remotely respectable. The
thing is that I did want to look like everyone else—everyone else
in the barbershop and on that TV screen. After all, even in the backseat
of a big ol’ Murrsaydeez, the woman on the balcony would
never mistake a brother with a flattop like this for being white.
Annoyed or dismayed by my new coif as he was, though, Pappy
allowed Clarence and me a generous amount of latitude when it
came to our personal style, as long as we were giving him our best
efforts in what he cared about most: the development of our minds.
What this meant, giving him our best, was not that we were pressured
to place first in our classes or even to get straight A’s on our
schoolwork, although it would have been welcome if we did. We
were expected to maintain decent grades, but it was deeper than
that. Pappy, no longer working as a sociologist, now put his PhD
and extensive store of personal knowledge and reading to use running
a private academic and SAT preparation service from our
home. From the second grade on, giving Pappy our best meant we
needed to try hard in school, but much more important than that,
we needed to study one-on-one with him in the evenings and on
the weekends, on long vacations, and all throughout the summer
break. If we could not do that, he was able to make our home the
most uncomfortable inn to lodge in. When Clarence began blowing
off work, he didn’t just get grounded, he came home to find his
bedroom walls stripped bare, his Michael Jordan and Run-D.M.C.
posters replaced with pastel sheets of algebra equations Pappy
had printed out and tacked up.
As for me, the first time Pappy called me into his study to explain
my summer schedule, I was seven and my eyes betrayed me,
welling with tears against my will. When he looked up from his
notes and saw this, he got so offended that he stormed out of the
room and I fell into my mother’s lap crying. I did not want to do the
work he had planned for me. I wanted to play with my friends and
have sleepover parties. I wanted to capture fireflies in ventilated
Smucker’s jars and beat Super Mario Brothers on Clarence’s Nintendo.
That was the truth. However, more than anything, I wanted
not to disappoint my father. With my mother’s encouragement and
some Kleenex, I followed Pappy into his bedroom and told him that
I had just had something in my eye and that, in fact, I had not been
crying. I was eager to start studying, I told him. He suspended his
disbelief and led me back to his desk, where he proceeded to lay
out an intensive program of regimented work in syllogistic and
spatial reasoning, vocabulary-building, Miller analogies, arithmetic,
and reading comprehension—his signature cocktail.
If Pappy was a tyrant, he was a gentle and conflicted one, who
did not relish the role. He yearned for a time when he would cease
having to be one at all. What he hoped was that if he could somehow
just make reading and studying appealing enough to his boys,
eventually we wouldn’t need his prodding anymore and we’d simply
do it on our own. To that end, he made sure not just to dangle
punishment over our heads, Sword of Damocles–style, and leave
it at that. He went out of his way to be fair. If we just did what
he asked without too much complaint, he would do us some real
solids in return, such as paying us generously for our time (“Study-
ing is your job, and an honest day’s work deserves an honest day’s
pay”), intervening on our behalf when our mother doled out
chores (“Studying is their only job”), and tolerating a slew of hair,
clothing, and dating choices that were in flagrant violation of his
personal tastes.
Despite these enticements, Clarence would always find it diffi-
cult to take to long periods of study, and he went through fits of
resistance routinely. Being the younger brother, I had the advantage
of learning from his mistakes and avoiding most of his battles. I
was what Pappy called a “dutiful son.” Most of the time this dutifulness
of mine sufficed. We were rarely in open conflict with each
other, and he was almost always patient and playfully encouraging
with me.
“Thomas Chatterton,” he’d say, addressing me by my middle
name as I sped through his study on my way to the kitchen, oblivious
to my surroundings. “Do you know you wear the name of a
brilliant poet, son?” he’d call from the other room.
“Yeah, of course, Babe,” I’d say, poking my head into the refrigerator,
looking for something sweet.
“And do you know they call him the Marvelous Boy, his poetry
was so fine?” he’d say, still talking to me from the other room.
“Uh-uh,” I’d say with my mouth full.
“Well, they do. His poetry was so fine, in fact, and he was so
young when he wrote it, that the adults couldn’t even believe the
work was his own. They all accused him of copying someone else,
someone much older.”
“They did?”
“They sure did. And do you know that he became so distraught
by this, he became so discouraged, that he killed himself when he
was only seventeen years old? He decided he couldn’t live with
the dishonor.”
“That’s horrible.”
“Yes it is, son. Life is not fair. But now you’re going to bring honor
to his name, aren’t you? It’s very important that you do that, son.”
“But I don’t know how to, Babe,” I’d say, returning to the study
with a bowl of ice cream or a glass of soda in my hand.
”Well, you don’t have to be a poet, son. You can be a great philosopher,
for example—pull up a seat.”
“A philosopher?” I’d say, and sit down.
“Yes, in fact, you’re a philosopher already, aren’t you?”
“I don’t think so,” I’d say, my cheeks flushing.
“Well, yes you are, son. Think about it: Do you question the
things around you? Do you reflect on their meaning? Are you interested
in the truth?”
“Yeah.”
“Then you’re a philosopher, son,” he would tell me, and I would
laugh, embarrassed because I didn’t feel at all like a philosopher,
whatever that was I could only imagine. I felt ignorant, which is
what I confessed to him. And he would tell me that ignorance is
the beginning of knowledge and talk of men named Socrates and
Confucius. He revered these two men perhaps above all other
men, Socrates for his edict to know thyself and Confucius for his
devotion to learning and personal excellence, he said. I would sit
there at Pappy’s desk, exhausting whatever sugary collation I had
brought with me from the kitchen, and listen to him talk. “Well, I’ve
told you enough,” he’d eventually say. “Now, you tell me—how am
I going to grow up and be smart like you?” We’d laugh and I’d try
to come up with some reply. These questioning talks I had with
Pappy were so frequent in my childhood that to this day the name
Socrates remains mingled in my mind with the image of my balding
and bearded father seated in his study. I cannot think of one
without inadvertently conjuring the other.
Sometimes, though, Pappy grew impatient waiting for the love
of learning to take root in me. “I don’t understand,” he’d say in moments
of frustration, “how you can keep walking past all these
books and never stop to pick up a single one of them. My people
told me not to read—don’t you know what I would have done to
have all this? Don’t you ever get curious, son?” These were simple,
honest questions that sometimes he put to me with a shake of
the head and wry smile. Sometimes, though, he didn’t smile at all.
In these latter moments, the look on his face was nothing like
anger and something like pain—a sort of deep, serious pain I have
only seen replicated in pictures of black faces of a certain age and
demographic. It was a pain that I knew I couldn’t have caused but
somehow must have mistakenly activated. I would stand there
looking at him, frozen, like a deer suspended in halogen beams,
and stammer some weak response.
That particular afternoon after my visit to the barbershop,
Pappy let drop the subject of my rectangular head of hair and
handed me my work for the day. There was no long talk and no
sadness in his face that afternoon. “Memory exercises and then
vocabulary, both synonyms and antonyms,” he said. “Write them all
out on flashcards and then come see me.”
“OK, Babe,” I said, and went to my room carrying a pale green
tachistoscope, a stack of SAT and GRE word lists, and a thick
Merriam- Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, glad to have dodged a
confrontation. After a morning spent at the barbershop, submerged
in Black Entertainment Television, speaking and thinking in my
florid second tongue—Ebonics—it was time now to return to the
staid and familiar language of my father.
Advance Reader Reviews from BookBrowse:
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Froma F. (Boulder, CO) Powerful indictment of hip hop culture This is an important book. Williams chronicles his life in hip hop culture and his eventual break from that culture as he moves away from negative values (empty materialism, denigration of women) into a life of self examination. Along the way he becomes a philosophy major and Williams is particularly gifted at explaining difficult concepts in language that makes them seem quite simple. Although this is not an introduction to Heidegger or Hegel, you will walk away understanding the ideas they propound. The book is filled with extraordinary insight about the values hip hop culture promotes, what it is like to grow up middle class and black in America and how pernicious the hip hop values are for most young, black people. Williams is very insightful and is most compelling when he reflects on his life. One caveat: Williams seems somewhat uncomfortable and overly self-conscious when writing about himself and the people he knows and in the early part of the book, the writing is stilted. Persist! This is a book that is well worth reading. Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Maria P. (Washington, DC) Culture Shift The ideas proposed in this book offer a culture shift away from what some believe to be popular, cool and hip. Hip today is not what hip was yesterday, and will not be what hip is tomorrow. The challenge for the young who want to be part of a group for reasons of safety, coolness or just belonging is to find the thoughts that can help create a cool, safe free society. The challenge for adults is to remember that what they do and say is heard and repeated by future generations. In "Losing My Cool" the family is challenging and wise and strongest group of all.
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Marta M. (Tustin, CA) An interesting read I found this book very interesting. In fact I couldn't put it down and I was reading it while on vacation. On vacation I usually read fiction. The author is well educated and the book is well written. It explained a lot to me about my fifth grade students. They all fans of hip-hop music but not so much with the education. This gives me a small insight into their world. This might help me in teaching them. I liked the way he blended philosophy with the fascinating story of his life. I don't think we have heard the last of this smart young man. I think that this is an important book that should be read by all.
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Terye B. (Scotts Valley, CA) How cool is cool? This was a fascinating story on so many levels. A young black man struggles for his identity and finds it in the black culture of Hip Hop and BET television. While fitting into a crowd, a group he never gets to know his true self. When away at college he finds himself and learns to appreciate the structured, collegiate life his father was preparing him for since childhood. This true story is told in an easy tone, and brings back all the teenage struggles for acceptance and the awakening of adulthood. I would highly recommend this for a book group.
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Irene M. (Ashland, OR) Losing My Cool This book is fascinating. I have not read anything that so clearly defines the peer pressure for young blacks in today's culture. I enjoyed reading about this author's decision-making process, and the influences that took him from a hip- hop life on the streets of his home town to become a graduate of Georgetown University with major in philosophy.
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Kendra R. (New Orleans, LA) Engaging and thought provoking I found it so engaging I read it in a day. Williams provides insight into what draws people into the hip-hop lifestyle as well as what it means to be black today. As he evolves his perspective, so follows the narrative. I'm already looking forward to rereading it and sharing it with friends so we can discuss it, black and white together.
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Barbara C. (Riverside, CA) A Father's Love Being the age of Thomas' father myself, that relationship was the thread that I followed through the book. The book was rich with philosophical turns, anecdotes, history, and culture from a very non-typical perspective....but very much driven by the loving, strong father. The book had so many facets to understand--hip hop to Hegel in 200 pages. I guess my desire would be to sit down at the table with Pappy and Thomas and understand the subtle nuances between their middle class and mine. I loved the book and couldn't put it down!
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Beverly D. (Palm Harbor, FL) a young man's look at hip hop Williams examines the seductiveness and potential dangers of the hip hop lifestyle as it applied to him as a young man growing up in Plainfield,N.J. Ultimately finding his "place" through the study of Hegel, Heidegger and his father's unending belief in study & learning, Williams is able to love the music but ignore the philosophy and find his way as a young African -American philosopher and first time author.
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Constance S. (Sacramento, CA) Losing My Cool It was difficult to read this well written, seemingly honest memoir by Thomas Chatterton Williams when I realized I was at odds with his conclusion about the reason so many African American students do poorly in school. He writes that they feel the need to adhere to only one culture, the hip hop one, and distance themselves from all others. This is called "keeping it real". As a Black woman I see this as only one of the causes. The hip hop culture through music,movies, TV and materialism is fed non-stop to our children and it is seductive. Nothing else seems to grant many youngsters the feeling of solidarity and the swagger and the elusive cool. To turn away from this is considered being disloyal and acting white. It is better to remain with the group than to seek many other avenues of success through education. Losing My Cool deserves four stars for creating a three dimensional picture of the hip hop world; and four stars for the very inspiring description of his awakening through his father's intellectual assistance and determination. I enjoyed his many references to philosophers and authors. I bookmarked and underlined his many well chosen quotations.
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Susan R. (Dublin, NH) Anticipating the next chapters in this man's life This thoughtful memoir is written by a young man whose mother is white and whose father is a black man who came up in the pre-integration south. When he finally got the opportunity, Mr. Williams senior embraced books and scholarship wholeheartedly. Growing up in a relatively white NJ suburb, the author and his brother bought completely into black culture as portrayed by BET and rap music. This is the story of how he moved selectively to the norms of the larger society. It's an interesting book with a few magnificent passages.
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Rosario D. (South El Monte, CA) Losing My Cool to Hip-Hop An interesting view at how hip-hop formed the mentality of Thomas and his friends so that their lives go hand-in-hand with the hip-hop lyrics they hear. Through the perseverance, advice, and love of his father, Thomas realizes that he can do more with his life than just listen to hip-hop and "keep it real". I really enjoyed this book, it is always nice to read a story about someone that was able to realize his/her full potential. Thomas shows us that is possible to follow ones dreams instead of doing what everyone else is doing. I also enjoyed the philosophical view of this book and believe that Thomas did a wonderful job of explain it towards the end of the book. Whether you agree or disagree with him, this is a must read in today's world where many of us are afraid to be individuals and instead decide to be part of the crowd.
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Vicky S. (Torrance, CA) Questioning values I enjoyed the questioning of values that the author experiences as he encounters a variety of other blacks or African-Americans, and non-blacks that he initially dismisses when he goes from high school to Georgetown University. The text would make for interesting book club discussions as the individuals could draw parallels to similar soul searching they have made when faced with challenges to their own values.
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by Nancy O. (Hobe Sound, FL) When you need a bit of inspiration... Losing My Cool is one person's story about how he learned to "interpret and navigate the world around us." There's always more out there, if you want it, and more importantly, it's attainable, as Williams shows in his touching story. This is a valuable message for everyone. It's an engrossing story -- I couldn't put it down once I'd picked it up. Williams is a talented writer -- I hope we see more from him in the future. Losing My Cool is definitely a book I would recommend to others.
Rated 5 out of 5 stars by WDH (New Port Richey, FL) Thoughtful Voice I like the author's voice throughout the book. He chronicles growing up and trying to find your place in the world very well. He is thoughtful in how he examines his life and the lives of his friends and his views about getting caught up in a culture and believing you are something you really are not are thought-provoking. The author acknowledges his father (and to a lesser degree his mother) and provides a showcase for the power and influence a key person with love, strength, patience and perseverance can have over a child's life. The description of his father's library and his love of books and knowledge was in itself a powerful message. This book is a good read.
Q: Tell us a little bit about yourself.
I grew up in New Jersey, but my parents are from out west. They moved the family to New Jersey when my father, a sociologist by training, took a job in Newark running anti-poverty programs for the Episcopal Archdiocese. My father “Pappy” who is black, is from Galveston and Fort Worth, Texas. My mother, who is white, is from San Diego. They both lament the decision to move east.
I spent the first year of my life in Newark, but was raised in Fanwood, a solidly middle-class suburb with a white side and a black side. We lived on the white side of town mainly because Pappy, who had grown up under formal segregation, refused out of principle to ever again let anyone tell him where to live.
I studied philosophy at Georgetown University in Washington D.C., and more recently, attended graduate school at New York University.
Q: Why did you write this book?
I started writing this book out of a searing sense of frustration. It was 2007, hip-hop had sunk to new depths with outrageously ignorant artists like the Dip Set and Soulja Boy dominating the culture and airwaves, and something inside me just snapped. I was in grad school at NYU and one of my teachers gave the class the assignment of writing an op-ed article on a topic of choice, the only requirement being to take a strong stand. I went straight from class to the library and in three or four hours banged out a heartfelt 1000 words against what I saw as the debasement of black culture in the hip-hop era. After some revisions, the Washington Post published what I had written and it generated a lot of passionate feedback, both for and against. I realized that there was a serious conversation to be had on this subject and that there was a lot more that I wanted to say besides. That was why I started.
By the time I finished writing, though, it had become something quite different, something very personal, a tribute to my father and to previous generations of black men and women who went through unimaginable circumstances and despite that, or rather because of it, would be ashamed of the things we as a culture now preoccupy ourselves with, rap about, and do on a daily basis.
Basically, the book began as a Dear John letter to my peers and ended as a love letter to my father.
Q: You fully embraced the black culture of BET and rap superstars starting at a young age. What drew you in?
I think I was drawn to black culture by the same things that have been drawing the entire world to it since the days of Richard Wright, Josephine Baker and Louis Armstrong. This culture is original, potent and seductive. As we all know, the evil of slavery and the sting of the whip have given us many things including the voice of Nina Simone, the prose of James Baldwin, the Air Jordan sneaker, the blues, jazz, moonwalking, and more recently gangsta rap.
What matters here is not that I found the black hip-hop driven culture that I was surrounded by alluring—that’s not significant, unique or particularly interesting. The crucial point is that this culture exerted a seriously negative influence on my black peers and me, and it did so in a way and to a degree that it didn’t for non-blacks. The main reason for this, I firmly believe, is that we (blacks) tended to approach hip-hop seriously and earnestly, striving to “keep it real” and viewing a lifestyle governed by hip-hop values as some kind of prerequisite to an authentically black existence. Non-blacks were better able to embrace hip-hop with a healthy sense of irony.
Q: Your father tutored you throughout your life, yet you still seem awed that you escaped the allure of hip-hop culture. Where are your high school classmates today?
Yes, I was and still am awed! Let’s be honest, like many committed parents my father faced daunting odds getting me away from the foolishness that surrounded us. Because we were not wealthy and living in seclusion, it was basically him and my mother against a neighborhood and high school of bad role models who were working in conjunction with a relentless and powerful propaganda campaign that streamed into the house 24/7 via Hot 97 FM, Black Entertainment Television and MTV. The odds were that his message would be drowned out in a cacophony of bullshit.
To answer the second question—and to be precise, we’re just talking about blacks and Latinos when we talk about my classmates here because I wasn’t really around anyone else in those days—I haven’t kept up with any of the classmates I mention in the book with the exception of Charles, who is like a brother to my brother and me and a son to my parents. Charles is doing fantastic, having recently graduated from one of the top two law schools in the country.
From what I hear and occasionally see on Facebook, no one else has done anything close to that. That’s sad to me because there were many other students who were intelligent enough to go that far, but they didn’t. Without my father’s encouragement and guidance, of course, I don’t think that Charles and I would have gone far either. The culture was stifling. None of us (except for one or two good girls who come to mind, but who were not influential at all on the rest of us) considered being smart very “real.” Most of the others that I mention in the book seem to be in solidly mediocre positions, having grown into adults with varying degrees of success. Some have done okay, but some have utterly failed. Some are happily married and some still dream of becoming rappers, which floors me. The girls seem to have done better than the boys. Are they all a bunch of criminals and crackheads? No, not at all, and I want to emphasize that. But was there a lot of needlessly squandered potential? Yes, absolutely.
Q: Your father owned 15,000 books, but says that he has never read for enjoyment. What is the difference between your attitude toward books and your father’s?
It’s true, Pappy is in his 70s and to this day he still underlines articles in the newspaper every morning. My father loves to read, but he can’t simply relax with a good book. Reading will always be work for him. He always felt pressure to read for the purpose of obtaining practical knowledge (even from novels). He was born black in the segregated south in the 1930s, and he figured out early on that if he didn’t teach himself what he needed to know through books no one else would. I contrast this with my own view that it’s nice to enjoy literature for purely aesthetic reasons.
In college and in my early 20s, I read for the latter reason mainly, for beauty and quixotic epiphany, both of which are valuable things, but a bit luxurious, too. Today, as a writer and someone who cares deeply about sentences, I find myself reading for many more practical reasons than I used to. I read for technical and inspirational knowledge about my craft. In that way I am more like my father than I used to be. However, I’m also always on the lookout for beauty for beauty’s sake and nothing more. I see it both ways now.
Q: In the book you describe Georgetown as “an outpost of white and international privilege” nestled into one of our country’s blackest cities. What was your attitude going into your first year? And upon graduating?
Georgetown is certainly that. Going into my first year, my attitude was essentially that I would be an alien there; at most I would just be passing through. I had no animosity toward the wider non-black world, I just couldn’t imagine myself reflected in it. It wasn’t real to me. By the time I graduated, I had become a stranger to the hip-hop culture I had grown up in. Crucially, though, I didn’t feel that I had started selling out or acting white at all. Actually, I felt prouder than ever to be black—it’s just my definition of what black could be had begun to expand dramatically.
Q: At different points in Losing My Cool , you identify hip-hop as “a culture,” “a way of being in the world,” as like a religion, an “opiate,” “captor,” “nation,” and, well, just music. What does hip-hop signify to you today?
For a lot of people I know, hip-hop is still all of those things, so it signifies all of that to me still. In my own life, though, more than anything, hip-hop is now the sound of my childhood and adolescence. It signifies the past and not the future. Of course, anything that reminds you of your growing up years is going to be special to you in certain ways, but I see hip-hop, by its very nature, as basically an obstacle to serious engagement with the world.
Q: Do Kanye, Jay-Z, and other current rap superstars have anything to offer society?
The thing I want to stress here is that it has never been my aim or desire to criticize hip-hop from a musical or formal standpoint. For one thing, I’m not qualified to do that, and for another, I’m already convinced that it is formally very interesting and worthy of respect from a variety of perspectives.
So with that said, yes, I do think artists like Jay-Z and Kanye West especially have something to offer society, and that is the spectacle of their talent. These are extraordinarily talented cats. Jay-Z’s wordplay on songs like “D’Evils” or “Can I Live?” surpasses what most Harvard and Yale graduates can do with language. As for Kanye West, he’s got to be one of the most gifted and original popular musicians of his generation in any genre. The things he hears you and I don’t hear.
It’s no secret that we all love to discover and marvel at talent, put it on a pedestal and gawk at it. But in my opinion, what these guys do for us seldom or never gets any deeper than merely displaying that they are clever, and doing so in strictly solipsistic ways. In terms of their ethics, interests, values, and the lyrical content of their work, these rappers have very little that is enriching and lots that is actually very damaging to offer their listeners. They engage us in a catchy way so we admire them for it, and hunger after what they produce, but it’s empty calories at best. The truth is that there’s very little that is nutritious to consume there. You can gain far more from an hour spent with Joan Didion or James Baldwin than with Jay-Z, period.
Q: How does your father feel about Losing My Cool ?
My father named me after a writer, always encouraged me to be a writer, and worked extremely hard to equip me with the tools to become one, so this book is my way of saying thanks to him and I think he gets that. The first time he read the book I was nervous, though, because he’s an intensely private man and here I was writing a memoir and exposing things about myself that he might find vulgar or embarrassing. Unlike with my mother and brother, I never let him read the manuscript; I waited until I had galleys before I shared it with him. When I finally gave him a copy, he took it upstairs to his reading room and read the whole thing straight through. And he took notes on it! He identified two minor factual errors in the text, which was really helpful. Other than that, he didn’t say much immediately about it, we just sat down and watched some NFL, but I knew that he was very happy because he was in a really playful mood throughout the game, laughing and joking with my mother and me.
Since then he’s read the book cover to cover at least three more times, underlining it extensively (always underlining!). We’ve spoken a lot about the more philosophical subject matter, which comes up later in the book, like Heidegger’s idea that groups rob the individual of him or herself. This is an important point for my father. Pappy is almost never in crowds, and he doesn’t belong to any scene and never has. That’s because, he says, he’s been trying his whole life to define himself and not be defined by others. I think he’s proud that I was able to touch on this.
Email Alerts
To keep up-to-date, input your email address, and we will contact you on publication