78 captures
15 Jan 2011 - 06 May 2021
About this capture
14 January 2011 Last updated at 16:30 ET
Exit Ben Ali - but can Tunisia change?
By Prof Emma Murphy
Durham University
Critics say President Ben Ali was the head of a corrupt network of power in Tunisia
Tunisia turmoil
Analysis: What next?
Key players now
Q&A: Tunisia crisis
In pictures: New protests
Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali came to power in 1987 through a constitutional coup and he appears to have been removed from power through a constitutional coup.
The key here on both occasions was not the constitution but the army.
In 1987 the army moved to secure stability as an increasingly senile and paranoid President Bourguiba threatened to bring the country to a political and economic crisis.
Today it has moved to restore that same stability by removing a president whose person and family have become synonymous with corruption, growing wealth disparities, and political repression.
The question now is whether the interim leadership council will be used to move the country towards a democratic future through meaningful political reforms, free and fair elections, a liberalised media and a new inclusive approach to rule, or whether this is a stalling tactic by the army and the regime elite to quell protests and then restore their grip on power.
'Ben Ali's man'
The signs are mixed. Mr Ben Ali's departure has been described by Prime Minister Mohammed Ghannouchi as temporary. The prime minister himself is a technocrat who was an architect of the very economic policies which the Tunisian public believe to have failed them.
He has been at the heart of the Ben Ali regime since very early on. He cannot himself be seen as anything other than Ben Ali's man, for all his oft-discussed personal integrity.
For all his language of constitutionalism, he is still backed by a state of emergency, enforced by the army and internal security forces.
The legal opposition are weak, personalised, factionalised and compromised by years of collusion with - or submission to - the Ben Ali regime”
Without serious reforms - and even so not within the six months pending the election - it is hard to see how this leadership council can oversee the emergence of a fully-functioning, genuinely representative form of political activism which can lead to a truly new regime.
The alternative is national government, inclusive of the various legal political parties and perhaps one or two others whom the military do not consider a threat to the stability of the country and its relations with important allies such as the US and the EU.
But the legal opposition are weak, personalised, factionalised and compromised by years of collusion with - or submission to - the Ben Ali regime.
Can they deliver anything more for the Tunisian people?
Probably not. But if democracy is going to come, the leadership council needs to make very early indications that there will be substantial reforms to the political party system, the election processes, freedom of association, civil rights and the freedom of the media well in advance of the elections.
An early end to the state of emergency and some clear indication that the committee into corruption announced a few days ago will directly address the activities of the Ben Ali and Trabelsi clans would go a long way towards convincing Tunisians that, this time, the promises of constitutional rule will be fulfilled, that this time national reconciliation will really mean just that, and that the army, in defending stability, will not once more succumb to the defence of authoritarian rule.
Emma Murphy is a professor at the School of Government and International Affairs at Durham University and an expert on Tunisian affairs.
More on This Story
Tunisia turmoil
Key stories
Analysis: What next?
Key players now
Q&A: Tunisia crisis
In pictures: New protests
In with the (almost) new
Region facing domino effect?
Bank denies gold taken
France in a fluster
Mid-East bloggers hail change
How does the US view events?
How cyber war fuels the protests
Country profile
Share this page
More Africa stories
DR Congo army man 'led mass rape'
An army commander in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo has been accused of leading the recent mass rape of at least 50 women.
Tunisian cabinet to meet amid row
UN praises south Sudan referendum
Top Stories
Ambulance bomber hits Iraq police
DR Congo army man 'led mass rape'
China and US seek common ground
Australians told to flee floods
Afghan blast kills 13 civilians
Features & Analysis
'Ask not what your country...'
The secrets behind JFK's speech success
Flying the flag
Is the British monarchy just for show?
Settlement showdown?
Palestinian bid for UN settlement vote puts US on the spot
Status anxiety
How China is getting under the skin of America
Most Popular
Australians told to flee floods
India aims for tidal power first
DR Congo army man 'led mass rape'
Swiss banker tried over secrecy
Ugly Betty star on Sundance jury
Ambulance bomber hits Iraq police
China and US seek common ground
UN praises south Sudan referendum
Smoking damages body 'in minutes'
Beheading trial opens for TV boss
Elsewhere on BBC News
Silicon Valley insider
Tech expert Michael S Malone on the traits of successful start-ups and what makes the Valley tick
News feeds
E-mail news
About BBC News
Editors' blog
BBC College of Journalism
News sources
World Service Trust
About the BBC
BBC Help
Contact Us
Accessibility Help
Terms of Use
Privacy & Cookies
Advertise With Us
BBC © MMXI The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.
HomeUS & CanadaLatin AmericaUKAfricaAsia-PacEuropeMid-EastSouth AsiaBusinessHealthSci/EnvironmentTechEntertainmentVideo