3 captures
17 Feb 2011 - 30 May 2016
About this capture
Weekly Ad

Pop & Hiss
« Previous Post | Pop & Hiss Home | Next Post »
Grammy Awards: Arcade Fire shocks Streisand, the universe, with Grammy win
Comments (16)
February 13, 2011 |  8:45 pm
CRITIC'S NOTEBOOK: A night of bold moves and noisy risks at Grammys 
Wow. I think it's fair to say "wow." Here I was, all ready with the bile, ready to rip on the Grammys for giving the trophy to Lady Antebellum's "Need You Now" or a Lady Gaga EP. 
Yet no...the Arcade Fire's "The Suburbs" was named album of the year. Repeat. The Arcade Fire's "The Suburbs" was named album of the year.
We're going to say that one more time: THE ARCADE FIRE'S "THE SUBURBS" WAS NAMED ALUBM OF THE YEAR. 
The Grammys got a lot of things wrong tonight, and this was a total shock, considering the band lost the alternative album field. Even Barbra Streisand seemed to struggle in saying "The Suburbs."
Yet the act with the most complex, thoughtful and adventurous album actually won the Grammy for album of the year. When was the last time that happened? Maybe 2004, when OutKast won for "Speakerboxxx/The Love Below." 
But this shows a few things: One, that the Grammy Awards is finally recognizing independent music in its top categories. Two, a band that has sold 484,000 copies, according to Nielsen SoundScan, can actually compete with performers whose albums have all sold more than 1 million copies.
Performance-wise, the show was the usual Grammy mess, but for the first time in years, I can say the Grammys got the top prize and best new artist right. It's a step forward.
A shame, however, that they cut Arcade Fire off on the band's second song.
-- Todd Martens
Photo credit: Los Angeles Times
Twitter: @PopHiss
Facebook: Pop Hiss
More in: Arcade Fire, GRAMMY AWARDS 2011, Todd Martens
Post a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.
Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.
If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

E-mail Address:
Remember personal info?
Comments (16)
Arcade Fire Rock.
Can't wait to see them!
Posted by: Johnathan Connell | February 13, 2011 at 08:52 PM
It's about time. This was, with the exception of The Suburbs, a mediocre field and any other result would have been a travesty. This was a brilliant record. I just hope that all the ignorant eminem fans will take this as an opportunity to open their ears and listen to the music.
Posted by: Brandon Caie | February 13, 2011 at 08:52 PM
So glad they won!!! They had a horrible selection as usual this year but I'm so glad that they won!! They are such a gem!
Posted by: Michellelovesmusic | February 13, 2011 at 09:00 PM
It's not THE Arcade Fire- just Arcade Fire!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Bieber6gfever | February 13, 2011 at 09:09 PM
It's amazing seeing all the Twitter comments from people wondering who Arcade Fire are.
Posted by: Brain Johnson | February 13, 2011 at 09:09 PM

Arcade Fire. They are complex and finally a game changer in music.Step away drone music,step away.
Posted by: conrad bobiwash | February 14, 2011 at 06:44 AM
What a JOKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Brandy | February 14, 2011 at 07:54 AM
Total surprise...much deserved.
Posted by: Mary | February 14, 2011 at 08:30 AM
Arcade Fire will probably experience a bump in sales - both downloads and CD's - but I would hazard a guess that there are a dozen or so Indie/Cult bands who could have won this award on "artistic merit", which in the case of music is a very personal opinion at best. There was something strange about the actual Awards part of the Grammys. The Show was actually pretty good, starting with the Aretha tribute at the start and I thought Mick Jagger was terrific. There is still life in some of the old guys yet! But Arcade Fire? Best Album? Will they now be a huge hit, reach a large audience AND be a powerful influence on future bands and individual artists? I don't think so. The Grammys were always political, but this Award smells of the "I don't like ANY of the nominees, so I'm going to vote for the least likely to win" or the "You didn't vote for my label, so I won't vote for yours" approach to voting. The Grammy Awards have taken another step towards total irrelevance. More and more I'm thinking that the FANS, the end users, the listeners should be the voters and nominators with some percentage input from the industry. Why Arcade Fire over the other nominees? Or for that matter - why was probably the biggest commercial album of 2010 not even considered? That would be "Animal" by Ke$ha. I can't say I'm a fan, but leaving what seems to be a truly contemporary pop artist (I'm not sure Ke$ha, or a lot of others in the "popular music" genre fit the industry definition of "artist") out entirely shows a basic disrespect for the largest part of the industry's audience. Call the choice of Arcade Fire's "Suburbs" elitist, political or just plain stupid, it is another example of an industry whose time may have passed trying to seem like they are above the crass commercialism that pays their bills.
Posted by: Bruce Scrogin | February 14, 2011 at 11:44 AM
I was bitching and moaning early on the show because of too much Gaga, Bieber, and Lady A. But the show redeemed it for me when they awarded deserving acts like the Arcade Fire and Esperanza the top prizes. I couldn't be more happy. Maybe, just maybe, music is finally heading in the right direction.
Posted by: samsee | February 14, 2011 at 03:37 PM
Justice for all: Arcade Fire won best album of the year. Justin Bieber won nothing.
Still, why a famewhore and T&A act like Kim Karshadian is allowed to show up at award shows where talent is rewarded, and she has none? It's an insult to the singers, producers, actors, directors, who work hard to produce quality entertainment.
Posted by: rocknmovies | February 14, 2011 at 03:41 PM
Arcade Fire is coming to Coachella. I am so there!
Posted by: Martin | February 14, 2011 at 04:56 PM
Arcade Fire wins? The Grammy voters get real for a millisecond. Then Back to Eminem, Bieber, etc.
Posted by: Jagexxx | February 15, 2011 at 07:37 AM
P.S. Why is Lady Gaga recycling Madonna such a big deal?
Posted by: Jagexxx | February 15, 2011 at 07:38 AM
Arcade Fire. What can I say other than overrated. Their album is awful, a hodgepodge of sound in a misguided attempt to be "indie". Normally, I don't care when terrible bands win awards or sell albums, that's life. My problem is with the arrogance of Arcade Fire. Saying "We're going to play one more song because we love music"? What an insult to every other artist in the room. How huge is your ego that you believe music is more important to you than to all the other professional artists in the room that have dedicated their lives to music. Here's to a tour bus accident!
Posted by: Danger Town | February 15, 2011 at 01:51 PM
Arcade Fire WOW THIS IS GREAT - they deserve it after 3 superb albums its is time we recognize them. Few bands since The clash or U 2 came with something different it is so refreshing, a true band.
Posted by: lakas | February 17, 2011 at 05:16 AM

L.A. Times on Facebook

Stay connected:


About the Bloggers
Chris Barton
August Brown
Gerrick Kennedy
Randy Lewis
Todd Martens
Ann Powers
Randall Roberts
Margaret Wappler

Recent Posts
Dave Alvin guests on FX's 'Justified' on Feb. 23, debuts new song |  February 17, 2011, 12:50 pm »
'American Idol': Grammy-winning songs move front and center |  February 17, 2011, 12:13 pm »
Pop & Hiss Premiere: Take's video for 'Begin End Begin (Take Remix)' |  February 17, 2011, 11:23 am »
This week's on-sales: Glee Live! In Concert, Tim McGraw, Mumford & Sons and more |  February 17, 2011, 6:28 am »
FuelTV's Daryl Berg: Five tips for getting your music onto TV shows |  February 16, 2011, 6:38 pm »

Recent Comments
RE: CDs still 74% of sales in 2010. Long live the CD! | comment by john gray
RE: Album review: Animal Collective's 'Merriweather Post Pavilion' | comment by เสื้อผ้าแฟชั่น
RE: Grammy Awards: Arcade Fire shocks Streisand, the universe, with Grammy win | comment by lakas
RE: Lost in the Nashville flood: Musical instruments galore | comment by Acoustic Guitar
RE: Album review: PJ Harvey's 'Let England Shake' | comment by Joseph
RE: Grammy Awards provide a big boost for indie music | comment by Janice


'90s nostalgia 2008: year in music 2009: year in music2010 year in music 2pac 30 seconds to mars 50 cent 72 hours a perfect circle a place to bury strangers aaliyahabe vigoda acm awards adele adorable afternoonsairborne toxic event album review alex chiltonalex pham alice in chains alicia keys alie ward alpine decline amanda blank amanda palmer amas american idol americana amoeba music amon tobin amy kaufman amy winehouse ana caravelle and what rough beast, its hour come round at last... angels & airwavesanimal collective hysteria ann powers anti- anti-grammys antony and the johnsons apple aquarium drunkard arcade fire aretha franklin ariana delawariariel pink's haunted graffiti arizona armand van heldenarmy navy art, etc. arthur verocai artist to watch artists for action asher roth ashlee simpson atmosphereaugust brown austin, texas auto-tuneautolux avenged sevenfold avi buffaloawards_&_biz axl rose b.o.b babies back to school backstreet boys backtracking band profilebaroness baths beach boys beastie boys beatles beckbeef beefing beer before and after: the year in popular songs ben harper ben lee best coast best of bet awardsbeyonce big boi big search big star bilal bill frisell billy bragg billy joel bishop lamont black eyed peas black hippy black iris black joe lewis black milk black starblink-182 blu bob dylan bob fosse bone thugs-n-harmony bonnaroo books boomers brad paisleybrandy breaking news breakups brian eno brian wilson britney spears broken bells bruce springsteenbruno mars buju banton bun b burger records burialbusdriver busta rhymes caetano veloso caf� tacubacalendar camilo smith camu tao captain beefheartcaribou carl craig carrie underwood cee-lo celine dionchamillionaire charlie amter charlie haden chartschemical brothers chris barton chris brown chris isaakchris lee christina aguilera christmas ciara civic dutyclive davis clubland cmas cmt awards coachella cold war kids coldplay comedy common common & friendsconcert biz conor oberst conspiracy theories contests & competitions conversations corinne bailey rae countrycourtney love crazy long blog posts critic's notebookcrooked i current affairs cut chemist cut copy cypress hill smokeout daedelus daft punk dam-funk dangerbirddanny brown dashboard confessional dave alvin david archuleta david bowie david cook david greenwald david lynch de la soul dead man's bones dead mediadeadmau5 deborah vankin decemberists deerhunterdeftones delphic demi lovato depeche mode destroyerdevendra banhart devo diane birch dibiase dick dalediddy dido die antwoord dierks bentley digital musicdiplo/switch dirty projectors dj a-trak dj am dj muggsdj shadow dr. dre drake drummers dublab duck saucedum dum girls dungen duran duran e. super eagles of death metal echo curio edward sharpe & the magnetic zeros el-p electric daisy carnival elektra records eleni mandell elina shatkin ellie goulding elliott smith elton john elvis costello elvis presley emi eminem entrance band erykah badu esperanza spalding evelyn mcdonnellevery new day is more like "the wire" exile faces to watch 2011 far east movement fela kuti fergie festivals fever ray fighting words film first listen fitz & the tantrumsfive questions flaming lips flo rida flying lotus fol chenfoo fighters food and drink foodies fool's gold four tetfrank fairfield frank nitt freddie gibbs free for all festivalfree the robots freestyle fellowship friendly fires ftf festfuneral party fyf fest game games garfunkel & oatesgarth brooks gavin rossdale genius/gza geoff bouchergerrick d. kennedy ghost of a saber toothed tiger giant drag gifts gil scott-heron girls glasser glasvegas gleegnarls barkley golden gods awards gorillaz grammy awards 2011 grammy museum grammys grandmaster flash grateful dead great northern green day greyson chance grinderman grouplove gucci mane guitar heroguns n' roses guns'n'roses hanni el khatib hard festhealth heavy d heavy metal icons henry clay peopleholiday music holly miranda hollywood bowl hollywood forever hollywood palladium iamsound records ice cubeidol notes iggy pop impending deafness incoming indie rockin' actresses infinite body ingrid michaelson itunesiyaz j.j. cale j.r. rotem jack johnson jack white jamey johnson jane's addiction janet jackson jason derulojason gelt jay dilla jay-z jazmine sullivan jazz jeff weiss jennifer hudson jennifer lopez jenny lewisjessica gelt jim hall jimi hendrix joan baez joanna newsom joe bataan john legend john lennon john lydonjohn mayer john tejada john wiese john zorn johnny cash jonas brothers jonsi josh groban joshua redmanjournimalism joy division juana molina justice justin bieber justin timberlake justin townes earle kanye westkaty perry kcrw ke$ha keith urban kelly clarkson kim gordon kings of leon kisses kode9 kroq kylie minoguel.a. record l.a. unheard lady antebellum lady gaga laura marling lawsuits lcd soundsystem led zeppelin leona lewis leonard cohen liars lil mama lil wayne lily allenlinkin park little boots little dragon little joy live at the times live nation live review living things liz phairlloyd miller lmfao local music local natives local radio lolcat reviews lollapalooza lord huron los angeleslos angeles times los angeles times music producers roundtable los lobos love is all low end theory lucinda williams ludacris m. ward m.i.a. mad men madonnamadvillain mandy moore margaret wappler maria taylor mariah carey mark milian mary anne hobbsmatthewdavid mavado mayer hawthorne mccabe'smelvins men men at work mercury prize merge recordsmerle haggard metallica metric mexicans with guns mf doom mgmt michael jackson mika mike mangan's big organ trio mike posner miley cyrus miranda lambertmitchell frank mixtape moby mog mogwai monicamonster massive morrissey mos def motorhead movie music mtv murs muse music music biz my dry wet mess my morning jacket namm nas nat king cole nate jackson ne-yo neil young neko case nelly nettwerknew album new boyz new kids on the block new musicnew orleans new york news nick cave nickelback nicki minaj nine inch nails ninja tune nirvana nite jewel no age no doubt nobody nocando not not fun notoriousobama obits odd future offspring ok go old school hip hop old style guitar shop one song onra open mike eagle origami vinyl our competitors paid dues pandoraparamore parson red heads paul mccartney pavementpeanut butter wolf pearl jam perfume genius personal playlist pete doherty pete wentz pharrell williamsphenomenal handclap band phish phoenix pink pj harvey plant & krauss poetic symbolism 101 politicspollyn preview prince princeton proximal psychedelic public image ltd. punk rock pure filth q-tip queen latifah queens of the stone age r&b; radio radioheadrage against the machine rainbow arabia rammellzeerancid randall roberts randoms randy lewisrandy newman randy randall ray charles reed johnsonreefer madness refused reissues religion remixes retailreunions review rhapsody rihanna rjd2 robert byrdrobert hilburn robert plant robyn hitchcock rock & rollrock hall rock operas roger waters roll the tanks rolling stones ron asheton root down ryan adams ryan bingham rza sade sage francis santigold sara bareillesscott pilgrim scott t. sterling scott walker screaming females sea wolf sean kingston sean lennon serviceyshania twain she & him shooting at the echo show announcement silver lake jubilee silversun pickups simon reynolds sleigh bells smashing pumpkins smeezingtonssnap judgment snoop dogg so zef, so fres so, it's come to this... so, what's your major? social distortion social media sonic youth soul train soulja boy soundgardensoundstrike soundstrike southern lord spaceland spank rock sparks sports spotify st. vincent stagecoach star trek steve appleford steve lawler sting stones throw sub pop sublime sufjan stevens sugarland summer concert series sun araw sunset junction sunset stripsupergroups swine flu is wrecking everything sxswsystem of a down t bone burnett t-pain t.i. taio cruztake talib kweli tame impala tanya morgan taylor swift techno technology teebs tegan and saratelevision the airborne toxic event the big pink the bird and the bee the cure the dirty projectors the do lab the even greater depression the glitch mob the grateful deadthe grates the greek the knux the like the national the necks the neptunes the next big thing the rolling stonesthe roots the runaways the shins the ting tings the vaselines the veronicas the week in pop (& hiss) the week that will be (in shows) the xx thom yorke ticketmastertiesto tim fite tiron tobacco todd martens tom morello tom petty tom waits tony pierce too soon tool tours travis mccoy trek life trent reznor trey songz troubadour tv on the radio twilightu2 ucla jazz and reggae festival underworld upcomingupright citizens brigade usher valentine's day vampire weekend van halen van morrison vic chesnutt videovillagers vince gill virtual boy virtual reality von bondies wait. think. fast. wale walt disney concert hallwango tango warner music group warpaint watson twinswavves we love you we the people festival we the people festival web/tech weed ween weenie roast weezerwhite rappers white stripes whitney houston wilco wild light will call will oldham wolf parade wolfmotherwonky world music wyclef jean wynonna judd x factoryeah yeah yeahs yelawolf yg young hunting youtubeyvonne villarreal zack de la rocha zef style zola jesus


More from The Times
Varsity Times Insider

Get the Entertainment Newsletter
From screen to stage, music to art.
See a sample | Sign up

Get Alerts on Your Mobile Phone
Mobile Phone (required)

Sign me up for the following lists:
BREAKING - News as it happens
ENVELOPE - The awards insider
ENTERTAINMENT - Hollywood news and buzz
SPORTS - Alerts and scores

More Times Movies Coverage

LATMG Media Kit
LAT Events
About Us
Site Map
Contact Us | Help

Coastline Pilot | Daily Pilot | Huntington Beach Independent | Valley Sun | Burbank Leader | News Press | KTLA | Hoy | Brand X | LA, Los Angeles Times Magazine | ZAP2it Baltimore Sun |Chicago Tribune | Daily Press | Hartford Courant | LA Times | Orlando Sentinel | Sun Sentinel | The Morning Call
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Los Angeles Times, 202 West 1st Street, Los Angeles, California, 90012 | Copyright 2011
A Tribune Web site
Subscribe/Manage AccountPlace An AdLAT StoreJobsCarsReal EstateRentalsMore ClassifiedsCustom Publishing
February 2011January 2011December 2010November 2010October 2010September 2010August 2010July 2010June 2010May 2010April 2010March 2010February 2010January 2010December 2009November 2009October 2009September 2009August 2009July 2009June 2009May 2009April 2009March 2009February 2009January 2009December 2008November 2008October 2008September 2008June 2008February 2008January 2008February 2004