Strenger than Fiction

by Carlo Strenger
| Last Update: 10.01.2011
Israel’s right have eyes but do not see, have ears but do not hear

Israel’s right-wing politicians are trying to divert blame for its isolation onto the country’s liberal critics.

48 comments Barak and Netanyahu Tess Scheflan / Jini 2009
Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
Israel is trapped in paranoid vicious circles

As Netanyahu continues to explain criticism of Israel's settlement policy as a conspiracy to delegitimatize the Jewish state, hatred turns on a real or imagined enemy - Israeli Arabs.

22 comments
Moshe Katsav - Archive - 2007.
How did Israel go from Albert Einstein to Moshe Katsav?

Those who voted for Katsav as president should ask themselves: What did I know about this man? Did I really think he was suited for what is formally Israel’s highest office? Was I capable of thinking beyond petty party politics and personal gain when I cast my vote?

50 comments
Salam Fayyad in Ramallah. AP
The Palestinians must not repeat their mistake of 1947

There are two choices in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict: the two-state solution, or descent of the region into chaos that will make earlier rounds of bloodletting look tame.

64 comments
Mahmoud Abbas (Eran Wolkowski)
A Palestinian state born in South America

The real reason for insisting on the two-state solution is that we want this state to have a Jewish character. And by Jewish we don't mean that it should be a theocracy, or that it should give Jews more rights than Arabs.

38 comments
Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
Israel’s post-traumatic isolation

Israel suffered truly existential threats until 1973, and then severe blows when it gave peace a chance; now many Israelis are deeply angry at anybody who tries to talk them into doing it again.

56 comments
Israel must choose between Enlightenment and Romanticism

Israel's right wing, to an ever growing extent, tends toward the position that Israel should not approve the language of individual human rights accepted today in international politics.

32 comments
Hebrew University Tess Scheflan 9.12.08
Academic objectivity rises above assaults by Europe's left and Israel's right

After endless boycott attempts accusing Israel's universities of cooperating with the occupation, now Israel's right is waging a totalitarian campaign against what they term 'anti-Zionism.'

22 comments
Nicole Krauss AP
Nicole Krauss protests against the duty of loyalty to Jewish history

In her long-awaited third novel, Nicole Krauss makes no attempts at a grand statement. Yet this work does make clear that the task of tying together and preserving the memory of all Jewish generations robs the present of vitality

12 comments
Three cheers for Israel's right

Because the right has been so phenomenally successful in its wise strategies, we can be pretty sure that it will continue to aggravate the world even further.

120 comments
Netanyahu Rabin memorial Knesset 20.10.10 AP
Mr. Netanyahu, you are not Rabin’s partner in peace

An open letter to the prime minister following his address at a memorial service marking 15 years since Yitzhak Rabin's assassination.

4 comments
Yishai Lieberman Knesset Jan2010 Emil Salman
Loyalty oath is not about Arabs, it’s about hatred of liberal values

Isaac Herzog is wrong when he says that fascism lurks at the fringes of Israeli society. It is now in the mainstream.

0 comments
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman
Strenger than Fiction / Political learnings for make benefit of understanding glorious nation of Israel

Israel after years of dedicated experimentation has developed the Glorious New Method of Government by Chaos.

0 comments
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, Reuters, Sept. 23, 2010
Strenger than Fiction / Ahmadinejad’s lesson for the Free World

The Iranian president’s conspiracy theories about 9/11 and his Holocaust denial shows how critical it is that the Free World protect truth from ideology.

0 comments
Gabriela Shalev at UN, January 2009 (AP)
Strenger than Fiction / How (not) to defend Israel

Never lower yourself to the level of Israel’s worst detractors. Don’t ever lie, and don’t twist the facts. Don’t use hollow propaganda phrases; you’ll lose your credibility the moment you do so.

0 comments
David Grossman book cover
Strenger than Fiction / David Grossman - A Guide for the Perplexed

David Grossman’s To the End of the Land is an indispensable guide for those who want to contain in their souls both the triumph and the tragedy that is Israel.

0 comments
Benjamin Netanyahu AP September 5, 2010
Strenger than Fiction / Advice to Netanyahu: Forget Churchill, try de Gaulle

Prime Minister Netanyahu likes to model himself along the lines of great statesmen.

0 comments
A boy peering from under an Israeli flag
Strenger than Fiction / To a Martian, Zionism could be confusing

Imagine an anthropologist from Mars sent to earth to compile a report on Israeli political culture, and to understand the distinction between Zionism and anti-Zionism.

0 comments
Netanyahu, Mitchell and Abbas drawing Eran Wolkowski May 2010
Strenger than Fiction / Peace talks are sure to fail, but what will be the consequences?

Netanyahu probably assumes that the Palestinians will walk out, and he will be justified in maintaining the status quo. But is he prepared for what comes next?

0 comments
Tony Judt
Strenger than Fiction / Tony Judt's Jewish identity

Despite accusations to the contrary, Tony Judt represents an important tradition of Jewishness.

0 comments
Sigmund Freud
The evolving relationship between psychoanalysis and Jewish thought

A look at a timely and welcome collection of essays by Jewish psychoanalysts exemplifying the whole range of Jewish denominations including ultra-Orthodoxy.

0 comments
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman
Strenger than Fiction / Why Israel keeps moving right

Israelis at this point prefer international isolation, painful as it is, to reliance on Arab peace partners for its own security.

0 comments
Khaled Meshal AP June 2010
Strenger than Fiction / Thinking outside of the box about Hamas

Talking to Hamas makes sense for Israel if there are good reasons to believe that, in the long run, the organization will take the course of the ANC and the IRA and move from terror tactics to becoming legitimate players in the political arena.

0 comments
North American Jews making aliyah
Strenger than Fiction / Is Israel alienating the Jews of the world?

Israel's lawmakers and politicians are blissfully unaware of what goes on outside their narrow fishpond, and they have no clue about the effect of their actions on the wider world.

0 comments
PA President Mahmoud Abbas and U.S. peace envoy George Mitchell
Strenger Than Fiction / Israel must admit its mistakes

Like Abbas admitted that the second intifada was one of the worst Palestinian mistakes, Israel needs to admit to its worst mistake: the settlement enterprise.

0 comments
Moshe Ya'alon
Strenger than Fiction / Ya'alon's style of nationalism is driving Israel further into the bunker

Vice Premier Ya'alon believes liberals have a 'distorted' vision of Zionism, but his own form is inflicting harm on Israel and pushing it into deeper isolation.

0 comments
West Bank checkpoint
Strenger than Fiction / Israel should consider a one-state solution

Israel would do well to become a truly liberal, secular state without ethnic dominance in which subgroups no longer impose their way of life on each other.

0 comments
Israeli flag burning Paris
Strenger than Fiction / Just holding on

It seems that the ideal of a liberal society in the Mideast is gradually slipping away; that the forces of nationalism, religious fundamentalism and sheer rage and fear are engulfing us.

0 comments
Gaza flotilla
Strenger than Fiction / Israel's bunker mentality

Israel is stuck in the belief that it is right, and everybody else is wrong and hence incapable of admitting that its policy vis-à-vis the Palestinians has been disastrous.

0 comments
Theodor Herzl
Angry Liberal Zionism can inspire a new generation of Israelis

The ideology of Herzl can give young Israelis a way to express their Jewish identity and without being stifled by right-wing totalitarianism.

0 comments
Hasbara campaign showing a foreign reporter with a camel
Strenger than Fiction / In order to change its image, Israel must change its policy

Saying Israel is progressive and creative doesn't work when its politicians focus on victimhood and aggression.

0 comments
American Professor Noam Chomsky
Strenger than Fiction / Israel is encouraging academic boycott by denying entry to Chomsky

If Israel feels it cannot survive free speech, then it is one step closer to flirting with totalitarianism.

0 comments
Alan Dershowitz in Tel Aviv, January 24, 2001
Strenger than Fiction / A triumph of academic freedom at Tel Aviv University

Behind the scenes a drama unfolded last week which could have done enormous damage to Tel Aviv University, Israel’s higher education system and to Israel as a country.

0 comments
Alan Dershowitz
Strenger than Fiction / The Dershowitz-J Street-JCall debate: Israel supporters needn't speak with one voice

It is important to differentiate between those who delegitimize Israel and those liberal critics who know that Israel is not solely responsible for the absence of peace.

0 comments
Bernard-Henri Levy
Strenger than Fiction / Jewish liberals from all nations, unite

Diaspora Jews around the world are realizing the time has come to reject the right’s dictate that being pro-Israel means that you need to support the policies of Israeli governments, no matter what they do.

0 comments
Israel's leaders have forgotten Herzl's dream

Israel must choose between either holy places and East Jerusalem, or peace and democracy.

0 comments
Can Obama stop the slaying of Isaac and Ishmael?

A U.S. peace initiative is needed to break the tradition of filial sacrifice associated with Jerusalem.

0 comments
Memo to Obama: Two little Hebrew words make all the difference

With the high priority Obama gives the Mideast conflict, he may do well to put his rhetorical skills on the line.

0 comments
Muzzling Israel's left only harms its democracy

Trenchant argument is of vital importance at all times, but even more so in this time of crisis.

0 comments
Why Israel's left has disappeared

The left has failed to provide a realistic picture of the conflict with the Palestinians.

0 comments
The fallacy of Netanyahu's worldview

Netanyahu seems to believe there is no tie between how Israel conducts itself and Arab rejectionism.

0 comments
Netanyahu's fateful midlife crisis

The PM faces one big question: Will he continue stalling, or will he muster the courage for a bold move?

0 comments
Are peace talks doomed to fail before they start?

There is a deep reason the majority of Israelis and Palestinians can't move toward the two-state solution.

0 comments
The peace process as therapy for Israel, Palestinians

The current U.S. reading must be replaced with one that looks at a Middle East scarred by multi-layered traumas on both sides.

0 comments
Israel's liberals are suffering political paralysis

Israel's liberal citizenry has all but disappeared from the political scene, but why?

0 comments
Who is the real Israel: its citizens or its politicians?

Citizens must pressure state to change the system, or we won't regain the pride that Israel could give us.

0 comments
What must Israel do to unify its splintered society?

Forecasts predict total lack of cohesion among different sub-groups within Israel - here's one solution.

0 comments
One-state solution is a blueprint for a nightmare

In a state from the Jordan to the sea there would be an endless Jewish-Palestinian struggle for demographic hegemony.

0 comments
The future belongs to Jewish liberal universalism, Rosh Hashanah 5770

On this Rosh Hashanah, it is time for Jews, religious and secular, to connect around a forward-looking agenda that does not deny our past.

0 comments
Why Israel must become a secular state: a thought for Yom Kippur 5770

The demand for secularization should be supported by all religious Israelis, because it is no less in their interest than it is in that of secular Jews.

0 comments
Ahmadinejad, Netanyahu and the Holocaust: The ethics of memory

In using the Holocaust to defend indefensible policies, Netanyahu harms the ethics of memory that Ahmadinejad is incapable of endorsing.

0 comments
What can the Mideast learn from the phenomenon of Obama?

Imagine a Jerusalem throughout which centers of learning and interfaith dialogue are built.

0 comments
What Netanyahu can give himself, and Israel, for his 60th birthday

Netanyahu at 60 needs to overhaul his worldview from Jewish Exceptionalism to Universalism

0 comments
Memo to Jewish haters of Liberals: The Middle Ages are over

The language of excommunication and apostasy has never been used lightly in Jewish history, and its implications can be dangerous.

0 comments
The world is sick of Netanyahu's lack of policy

Even Israel's friends no longer buy Netanyahu's excuses for doing nothing but build in W. Bank settlements.

0 comments
The future of Israeli high-tech: Jewish brains aren't enough

Netanyahu's claim that Israel's economic growth is unaffected by the general political situation is highly questionable.

0 comments
Shlomo Sand's 'The Invention of the Jewish People' is a success for Israel

Some may be surprised to find that Sand's goal is to preserve Israel as a democracy with a Jewish character.

0 comments
Palestinians have learned from early Zionists

EU recognition of a Palestinian state and capital might reignite the peace process.

0 comments
Tiger Woods and the psychology of spiteful glee

It's not enough that Tiger Woods' name is dragged through the mud; he must be tarred, feathered and humiliated.

0 comments
Save Hanukkah: Keep religion out of politics

Such is the reality of the Mideast that even the most innocent holiday gets tangled up in politics.

0 comments
Jimmy Carter, his apology and Western hatred of Israel

Israel and the Christian world have been locked in a very complex relationship that has deep historical and theological roots.

0 comments
Dear settler, please respect Israel's democracy

At first, I did think you were using a cynical ploy in comparing the settlers to Rosa Parks.

0 comments
Dear Haredim, while you were sleeping, secular Jewish culture was thriving

A response to Aryeh Deri's claim that secular Judaism has given us education but no culture.

0 comments
Lieberman, ethnicity and Israeli politics: an open letter to Yossi Sarid

In an op-ed about Avigdor Lieberman you have tacked one of the most sensitive questions in Israeli society.

0 comments
A pragmatic vision for Israel's Left: A reply to Benny Morris

A credible vision for the Left requires sticking to our moral principles, but to take a much more pragmatic approach to peace-making.

0 comments

About the blog

Carlo Strenger is a psychoanalyst, philosopher and public intellectual engaged in the defense of individual liberty, a high level of public discourse and a sane solution of the Israel-Palestine conflict. A professor of psychology at Tel Aviv University, he studies the difficulties involved in maintaining a stable sense of identity and meaning in the global era.