Books, arts and culture
Prospero
The ruins of Detroit
Up from the ashes
Mar 3rd 2011, 16:58 by G.D. | LONDON
YVES MARCHAND and Romain Meffre, two self-taught French photographers, have always been fascinated by ruins. After seeing photos of the formerly prosperous North American town of Detroit in 2005, they realised it would be a perfect place to work.
Detroit was one of most important American cities in the 20th century. But over the past generation it has suffered perhaps the worst economic downturn of any American city. Schools, libraries, theatres hotels and concert halls that were once sources of pride now stand empty and unloved. Some are being torn down, others are merely crumbling with neglect. Others still, especially in the downtown area, have been purchased by millionaires with plans for renovation, but the process has been a slow one.
Yet Detroit is slowly rising from its ashes. Marchand and Meffre say there are plans to convert quite a few of the downtown buildings into lofts and luxury condominiums in the next ten years. But parts of the city are clearly breathing their last gasp. Marchand and Meffre’s book "The Ruins of Detroit", originally a series for Time magazine, records the lost city of Detroit for posterity. The two photographers spoke to More Intelligent Life about their inspiration for this book.
What is it about “ruins” that you find so alluring?
When a building is abandoned, in some way it’s escaping from us, from our human context. It's like it’s slipping into another reality. We try to depict that. Ruins and buildings are really good metaphors for human nature, for our ability to create and destroy.
A fading and rotting building reminds you how fluctuating and ephemeral things are. Ruins are a kind of humanisation of architecture. Their fragility brings them closer to us. They turn structures that can be perceived as inanimate and cold into something really moving. The Michigan train station for instance is even more iconic as a ruin than if it was clean and painted white.
What were the most distressing photos you had to take?
The most distressing pictures we made were probably those of the schools and libraries full of books. Even if you know the context, you really don't get why it has been left like that, and it says a lot about the loss of culture, lack of education and social waste. This is the great paradox of these ruins. They are not empty but full of objects. It's like consumerism being applied to a whole building, to a whole city; it's a kind of industrial logic of replacement and abandonment. Once a building is useless (when there is a new one in the suburbs or even just next to it for instance) you just throw the old one away, like a disposable product. It's a kind of misery within the abundance and that's what is really troubling.
Was it also a hopeful experience? Decline often gives way to rebirth.
Of course, it's a cycle. Unfortunately the city stayed a little bit longer on the wrong side of the loop compared to some others. Detroit has a very short and violent history, it rose to the very top in 50 years, and fell to the very bottom within 50 years as well. It would not be a surprise to see it rise again. We are optimistic. If a building is still standing, it has the hope of being reused.
"The Ruins of Detroit", published by Steidl, is out now
About Prospero
Named for the hero of Shakespeare's "The Tempest", an expert in the power of books and the arts, this blog features literary insight and cultural commentary from our correspondents, and includes our coverage of the art market.
Advertisement
Economist blogs
- Americas view
- Asia view
- Babbage
- Bagehot's notebook
- Banyan
- Baobab
- Blighty
- Buttonwood's notebook
- Charlemagne's notebook
- Clausewitz
- Daily chart
- Democracy in America
- Eastern approaches
- Free exchange
- Global Leadership
- Gulliver
- Johnson
- Leviathan
- Lexington's notebook
- Multimedia
- Newsbook
- Prospero
- Schumpeter's notebook
- The World in 2011: Cassandra
Most commented
- Charlemagne: No time for doubters
- Turkey and Europe: Mr Erdoğan goes to Germany
- Insurance and rights: Can same-sex bathrooms be far behind?
- China's foreign policy: Setting sail for Libya
- America’s security commitment to Taiwan: From keystone to millstone?
- This week's caption competition: Caption competition 7
- China's pre-emptive crackdown: The people doth not protest
- Oil and the economy: The 2011 oil shock
- Mormons in politics: When the saints come marching in
- The Libyan conundrum: Don't let him linger
Over the past five days
Most recommended
- China's pre-emptive crackdown: The people doth not protest
- China's foreign policy: Setting sail for Libya
- Turkey and Europe: Mr Erdoğan goes to Germany
- Oil and the economy: The 2011 oil shock
- Psychiatry: Therapist-free therapy
- Libya: The limpet's legions
- Mormons in politics: When the saints come marching in
- KAL's cartoon
- Insider trading: A tip too far?
- A special report on feeding the world: The 9 billion-people question
Over the past seven days
Advertisement
Latest blog posts - All times are GMT
- Free books!
- From Prospero
- Reading material
- From Prospero
Subscribe to The Economist's free e-mail newsletters and alerts.
Subscribe to The Economist's latest article postings on Twitter
See a selection of The Economist's articles, events, topical videos and debates on Facebook.
Advertisement
Readers' comments
The Economist welcomes your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful of other readers. Review our comments policy.
Sort:
People in Detroit have taken to calling this sort of thing "ruin porn." Out-of-town journalists come in, snap some shots of the most picturesque abandoned buildings (the train station always makes the cut) and off they go. It's cheap and exploitative, but there seems to be a market for it.
Foretaste of USA in 30 years.
Detroit forever!!! have never been to the USA in my life, but if i somehow do manage a visit i shall make my way to mecca/detroit! The rare soul music from the 1960's (northern soul) has fascinated and enthralled hundreds of thousands of people in the UK for over 40 years!!! NABAY-"BELIEVE IT OR NOT" punch that into youtube and listen to what i mean.
I have every faith in the workers of detroit to transform the situation they presently find themselves in. But it's the same old story in a lot of western countries, whose governments have just sat back and watched manufacturing disappear overseas to cheap labour markets... or in the case of britain just sold all the silverware... to prove to the masses, that the people who they elect are ACTUALLY REPRESENTING THE INTERESTS OF BIG BUSINESS AND NOT THE INTEREST OF THE WORKERS WHO ELECT THEM!
Workers of detroit! a new day is dawning- the social revolution will liberate you- get politicised, read Marx and Trotsky.
KEEP THE FAITH
Ah memories. I lived in Miami for 34 years and so much of what I knew and loved was torn down for profit, then there was Andrew and that destruction and finally, even the language changed.
Chicago will go thru many changes and the people who loved it will go away and a new place will emerge. And those folks will love it just as much as the former did. Time marches on.
Fall of Detroit was because of downturn of Automobile industry. But...
But is it true that it did not rise again because of violence & drug infested young black population which repels new comers, despite low housing prices ???
I suggest that Detroiters start grazing a few sheep and cattle through the ruins. Upper crust British tourists have shown a strong attraction for that sort of thing.
Dark humor aside, this has got to be some sort of portent of things to come. Ordinarily, in the scheme of things in the United States, someone's abandoned property is someone else's opportunity. Why is that not the case in Detroit?
Detroit looks like some scene out of the "Terminator". It's back to the Stone Age, guys.
Scary..
@ lev,d:
Sorry buddy, but you're barking up the wrong tree. Americans stopped reading a long time ago! If you don't beleive me jus watch the shows: "Smarter than a 5th Grader" - NOT or "Jerry Springer" or "Maury Povich" or even "FOX News" for that matter!
The dumbing of America is complete..
@Nirvana-bound,
The american peoples are not responsible for the "dumbing down" of society by the establishment- fox news is a good example. The ruling elite have to keep the masses as disenfranchised as possible, how else could so many ceo's expropriate so many millions of dollars a year wages, or Paulson walk away from his last job with a $120 million dollar golden handshake?
America has given the world the best music the world has, or will, ever know. I could go on with many things America has given the world... as far as the dumbing down process being a fate accompli, i would not agree at all with this. With the death agony of the capitalist system upon us, and the inevitable assault on the living standards of the masses, as the class struggle intensifies the workers will retrace the steps of their illustrious forebears the IWW, the international workers of the world, who fought the guns of the bourgeoisie just for the right to go on strike.
The great detroit will again rise from the ashes of the bankruptcy of the capitalist system, which is so intensly patriotic that they take their industrial production to china, purely for profit, not for the benefit of detroit... the workers will learn very quickly through struggle, the need to build a revolutionary socialist labour party with a leadership willing to fight to the end and cleanse society of all the "financial terrorists" and other unsavoury creatures who are not accountable to anyone but themselves...
"screw you guys, i'm goin' home" Peggy: "Al. i want sex on the kitchen table" Al: "Peg, i want food on the kitchen table! do without, i do".
Workers of detroit and america! a better life is possible, the capitalists are squandering your wealth- organise your own political party through your trade unions, and prepare for power!
workers of the world unite!
I was born and raised in Detroit during the 40's and 50's. I can recall some of the downtown movie theaters with wondrous proscenium, velvet curtains and magnificent pipe organs. It is painful to see the photographs shown as part of this article but I concur that what goes up, comes down, must go up again. I have a great deal of faith that Detroit will rise again, but we really don't build structures the way we used to: the hard woods, the marble, the great stair cases. What rises will be different.
One of the aspects of living in Detroit is seeing these ruins up close, every single day. And it's not just the ruins here; there's a whole lot of empty space from ruins that have since fallen down and been cleared. There are certain areas of the city that look post-apocalyptic--blocks and blocks with nothing but wild flowers and gardens planted by people who live in the 'burbs. And there are whole neighborhoods full of apartment buildings and houses that are destroyed. Is it cheap? Is it exploitative? Yes. But it's also reality. I've lived in and around Detroit for 10 years. I hope in and invest money into its renewal. It's tiring to see people from other cities come in and take pictures of the worst of Detroit; but it makes me hope that we'll get some support not just from locals, but from the entire nation in order to resurrect this town I call home.
The ruins of Detroit are just that: dilapidated, decaying & crumbling buildings in a decaying & crumbling nation. As someone so cogently remarked: a foretaste of what's happening nationwide.
The decline & fall of the not-so-great USofA..
I second the "ruin porn" observation - seems this is the MO for many photogs and journalists, even television shows (ie "Detroit 1-8-7"; for all its good intentions to prop up the city, it operates on much of the same 'ruin porn' principles...)