Demonizing Muslims
Peter King’s hearings pander to religious extremists as well as white supremacists
THE Muslim Americans find themselves in the spotlight all over again. Representative Peter King has taken it upon himself to “save America” from Islam and Muslims, claiming that the community is a clear and present danger to the Land of the Free. The Congressman from New York claims that 85 percent of mosques in the US are run by terrorists and that the Muslim community has not just failed to “stop the radicalization” in its midst, it has become a grave threat to the country. So King has been holding his own court, conducting “public hearings” about the threat of “extremist Islam” to the American way of life.
Now the great melting pot that America is, it has its fair share of all sorts of freaks and fruitcakes. So these rants by King shouldn’t excessively worry the thriving Muslim community in the US or the American society at large. But King is not just like any other politician or lawmaker. He heads the powerful House Homeland Security Committee.
The issue is so serious that in the run-up to the hearings, the White House had to issue a statement affirming its faith in the Muslim community. Several rights groups have also held demonstrations protesting against King’s hearings that are completely one-sided and unabashedly pander to religious extremists and white supremacists. Many in the US media, including the New York Times, have condemned King’s rants against Muslims and ridiculous claims about the community being some sort of fifth column as being “foolish and dangerous.”
However, the damage inflicted by King’s dangerous shenanigans is likely to last long and is bound to add to the woes of the diverse minority community that has already been pushed to the margins after the outrage of 9/11 strikes. Islamophobia in the US and across the Atlantic in Europe has already touched alarming levels. Memories of the storm set off by the vicious campaign against a community center-mosque near the World Trade Center and a Florida priest’s threat to burn the Holy Qur’an last year are still fresh in the minds of Muslims.
The Muslim community has demonstrated admirable restraint, courage and understanding to deal with the blistering wave of anti-Muslim sentiment following the 9/11 attacks and has bent over backward to address the US authorities’ demands and concerns about potential terrorists in its midst. This despite the fact that nearly half of terror plots were thwarted with the help provided by Muslim groups. As Los Angeles County Sheriff Lee Boca insisted at the hearing on Thursday, the Muslim Americans have played a crucial role in “securing our homeland.” More important, the majority of terror attacks since 9/11 were plotted by non-Muslims, especially white supremacists and Christian extremists. Examples include the failed Martin Luther King parade bomber; Jared Lee Loughner, the Arizona shooter who killed six people and Joseph Stack who flew his plane into an IRS building last year. At least a thousand hate groups and anti-government zealots currently operate in the US. So this targeting and demonization of Muslims is not just absurd, it’s downright dangerous. Especially by someone like King who not long ago defended the terrorist attacks by the IRA. That such a hate campaign should be encouraged and tolerated by the Republicans, one of the two main political parties, is most unfortunate and disturbing. For the nuts like King are not just a threat to Muslims and religious peace, they’re a mortal danger to the very idea of America.
Comments
AHMED
Mar 13, 2011 23:04
Report abuseNISHTHAR IDROOS
Mar 13, 2011 23:16
Report abuseWILLOUGHBYLLOYD@SBCGLOBAL.NET
Mar 13, 2011 23:18
Report abuseU. MADHA
Mar 13, 2011 23:23
Report abuseSINGER
Mar 14, 2011 10:01
Report abuseMUHAMMAD ASIM RASHID
Mar 14, 2011 10:06
Report abuseAMERICAN
Mar 14, 2011 10:10
Report abuseThis is another one of those editorials claiming victimhood for Muslims with plenty of veiled threats. Sorry, but the American public is not buying it. According to the most recent Rasmussen Report conducted March 8-9, 2011:
[...Most voters donâ™t believe their fellow citizens are unfair to Muslim Americans. They also think Muslims in this country (America) should be louder in their criticism of potential domestic terrorist attacks...only 10% of all voters think American Muslims are speaking out enough against potential terrorist attacks in the United States...Most Americans now fear that the political unrest in Arab nations like Egypt and Libya may get America into another big war.Â
But 80% of voters now think terrorism is a bigger threat to the country than traditional wars. Seventy-three percent (73%) fear a terrorist threat more than a nuclear attack... ]
These are Congressional hearings, NOT a witch hunt! People are testifying as to why Muslims are radicalized and why not enough is done by the Muslim community against terror. If most terrorist were Lutherans from Minnesota, then there would be hearings on those.
No Muslims are being denied their rights, jobs, housing or equal treatment under the law. Muslims are not being rounded up en masse and imprisoned, killed or deported. Which is more than one can say for nonMuslims in Islamic states.
Saudis demand that the kingdoms values be respected. Guess what, Americans demand the same in their country. Respect American laws and values or leave. The article claims that the hearings are demonizing Muslims. That is an unmitigated lie. It is Muslims who demonize the west and everything that is nonMuslim. One can read plenty of that right here at Arab News every day of the week.
Americans have memories too. They remember many unprovoked attacks by Muslim terrorists on Americans and others since 1979. Americans remember seeing photos and videos of Muslims celebrating, dancing in the streets and passing out sweets after the 9/11 attacks. The Palestinians are today celebrating the recent murders of a whole family, including little children, by once again passing out sweets.
That sort of savage behavior does not show Muslims in a good light.
The idea of America is in no danger. Muslims in America are in no danger. They can live freely like all other people in the U. S. Terrorism is the greater mortal danger to Muslims, because terrorists target, maim and kill more Muslims than nonMuslims.
Only Muslims can stop islamist terror. Once terror is stopped by Muslims, there will be no need for any more Congressional hearings.
ISMAEEL MARIKAR
Mar 14, 2011 10:11
Report abuseIt was orchestrated and staged, to get into Iraq and afghanistan. Despite there being no approval of the UN Security Council, that illegal war goes on, where they are bogged down..Millions have been killed and "trillions" spent to kill them.More Americans have been killed in this war than those killed on 9/11.
There have been cartoons, threatened Quran burnings and what not , all
to blame Islam for the problems created by their democracy and capitalism.
Take a count and you will find that more and more Christians are abandoning their religion and becoming Muslims. Take a count and you
will find that there are more Qurans than American Flags being sold.
The more you go on the offensive against Islam, you will find it counterproductive.It has been proved in history.
However much muslims are demonized.its growing.
As Nishtar suggests Islam is the answer, it is the solution, not
the problem as misread by most people.
DR. SHABBIR THINGNA
Mar 14, 2011 10:11
Report abuseFIL MUNAS
Mar 14, 2011 10:11
Report abuseRAHMATOOLA RUJEEDAWA
Mar 14, 2011 10:14
Report abuseMOHAMED ISMAIL
Mar 14, 2011 10:15
Report abuseANTAR IBN-STANFORD
Mar 14, 2011 10:18
Report abuseDear Representative King:
If you want to discuss decreasing terrorism, you need to discuss support for terrorist states like Israel. How Israel came into existence cannot be ignored if justice and peace is to be achieved. Support for the creation of a nation as a result of ethnic cleansing and support from colonial powers is unacceptable. Accepting the creation of Israel and rejecting the rights of Palestinians is tantamount to not only accepting but also rewarding the following:
⢠In 1918 the reality on the ground was that Jews owned about 2% of the total land area of Palestine and were 8% of the population. ⢠In 1948 Jews dispossessed over 800,000 Palestinians from over 500 towns and villages. ⢠After 1948, 92% of the land that became Israel was formerly Palestinian. ⢠The land was not sold or freely given up. There were expulsions, military assaults, massacres, and fear of assaults and terrorism.
Examples of the later, as pointed out by the Palestinian Academic Society for the Study of International Affairs, include:
⢠1948 April 9: Irgun and Stern Gangs lead by Menahem Begin and Yitzhaq Shamir massacre 245 Palestinians in the village of Deir Yassin, western suburb of Jerusalem. ⢠April 11: Haganah destroy village of Kalonia near Qastel and occupy Deir Yassin. ⢠April 30: All Palestinian quarters in West Jerusalem occupied by Haganah and Palestinians were driven out.
Many politicians condemn the response of Israelâ™s neighbors as being âÂÂœconstant aggression.â This is ignoring the right of Palestinians to resist the impositions of colonial powers and Israelâ™s mass expulsions and ethnic cleansing of Palestinians. The only possible reasons for ignoring these acts stem from a lack of concern for the rights of Palestinians. I have no doubt that if Palestinians had had our support, they would not have attacked and killed civilians. If they are given their just rights, they would not resort to attacking civilians. The American civil rights slogan, âÂÂœNo justice, no peace,â is more than slogan. Itâ™s a reality.
Many politicians insist that âÂÂœthe United States enjoys shared democratic values.â Iâ™m wondering if those values include support for Israelâ™s Law of Return and rejection the Palestinians Right of Return. The Law of Return 5710-1950 reads as follows: âÂÂœRight of aliyah (immigration of Jews). 1. Every Jew has the right to come to this country as an oleh (Jew immigrating, into Israel).â The Palestinian Right of Return is clearly expressed by Al-Awda, the Palestine Right to Return Coalition, which affirms that the Palestinian Arab people, regardless of their religious affiliation, are indigenous to Palestine. Therefore, they are entitled to live anywhere in Palestine which encompasses present-day "Israel", the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Al-Awda regards the "Israeli" definition of Jewish nationals, granting exclusive rights to citizenship and land to any Jew from anywhere in the world, as part of the racism and discrimination inherent in Zionist ideology which underlies the policies and laws of the settler state of "Israel".
Not only is the Right of Return morally correct, but is also legally correct.
Al-Awda presents a three point legal basis. It reads: 1. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights article 13 affirms: "Everyone has the right to leave any country, including his own, and return to his country." 2. The International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination [Article 5 (d)(ii)], states: "State parties undertake to prohibit and to eliminate racial discrimination on all its forms and to guarantee the right of everyone, without distinction as to race, color, or national or ethnic origin, to equality before the law, notably in the enjoyment of ... the right to leave any country, including one's own, and to return to one's country." 3. The International Convention on Civil and Political Rights [Article 12(4)], states: "No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of the right to enter his own country."
Some politicians insist that Israel is âÂÂœa reliable and valuable partner in meeting U.S. goals for stabilization in the region.â This position bewilders me. It bewilders me why the U.S. only speaks of peace and stabilization in the Middle East and never mentions justice. Is it because of attempts to avoid addressing the issues of ethnic cleansing, mass expulsion, Israelâ™s being founded on terrorism and support of colonial powers, and the acceptance of Israelâ™s Law of Return and rejection of Palestiniansâ™ Right of Return? This policy reminds me of the policy towards Native Americans and rebellious enslaved Africans. That policy is embodied in the following. On March 5, 1821 President James Monroe said in his Second Inaugural Address: President Chester A. Arthur wrote in the Annual Message of the President to the Senate and House, "it is confidently hoped that serious outbreaks will not again occur and that the Indian tribes which have far so many years disturbed the West will hereafter remain in peaceable submission" (12/4/1883). Stabilization of the Middle East via ethnic cleansing and military might is unacceptable.
Why the increase in terrorism? One answer is the total unwillingness for politicians, government officials and the media to have a discuss or hearing concerning the blind support for Israel. Sincerely, Antar I. Smith, Ph.D. Near Eastern Studies
JANINE
Mar 14, 2011 10:19
Report abuseIt's also very true that there are many non-Muslims in the USA who have been committing terrorist crimes which the Western media outrageously blamed upon Muslims w/o any shred of proof.
Just to name a few is Eric Rudolf, who hid in the underground caves of North Carolina and eluded our law enforcement agencies including the FBI, for many years. Another is Ted Kozinski, the Unibomber who also did the same, until his own brother turned him in. There are many more such terrorists who bombed clinics in the USA due to their extreme Christian views.
The Jewish extremists in America have also killed innocents whose crimes were downplayed in many American news sites.
In NYC just this past week, some well known American celebrities took part in a protest against King's diabolical hearings. By showing their support for the Muslim community, they shed light on a dirty little secret known as bigotry. Thank goodness for such Americans who reflect the genuine aspirations, hopes and dreams the United State's Founding Fathers and its Constitution. Peter King has done a fine job of trying to shred this great document with his abuse of Constitutional powers which he should have never been granted by the voters of New York. It's high time he was voted out of power.
J. Smith
Dover, Delaware
USA
AMIN SHARIEFF
Mar 14, 2011 10:20
Report abuseThere is a sectionof muslims that believe in a sterile, intolerant and contemptous islam. They view ALL others as not worthy of any importance threatening not only non muslims but also the vast majority of muslims.
I am no sure how alluding to this is 'witch humting'. Its interesting to note that there are more buddhists in the US than muslims yet they are not a source of any phobias. Why is that ? Its simple.
Some muslims are inflexible and want all the advantages of living in the west but reject the civic responsibilities that accompany it. Its not how it works. If muslims are not cognisant of this fact, ther are many 'muslim' countries out there to emigrate to. Expats in KSA have such a fulfilling life after all.
Islam is welcome in the US, but intolerance is not. As long as it will be projected from muslims towards others, it will be reciprocated. When the muslim world sheds its own prejudice, that will stop people from viewing it with suspicion. Till that time, expect scrutiny. None of us need a bomb to explode to end my life because some zealot thinks its the 'right' islamic thing to do.
GEORGE
Mar 14, 2011 10:21
Report abuse?
Mar 14, 2011 10:25
Report abuseGENE
Mar 14, 2011 10:41
Report abuseWe must all get a grip on the realities of the situation. We have rogue elements trying hard to kill as many Americans as possible using the name of Islam. The mothers and fathers all Muslim are testifying before this body and telling how their children have been lost to this madness and are now dead or in jail for planning mass murder of people they do not even know. I am very sorry my friend, but, Al Qada is not Islam it is a group of people bent on death and more death..
SAUD BIN TURKI ALSAUD
Mar 14, 2011 10:48
Report abuseKHALID AL-SAUD
Mar 14, 2011 13:07
Report abuseABDULAZIZ AL ZAHRANI
Mar 14, 2011 13:07
Report abusePHILIP B. CEZAR
Mar 14, 2011 13:08
Report abuseVIVEK
Mar 15, 2011 00:57
Report abuseREX
Mar 15, 2011 01:09
Report abuseEMW1
Mar 15, 2011 01:12
Report abuseDESERTDUNES
Mar 15, 2011 01:14
Report abuseI believe this guy is a Born Again Christian, the same faith who are trying to spread rumors of impending trouble here in KSA,
STEVE JAMES
Mar 15, 2011 01:14
Report abuseHASSAN ALI
Mar 15, 2011 01:17
Report abuseS2R786
Mar 15, 2011 01:18
Report abuseSALMAN
Mar 15, 2011 01:30
Report abuseNISHTHAR IDROOS
Mar 15, 2011 01:34
Report abuseJHAMADI
Mar 15, 2011 01:37
Report abusePeter King is holding these hearings to understand why so many young Islamic males have been commiting acts of terror around the world in the name of their faith. Fair question.
DR MERSAL
Mar 15, 2011 05:20
Report abuseMITCH
Mar 15, 2011 05:22
Report abuse