49 captures
14 Mar 2011 - 28 Jul 2020
About this capture

HuffPost Has An Android App
Download and install it here

Smarter Ideas| More...

Log In | Sign Up
March 14, 2011

WORLD Get Alerts

Uriel Abulof
Assistant professor, Tel-Aviv University; Associate, Princeton University’s Liechtenstein Institute on Self-Determination
Posted: March 10, 2011 03:20 PM
Become a Fan
Get Email Alerts Bloggers' Index
What Is the Arab Third Estate?
Read More: 1848 , Abbé Sieyès , Clash Of Civilizations , Egypt Internet , Egypt Revolution , Egypt Riots , Egyptian Revolution , End Of History , Ethnicity , Failed States , French Revolution , Jean-Jacques Rousseau , John Locke , Napoleon Bonaparte , Nationalism , Social Contract , Spring Of Nations , Tahrir Square , The Middle East , The People Want To Bring Down The Regime , Thomas Hobbes , Tunisia Protests , What Is The Third Estate , World News

share this story
Get World Alerts
Sign Up
Submit this story
digg reddit stumble
On July 1, 1798, just before disembarking on the shores of Alexandria -- in what is often depicted as the moment when the West, indeed modernity itself, landed in the Middle East -- Napoleon enlightened his troops: "The first city we will encounter was built by Alexander [the Great]. We shall find at every step great remains worthy of exciting French emulation." By noon, the Mamluk army had fled; the modern force had had its way, oriental emulation notwithstanding. Napoleon now called upon the local population to distance themselves from their usurpers: "People of Egypt, they have told you that I come to destroy your religion, but do not believe it... I come to restore your rights." He did not.
For two long centuries, the Arab Middle East has struggled to meet the challenge of modernity, a task exacerbated by the lingering, and increasing, dissonance between the glorious past and the shameful present. Measures were taken, of course. But they were just that -- means to ends, rather than the essence of change. Techniques and technologies were imported, as were the shells of ideologies. Turning to copy-paste (with special formatting), Arab autocrats capitalized on post-colonialism, socialism and pan-Arabism ostensibly to restore Arabs' rights. They have not.
Then came the war and the writing on the wall. The defeat of 1967 prescribed for many the age-old panacea: "Islam is the Solution" (الإسلام هو الحل).‎
But wherever a heavy dose was taken, as in Iran and Sudan, on the outskirts of the Arab world, the patients got sicker. The oppressive Iranian regime is engulfed in an acute legitimacy crisis, and Sudan, the largest African country, is about to be dismembered for its regime's genocidal inclinations.
It is easy to mistake the contemporary Arab Middle East for the Middle Ages. Since 2002, the UNDP series of Arab Human Development Reports, written all by Arab experts, has charted the past and present of a politically stalled region. On key parameters of progress -- be they poverty and unemployment (2002), knowledge gap (2003), freedom (2004), gender inequality (2005), or human security (2009) -- Arab states and societies lag behind. Enlightenment, liberty, and peace -- the holy trinity of modernity -- seems to have gone AWOL. Still, the riches beneath the earth, foreign aid and advanced technologies allowed the Arab world to join other developing countries in improving health, education and living standards -- containing political change. This deformed social contract -- combining Hobbesian politics with Lockean (ostensibly neo-liberal) economics -- for long seemed to be doing well, insulating the state from the street through the former's security apparatus and patronage networks.
Then came the revolution, the Tunisian "black swan" and the (mass) "demonstration effect" across the region. We political scientists and Mideast experts, accustomed to asking, and trying to answer, Bernard Lewis's aching still-echoing question -- '"what went wrong?" -- may now have to recast it into "what took you so long?" Yet we lack sufficient answers. Too many theories seem now either false or non-falsifiable. We have not foreseen the future, and may have been myopic about the present as well.
Still, we must hone our vision, perhaps inventing a new one. For the last generation, since the fall of the wall, two seemingly contradictory visions have guided our political thought: Francis Fukuyama's End of History and Samuel Huntington's Clash of Civilizations​. Amidst this "clash of histories," we now seek insights. One coded image tells it all. The photograph of the mass demonstration in the once-titular Square of Liberation, Cairo, during Friday prayer is the Rorschach test of our age.
In this digital ink we recognize the Janus-face of the shape of things to come. In the middle of the square the big banner declares the uprising's motto: "The people want to bring down the regime." We have seen it once before, in 1989: it must be the end of the Arab world as we know it, the end of history revisited and finally vindicated, with the universal call of democracy answered by its last outlier. Then we see the immense crowd, the thousands of orderly lines, prostrating on the ground, signaling submission (that is, Islam) to the will of God. Isn't that 1979 reincarnated? The autocratic devil we know and can deal with now ousted in favor of a great unknown soon to be taken over by the inevitable theocracy. After all, they belong to another, innately antagonistic, civilization.
Both readings appeal to our hopes and fears, to our minds, to tell the ideal from the real. Still, we have got lost in translation.
Virtually all English renditions of the uprising's call missed its singular, key letter: "The people wants to bring down the regime." This seeming semantics marks a sea-change in political ethics. For in the two long centuries since Napoleon landed in Alexandria, the moral foundation of modern politics -- popular sovereignty -- has been absent from the Arab Middle East. The Arab people became the object for colonizers, dictators and imams, with their call to submission and arms. Never a subject for thought and action, the people lacked political agency, powerless to forge a collective moral self, let alone a nation to demand self-determination: the right to tell right from wrong in the public sphere.
Whether Arab popular uprisings will eventually transform political systems -- thus nominally qualified as real revolutions -- remains to be seen. But one revolution is real and clear: the people (شعب, sha'ab) was born -- a collective, rather than a collection, of individuals, a whole greater than the sum of its parts. The uprising's slogan was not simply, as one might have expected, "down with the regime." It is precisely because the demonstrates felt that the existence of such a people, let alone one in possession of agency, is far from obvious, that they added, in a resolute speech-act -- an act created by speech -- "the people wants."
In an irony of fate, the autocrats' success was their undoing. Reifying Arab states forged public patriotism; glorifying pan-Arabism brought down the dominoes; and finally, importing new technologies planted a Trojan digital horse -- the information revolution -- in their midst. Easily monitored, it was less a tactical resource for orchestrating the popular uprisings and more a strategic source for imagining the people, a people, in the first place. The social network undermines the fragmentation that underlines the social contracts of both Hobbes and Lock.
Nine years before Napoleon paid his visit to the Middle East, Abbé Sieyès wrote what would soon become the manifesto of the French Revolution. Pondering on the three traditional "estates of the realm" -- clergy, nobility, and commoners -- Sieyès challenged their division and hierarchy. His preambling Q & A echoed throughout France: "What is the Third Estate? Everything. What has it been until now in the political order? Nothing. What does it ask? To become something."
And so it was; and so it is, with the Arab world today. By corporal and virtual social networking, it has re-found and founded its Third Estate. The deficiencies of the deformed Hobbesian and Lockean social contracts have left in their wake Rousseau's volonté générale​, the general will of the people. Whether 2011 will eventually lead to an Arab edition of 1989 or 1979 is still unclear, but 1789, better yet 1848, is near. And as with the European Spring of Nations, the (up)rising of Arab nations, while prone to mishaps, is bound to change the region's geopolitics, ushering the Middle East into a new era of re-aligning identities with authorities, policies, and -- eventually -- polities.
Important as the new governments' policies surely are, of deeper significance are the choices to be made by the peoples -- between divine and popular sovereignty, between civic and ethnic nationalisms. There may be (more) blood. Not all Arab states are certain to engender peoplehood, and failed peoples may well engender failed states. Not all Mideast peoples have states, and stateless peoples may well demand they do. Asking, and, even better, answering, 'What is the Arab Third Estate?' will help both Arab peoples and foreign powers advance the cause of peaceful change.
1 of 2
Arab unrest: Build your own revolutionary index | The Economist
Iran Basks in Unrest of Arab World - NYTimes.com
U.S. Struggles To Keep Up With Arab World Changes : NPR
Good AP roundup of today's Arab world news ...
sxsw curated by @meedan
Increase in oil revenue amid unrest in Arab world gives Russia some breathing room | Russia in Foreign Media | RIA Novosti
More in World...

Egypt's Revolutionaries Face Constitutional Battle
Japan Nuclear Plant Rocked By Second Blast,...
Atlantis, Lost City Swamped By Tsunami, May...
Hiromitsu Shinkawa, Japanese Man, Saved 2 Days...
Pending Comments
View FAQ
Login or connect with: 
More Login Options
Post Comment
Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
Share your Comment:
Post to Facebook.
Post to Blogger.
Post to Twitter.
Post to WordPress.
Post to TypePad.
Post to Tumblr.
Post to Yahoo!
View All
Recency  | Popularity
Jabel   1 hour ago (1:23 PM)
0 Fans
A beautifull​­y presented thesis. But we should remember that virtually none of the North African and more so the Asian Islamic countries are natural entities; almost all were the creations of the West and mostly in the twentieth century. So is there a people to be found in each of these states? If we do see open free and fair elections - in itself, I think, an unlikely propositio​­n - we will then see what will emerge. But that is only a start. We have in our time witnessed free elections that have turned out to be the last free election. Despite the elegance of this piece I am not sure yet that there really is an Arab Third Estate? I hope, however, that I will be proved wrong.
Jabel: A beautifully presented thesis. But we should remember that virtually
Permalink  | Share it
bennymorr   7 hours ago (7:25 AM)
0 Fans
Very nice piece. But the question really renmains whether the crowds we see and the slogans we hear in the squares (Cairo, Tunis, Sanaa) are really vox populi or just the voice of the (Westernis​­ed part) of the middle class. The answer to this question will be provided when these states hold free elections - and the masses may well opt for Islam rather than liberal democracy.
Benny Morris
bennymorr: Very nice piece. But the question really renmains whether the
Permalink  | Share it
CAMBEL   01:45 PM on 3/11/2011
504 Fans
I hope that the Middle East brings along women for the ride whicever direction it moves. It can bring tears to my eyes reading about women not being allowed outside without a make guardian in Saudi Arabia. I think that this is a time of hope.
CAMBEL: I hope that the Middle East brings along women for
Permalink  | Share it
Taxim   11:18 AM on 3/11/2011
19 Fans
The "Arab World" has been under one flavor of colonialis​­m of another for over 500 years. Remove the imperialis​­ts, their representa​­tives and puppets, and eliminate the superpower​­s and then we will see what the Arab world is capable of. About 10 years.
Taxim: The "Arab World" has been under one flavor of colonialism
Permalink  | Share it
cdncommentator   04:33 PM on 3/10/2011
79 Fans
A very well written and considered article. I recommend it to all those interested in the middle east, and particular​­ly, those with only minimal understand​­ing and a black and white focus on everything​­.
cdncommentator: A very well written and considered article. I recommend it
Permalink  | Share it
New comments on this entry — Click to refresh
Loading comments…
Most Popular on HuffPost
1 of 2
Fukushima Explosion: Japan Nuclear Plant Rocked By Hydrogen Explosion (VIDEO)
PHOTOS: Devastating Shots Of Japan's Massive Quake
Alec Baldwin Two and a Half Men Is Better Than None
Stylelist: Kate Middleton Bikini Photo Is White Hot
Popeater: Lisa Rinna and Star Jones Got 'Ugly' Behind the Scenes of 'Apprentice'
Japan Earthquake 2011: Battered Country Faces Threat Of Nuclear Meltdown As Death Toll Rises
Mary Bottari WI Firefighters Spark "Move Your Money" Moment
Popeater: Natasha Henstridge Ties the Knot in Secret Ceremony
Jobs Articles: PARADE'S What People Earn: Celebrity Salaries Revealed
Don't Miss HuffPost Bloggers
1 of 5
Dylan Ratigan
Rescue Choppers or Corporate Jets?
Jimmy Kimmel
A Dramatic Story, at the End of Which Nothing Happens
In Japan, Worry — and Confusion — Over Nuclear Risk
Tokyo: Bicycles Sell Out as Stranded Commuters Turn to Pedal Power
Online Offering: Send Aid to Japan Using Social Media
Time - World
Japan's nuclear crisis widens
Japan's nuclear crisis widens
Violence in Bahrain, Yemen; Oman's ruler cedes some power
More World News at latimes.com
1 of 7
Rescues start in Japan
Raw Video: Boat Caught in Japan's Swirling Water
Raw Video: Quake Shakes Items Off Store Shelves
Japan Nuclear Plant Rocked By Second Blast
Hundreds Of Bodies Wash Ashore After Quake
INTERACTIVE: Before & After Japan Earthquake (SATELLITE PICS)
A Dramatic Story, at the End of Which Nothing Happens
RT @jimmykimmel: for those interested in my tsunami story, the whole thing, in detail http://huff.to/hU06rA
Former U.S. Sen. Evan Bayh lands gig as a Fox News contributor - Huffington Post http://huff.to/e0YirU
Surgery Helps Main Regain Fertility After Cancer
The Best Carrot Recipes From Food52.com
What Does Michele Bachmann's Grasp Of History Mean For The Children?
2012 Speculatron
HUFFPOST HILL - Politico: Civil Rights Don't Win Mornings
HuffPost Hill
Gilbert Gottfried Fired As Aflac Duck After Japanese Tsunami Tweets
Japan Tsunami
Cable News Ratings On First Day Of Japan Quake Show Several Different Winners
St. Lucia Responds To Attack On 3 Gay American Tourists
International Destinations
Martin Harty Resigns In Wake Of Suggesting Mentally Disabled Be Sent To Siberia
Amber Rose Reveals Her Weight, Asks 'How Am I Fat?'
Celebrity Body
more big news pages »

WORLD Get Alerts

<img src="https://web.archive.org/web/20110314224537im_/http://b.scorecardresearch.com/p?c1=2&amp;c2=6723616&amp;c3=&amp;c4=&amp;c5=world&amp;c6=&amp;c15=&amp;cj=1" width="1" height="1" alt=""/> <img src="//web.archive.org/web/20110314224537im_/http://pixel.quantserve.com/pixel/p-6fTutip1SMLM2.gif?labels=World" style="display:none" height="1" width="1" alt="Quantcast"/> <img src="//web.archive.org/web/20110314224537im_/http://secure-us.imrworldwide.com/cgi-bin/m?ci=us-703240h&amp;cg=0&amp;cc=1&amp;ts=noscript" width="1" height="1" alt=""/>