The CWG opening show reality: Rs 350 crore : Sports : Rajesh Kalra : TOI Blogs
You are here: Home Blogs Sports

RANDOM ACCESS

The CWG opening show reality: Rs 350 crore

Rajesh Kalra
05 October 2010, 04:38 PM IST


The praise for the Commonwealth Games’ opening ceremony has been uniform, including from those who have been the bitterest critics over the months, such as the media in Australia and UK. Remember, it was the set of pictures on the BBC website of the filthy games village that turned viral, that did more harm to our image than perhaps all else put together.

Going by the reactions from world over, the stunning opening ceremony, not only wiped off that smear, but may have established us as someone who can deliver on the big stage, when it matters. The overall concept, the colours and organised chaos was so spectacular that some of niggles such as the lack of synchronisation among those who formed the tri-colour etc were easily overlooked. The object of much discussion in the run up to the ceremony, the aerostat, was the star enabler of the show. I wouldn’t call it the star, for that was undoubtedly the classical dancers and musicians of India who showcased to the world how diverse we are and how beautiful we can look when together. Another thing the opener achieved was to reinforce the widely held belief that we have an unparalleled ability to somehow make things happen against all odds, at the last moment. However, whether one should take it as a compliment or not is debatable.

The nation is mighty proud of the show, deservedly so, and the smooth conduct of the rest of the games would easily add to this growing sense of pride. Even the much ridiculed Organising Committee and the sundry ministers and officials involved with the games would bask in the success, hoping the stains of their past misdeeds would now be forgotten.

I don’t want to sound a party pooper, but do you know how much that spectacular 2.5 hours ceremony cost the nation? Brace yourself. It was Rs 350 crore. The original budget for the ceremony was Rs 50 crore. I can understand exceeding the original budget, for the cost of aerostat and its added paraphernalia alone was Rs 60 crore. But the rest of the ceremony cost Rs 290 crore! I spoke to several big event organisers and all of them were stunned at the amount claimed to have been spent on the ceremony.

In all fairness, shouldn’t we demand that the government show transparency for a change and share with us taxpayers the category wise list of expenses.

I am sure very few of us are against hosting big ticket events. For a nation with growing aspirations, events such as the opening ceremony help bolster its international appeal. But we are willing to spend the amount that is genuinely required for the event, not something that is so shamelessly and brazenly inflated that it looks obscene. Rip us apart, but not like this.

As I have often said in the past, it is easy to get carried away by the successes and there would soon be clamour for hosting the Olympics too. But if we are going to be spending money as recklessly as this, it is not on. It may just bring temporary succour in the form of international appreciation, but will suck us dry even more. To forgive and forget those who have plundered our money and fattened their bank balances at our cost in the garb of these games would be stupid.

Follow Rajesh Kalra on Twitter

175 Comments |  Comments are closed. Rated
Do you like this post?

Related Blog Posts

 
 
 

Comments:

Sort by: Newest | Oldest | Recommended (174) | Most Discussed (26) | Author´s Responses (5) | Agree (175)


Sukhi Kaur_Birmingham says:

October 17,2010 at 12:39 AM IST

Further to your blog,I think the nations outside India were awed after the spectacular show but, however I think that money could have been distrbuted to the poor instead of putting on a glamorous shows like that, becuase even after the oppening show there was still criticism i.e. with the running track, distraction from spectators when other nations were playing like England, the isue with the swimming pool etc.

 

sashi says:

October 16,2010 at 02:07 AM IST

From a retired Army Colonel after all said and dfone will soomeone compare wmg and cmg in terms of money and no of cpountries participating . I think army did a much better job

 

sameer suryaji says:

October 15,2010 at 02:24 AM IST

The peoples found guilty should be behind the bars on cwg scams. The cost of cwg was 20 times more ie 70000 cr then 3500 cr. Is for this we pay tax to country. It dept should see who r the peoples who became millionare after cwg. we must never forget CORRUPTION starts at Top. Its shame to say by me that Mr. Kalmadi is from Maharastra. WE NEED JUSTICE. Let is show that no one is bigger than LAW.

 

utkarsh says:

October 14,2010 at 08:53 PM IST

well i want to make following points regarding this article and the comments: 1. the figure given by author is unverified. saying our govt spent 350cr is one thing but what is the credibility of information. no audit can be performed of such megaevent in such short span of time. so the possible inference is that the author cooked the information just for the sake of criticizing govt. The public reaction is shortsighted and we immediately start bashing our government. This is similar to the aussie reporter who cooked up the story in which he takes a bomb in the games village.Such kind of media should be highly discouraged. 2. Many people above commented that the government should give an account of spending of taxpayers money. They should be aware that government presents an account of all reciepts and expenditure done annually in the parliament called budget. It accounts for every single penny spent by our govt.A copy of budget can be availed through GOI website 3.Suggesting that people should stop paying tax is not a good suggestion. Tax receipts are essential for running our economy and there is much more spending than just a single event. 4.Suggesting that the current government does not represent public goodwill is not correct totally. Afterall it is a democratically elected government by the people.If people have any issues with the government they have the electoral power to vote. Why criticize the government which has been chosen by the you....???? NOTE: i am not suggesting that there is not any corruption in the organizing committee. what i am saying is that we should not mindlessly bash the authorities without looking into depth. It is our country and our government. Corruption always starts from the grassroots which is us. It is a complete democratic setup which gives power to the citizens. All they need is to be aware. Criticism would be welcome. mera bharat mahaan

 

Rakesh says:

October 14,2010 at 03:00 PM IST

Can the media use RTI to unearth more details and present it infront of the people?

 

hortense vaughan says:

October 10,2010 at 04:39 AM IST

This crap about the CWG opening ceremony reflecting Indian culture is just that :there was not one bloody elephant or sacred cow featured and not even a skit from the Kama Sutra. The Tokyo Seoul Sydney and Beijing Olympic Games opening ceremonies were far superior.

 

Kumar says:

October 09,2010 at 06:22 PM IST

Can we use our Right to Information to get information on the CWG (Games) scam budget????

 

sheereen says:

October 09,2010 at 12:25 PM IST

hey i have a total quality management project to make..i am doing it on CWG..and i need to have the list of all the expenses..the detailed alloted budget for the entire event and so on..where could i end up getting it

 

Saurabh says:

October 09,2010 at 10:31 AM IST

look, can I say something frdnz..??I am sure about that everyone in the world(not only Indians), will do the same when he/she will get the opportunity to earn some(or huge) amount of money without revealing anything.And we are discussing this thing, because it's a huge amount. But, let me divert this thing to a different aspect. When a corporation/municipality gives a tender(eg : road construction) to a contactor; is he not going to gobble a large amount from that govt money?Isn't that the tax-payer's money(our money) also.??So, why dont we file a case against them..??Those constructions are also not very good and those roads are also damaged after facing a single rainy season torture..??So, lets shout against them also..??We are talking about corruption in CWG.Let me remind you, we all know about corruptions we are facing day by day from very ground level.When a policeman stops your bike for breaking traffic rule;does he makes a receipt for the fine.??Or just he takes some money from you and then leaves you.Kalmadi and his committee is also the common people.They are also the face of other Indians also.More specifically they are somehow like us.So, how is it possible for them to be different when all the rest of India is running by the same mentality.I saw in the Indian Railways, that the Ticket Chekers there taking lots of illegal money from the people who are taking some luggage in railways without giving any receipt.So, are they not the criminals.We all face these issues everyday.So, lets make a investigation file on each of these issues.Try to punish them for what they done.We want to eradicate corruption ;let's start it from the ground level.Then,in the next big event we will automatically get good Kalmadi & co. Which is going to spend all the money in the right way.We dont need to file a investigation against them.Then, these things will change.Otherwise, these things will happen in the same way in near future also.

 

Kenai says:

October 09,2010 at 09:09 AM IST

You Indians deserve it. In India only salaried are taxed. NOBODY else pay taxes. You guys are screwed until you fix this.

 

Shrikant Kambli says:

October 09,2010 at 02:05 AM IST

There is a company called Wizcraft and they are arbitarily being given all the contracts by the government. One wonders why there is no open tender. Also- all the film festivals run by the govt are being given to them. There should be an investigation into this company. But who will order the investigation?

 

Vatsal Vaidya says:

October 08,2010 at 11:36 PM IST

Thank you sir! This was badly needed .. somebody to bring this out. Someone had to blow the whistle and really proud that you did it. This is ridiculous. There should be an inquiry and every penny that has gone towards corruption and over charges needs to be recovered and used in proper manner. Two days back my father got an Income Tax audit and the officer identified that he had taken a deduction of Rs.4000 by mistake. They asked him to pay it. And here there is no account of Rs. 350 crores.. only 60 crores for the aerostat and 290 crores for creating those puppets,drums and colored clothing ???

 

Dip Chakraborty says:

October 08,2010 at 08:18 PM IST

Only solution is organize a group like Naxals, and get all the branded crook politicians and punish them with an open public court. Easy to say I know but it can not be done because MM Singhji has to deliver Rahul Gandhi as our next PM. MonMahan, Pranab and other senior Ministers are all on the Bofors pay roll in including Advani group so sing sare jahan se achha and watch the game on big LCD TV.

 

Diptendu Chakraborty says:

October 08,2010 at 07:37 PM IST

All the comments are made supporting my views that my country has been taken over by a group of united political Mafia of all parties. After the game a commission would set up for an eye wash. No CBI inquary will be ordered, even if ordered MM Singh Govt. would cover up or hush up the investigation. People of India are taken for a ride since Independence. MonMahan to Advani all are white color educated crooks. India needs revolution like JP once on the road. We have to rebuild the country from the basic again changing the constitution that no accused can ever contest the election.

 

Shahul Hameed says:

October 08,2010 at 06:04 PM IST

Nothing will ever happen. You scratch my back and I will do it for you is the policy being adopted by all political bigwigs. National interest is not in anyone's agenda. And we the poor public mutely continue to watch and undergo pain and agony. Do we have alternative?

 

nandavantsa says:

October 08,2010 at 03:24 PM IST

unfortunately in the present times, even the opposition is in cahoots with the government and get a share of the spoils... so there is no check on the extravaganzy unless the Judiciary decides to step in.

 

counterview says:

October 08,2010 at 02:59 PM IST

Finally someone rooting for taxpayers money. In India it seems that public money is up for grabs, with media and govt showing disinclination to punish any offender. Most of media's sting operations are politically motivated. Otherwise we would have got to know a lot more about the obscene amount of wealth pilfered in the name of the Games.

 

Sunil Sridhar says:

October 08,2010 at 12:12 PM IST

Very good article Rajesh!! You have amassed the information very well and brought it to the notice of everybody. Just a thought though. This is a good first step but no action would be taken against this. Can you do us all a favor by compiling all the comments and getting signatures and filing a public interest litigation against the Govt that allowed such a brazenly deceitful act against our sovereign nation? Articles like this are very helpful in propogating the corruption but do nothing to curb our great politicians from keeping at it. Do let me know your thoughts and maybe we can create a forum and create some noise atleast.

 

Deepa says:

October 08,2010 at 11:45 AM IST

Now TIME has to come to change ourselves. Believe it or not “CWG is nothing but our own IMAGE.”

 

Mir says:

October 08,2010 at 11:19 AM IST

what Mr Karla have in mind can he do this Kind of Show in Peanuts. then let Him be an event organizers then he should spare us from his sarcastic comments occupying this space.

 

Gaurav says:

October 08,2010 at 11:11 AM IST

It was a celebration of India. Do you know how much the event did to uplift the morale of Indians in general and athletes in particular? The intangible gains are huge here. I know it sounds cliched but I am ready to give up a meal or two if an event like this is going to take more than what it ideally should. Let's not look at it only from the money perspective

 

amit says:

October 08,2010 at 08:58 AM IST

stop whining

(Reply to amit)- nandavantsa says:

October 08,2010 at 03:25 PM IST

i guess this is more a 'lament' at the sheer wastage of National resources

 

Jayesh A says:

October 08,2010 at 07:53 AM IST

There should be a detailed audit on the complete expenditure. People who have genuinely invested on right places should come clear in their facts and figures.

 

Ed says:

October 08,2010 at 07:09 AM IST

It’s no wonder a lot of highly educated and patriotic young Indians leave the country and go to western countries in search of a better life. Why should we be forced to put up with the low standards of living and low ethics the government imposes on us? There is so much corruption that we can’t get anything done without having to bribe someone. The past events in Delhi have left us, who are outside the country, hanging and hiding out face in shame. There is no hope for India when we let the worst criminals run the country. As my Professor back home in India use to say, “The best thing that can happen for India is, one morning we should all wake up to find that all our politicians have disappeared”. Couldn’t agree with him more!

(Reply to Ed)- avtar says:

October 08,2010 at 05:17 PM IST

Fantastic! Your professor back home deserves award/s from the state for having said as reported by you. It ought to have become a famous quotation by now !Has it ?

(Reply to avtar)- Ed says:

October 11,2010 at 04:06 AM IST

I wish it is more often quoted.. but not many are willing to go up against the politicians for fear of retaliations.

 

Philip of Melbourne says:

October 08,2010 at 06:09 AM IST

The Delhi 2010 Rugby 7s scoreboard has just collapsed in the last few hours. This follows the collapse of the stadium footbridge and panels from the weightlifting venue falling down over a week ago. Yes I loved the stunning Opening Ceremony but the Indian Government ought now to conduct an independent investigation/audit into the organisation of the Games, and it should be run independently by private sector. This is latest collapse is not only dangerous but internationally embaressing, not only for the Indian people.

(Reply to Philip of Melbourne)- Indian of Sydney! says:

October 08,2010 at 09:51 AM IST

Dear Philip of Melbourne, Shut ur racist pie hole. Who gave u the right to condemn another country. Take the plank out from your eye first. Which year was it that you all recognized the aboriginals as humans?? 1967?? There is no other country that's has a more shameful past and present than Australia!!

 

Sukhi says:

October 08,2010 at 05:24 AM IST

Actually the cost was around Rs70-80 Crores . rest is with Mr Kalmadi . obviously - He will come out clean on these allegations after the games . We have a very short memory - We as a nation do not remember things .

 

avtar says:

October 08,2010 at 04:49 AM IST

The beautifully articulated & melodramatically humming with the hissing sound of a nearby 'grass snake' offers due credit to the pen master of the subject article ,squarely & firmly befitting the occasion ;in every sense of humour & biting wit too :snuggling each other in the beginning of the fall itself ! The disclosures of the cost high function ,bit by bit , have sent freezing chill,even make shiver the marrow in the bones !Let us earnestly hope that such an event is allowed to take place extravagantly just once in a blue moon ! It is going to be huge & colossal Tax-payers' 'Dough' being mercilessly drained to the sewer ,with a lot of spillage too !

(Reply to avtar)- Ed says:

October 08,2010 at 09:56 AM IST

This Comment was found to be offensive and has been removed by the Administrator.

(Reply to Ed)- avtar says:

October 08,2010 at 04:54 PM IST

Using such a language against a writer ,without having been offended is inappropriate . Plz avoid in future . Thanx

 

Kamlesh Vyas says:

October 07,2010 at 11:10 PM IST

Dear countrymen, Why do we bother so much? see the gains from the CWG10. We have created billionaires. The OC has brought the money in circulation. National and international records have been created in sports like Cost-over-run and time-over run. case studies have emerged in how to buy something at unimaginably high prices. How to create benefits for people even remotely related to the organising committee is another innovation. How to repair a stadium for 900 cr when the new one costs 40 crore is a economic invention. And at the opening ceremony Mr Kalmadi has already praised and thanked everyone (was it a vote of thanks on successful closure?), he has been so busy cooking up books and finding more and more ways of stealing public money that he cant differentiate between cheers and jeers. But the man must be held in high regard for his consistency- he never let the levels of theft dip? It will be a good idea to make him our next president- how much can you steal in the Rashtrapati bhavan compared to the 70,000 cr loot, plus he has done in 3 months what the British could not do in 400 years- England, Northern Ireland, scotland and wales should hand over all their medals to him- he has done it better than their forefathers - in the art of plundering India. He represents the concepts of the queen of common wealth like no other. He has just validated what we have known all along ( and Rajiv Gandhi said so) its 10% that trickles down- so all of you there why do you keep saying its been expensive- divide the figure by 10. The OC also deserves a Nobel price in economics- provng something the 1 billion nation knew but did not have empirical proof for. He should have been our flag bearer. And dont even think of making too much noise- else Mr Kalmadi will need to award contracts to his inlaws to make the aerostat 'thought blocker enabled' for guest athletes & it will cost a further 100 cr. So just keep mum & enjoy the common wealth go. Jai Hind and hail King Kalmadi.

 

SidD says:

October 07,2010 at 10:35 PM IST

the event showcased india's superiority and development along with india's cultural diversity. I would say, it was worth every rupee spent!

 

Tarin says:

October 07,2010 at 10:22 PM IST

A crowdfund for public interest litigation. I feel that public memory in India is extremely short term and corrupt politicians can get away with CWG-like heists because of it. Most people don't pursue cases of blatant corruption against the government because of the sheer effort involved. However, many of us, myself included, would be more than willing to contribute non-trivial sums of money - I can sign on for donating Rs 5,000 tomorrow - to a common PIL fund that funded hard / tough legal action against those involved. This coupled with relentless media mentions would improve things a bit. Any thoughts ?

 

Kirt Kumar says:

October 07,2010 at 10:21 PM IST

Really INDIA get Dry, if anyone sensibly think what is the limit of budget & how Govt. of India procuring & in which way they spending the money. Really its time to realize and revolution against these corrupted hand behind name of Govt., where they even not with think of its every citizen's money.They are just Parasites & Termites. And I wanted ask to Govt. who involved in CWG organizing committee, who are they, from where they came& Whats their identity? i think behind Govt. they are just nothing, its a AVERAGE thinker MAN or Just are as ILLITERATE hungers eating every citizen's money, if they so really talented & honest man beneath regulating Govt. then every things would have been Proud full but not yet proud happened still India not Developed country....its shameful for India with immense talent's enriched people are not running India despite we live under dump regulator Government's man. Damn Parasites. Incredible India.

 

Shyamal Pal says:

October 07,2010 at 09:59 PM IST

Spending Rs.350 crores of the INDIAN tax payers money for the CWG opening ceremony CERTAINLY NEEDS TO BE HONESTLY AND EXPERTLY PROBED. Any event management company WORTH ITS SALT,other than the one hired by the CWG OC if any, would be laughing at YET another crude attempt by KALMADI and CO.to launder AWAY the Indian Tax Payers money unashamedly.DISGRACEFUL and DECEITFUL conduct to say the least. Shyamal Pal

 

govind raj k r says:

October 07,2010 at 09:30 PM IST

Do Kalmadi, Dikshit, Gill, Reddy, the PM and Sonia Gandhi know how much was 'sanctioned' and grudgingly sent to Leh after the flood-disaster, as compared to the 350-crores (loot included) CWG opening show? So much for Indian lives in Leh.

 

Prince Behl says:

October 07,2010 at 06:51 PM IST

Nicely penned down. Whether it is corruption or the great opening show of CEG, it has covered each aspect of the games very neatly. I agree with writer, we should take severe steps against the people who have inflated the budget of games for their bank balance and should not get them away under the eulogies India is receiving for such a great show. We are never against organizing or performing on an international stage until we are working in budget.

 

Siddhartha Passi says:

October 07,2010 at 05:56 PM IST

After coming to India it has not remained ‘COMMON Wealth Games’, it has rather become, ‘CONGRESS Wealth Games’!! I wonder when will these politicians stop playing ‘games’ with the ‘Common Wealth’ of the nation?! - Siddhartha Passi

 

somu says:

October 07,2010 at 04:39 PM IST

this money should be used for some good purposes lile removing poverty, building good roads etc instead of CWG.

 

SP says:

October 07,2010 at 03:09 PM IST

A paltry 350 crores for the opening fiasco out of a whopping 70000-100000 lacs on the CWG 2010 (tentative estimates)! Have we not portrayed to the entire world that we are well off ? can we not now proudly proclaim that there is not an iota of poverty in India ? Who in India cares for Taxpayers' money & who is bothered about the Crores of Rupees that have been bungled in the current CWG. There must also be a tentative estimate for the CWG closing extravaganza. You better get busy with that figure. All those involved in the CWG don't care a tuppence for the problems afflicting' MERA BHARAT MAHAN'.

 

AngryIndian says:

October 07,2010 at 01:59 PM IST

Aaargh !! Mr. Kalra, can you stop bickering for a while? Atleast till the games are over.... 350cr?? Where do you obtain these numbers? What's the source of this information?? Have you started to work as an independent auditor? I have followed quite few posts of yours and most of them are pathetic. TOI and the bunch of guys like you are resorting to petty tricks to brazen the CWG games...Shame on TOI to have tarnished India's image on the world arena!! Get a life people !! Jiyo aur jeene do !!

(Reply to AngryIndian)- Sukev says:

October 09,2010 at 11:33 AM IST

You are RIGHT..

 

debashis bhattacharya says:

October 07,2010 at 01:54 PM IST

NO BODY WILL DEMAND THE EXPANCES ACCOUNT AND AUDIT EXCEPT MAY BE MEDIA HOUSE. ALL POLITITIANS ARE PAID HANDSOME AMOUNT THERE FORE ALL WILL KEEP MUM. PUBLIC HAS NO ALTERNATIVE BUT TO PAY TAX . WHY DONT TOI INITIATE THIS MOVE IN MASS SCALE.

 

SK Verma says:

October 07,2010 at 01:19 PM IST

Kalmadi and the like should be awarded "Cold Metal" (i.e., behind iron bars) in Tihar Jail

 

Urvashi says:

October 07,2010 at 01:15 PM IST

Many of us didn't knew that 350 crore was spent on that 2.5hrs of opening ceremony. It really a shame for us that one side we are starving with hunger, devastating flood which has ruined the life of general public and on the other side we are spending that much amount on inaugral ceremony. The government should definitely give the list of expenses what was planned and actually what happened. But this is really like a dream to expect the explanation from goverment. At the end only "common man" of india will suffer.

 

Sonu says:

October 07,2010 at 01:06 PM IST

CWG Delhi website leaves a lot to be desired. I wonder how much money was spent on this ?

 

anjali g says:

October 07,2010 at 12:45 PM IST

People, especially those living abroad are now wondering what the fuss was all about- even criticising Indian media for doubting our capabilities. My fear is that the culprits will not be taken to task riding as they are on the current wave of public euphoria. Even corporate heads have remarked on the wrong priorities of the govt and the colossal wastage of money in the name of CWG. If the govt wants to make Sports a national priority, it needs to build state of the art sports facilities for our athletes in small towns first. It is perhaps wishful thinking by foreign observers that India will learn from this experience . Regrettably the OC officials seem to be giving themselves a pat on the back .

 

R B Kler says:

October 07,2010 at 11:17 AM IST

Agreed, we need transparency in the amount spent. We should have more events but cost needs to be justified and the organisers need to be answerable. The shine we saw in the opening should not cover up the muck of the days leading up to the CWG

 

Frustrated says:

October 07,2010 at 10:33 AM IST

I agree 100% with you Rajesh. Personally I think the Commonwealth games to be little more than "Loot the common man games", as most of the money that was LOOTED from the public (by raising prices of just about everything in Delhi multiple times, from petrol to vegetables, food items and even essentials like milk) has ended up in the pockets of those involved in organizing this awful mess of a Games. And even then, they couldn't get it right as we all know by now. Ok, things went to plan during the cermony, but as you say, thats hardly an excuse for everything else thats been going on. Most in Delhi don't want ANYTHING to do with this mess, but on it goes regardless <sigh>. And the sad part is, I'm pretty sure those responsible for the looting (read those in power) will never be punished for what they did. In fact, as most say on here, the public will forget what they did, and carry on as usual - pretty much because this type of thing is normal in India. And if by some slim chance someone does try and take action against them, chances are they'll be paid off not to do so or their cases would languish for years in the court system. Either way, they get off scot-free. About par for around here though, the common man's opinion has little or no value (except when it's time to buy their votes). . .

 

parvathi says:

October 07,2010 at 09:38 AM IST

Olympics ! Oh, No. Enough of this squandering. Do not bulge many more bank accounts with swindled money by staking claims to more mega events. National pride comes from improving the living standards of millions who carry stones to build stadiums rather than singing few colorful songs.When half India is still living in misery spending like water and swindling in the name of spending is unpardonable. Pl do not burden us any more. Build schools and hospitals with proposed expenditure.

 

Ram says:

October 07,2010 at 09:13 AM IST

everyone I would like my two cents worth, Suresh Kalmadi was proudly saying the cost of a roll of toilet paper is Rs 40 ie almost Aus$ 1. I live in Sydney and get toilet paper in our supermarket for 30 cents for a roll. So for the Super Markets who buy in bulk it must be much cheaper. In other words since CWG organisers were buying toilet paper for a dollar they were paying three times the amount any bloke would pay in Australia. So the accounts have to be audited but I am sure the paper work will be perfect. In other words money has been wasted.

 

Priyanshu says:

October 07,2010 at 05:23 AM IST

As always, Kalra you write what one has come to expect from you. The truth! Well done and Gof bless!

 

Varun Thakran says:

October 07,2010 at 12:19 AM IST

Now You SEE when games are moving on relatively smoothly, every body is trying take the credit of hosting it. Just because one Opening Ceremony unarguably went spectacular, everyone is just moving around it only. BJP saying congress cant take the credit alone. Huh Games are not over yet. big job ahead. Run Up to the games has already been tarnished. You guys read any newspaper of the world, every headline bear "glitch, trouble etc" words ven when praising for opening ceremony. APPEAL Hope the games go well. and after that everyone needs to raise the voice against people because of whom we nationalists Indians have had to face embarrassment. CMON WE CANT LET IT HAPPEN TO OUR COUNTRY AND OUR SPORTS

 

Ayush says:

October 06,2010 at 11:30 PM IST

Rajesh i thank the media for bringing all the filth about the CWG in the open however it now seems that game bashing has become a media sport. Post such blogs accusing someone only if there are credible proofs else you will only aid the wrong doers in their defense

 

srikanth says:

October 06,2010 at 09:49 PM IST

Beijing Olympics in numbers: 205 countries taking part in the Games £20 billion (British pounds) cost of Olympic venues and infrastructure £60 million cost of Olympic opening ceremony Delhi CWG by numbers: 71 countries taking part in the Games 70,000 crore Rupees = £10 billion cost of venues and infrastructure 350 crore Rupees = £50 million cost of opening ceremony

 

Amit Gupta says:

October 06,2010 at 08:51 PM IST

Please enjoy the moment. Criticism is easy, what is the solution. Delhi is being showcased internationally and article like these can not dampen the pride I feel for the city and as a citizen of this Country.

 

nikhil says:

October 06,2010 at 07:19 PM IST

When hundreds of people in India are not getting two sqaure meals a day , we who live in glass house chher of the greatness of India , the India does not live in the houses but in slums , let one Indian leader show how he has helped them to rise hardly anyone , we pat each others back seat in the airconditioned comforts of hotels and restaurent and discuss world economy and how we are going to be super power, but we never go to a govt hospital or to avillage and see how 90 % of the mass does not have the basic neccessity of education , health , hygiene but our netas talk of roti , kapda or makan probably for themselves and go around in chaufered cars with z security paid by the public at large , we are leaving in a dream world we would be only superpowers in our dream or in our discussions with the likes of us, we willnever be able to see the ground reality. I am ashamed to be PIo with this type of my fellow cioutrymen

 

Kanu Mistry says:

October 06,2010 at 05:03 PM IST

We, as Indians, do not have the stomach for success or thinking big. The author of this article is one of them who cannot digest a success and has started vomiting.

 

Disgusted says:

October 06,2010 at 03:29 PM IST

In all this debate and discussion, has anyone thought of the basic problem: the preoccupation of Indians with song and dance , how easily they get diverted by mere tamasha, and how their sole aim in life seems to be incessant entertainment at the cost of serious work? THAT is where the root of the disease lies. The politicians merely capitalise on this penchant.

 

sviwspb says:

October 06,2010 at 03:08 PM IST

350 crores is not so big by international standards.

 

Ajith Kumar says:

October 06,2010 at 01:52 PM IST

NOTHING,REPEAT,NOTHING IS GOING TO COME OUT ON THE EXPENSES STATED> EVEN THIS SHORT COMMENT MAY NOT APPEAR. OUR BOYS AND GIRLS-UNDER PAID,WITHOUT ANY STATE SUPPORT WILL BRING GLORY TO INDIAN SPORTS.IN THIS EUPHORIA EVERYTHING WILL BE BURIED AND THE PERPETRATORS WILL GO OUT TO LOOK FOR MORE PASTURES- WE ARE INDIA.

 

Satbir Singh Bedi says:

October 06,2010 at 01:29 PM IST

This is an excellent article and sincere journalism. We must relentlessly go after all the scamesters and not heave a sigh of relief till we have them all punished. Merely by spending Rs.350 crores on Opening Ceremony of CWG, we cannot wash away the sins of the Prime Minister who did not appoint a coordinator for the Games and did nothing to punish the guilty, Jaipal Reddy, Kalmadi (who says shamelessly that he would not resign even after the Games) and Sheila Dixit etc. There is the report of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India and the Government must go into it and punish the guilty. After the Games are over, people should agitate and force this Govt. to act against corruption. The Prime Minister is no doubt an honest man but he is presiding over a Cabinet of Corrupt and inefficient people like MS Gill, Jaipal Reddy, etc. Sonia Gandhi too is not acting. She must remove Kalmadi and Sheila Dixit as soon as the Games are over. They would submit their resignations in no time the moment Sonia Gandhi asks them to do so. There is also need to punish Mani Shankar Aiyer, the ex Sports Minister who for two years did nothing. Nobody should be allowed to go scot free. In fact, there is need to replace the Prime Minister also who does not even understand that for such big events, coordinator needs to be appointed.

 

Aman says:

October 06,2010 at 01:26 PM IST

Sometimes, I feel, if anyone of all the people commenting here, would have got a safe,clean opportunity to earn say 50 Lakhs, would they have strongly denied that?

(Reply to Aman)- sharan says:

October 06,2010 at 08:16 PM IST

That is a very pertinent question. In fact, I believe that almost any of us will do the same things that our corrupt leaders are doing if we are put in the same positions. Some of the reasons are: 1. The rewards of incompetence and corruption are very high in India, 2. The chances of getting caught for criminal acts are very low, 3. Even if they get caught, the chances of their conviction are very low, 4. Even if they are convicted, the penalties are very low compared to the tons of loot they have already collected and salted away, so they still win. 5. At the same time, the penalties of being honest, of going against the corrupt majority, of "swimming against the tide", are very great. The net result of such forces ensures that practically anyone in those positions will sooner or later end up indulging in such base practices. To change this situation, you will have to change the composition of the forces acting on the people in those positions. Simply changing the people makes little or no difference. What can one Abdul Kalam achieve when pitted against a thousand established and hardened criminals who will stop at nothing to get what they want? We will have to introduce meaningful checks and balances to curb the currently limitless powers of our so-called leaders. Criminals must be banned from contesting elections. Minimum educational and other qualifications and skills must be an absolute must-have for contesting elections. Also, the penalties for criminal acts must be swift and severe. Without effective, swift and severe penalties being introduced to counterbalance the forces of temptations, nothing is going to change.

 

Gaurav says:

October 06,2010 at 01:07 PM IST

front row seat at cwg opening : Rs. 25000 declared cost of cwg opening : 50 crore cost of aerostat : 60 crore total actual cost of cwg opening : 350 crores total cost of cwg : 70k crores getting away easily after the loot : PRICELESS!!!

 

thomas gracias says:

October 06,2010 at 12:42 PM IST

in hindsight the former sports minister MS Aiyar was right

 

Thomas Gracias says:

October 06,2010 at 12:36 PM IST

Does a Indian politician ever got naied on corruption charges, The Indian politician is corruption proof that is why so many political dynasties are emerging all over the country, forget about not paying tax etc, we will be the ones to be hounded wheras the looters will be laughing all the way to the bank

 

Indian Devil says:

October 06,2010 at 12:22 PM IST

The article is bang on target.

 

Sandy says:

October 06,2010 at 11:57 AM IST

70K (plus) crore rupees for organizing the CWG. 350 crore for it's opening ceremony. what's the budget for closing ceremony ???

(Reply to Sandy)- kamesh says:

October 10,2010 at 03:41 AM IST

70 K * 11 days = 770 K..will it be sufficient or total glod medals won by indians (24 * 70K) or number of spectators for closing ceremony * 70 K....Mr. Kalmadi - pls decide tell which one u r going to opt....

 

Sukev says:

October 06,2010 at 11:40 AM IST

350 crores for opening ceremony is nothing compared to wide publicity and accolades it received showing such a stunning opening ceremony.As usual there are critics within India.. this is one such article...success in conducting such a magnum ceremony will bring by itself Foreign Direct investments as such events is a showcase for foreign investments..lets all stand together and make it a grand success...from a Third world country status India has now become third biggest economy..in such situation conducting a 50 crores opening ceremony...even rich peple in India conduct lavish marriage parties...involving crores..remember all these money are spend within India.. not flushed out...

(Reply to Sukev)- Sanjiv says:

October 06,2010 at 02:57 PM IST

I love the naivety of the notion that the entire world would be impressed by the opening ceremony. Sorry – not so. I would have expected a ceremony of similar (or better) quality for a smaller sum even if it had taken place in London, New York or Berlin. The only conclusion I can draw is that kick backs are still essential to ‘do business’ in India, and even when the bribe is paid , Quality is not ensured – look at the field and track nonsense,….nothing is ready after all the money spent. – and no-one will ‘pay the price’. It has been a useful exercise, the whole world can see nothing has changed in India despite the GDP alluding to a top table seat.The country still exudes a third world mentality when it counts – and open talk by the highest officials of ‘LOWER-CLASS’ people making up the numbers in the seats make everyone know the caste system is still predominant. Sad but true.

(Reply to Sukev)- nikhil says:

October 06,2010 at 07:23 PM IST

Have u ever had a time that you did not get your two sqare meal aday , I do not think so, otherwise you will realize how stupid we can be

(Reply to Sukev)- Jitu Patel says:

October 08,2010 at 07:25 PM IST

As regards the international publicity that the CWG has received, I am presently in the United States and do watch TV for news. However, did not find any mention of CWG anywhere till date... neither opening ceremony nor the games that followed. Maybe the media in China, Japan, Europe, Russia, Brazil are actively showcasing the CWG. The plus side is that there has been no mention of the corruption either in the media over here.

(Reply to Jitu Patel)- Sukev says:

October 09,2010 at 10:06 AM IST

Watch BBC, CNN...they have mentioned...otherwise they are not news broadcasters... Dont think anything happening in India is mediocre and even minor happening in America is big...21st century belongs to India and China...

 

Sam says:

October 06,2010 at 11:14 AM IST

Dude u stop being a pain by finding all bad things.. Let's see and explain Gus things plzz

(Reply to Sam)- sharan says:

October 06,2010 at 01:42 PM IST

Why don't YOU do that, asap? I'm very interested to see what "Gus things" you can come up with.

 

Bhartiyah says:

October 06,2010 at 10:48 AM IST

We Indians suffer from Short-term-memory-loss. Once this whole fan-fare and hoopla is over it will be show cased at grand success and the people will bask in its glory and international applaud. But the cost we paid to acheive this is so shamelessly high that it takes away that zing from all this. U give this amount of money to even a country in carribean island and even they would be able to come up with such great spectacle. The point is after all this is over will the people who are responsible for such waste of money be questioned by law? will they be punished for their shamefull act? Will we, as a citizen, be given the account of all the expenses? Is it possible that we as citizen of this country tell the government that we won't pay any taxes untill we are given the total account of the CWG expenses? And to end this I don't want Olympics to be hosted in India for another 2-3 deacads because then even our childer would be in debt from the expenses.

 

Sharma M C L says:

October 06,2010 at 10:42 AM IST

Rajesh, Not only for CWG, for all Government spending they should allow people to have access to financial reports. This way we'll all know where is our tax money going.

 

Saurabh Singh says:

October 06,2010 at 09:26 AM IST

Dear Rajesh I am hopeless . As we Indians did not even vote after the 26/11 attack in our dear city Mumbai , what do you expect us to do for CWG? The Govt is so is so arrogant & shameless they are just not fearing anything or anyone . I remember in the Eighties Rajiv Gandhi's Govt was shown the door for "JUST 80 Crores" ,in ninties the size increased to the tune of 4000-5000 crore ( Telgi scam and other) now look at the magnitude of all the corruption !! Even a 70,000 crore is not bothering the Govt (or us?? ). At least Kalmadi should be kept out of all the ceremonies , instead he is giving medals to our Sports people.Even the opposition is not making any noise I guess they too have got their cut ...

(Reply to Saurabh Singh )- nikhil says:

October 06,2010 at 07:25 PM IST

Kalamadi has shared the loot with everyone ,so if you want him out whom do you want not to be out .

 

sharan says:

October 06,2010 at 08:34 AM IST

Rajesh, for those idealistically naive Indians waiting with bated breath for our "international statesman PM" to "punish the criminals after the games", here's a hot tip right off the press: stop holding your breath. Here’s an excerpt from an article in today’s TOI on Shiela Dixit who, incidentally, is basking happily in the aftermath of the applause she received at the CWG opening ceremony: Question to Shiela Dixit: "There have been allegations of corruption and nepotism in the Games. What sort of action can we expect?" Answer by Shiela Dixit: "None of the allegations has been proved. There is a set procedure of the CVC to judge the quality of work. That procedure is being followed. What has not happened is a preliminary inquiry. The PM, Sonia Gandhi and myself have said time and again that if substandard material has been used or any other deficiencies are found, blame will be apportioned and the guilty punished. But you cannot punish someone unless guilt is proved." That's it! "Nothing has been proved", she says! No talk of investigating the outrageous cost escalations or all the bungling, mess-ups, delays, etc. Of course nothing has been proved, Brainiac! Proof will not fall out of the sky and land in your lap, conveniently bound in A4 size. It's your job to investigate and obtain proof, by conducting detailed audits, costing analysis, price comparisons, etc. You are supposed to involve the right people and put in all the time and effort necessary to bring the criminals to justice. Don't you know even this much? It is a clear indication of our sorry state that Ms Dixit can be a celebrity for "salvaging the games" or whatever. One bunch of unqualified and incompetent so-called leaders makes an absolute mess, and then another comes along and applies some bandage willy-nilly at the last moment and thereby attains celebrity status. It’s no use feeling “sad” or “shocked”. Nothing is going to improve until Indians start feeling ANGRY.

(Reply to sharan)- Rajesh Kalra says:

October 06,2010 at 09:00 AM IST

She is as responsible for the mess as Kalmadi. Don't you think so?

(Reply to Rajesh Kalra)- sharan says:

October 06,2010 at 01:37 PM IST

Absolutely. It is quite natural that she doesn't want any part in exposing the culprits; after all, she is equally culpable.

 

C.D.P.DAS says:

October 06,2010 at 08:22 AM IST

Basic problem here is the commitment as an Indian citizen. We must be more selfless, when it comes to building and conducting national events.

 

Blogger check says:

October 06,2010 at 04:46 AM IST

Reminder News for all of you - "Prime minister has cleared the name of tainted telecom Secretary of PJ Thomas for the post of central vigilance commissioner.Central vigilance commissioner is the chief who looks over the corruption charges in the country.But with the inception of the telecom secretary who himself was involved in the biggest scam of the decade in favoring certain companies in 3 G spectrum distribution the nation is questioning the intention of the UPA government and it's seriousness in removing corrption from the country". When Opposition leader could not do anything by meeting President in this matter...who you are buddy ? On the contrary, same Media and congress peaker says what was the need of doing "tamasha" in front of President. You had a chance to throw out congress before 1 year .. didn't do...what will you do now ? Ohh forgot Telecom Scam ....

 

Varun Thakran says:

October 06,2010 at 02:13 AM IST

just to correct you, in the first para, the biggest critics are people in india only and not abroad. secondly, i agree that 350 crore spent on opening ceremony was a huge amount but it was fantastic and elicited much praise atleast. But what about spending thousands of crores on the preparation of games, venues etc and still get the flak. india can afford to spend a little extra as it did for the games but cant afford to lose image of powerful emerging economy of 21 century. thanks to brazen Kalmadi, his overweening has brought india a lot of criticism. He talks a lot. SUGGESTION: As soon as the games are over, first act should be to remove him from officer and allowed to interfer in sports. and Begin an overhaul of Indian Olympic Association. It shoul be brought. We have seen what Kalmadi and his ilk has done , in order to avoid such embarrasement again, please look after, 1.Randhir Singh-Secretary- General IOA 2.Vidya Stokes-Hockey chief 3.Digvijay singh-Shooter's chief 4.Praful Patel-football chief etc

 

Gautam De says:

October 06,2010 at 01:28 AM IST

Mr. Kalra, no matter what we write here, Government won't pay attention. Because they can afford to. There is no election near, and the Prime Minister is a puppet in the hands of the Gandhi family. He is a total shameless fellow to be authorizing mass loot of public money and turning a blind eye towards it, so that Party Supremo is happy to have 1000s of crores to be looted among he Party bigwigs and powerful supporters. And I am sure, once the games is over, no one will pursue the corruption and wastage in the preparation. I calculated personally, the total cost will be around $20 billion, where original estimate was 300 million!!! This is India. Ruled by mafia. Period. Oil price will go up further regardless of international price. Food price will be even higher. No hope in sign.

(Reply to Gautam De)- Diptendu Chakraborty says:

October 08,2010 at 07:43 PM IST

I agree with Gautam. Scolar MM Singh is a spinceless puppet of corrupt Gandhi family.Mafia has been taken over India. Churchill said that India would be ruled by thugs and devils and exactly that is happening now.

 

Ashith says:

October 06,2010 at 01:12 AM IST

This Comment was found to be offensive and has been removed by the Administrator.

(Reply to Ashith)- Deepika Santook says:

October 06,2010 at 08:13 AM IST

Ashtish, your message in capital letters needs to be first followed by you, because your words & content are intemperate. Tell me honestly, are u one of those who are at the receiving end of this 7% (or 70%)?

(Reply to Ashith)- Rai(up) says:

October 06,2010 at 08:22 PM IST

my friend Ashith ! we ARE proud of putting such a beutifull show.but its our right rather our duty to see where this huge ammount of earnning is spent.it will certainly take time to improve but only if we initiate.

(Reply to Rai(up))- Ashith says:

October 07,2010 at 12:03 AM IST

Thanks for your input Mr.Rai, I have already replied back to this in the below comment.. please follow the same..

(Reply to Ashith)- Sam says:

October 06,2010 at 08:42 PM IST

Remember this injustice and corruption when voting the next time - All those who complain here. Remember that they gave only Rs 125 crores for aid in Ladakh when lot of people died due to natural calamity and they spent Rs. 350 crores in 2.5 hrs. ceremony for entertainment. Remember this and make a note - Death to Congress party at voting booth. Not a single vote to Congress Party and the Royal Family of India. Alas, I am just dreaming, people will still vote the charming Rajkumar/Yuvraj of India and the Italian Queen.

(Reply to Sam)- Ashith says:

October 07,2010 at 12:01 AM IST

Do u know the amount of funds would come into india... thats more than 5billion dollars... So guys, no offence here.. please be business minded. If you tend to spend 350 crores or more for an event and if you get back with investments worth $5billion and also with more than 1 million jobs for the unemployed.. wat more do u think, would be better..

(Reply to Ashith)- sharan says:

October 07,2010 at 09:27 AM IST

Wah, wah! "$5 billion foreign investment in India, and more than 1 million jobs" are going to be created in India by blowing 350 crore rupees through fake billing and shoddy output???!!! These are hilarious theories indeed. You are a born comedian with a rare talent! Why don't you rush to the US and patent your groundbreaking idea, then license it to the US? Those poor fellows are desperate to come out of their depression. They have already spent billions in trying to kick-start their economy, with very limited success. Maybe they should hire Kalmadi and Co. to hold a CWG in the US (with your help, of course), with $200 toilet rolls and $500 flower pots, and then the US will be NUMBER 1 in the world again?! Soon every country in the world will be having its own CWG, and we will then see huge bundles of $5 billion in hard currency materialising out of the sky like magic and racing back and forth among these countries, like migratory birds or airplanes! And millions of new job offers in every country so that we can all change our jobs every day and country hop while we job hop! Really, if we were going to get even $1 of foreign investment or even one part-time job created because of this rip-off called CWG, you bet our opportunistic netas would have taken out full-newspaper ads, not just full front page ads (at our expense, naturally). Did that occur to you? Unless of course you are Mr Kalmadi himself, writing incognito here, which is quite possible considering your vicious attack on the article. Finally, a friendly caution regarding prayers: when we pray to God asking for gifts, we must be very careful with our wording. For example, we may ask for the gift of “bliss”, but a mischievous God may grant us “ignorance” and then chortle that “ignorance is bliss”, which unfortunately seems to have happened in your case.

 

Geetu says:

October 05,2010 at 11:39 PM IST

Very Apt Rajesh...wonder what the Indian citizens have to see more..

 

wd says:

October 05,2010 at 10:18 PM IST

we need Media's noise to echo people's voice AFTER CWG. Let there be a RTI and yes we need the account of EVERY PAISA spent even if the event is paisa vasool. And a fast track court. Kasab & Co are no different in fact are worse than Kasab since they are Indians. When Indians everyday due to hunger and disease and when funds are diverted to PERSONAL accounts in the name of national pride, its just another form of homicide. PLEASE POST THIS ARTICLE AFTER CWG, AGAIN.

 

frank says:

October 05,2010 at 10:17 PM IST

ru sure that is 3.5 billion dollars i dont think so pls verify the figure

 

alok says:

October 05,2010 at 09:59 PM IST

why critics have to criticize for the sake of criticizing?. why cant they rejoice with others, are they sadistic in nature... i have pondered over these question many times hope u give me my answer

 

Sam Bhattacherjee says:

October 05,2010 at 09:52 PM IST

Desh Hamara Hindusthan, Jai Jai Bharat Hindusthan.

 

Siddharth Pathak says:

October 05,2010 at 09:52 PM IST

I would not like to agree with Rajesh here. Fine the envisioned original cost was 50 crores which ended up being 350 crore. But we must not forget that with this opener we showed the world that we are also capable of hosting huge international events like these. 350 crores is extremely small price to pay when it comes for increasing your country's reputition. Take a look at China-the first Maglev train was opened in Shanghai. The yearly loss of the government is tremendous. Still the Chinese are continuing the train. Why? Because it provides an excellent source of pride, first impression on foreign tourist and the sense of awe. But in India such things are not even considered..

(Reply to Siddharth Pathak)- Ruchi says:

October 06,2010 at 06:57 PM IST

It is not about saving the Indian pride. If rightly spent, no Indian would say no. The point is: were 350 crores actually spent on the ceremony or did they make it to the pockets of the corrupt people. We can't justify the corruption by saying that the show was good.

(Reply to Siddharth Pathak)- indian(UP) says:

October 06,2010 at 08:13 PM IST

nobody said that india should not take this type of big steps,but question is whether it is ok to spent unlimited money earned by hard work of indian citizens without any accountability...

 

Rohan Lawrence D'souza says:

October 05,2010 at 08:45 PM IST

The Old saying - If you ask the price then you can't afford it applies here. Think of NOT what it costed INDIA but of what part u played in helping? You are being a party pooper.

 

Shruti says:

October 05,2010 at 08:24 PM IST

I am reminded of Premchand's story titled Parda (Curtain). It is a story of a limited income household who can afford just one set of clothes which has to be shared by all the women in the family. Hence, in order to hide their poverty, the family always has a curtain in good condition on the front door of their house.

 

Rajni kant Singh says:

October 05,2010 at 08:18 PM IST

Commonwealth was brought to India with a scam and to do the biggest scam ever in the history. Ask Kalmadi how he got the games to India? and why is known to all... India is not ready to accept this extravagenza 8-10 times of extra cost than required. Why the hell a single bit of credit should be given to organising committee and what the hell they have done. NO CREDITS rather and international level probe should follow the CWG to audit why 8 times money was spent and all responsible for this chaos must not be spared.

 

Amit Mirani says:

October 05,2010 at 08:13 PM IST

Indians are always fooled by politicians in the name of National Pride. They forward us mails showing the positives of CWG and govt. says "It will earn Rs. 5bn in the coming years". You can't spend 70,000 crores for the event to earn revenue, which could have been done in just few thousand crores. The Congress govt. is surely going to hide the corruption as it has been doing from the last 60 yrs now. Our media will get some other idiotic topic as always and they will play around other interesting topics. Rajesh, I hope you will continue with your articles even after the games are over and not only you the TOI team would help the nation make sure all those behind the scandal are behind the bars Thanks for your article and making people aware of the costs because Indians really no doubt can easily be fooled by our politicians Jai Hind, Jai Bharat

 

Ravishankar says:

October 05,2010 at 07:57 PM IST

Guys like you can organise a peace rally against corruption after CWG games are over. People are so numb about corruption. People must ask why and shout loudly against corruption. Raja still in ministry is a symbol of Indian people without nerves. If CWG organisers go unpunished it is the people to be blamed. ORGANISE PROTEST NEXT DAY OF CWG CLOSING CEREMONY.

(Reply to Ravishankar)- coolmonty says:

October 05,2010 at 08:13 PM IST

want to see u also...put up or just shut up

 

Vivek Thaokar says:

October 05,2010 at 07:42 PM IST

I would love to hear the President of India declare at the closing ceremony " Let the Audits begin"

(Reply to Vivek Thaokar)- Bhartiyah says:

October 06,2010 at 11:02 AM IST

Good One... but as we all know it would never ever happen.

(Reply to Vivek Thaokar)- AuditWizard says:

October 07,2010 at 03:30 PM IST

I have already tendered for the audits with a fifty per cent cut for you know who! I hope no one pips me to it with a ninety five per cent cut. If that happens I will simply up the fees and offer ninety nine per cent. That should do the trick!

(Reply to AuditWizard)- Vivek Thaokar says:

October 07,2010 at 08:11 PM IST

Man ...that would mean we would have to audit the auditors too...not surprising judging by what Satyam auditors did.

(Reply to Vivek Thaokar)- Ashok Gupta says:

October 09,2010 at 10:40 PM IST

President is a puppet in the hands of the Govt.

(Reply to Vivek Thaokar)- Abhijit says:

October 10,2010 at 01:02 AM IST

Nice sense of humour :)

 

Dsri says:

October 05,2010 at 07:40 PM IST

In future India want to conduct this type of Big circus i mean events, they should completely remove the responsibility from the hands of Gov. people, politicians and beaurocrats and they should give it to Private companies, so they should responsible for organizing whole event and whole money should get from sponsoring from other private companies, so gov. of India no need to spend single penny from tax payers money. So this idea evolves from the so called Coca-Cola games conducted by America, i think Atlanta Olympics, completely funded by private companies. This is the only future saving grace for India for avoiding, getting rid of these Kalmaddi's and ugly mouth Bhanot's and other ugly corrupt politicians and corrupt beaurocrats who almost increased this Big circus budget to almost 10 times compared to initial budget. I can expect almost 30 to 40% of CWG budget goes to corruption, the rest what we're watching. Despite of corruption they shamed nation by showing ugly toilets and dogs wandered beds to outside world, Only saving grace is Wizcraft's extravanza, so always corporate companies deliver for such cost, but always gov. people fail with their lazy and corruption practices.

 

ABSheikh says:

October 05,2010 at 07:25 PM IST

Rajesh, as you say, you are indeed a party pooper! Bearing in mind the amount spent on items which brought us nothing but shame, the amount which seems to have been spent on the opening ceremony was worth every paisa. 70,000 crores for shame and 350 crores to wipe out that shame sounds like an extra ordinarily good deal to me. Paisa wasool as a gujju would say!

(Reply to ABSheikh)- Rajesh Kalra says:

October 05,2010 at 07:40 PM IST

Haha! Right. Wonder why I never thought of it before :)

 

Ash says:

October 05,2010 at 07:22 PM IST

Guys see it through this angle: If 70K crores of investement can't filter through the corruption, the burecracy & the politics then nothin can...We have seen till date that Crores were spent on developi......ng India but nothing reached the common man...you know why??? Because the people who should have genuienly spent all this money for the development were indeed developing themselves... 70 thousand crores is a lot of money to mess around with...no doubt quite a lot must have gone into a lot of people Swiss accounts, party funds etc. but see it has still managed to filter thorugh the nonsense for the infrastructure development.... YOU CAN'T stop corruption in India...the only way forward is "the pie to be of such a mammoth sizeeeeeeeeee" that it reaches out to the Common or the Poor man in india... So please be patient...what we should be asking the Politicians or the Indian government is this: Now that you have invested 70,000 crores of money on the Infrastructer development under CWG2010, please shows us the ROI Plans (Return on Investement)...

 

S,.M.Singru says:

October 05,2010 at 07:05 PM IST

Dear Rajesh, you do have a point and it is probably wrong to spend on this scale when some basic needs of our people have not yet been fulfilled. But then, there are always people who feel that the two efforts must go side by side:Eradication of poverty and a certain image building for international consumption.In addition, there is the point of giving a spurt to our effort in sports.But, irrespective of which view one takes, there is no doubt that every rupee spent for such an event must be wisely & well spent, & there must not be any lining of pockets.And it is precisely this which hurts, because there is no doubt that, in creating this event,some people have become rich at the cost of quality & probity.

 

Vivek says:

October 05,2010 at 07:05 PM IST

Kalmadi got away with the loot in 2008 at the CYG in Pune . Delhi citizens , please dont let him get away this time, otherwise he will bring Olympics to your city and screw up even more.

 

srikanth says:

October 05,2010 at 06:34 PM IST

Good post Rajesh. The whole world is outsourcing services to India 'coz it is cheaper and has better quality than when done in their own countries. But, we in India spend 350 crore rupees to put up a show which wouldn't cost that much even in the UK which is the most expensive country in commonwealth. So you do the math. It's not hard to point out the high level of corruption that India is burning with. In every single government organization in India you'll see roots of corruption so deep seated that even a non-corrupt official is blatantly pulled into this and turned into a corrupt one.

(Reply to srikanth)- coolmonty says:

October 05,2010 at 08:09 PM IST

ah...Srikanth is the only person in India who never bribed anybody ...gandhiJi...

(Reply to coolmonty)- srikanth says:

October 06,2010 at 01:06 AM IST

I never said I never bribed anyone. I'm a culprit as well. In fact I'd say almost 90% of Indian population are culprits. Have you seen anything done in a government office without actually bribing someone. Well, I haven't.

 

Manish says:

October 05,2010 at 06:24 PM IST

Our sports people do all the hard work for peanuts and our politicians, administrators and their contractors rake in the moolah in their name while we fools pay through our noses for it. Already the cost of living has shot through the ceiling. With rip offs like these, there won't be any respite for common man.

 

LRB says:

October 05,2010 at 06:15 PM IST

Hello Rajesh, Nice article showing the actual invisible faces of corruption not under the table but openly over the table. Overall appreciation of a very good show is of the "Security Forces" who had controlled the whole show without any terrorist incident, although the whole Delhi was closed. LRB

 

Rajes says:

October 05,2010 at 06:10 PM IST

Rajesh were you forced to put this article by Congress Pary, As only out of mind person will praise these games where you are mentioning 350 crores were spent on one night. Did sonia or MMS paid from their pocket no. OK agreed for country reputation we have to sacrifice but here our sacrifice meand pocket fillment exercise for Congress politcal leaders.

(Reply to Rajes)- Rajesh Kalra says:

October 05,2010 at 06:52 PM IST

And what makes you think anyone was behind this post? Hope you read it fully. Thank you for your comment

 

Ashok Gupta says:

October 05,2010 at 05:57 PM IST

Dear Netas/ Bureacrates: Please Go on looting......... till the exchequer shows blank.

 

sharan says:

October 05,2010 at 05:50 PM IST

Very valid point, Rajesh. If I remember rightly, perhaps that amount was the initial estimate for the entire CWG drama including all the infrastructure; not just for the opening ceremony. Kalmadi and Co. will be depending on the Indian public's legendary shortness of memory to get away with their thievery, especially after the rave reviews that the opening ceremony seems to have attracted. In fact, I am sure that even some of your readers will find it "offensive" that you are "nitpicking" at "few rupees here and there". We must never forget that the efficiency of the whole CWG process has been abysmally low, and that we are getting extremely low value for our money, in spite of all the razzle dazzle that we are being exposed to. If the price of bottled water at the local shop goes up from Rs 10 to Rs 11, most of us would immediately notice and question it. But here the costs have increased by at least 50 times over the initial estimates; like the price of bottled water going up from Rs 10 to Rs 500. How much more should we be concerned? Which self-respecting "leader" can offer such a meaningless "budget" or "estimate" that is then exceeded by over 50 times in reality? Our so-called leaders have lost all sense of shame that they can even say these ridiculous things without batting an eyelid.

(Reply to sharan)- Rajesh Kalra says:

October 05,2010 at 06:18 PM IST

Thank you, Sharan. Your comment is apt, as always.

(Reply to sharan)- Ashith says:

October 07,2010 at 06:42 PM IST

http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/govt-expects-cwg-to-add-5-bn-to-economy-create-25-mn/410379/ To Validate my comments.. please check this out. Pls dont be as narrow minded as you are now.

 

Amit Deshpande says:

October 05,2010 at 05:40 PM IST

It is crazy to know the amount spent on the bash. Reminds me Saif Ali Khan was paid Rs. 2 crore to dance on a song, at the closing ceremony at Melbourne Games which was an announcement of the Delhi Games. Would be interesting to know how many streams of sports in our country could get alloted their budget in the Rs.350 crore every year.

(Reply to Amit Deshpande)- Rajesh Kalra says:

October 05,2010 at 06:20 PM IST

Thank you, Amit. Hope we don't forget to question those who have milked us in the name of these games once they are over. I am hopeful some good comments and suggestions would come and we can then act on them. Cheers

 

Qaari says:

October 05,2010 at 05:34 PM IST

It is imaginable that people who formed Tricolor or Namaste are indian people. They might have been paid twice, thrice for working over time in practice or so. We can imagine that all the scenic fire work may be from Sivakasi cottage industry output. So if the Opening ceremony budget is multiplied from 50 crore to 350 crore for any reason (corruption included)we wouldn't mind because of only one reason: GHEE KAHAN GIRA? KHICHDI MEIN. (where did Ghee fall? in the Khichdi). If most of the show is by imported technology, it means our money is siphoned in foreign banks. If we can't do any thing with our own hands then what are we showing? HAATH KI SAFAI or dirty hands?

(Reply to Qaari)- antrixv says:

October 06,2010 at 02:32 PM IST

It is the most stupid argument ever. In that case why such brouhaha over Kalmadi, after all he and his cronies are Indians ...going by your logic of ghee and khichdi, the money was made by the fellow Indians. Wake up and be sensible...whereever the ghee falls, I need to know if it fell in the right thali..and that is not the case with CWG. The UPA acted like Shikhandi when bhopal victims asked for the aid and showed some 450 crores but shamelessly spent or rather siphoned thousands of crores of public money in the name of games that nobody goes to watch...did you see latest cnn clippings

 

Anil Kumar says:

October 05,2010 at 05:30 PM IST

When Mayawati can spend 2600 Crore on her own statues, stones and permanently damaging environment, Then why can't we spend 350 Cr to have some national pride..

(Reply to Anil Kumar)- SM says:

October 05,2010 at 06:01 PM IST

Anil: Are you saying that everybody is happy with money Mayawati is spending on unproductive activities? If yes, you know it's not true. Also note that looking at Kalmadi's track record, we are certain that at least 7% of that money has gone into the pockets of many friends and bosses of Kalmadi, hence this article.

(Reply to SM)- Sughosh Bansal says:

October 05,2010 at 06:45 PM IST

SM - You are missing the point. The crux is that no one including Mr. Rajesh Kalra had made any noise worth hearing on the expenditure of Rs. 2,500 or whatever by Mayawati. and we all are making noises on CWG. By no means I intend to justify the corruption, chaos, mismanagement etc. but should we not concentrate our energies on more worthwhile issues. Yes if every one agrees, let us make an important issue on Corruption and let us strt with CWG. Another crux is how many of we Indians are honest in paying Taxes? some study says it is less than 10% of the probable Tax Payers. So another issue is to launch a crusade for paying taxes honestly by at least 80% if not more.

(Reply to Sughosh Bansal)- Anil Kumar says:

October 05,2010 at 07:17 PM IST

ditto

(Reply to Sughosh Bansal)- Thinking out of box says:

October 06,2010 at 09:53 AM IST

The problem with India is that even after 60 years of Independence after slavery of over 1000 years (including British and Muslim), somehow majority of us think (probably genetically) that the Indian government is foreign. On the other side, the majority of leaders and 99% of bureaucrats (may be in their genes) think that this chance of making money for their family will never come back.

(Reply to SM)- Daniem Perreira says:

October 05,2010 at 06:58 PM IST

SM, I think you must be rather naive to believe that the percentage is 7%. I think it is above 15-20%

(Reply to SM)- Anil Kumar says:

October 05,2010 at 07:26 PM IST

No. no no no.. I actually wrote that in frustration, coz Mayawati got away with that amount of waste which has done no good to anyone. Atleast this 350 Cr has brought some glory.

(Reply to SM)- Ananth says:

October 05,2010 at 08:39 PM IST

SM, did you miss out a zero ? 7 percent is too small to be seen by like of Kalmadi and his friends ( though it may be a big amount to you and me) - were you thinking of 70 % ?

(Reply to SM)- Anshul says:

October 08,2010 at 12:55 PM IST

Dude..why blame Kalmadi for everything. Kalmadi is just part of the whole empire. Well yeah your 7% for Kalmadi is a reasonable guess. I accidentaly overheard the things in one of the govt. funded schemes. The secretary on phone himself said 30% is for bureaucracy in any govt. scheme...

(Reply to Anil Kumar)- Rajkumar says:

October 05,2010 at 07:54 PM IST

It looks like all of us are doing hard work and paying tax for such of corrupt people. Please spread it, we should stop paying tax.

(Reply to Anil Kumar)- Kailash says:

October 07,2010 at 02:05 PM IST

“Inflation will not go down ever, recession will die never”. In practical life “Inflation will not go down ever, recession will die never”. Time has proved that single channel earning is always weaker than the plural channel earning irrespective of its size. Diversification brings growth and stability for business owner similarly diversified income source brings financial stability, growth and prosperity for individuals and families.Still some people think this is not their stuff! See the survey report data below – One in 9 people do (telecommuting) online work from home job Part time / full time worldwide. Almost a third are in professional and related services 50.3% are between the ages of 35 and 54 60.7% have children that are not present while they work from home, despite the stereotype of the Stay-at-home parent with young kids in the next room 78% have at least some college education (including 46.5% with a bachelor’s degree or higher) 42.6% earn $75,000 or more annually 81.7% are non-Hispanic whites 67.8% are married 94.8% are U.S. citizens http://www.worldwideoutsourcinghub.com Worldwide Outsourcing Hub Create a secondary source of income. Today

(Reply to Anil Kumar)- Swapnil says:

October 07,2010 at 03:40 PM IST

Mayawati had spent 2600 Cr on her Statues, however when flood hit the state she had to beg for 2000 Cr. to centre.The 2600 Cr was not justified at all. Wish those statues becomes her "Makbara".

(Reply to Anil Kumar)- Raghavendra says:

October 08,2010 at 06:16 PM IST

Criticizing Mayawati deeds is not going to wipe off Kalmadi&co. stain.

 

Rini Khanna says:

October 05,2010 at 05:25 PM IST

I think we should demand an audit of the Games....and refuse to pay the taxes that will be imposed on us to recover the monies siphoned off by the corrupt and inept officials...

(Reply to Rini Khanna)- Rajkumar says:

October 05,2010 at 07:51 PM IST

I am comletely agreed with Rini and I hope whole of our indians pepole will agreed. We should stop paying tax till the time we do not get the correctness and true & fair view of such a huge expenses. why should we bear the burden of tax and put the money into some of corrupt,dishonest politicians.

(Reply to Rajkumar)- Ram says:

October 05,2010 at 08:16 PM IST

I agree.

(Reply to Rajkumar)- Rachit Jauhari says:

October 06,2010 at 04:48 PM IST

In Many Companies Tax is already deducted. How we make sure that Tax should not be deducted? So, this point not to pay tax is irrelevent.

(Reply to Rini Khanna)- Gautam De says:

October 06,2010 at 01:30 AM IST

Yeah. But Govt. will FORCE the auditors to cook the entire data sheet - and anyway the auditors around the world is doing that for Governments and Private companies.

(Reply to Rini Khanna)- greatbear says:

October 06,2010 at 08:10 AM IST

Just to let everyone know, in Indonesia, due to widespread corruption noticed people stopped paying income taxes till one of the big culprits i.e. Income tax official was booked and imprisoned. This guy had absconded to Singapore. After people stopped paying taxes, within 24 hrs, he was caught and brought back. Though this does not mean that all the corruption was cleaned up, but at least it had some affect. Now media has done its job to highlight. It is upto you and me to decide what to do next. CAN YOU DARE????

(Reply to Rini Khanna)- Blogger Check says:

October 07,2010 at 02:56 AM IST

Friends!! On your request after CWG, Govt will say we respect your( public) sentiments and appoint a committee to find out the irregularity happen in CWG spendings. Thats well experienced answer govt have( after all its not first scam for Govt). It seems then every one will be happy and will celebrate win !!!! God Bless you !!!

 

mshagv says:

October 05,2010 at 05:22 PM IST

Rightly said. The artists need to be complimented for their sincere and tireless performance. No credit may be given to the members of org committee. Taxpayers should be shown the details of expenditure of each Rupee spent. In democratic country, transparency has to respected. We should never forget the looters till they have faced the justice. Media must follow up.

(Reply to mshagv)- Rajeev says:

October 06,2010 at 03:28 PM IST

Yes,to tackle corruption all the expenses approved/claimed by all officials,workers of all government departments on various tasks should be published on a website. Also,while I thoroughly enjoyed the opening ceremony,the following words of Mani Shankar Aiyar were reverberating in my guilty mind "let us not forget that 70 crore people in our country are so poor that they earn less than 20 rupees a day.The 70,000 crore may well have been spent to alleviate poverty and assets creation". I think perhaps(as an example) rather than spending Rs.30,000 crore on Delhi metro,the government could have created a public private entity for modern rail coaches for Rs.10,000 crore which might have reduced the overall costs and may have given jobs to hundered of needy families.

 

anuj says:

October 05,2010 at 05:21 PM IST

Let there be an international kind of audit (Paul Volker in Iraq scam) and you will find that this 'Tamasha' is a 'Tamacha'. While the whole world is turning to India for high quality still substantially cheaper engineering services, we are spending so much on a show which is definitely a very low quality 'nothing spectacular' just old remixed show. But how to get that done, Rajesh do you have an idea how citizens and taxpayers get it done.

(Reply to anuj)- Sachetak says:

October 05,2010 at 08:52 PM IST

The Govt had assured the Parliament that after the games there would be a thorough enquiry of all CWG contracts and expenses. Let us wait for a fortnight and see if this shameless Govt keeps its word. Yesterday, LK Advani had also issued statements that, after the games, the opposition shall take up this issue with the Govt. As to the expenditure on opening ceremony, it is very much on expected lines - when all other expenses have been inflated how could this be exempted? Kalmadi&Co may not be HONEST but it is FAIR to apply DISHONESTY in all deals without partiality. I sincerely hope, Rajesh and all other scribes, who have so relentlessly pursued the CWG scam, would not let the scamsters go scot free.

(Reply to Sachetak)- Ashok Gupta says:

October 05,2010 at 11:00 PM IST

They all will forget Including Rajesh, I Assure you. We all have the 'The Art of Forgetting", or the apathy to happenings around us but not directly affecting us. Regards.

(Reply to Ashok Gupta)- Tanuj says:

October 08,2010 at 12:52 AM IST

Sad, but true!

(Reply to Sachetak)- ramesh says:

October 06,2010 at 04:20 AM IST

THE CONGRESS IS SETTING VERY HIGH NORMS IN CORRUPTION.MMSINGH HAS SET HIS EYES TO MAKE INDIA THE MOST CORRUPT COUNTRY IN THE WORLD. WE WILL BE ABLE TO PROUDLY SAY THAT WE ARE ON TOP.KALMADI IS JUST A SMALL FRY.NOTHING WILL HAPPEN.

(Reply to ramesh)- Niks says:

October 08,2010 at 12:45 AM IST

If the threadmill can be rented for Rs 10 Lac for 45 days then opening ceremony can also cost Rs 350 Cr. Thank God it didn't cost 3500 cr. After games are over all files will go missing and Govt will say since we couldn't file files we can't do anything including replies to RTI. for example recently when an RTI was filed to find out the telephone records of PM's office at the time of Bhopal Gas tragedy, GOI responded by saying no records are availble. So don't expect too much. Sometime there is fire in MoH then something goes missing from MoE etc. This time everything will go missing from Ministry of sports office.

(Reply to Sachetak)- RK says:

October 06,2010 at 07:23 AM IST

the bloody govt & politicos are shameless and always hide behind enq./commissions

(Reply to RK)- Sachetak says:

October 06,2010 at 10:38 AM IST

Its very true. Let us wait for the Govt to keep its word. If, you see any dilly-dallying, COME OUT ON THE STREETS WITH BLACK ARM BANDS and FORCE THE GOVT to punish the scamsters. Please collect photos of all roads that have caved-in. These were not well laid out roads, but only side walks with superfluous carpeting on top of the soil. Cross-section of caved-in roads will reveal that. Otherwise, just pull a corner of the carpeting and it will reveal the soil. Reddy, Shiela etc who have been boasting of beautiful roads in Delhishould be taken to the site and shown the actual condition of these roads, and they should be booed and jeered by the public. These shameless entities should be ridiculed by the citizens where ever and whenever they are seen in public.

(Reply to RK)- avtar says:

October 08,2010 at 06:48 PM IST

A well worded reminder for all those who understand the language of the scribes !

(Reply to Sachetak)- SP says:

October 07,2010 at 03:16 PM IST

It is not that Rajesh & Co. (read other scribes)will let the scamsters go scot-free, but the naked Indian reality facing us all, that no scamster is ever punished, & even if after endeless years of Court trials, he/she is punished, the punishment is a mere drop in the ocean, in terms of financial & other harms that the country faces/d.

(Reply to anuj)- Nadar Venky says:

October 07,2010 at 10:41 AM IST

IN FUTURE, I'M GOING TO JOIN AS MEMBER OF ORGANIZING COMMITTEE OF OLYMPICS AND LOOT A LOT OF MONEY, AND WHEN EVERYONE INCLUDING MEDIA CRITICIZE ME, I'LL SPEND Rs.500 CRORES ON THE GRAND OPENING CEREMONY, SO THAT ALL CITIZENS INCLUDING MEDIA WILL FEEL PROUD AND FORGET THE CORRUPTION AND I'LL CONTINUE MY LOOTING FOREVER AFTER. CHALTHA HAI INDIA.

(Reply to Nadar Venky)- Tanuj says:

October 08,2010 at 12:54 AM IST

That is what exactly has happened. I hope the scam masters get punished.

(Reply to Nadar Venky)- Ashok Gupta says:

October 09,2010 at 10:34 PM IST

I wish you a good Luck.

Comments on this Post are now closed.

Top Rated

More
  • Day
  • |
  • Week
  • |
  • Month
  • |
  • All Time

Archives
« March 2011
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
  
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
10
11
12
13
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
  
       
Today
 
SEARCH TIMES BLOGS
 
 
ABOUT RAJESH KALRA More
Rajesh Kalra is the Chief Editor of Times Internet and responsible for innovations. A journalist for two decades, he also tried his hands at entrepreneurship in between. Although he has written on several subjects, he has a weakness for IT and telecommunications. He is an avid sportsman, a trained high-altitude mountaineer and a marathoner. His blog, Random Access, will cover issues that take into account these varied interests.
 
The views expressed in Random Access are the author´s own.
 
 
Powered by Indiatimes