What if Iran had carried out the Gaza carnage?

By KOUROSH ZIABARI

It's not unjustifiable to consider Israel as the absolute incarnation of fraudulence, relentlessness and brutality. Since its establishment, the Zionist regime has carried out actions which contravene the international regulations and cancel out human rights in one way or another. Only a brief look into the account of Israel's bloody interaction with the Palestinian people over the past years shows us that this fabricated regime does not deserve "the right of existence", as the US and European officials put it periodically.

The Monday assault of the Israel Defense Forces on the flotilla carrying humanitarian aid to the besieged Gaza Strip from Turkey left at least 10 dead and several other wounded. Never mind that Israel's criminal action violated the 4 Geneva 1949 Convention. Just imagine for a single moment that Iran had carried out the carnage instead of Israel. Simply replace the two names and then read the news as reported by CNN: "The Free Gaza Movement, one of the organizers of the aid, said that Israeli commandos dropped from a helicopter onto the deck of one of the ships early Monday and immediately opened fire on unarmed civilians."

Since September 2000, Israel killed more than 6,300 Palestinians, most of whom were children and defenseless civilians. Israel has also demolished more than 25,000 Palestinian homes since 1967. It possess up to 200 nuclear warheads in violation of the United Nations Security Council Resolution 487. Interestingly, it receives something around $7 million of military aid from the US per day. 7,383 Palestinians are being kept in the prisons of Israel. The racist regime of Israel has built 223 settlements on the Palestinians' confiscated lands. Over the six-year period between September 2000 and February 2006, 36,589 Palestinians were injured by the Israeli forces of whom 3,530 Palestinians were permanently disabled or maimed. Shockingly, this six-year period was witness to the confiscation of 249,680 km of Palestinian lands. Israeli forces even refused to overlook the Palestinian trees as they uprooted 1,187,762 Palestinian trees from 2000 to 2006. This shows the nature of the brutal regime of Israel which is even at odds with the natural resources and trees, let alone human beings.

Although it's practically unthinkable, try to replace Iran and Israel, imagining for a single moment that Iran is the occupying state that kills at least two foreign civilians a day, beleaguers some 1.5 million people who don't have any access to the barest rudiments of their daily life and live under the continual threats of military assault and are in dire need of humanitarian assistance. Would the so-called international community tolerate it? Would the UN secretary-general suffice to a simple "expression of concern" with regards to such an incessant viciousness, if it had not been Israel?

To be honest with ourselves, Israel is enjoying an unconditional impunity from all of the international rules, laws and regulations and acts like an autonomous state which does not come to terms with any obligation and responsibility. After the dissolution of South Africa's apartheid regime, which was recently revealed to have had a nuclear deal with Tel Aviv in 1957, Israel is the only apartheid entity which remains on the face of the world map and the unyielding support of the superpowers holds up this flimsy existence at any rate.

United States and its European allies always lent their support to Israel and backed the felonies of Tel Aviv even in the most crucial pivots, such as the Operation Cast Lead of the September 2008 — January 2009 which led to the termination of Israel's diplomatic relations with four countries: Venezuela, Bolivia, Qatar and Mauritania.

Anyway, the international reactions to the latest brutality of Israel in a pre-dawn attacking to the civilians asleep in a humanitarian aids flotilla which included 700 peace activists from different nationalities was expected and at the same time, unpardonably deplorable.

The Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper who has several times attacked Iran over its nuclear program has simply expressed his regret over the deaths and injuries which "occurred", shrugging off the responsibility of the atrocious perpetrator and the architect of the massacre. "Canada deeply regrets the loss of life and the injuries suffered. We are currently looking for more information in order to shed light on what exactly happened," the ridiculous statement of the Canadian premier reads. Canada is still looking for information about what has happened! Maybe the Israel Defense Force can answer the questions! "They had not coordinated with us as to the shipping of humanitarian aid to Gaza, so we shot and killed them in the morning."

The reaction of the other countries was not something of more value. Some of them summoned the Israeli ambassadors for clarifications, some of them regretted the death of civilians and sympathized with the families of the dead, some of them expressed their "serious concern" over the happening and the rest remained indifferent as the Israeli officials gave their strong backing to the massacre, leaving thousands of unanswered questions and bunches of ambiguity regarding the modality of international relations which make a fabricated state such as Israel so guaranteed and impervious to international regulations that nobody can stop it.

The NPT 2010 review conference in which 189 countries unanimously called on Israel to put its nuclear activities and facilities under the comprehensive IAEA safeguards was similarly responded arrogantly by Tel Aviv: We are not NPT signatory and thus we don't need its supervision, we want to possess our nuclear weapons to use them whenever necessary!

Anyway, the "international community" which in the most cases comprises the United States and its European friends who gave birth to this inauspicious child should tolerate the consequences of the great mistake they made 60 years ago. From the very beginning, it was clear that the establishment of the regime of Israel would be tantamount to insecurity, anxiety and disorder in the Middle East. Now Israel is expanding the frontiers of its aggressiveness and one can easily foresee the days when the European and American civilians are massacred by the Zionist regime, a simple instance of which we witnessed in the flotilla case.

Again, I'm thinking of the same question. What would happen if Iran, my country, had carried out such a vicious action? The country which has never attacked nor occupied any lands over the past 100 years; the country which has never killed any foreign civilian under fallacious pretexts; would it have been treated the same way as Israel?

— Kourosh Ziabari is an Iranian writer.

Comments

ALIREZA

Report abuse
mr Ziabari
this morning i asked myself the same question , what if iran did this ?
i was watching cnn today , they just showed for 2 minute what happend in gaza . if it was iran , the whole day in the news would be reserved for punishing iran. I hope People EYES will be wider .

MEHR

Report abuse
Well said!
The answer to your questions has two aspects: (1): the media is under the control of pro-israeli's and if any US or Canadian president wish to stay in power need to satisfy their lobbyists. Is Iran controlling the media? NO. (2): Atany point of time, US need an enemy to drive its agenda and during cold war it was Soviet Union, now it is poor iran. Does Iran deserves that ? NO. It seems US and west does not know how to work without an enemy and in peace.

NIMA

Report abuse
Great article Kourosh,you and I both know that Iran would not recieve the same reaction as Israel did.Iran would be demonized and severely punished.Love your article!

ESTHER HAMAN

Report abuse
The Zionists Propaganda machine which controls the US and most of the Europe will twist the current events and atrocities of the Zionist to be blamed on Iran and the Palestinians. This issue just like the "Goldstone" report by the UN will be dismissed by the west as a provocation by Arabs and the Muslim world against the poor Zionists.

It is up to the Arab world to glue their relationship with Iran and to close the gaps and cracks that the foreign governments are creating between them for their own benefits. It is time to open your eyes an dstop th e"Divide and Conquer" policies of the West. No one else will do it for you.

Get up.
Post your comment

required

required (email will never be displayed)

Please enter the following characters in the box provided (case sensitive). This helps us prevent automated programs from creating accounts and sending spam.

All comments are subject to approval

Terms and conditions

Newsletter

Yes, I would like to receive daily news updates from Arab News in my mailbox.

Latest comments

HRC assigns lawyer to pursue case of ‘tortured’ housemaid

How much has to happen before you stop using 'alleged?!?" That's like saying the ''alleged lack

rain at Nov 24, 2010 05:39

2 comments

Afghans party after fulfilling pilgrimage

As usual, notice that the women are conspicuously absent form this picture, except for the hard

rain at Nov 24, 2010 05:39

4 comments

UAE, India to boost historic ties

not belly ache DR. Gopinath <br/> <br/>more like migrane to see Innocent making friends with a

morpheus at Nov 24, 2010 05:39

10 comments

Tariq Aziz will seek presidential pardon

Pardon for what. This man was a part of an administration and high enough to share the blame fo

Hani at Nov 24, 2010 05:39

11 comments

Stab victim won’t forgive Haia man

@ HAROON ..... can you show any proof from the Quran that say not covering the eyes is a sin? a

HUNTERS at Nov 24, 2010 05:38

14 comments

Missing Pakistani gynecologist found in Makkah hospital

Thank You Arab News for your Service to Mankind, And All Praise be to Allah -

Mujeeb at Nov 24, 2010 05:37

25 comments