FEBMARAPR
22
201020112012
104 captures
10 Mar 2011 - 07 May 2021
About this capture
MIDDLE EAST
9 March 2011 Last updated at 03:30 ET
History's lessons: Dismantling Egypt's security agency

A protester carries away with the SSI sign after Egyptians stormed the building
Egypt's Revolution
Egypt's secret torture unveiled
Rebuilding after sectarian strife
Growing fears of Egypt's Copts
Bowen: Bumpy ride
The task of dismantling Egypt's repressive security service may seem immense, but Middle East analyst Omar Ashour draws lessons from other once feared and hated secret services around the world.
History does repeat itself.
The evening of 5 March in Egypt was much like that of 15 January 1990, when thousands of German protesters stormed the headquarters of the State Security Ministry (Stasi) in Berlin.
The direct causes of the protests were shockingly similar - state security officers were seeking impunity by destroying files that documented corruption and repression. Consequently, citizens gathered and tried to safeguard the incriminating evidence.
Fortunately for the Stasi, YouTube and Facebook did not exist in 1990. Unfortunately for Egypt's State Security Investigations (SSI), they did.
When I saw my two kids I did not recognise them and they did not recognise me”
Magdi Zaki
Former political prisoner
Egypt's secret torture unveiled
Secret graveyards, medieval-like dungeons, files of political dissidents held for more than a decade, lists of informants - celebrities, religious figures, talk-show hosts and "opposition" leaders - were all captured on camera and uploaded onto the popular websites.
"I spent 12 years in the political section of Liman Abu Zaabal prison - without charge, without visits," former detainee Magdi Zaki told local media.
"When I saw my two kids I did not recognise them and they did not recognise me. But worst of all was the month I spent in the state security building," he said.
There are reasons for this.
'Red lines'
Torture rooms and equipment were captured on camera in every SSI building stormed by protesters.
Unfortunately for the SSI and its last head, Gen Hassan Abd al-Rahman, who ordered the destruction process, reassembling the enormous amount of shredded files will not take a decade like in the case of the Stasi. Advanced computer-assisted data recovery systems exist now.
For many Egyptians, the sheer size and the graphic details of the released files were shocking.
The unlawful detentions, kidnappings and disappearances, systematic torture and rape, and the inhuman prison conditions have all been well documented since the 1980s, by both human rights organisations and Egyptian courts. But many media outlets did not dare to address those "red lines".
Amateur video purportedly shows protesters raiding ministry and secret police offices in Cairo
Aside from the horrific stories, more mundane matters help to illustrate how Egypt was run under Mubarak.
In early 2000, I met an SSI general who effectively ran Cairo University. The intellectually unsophisticated general - to put it mildly - decided which dean should run which school, which professors got hired, fired, or promoted, and which students should discontinue their education.
Never openly discussed before, these former "red lines" are now being exposed.
"The fall of the state of state security" was the headline of al-Ahram newspaper, the one-time mouthpiece of the Mubarak regime.
Lessons from abroad
Democratisation processes have at least four phases: dictatorship removal, transition, consolidation and maturation.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel visits the Stasi archives in Berlin
With the fall of the SSI, Egypt seems quite close to completing phase one of its inspirational struggle for democracy - the removal of its dictator and his coercive apparatus, one that behaved more like a crime syndicate than a professional security service.
But moving into the transitional phase will require institutional and legal reform.
The experiences of other countries - notably Chile, Indonesia, South Africa, East Germany, Argentina, Spain, and South Korea - are quite useful.
Comprehensive security sector reform (SSR) was at the core of democratisation in those countries. It targeted the intelligence services, police, judiciary, prison system, and the civilian management of the security services.
The core idea of the reform was simple: the security of the individual citizen is the primary objective of the security apparatus, not the security of the regime or any other entity.
This simple idea reverses the reality in Egypt, where the principal threat for many law-abiding citizens was not al-Qaeda or the Mossad, but the SSI and other Egyptian police institutions.
Final stages
In the aforementioned countries that moved into the transitional phase, the SSI-equivalents were dismantled - the Stasi in East Germany, the Bakorstanas in Indonesia, and the National Centre for Intelligence (CNI) in Chile.
The accompanying emergency laws were also annulled, most notably Indonesia's notorious 1963 Anti-Subversion Law.
A third critical step in security sector reform is the continuous monitoring of security agencies by elected parliamentary committees.

The death in custody of Khaled Said last year was an early rallying point for Egypt's revolutionaries
In Indonesia, parliamentary oversight was introduced under President Abdurrahman Wahid (1999-2001). As a result, three parliamentary commissions monitor every security apparatus in the country.
In Chile, the Senate approved the creation of a civilian National Intelligence Agency (ANI) and, by law, all security agencies have to provide any requested information to that body.
Even highly professional security agencies in the West are monitored. The British MI5, for example, is overseen by the Intelligence and Security Committee that comprises nine parliamentarians drawn from the House of Commons and the House of Lords.
A fourth critical step is dealing with gross violations of human rights committed by the SSI against Egyptians.
In that regard, a Truth and Reconciliation Commission, akin to that of South Africa, may be essential to form a restorative justice system for the victims. Victims would be invited to share their testimonies, while perpetrators of gross violations could give their statements and apply for amnesty.
Overall, despite the numerous hurdles along Egypt's road to democratisation - including attacks by remaining elements of the security forces against mosques, churches and pipelines - the country seems to be on the right path.
The dismantling of the SSI, the annulment of emergency law, the parliamentary oversight of security apparatuses, and the formation of a reconciliation commission will usher in a democratic transition in Egypt.
Omar Ashour is a lecturer in Middle East Politics and Director of the Middle East Graduate Studies Program at the Institute of Arab and Islamic Studies, University of Exeter (UK). He is the author of The De-Radicalisation of Jihadists: Transforming Armed Islamist Movements.
More on This Story
Egypt's Revolution
Features and Analysis
Egypt's secret torture unveiled
Hundreds of Egyptians raid state security headquarters in Cairo to claim hidden torture documents, the BBC's Alastair Leithead reports from Cairo.
Rebuilding after sectarian strife
Growing fears of Egypt's Copts
Bowen: Bumpy ride
Inside the Brotherhood
Final moments before the fall
Can military meet demands?
Economy under pressure
Profiles
Mohamad Tantawi
Hosni Mubarak
Omar Suleiman
Wael Ghonim
Mohamed ElBaradei
Muslim Brotherhood
Guides
Q&A: Constitution referendum
Q&A: Egypt protests
Key military figures
Protest timeline
Map timeline
Protests map
Related Stories
Egyptians raid secret police HQ 05 MARCH 2011, MIDDLE EAST
Share this page
More Middle East stories
US crew rescued after Libya crash
Two US airmen are rescued in eastern Libya after their warplane crashed during allied operations, officials say.
Yemeni president warns of coup
Strikes on Gaza 'kill children'
Top Stories
US crew rescued after Libya crash
Karzai names Nato pullout areas
Power cables laid at Japan plant
Strikes on Gaza 'kill children'
Yemeni president warns of coup
Features & Analysis
Obama's war tent
How the US leader keeps Libya strike secrets while on the move
Baptism by ice
Russia's trend for dipping children in frozen rivers
In pictures
Why ex-Miss Venezuela wanted people to see her cancer battle
Knut's story
Is it wrong to keep polar bears in zoos?
Most Popular
Shared
Read
'Extinction threat' to religion
US warplane crash-lands in Libya
Tests shed light on life origins
Putin denies Russia rift on Libya
Barack Obama's top secret tent
Power cables laid at Japan plant
Live: Libya crisis
In pictures: Ex-Miss Venezuela's public cancer battle
German incest case father jailed
Cameroon 'robbers' killed at sea
Video/Audio
Elsewhere on BBC News
Invisible hazard
What impact could radiation concerns have on Japan's food industry - at home and abroad?
Programmes
HARDtalk
Media tycoon Alexander Lebedev admits his Moscow newspaper Novaya Gazeta runs 'slight risks'
Services
News feeds
Mobile
Podcasts
Alerts
E-mail news
About BBC News
Editors' blog
BBC College of Journalism
News sources
World Service Trust
Mobile
About the BBC
BBC Help
Contact Us
Accessibility Help
Terms of Use
Jobs
Privacy & Cookies
Advertise With Us
BBC © MMXI The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.
HomeUS & CanadaLatin AmericaUKAfricaAsia-PacEuropeMid-EastSouth AsiaBusinessHealthSci/EnvironmentTechEntertainmentVideo
DeliciousDiggFacebookredditStumbleUponTwitterEmailPrint
NewsSportWeatherTravelTVRadioMore