College of Journalism
  • You are here:
  • Discussion

BBC College of Journalism Blog - A vigorous and robust discussion about journalism from every perspective.


The cult of celebrity is firmly established in journalism and, whether you like the idea or not, it's producing compelling television.

Ross Kemp's Extreme World on Sky 1HD (below), about the Mexican city of Ciudad Juarez, is the latest from the Bafta award-winning reporter formerly known as Grant Mitchell.

I haven't seen any of journalism's big beasts popping up in this part of the world, but there's the former soap actor hardman poking his unwelcome nose into cartel atrocities that have made Juarez one of the most dangerous cities on earth.

Extreme World: Sky website.

At least 28,000 people have been killed in Mexico since President Felipe Calderon's campaign against organised crime, according to the country's national security agency.

In the few days of Kemp's visit to Juarez, more than 40 people were murdered, casually, in cold blood; and often in full view of the population. This was despite 11,000 police and troops patrolling the meanest streets.

It's a war in all but name, and Kemp risked life and limb to shine a light on a place so violent that your survival choices can come down to a simple question of silver or lead - you take a bribe to comply with the gangs or they kill you.

In a place where the homicide clear-up rate is about 5%, Kemp chatted to gang-member teens, rode with a first-on-scene paramedic, visited a maximum security prison to quiz a cartel hitman, and even interviewed a senior figure in the organised crime scene.

Was there enough intellectual rigour to his questions? Probably not. Could his report have been more layered, more detailed, more journalistic? Absolutely. And Sky's website could, and should, have made so much more of his trip.

But there was Kemp, in harm's way and tugging at the threads of much bigger issues: extreme wealth and extreme poverty; venal politicians and the exercise of power; the lure of drugs and the gravitational pull of the US as the biggest cocaine market in the world.

It's one of the great strengths of the BBC website that it's possible to track back through coverage of topics that register on your radar. A quick search reveals more than 180 news results for Ciudad Juarez, including one-off reports like a particularly violent weekend last month, as well as more feature-led pieces such as the online "Tale of the Border" from 2009 or this graphic audio slideshow which ends prophetically with the words that the violence "will keep getting worse".

But look for video and audio in the search results and the pickings are much thinner. That may be down to inadequacies of the BBC search engine; or it may be that the occasional package is seen as sufficient; or that the story doesn't resonate here and is better left to the US networks.

It may also have something to do with the perilous nature of trying to report from the country, according to Mike O'Connor of the Committee to Protect Journalists. "My strong impression is Mexico is losing its sovereignty over much of its territory to the cartels," says O'Connor, who is critical of superficial US press coverage. Incidents are reported but there's very little on the causes and consequences of what is happening in "our backyard", he says.

You can read a fuller account of his thoughts in Joseph J. Kolb's Editor and Publisher article Losing the War on Reporting the Mexico Narco Violence. When you have, take your hat off to Kemp and ask yourself why mainstream news organisations aren't doing a better job of reporting this bloody conflict and the wider issues it raises.

Footnote: Hat tip too to Al Jazeera's Chris Arsenault for his feature on the city's murdered and missing women, which ran on International Women's Day.



Comments

or register to comment.

There have been no comments made here yet.


Search CoJo Online

 

About Discussion on CoJo

A vigorous and robust discussion about journalism from every perspective.


This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.