MARAPRMAY
16
201020112012
47 captures
16 Apr 2011 - 10 Mar 2021
About this capture
Search All NYTimes.com

The Opinion Pages
April 15, 2011, 8:30 pm
In Defense of Offense
By DICK CAVETT
Dick Cavett on his career in show business, and more.
Tags:
‘HUCKLEBERRY FINN’, ‘MIRAL’, NETWORKS, POLITICAL CORRECTNESS
Brief dialogue:
Network executive: We’re afraid some viewers might be offended.
DC: So?
Thus began, with my shocking impertinence, my first lesson in network nervousness.
It couldn’t have come at a more discouraging time. I had just finished taping my very first show on ABC.
I was proud of the lineup of guests I had managed to snare for the scary maiden voyage on the stormy seas of hosting a 90-minute talk show. The guests booked were three distinct personalities. What is known in the talk show game as “a good mix.” Muhammad Ali, Angela Lansbury and Gore Vidal.
The talk was brisk and lively and there was much gratifying laughter from the studio audience. I came offstage relieved not to be dripping flop sweat and delighted to have the first one down and at having it go so well.
I expected a cheery slap on the back from the network man, and more or less got it. Only it was applied elsewhere.

“Nobody gives a goddamn what Muhammad Ali and Gore Vidal think about the Vietnam war.”
Shock preceded anger.
Hadn’t I done what I was supposed to do? Booked remarkable guests, kept the conversational ball in the air and entertained the viewers?
Apparently not.
I asked what it was about the show I had just done that the network could be worried about.
“We just don’t want to offend anyone,” he said to my wondering ears. So that was it. Someone somewhere might be offended.
I’ve never quite understood why this word — “offended” — is so horrifying. What doesn’t offend somebody? And who wants to see, read or write anything that is simon-pure in its inability to offend those dreaded “someones”?
“What could be more offensive than an offense-free show?” I sincerely inquired of the network suit.
That was considered offensive.
My favorite first dose of offended reaction is one I may have reported here before. It came from an apparently ruffled resident of Waco, Texas. My secretary was reluctant to show it to me. Hand-printed in pencil and all in caps, it read: “DEAR DICK CAVETT YOU LITTLE SAWED OFF FAGGOT COMMUNIST SHRIMP.”
A lot of thought went into that.
Untypically, there was a return address and I shot right back, “I am not sawed-off.”
Anyone working in the media can tell you that there seems to be an always-ready-to-explode segment of the populace for whom offense is a fate worse than anything imaginable. You’d think offense is one of the most calamitous things that could happen to a human being; right up there with the loss of a limb, or just missing a parking space.
What is our obligation to the offendees? To help them limit their suffering by avoiding all offense? With what advice?
You could stay in the house, watch no TV, read nothing of any kind including potentially upsetting snail mail or e-mail, and you just might manage to glide through an offense-free day. No surly neighbor, no near-misses by unpunished, demented, sidewalk-riding cyclists, no cab driver letting other cabs in ahead of yours while distractedly nattering on his phone in no known language. Stay cocooned and you will risk no insults from rude waiters, no pain from gruff clerks, no snarls from airline employees.
“What sort of thing offends you, Mr. Cavett?” an interviewer asked me recently. “In other words, what to you is politically incorrect.”
“Anything that is politically correct.”
Such as?
Well, the infantilism of the phrase “the n-word,” for example, and of those of less than fully formed cerebral development who have bowdlerized Mark Twain’s masterpiece because of the references to Huck’s beloved friend in the authentic vernacular of the time. I hate to spoil the fun of the benighted and alleged educators who have even pulled this great book from the school shelves, but Jim is the moral center of the story.
Presumably those same people would deny students the pleasure of Joseph Conrad’s “The … [what? ‘Person of Color’?] … of the ‘Narcissus’”? Why endow a word everyone knows with such majestic power that, like Yahweh of the Old Testament, it cannot be uttered?
A current example of offense ready to spring is the reaction of some to Julian Schnabel’s remarkable and stirring new movie, “Miral.” Anything set in the always-simmering Middle East is going to be a lightning rod. But the nay-saying here is upsetting.
Taken from Rula Jebreal’s excellent novel of the same name, much of the expressed heavy criticism of it is all wrong. The movie has had rained upon it the ire of the offense brigade. (Embarrassingly, some prominent Jewish organizations have not felt the need to see it in order to denounce it. Others, though, have praised it.)
Those who take “Miral” as an out-and-out political screed don’t seem to get it. It’s a dramatic rendering of the life of a girl caught up in a troubled world of violent passions. Not, as some fevered detractors have seen it, a venomous assault on Israel.
I have at least two sets of friends who’ve announced that they are definitely not going to see the movie.
I was taken aback. “Shouldn’t you have seen the movie in order to be able to say that?” I said, jesting partially, inspired perhaps by Mark Twain’s opinion that three specific literary scholars who extolled James Fenimore Cooper’s writing might have done well to have read some of it.
As to “Miral,” I suggest you see it.
How sad when art is viewed through a dreary political lens. In a world with a better grip on itself, the proper reaction to Schnabel’s and Jebreal’s touching movie would be, “What a hell of a good story!”
I hope that doesn’t hurt anyone’s feelings.
'huckleberry finn', 'miral', networks, political correctness
Previous Post
Ethical Businesses With a Better Bottom Line
By TINA ROSENBERG
Related Posts from Opinionator
Next Post
An Uncivil War
By PETER CATAPANO
Search This Blog
The host of “The Dick Cavett Show” — which aired on ABC from 1968 to 1975 and on public television from 1977 to 1982 — Dick Cavett is the author, most recently, of “Talk Show: Confrontations, Pointed Commentary, and Off-Screen Secrets.” The co-author of “Cavett” (1974) and “Eye on Cavett” (1983), he has also appeared on Broadway in “Otherwise Engaged,” “Into the Woods” and as narrator in “The Rocky Horror Show,” and has made guest appearances in movies and on TV shows including “Forrest Gump” and “The Simpsons.” Mr. Cavett lives in New York City and Montauk, N.Y.
Inside Opinionator
April 15, 2011
An American Romantic Goes to War
Why militant abolitionist Thomas Wentworth Higginson refused his officer’s commission – at first.
April 14, 2011
Lincoln Declares War
An examination of the language in Lincoln’s Proclamation of April 15, which called up 75,000 troops.
More From Disunion »
April 15, 2011
An Uncivil War
It’s spring, but the budget fight has been anything but a breath of fresh air.
April 8, 2011
Freedom to Inflame
Should the Florida pastor who staged a burning of the Koran be held responsible for inciting riots murder a half a world away?
More From The Thread »
April 15, 2011
In Defense of Offense
The bane of political correctness, in film, television, literature and life.
March 25, 2011
My Liz: The Fantasy
Elizabeth Taylor’s brief career as a magician’s assistant.
More From Dick Cavett »
April 14, 2011
Ethical Businesses With a Better Bottom Line
Why do some companies go to the cost and effort to be socially responsible?
April 11, 2011
A Scorecard for Companies With a Conscience
Any business or brand can claim to be socially responsible, but now there’s a way to prove it.
More From Fixes »
April 14, 2011
Red State Home Companion
How cutting funds for public radio hurts conservative listeners, too.
April 7, 2011
Billionaires Unleashed
Paul Allen, Bill Gates and what all that money does and doesn’t bring.
More From Timothy Egan »
April 13, 2011
The Timid Need Not Apply
Learning on the job — about sin, pleasure and New York.
March 23, 2011
We Were Kittens Once, and Young
I grew up, but my cats got old.
More From Townies »
April 12, 2011
One Step Forward, 20 More to Go
Now, let’s hear how Obama plans to balance the budget. Are higher taxes on wealthier Americans enough to do the trick?
April 6, 2011
The Budget Battles and Beyond
Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security, Paul Ryan and what exactly is the path to prosperity?
More From The Conversation »
April 12, 2011
How to Save a Trillion Dollars
As Congress tries to get the budget under control, it’s worth noting the fiscal toll of treating “lifestyle diseases.”
April 5, 2011
Go Philly!
A nonprofit and a mayor are bringing nutritional progress to a city once ranked low on the real-food chain.
More From Mark Bittman »
April 11, 2011
A Dollar Is a Dollar: Elena Kagan’s Style
In a Kagan dissent, hints of a Supreme Court counterweight to Scalia?
April 4, 2011
Talking to No Purpose
Ritual, if empty, conversation has its time and place, and it’s often during halftime.
More From Stanley Fish »
April 6, 2011
Gitmo Fatigue at the Supreme Court
Three rejected appeals this week may mean the justices have nothing left to say about the legality of the detentions at Guantánamo,
March 23, 2011
A Surprising Snapshot
A look at the Supreme Court decisions this term reveals that corporations don’t always win, employees don’t always lose, and Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas don’t always agree.
More From Linda Greenhouse »
March 30, 2011
The Reform That Wasn’t
On Wall Street, it’s pretty much business as usual again.
March 16, 2011
Degrees of Influence?
As elite higher education turns prohibitively expensive and the job market shrinks, a reminder that dropping out is no guarantee of failure.
More From William D. Cohan »
March 27, 2011
The Future of Manufacturing Is Local
In San Francisco and New York, manufacturing industries are showing signs of life, thanks to a new approach.
January 13, 2011
All Tomorrow’s Taxis
Let’s raise the bar for New York City taxi design.
More From Allison Arieff »
March 19, 2011
Still in the Fight: Steps
Three wounded Marines face the hard work of rehabilitation and a long road ahead.
March 17, 2011
Still in the Fight: Scars
After 30 surgeries in three months, a gravely wounded Marine starts to look ahead.
More From Home Fires »
March 10, 2011
The Ashtray: This Contest of Interpretation (Part 5)
The series on incommensurability concludes with a trip down the minefield of memory lane: a return to Princeton.
March 9, 2011
The Ashtray: The Author of the ‘Quixote’ (Part 4)
The series on incommensurability continues with ‘The Existentialist’s Nightmare’ and the Humpty Dumpty Theory of Meaning.
More From Errol Morris »
March 10, 2011
The Ashtray: This Contest of Interpretation (Part 5)
The series on incommensurability concludes with a trip down the minefield of memory lane: a return to Princeton.
March 9, 2011
The Ashtray: The Author of the ‘Quixote’ (Part 4)
The series on incommensurability continues with ‘The Existentialist’s Nightmare’ and the Humpty Dumpty Theory of Meaning.
More From Errol Morris »
Opinionator Highlights
Still in the Fight: Steps
By MICHAEL D. FAY
Three wounded Marines face the hard work of rehabilitation and a long road ahead.
A Pay-for-Performance Evolution
By TINA ROSENBERG
Many readers believe that a cash-on-delivery approach to foreign aid is unrealistic. But many similar models are working around the world.
Still in the Fight: Scars
By MICHAEL D. FAY
After 30 surgeries in three months, a gravely wounded Marine starts to look ahead.
Art, and War and Consequences
By THE EDITORS
A war artist’s views of the before, during and after of war.
The Power of Partnerships
By DAVID BORNSTEIN
The “collective impact” strategy of creating alliances of civic and business leaders is being applied to social problems across the nation.
Previous Series
Line by Line
A series on the basics of drawing, presented by the artist and author James McMullan, beginning with line, perspective, proportion and structure.
The Elements of Math
A series on math, from the basic to the baffling, by Steven Strogatz. Beginning with why numbers are helpful and finishing with the mysteries of infinity.
The Stone
Contemporary philosophers discuss issues both timely and timeless.
Subscribe
Opinionator RSS
Dick Cavett RSS