CONNECT    

The Smurfs Are Racist, Anti-Semites, Antoine Buéno Suggests In 'Le Petit Livre Bleu'


First Posted: 06/ 3/11 07:21 AM ET Updated: 06/ 3/11 07:38 PM ET

Smurf Village or Hitler's Berlin? Same thing, posits one new book.

French sociologist and author Antoine Buéno asserts in "Le Petit Livre Bleu," or, "The Little Blue Book," that the seemingly friendly little blue creatures living a mostly idyllic existence are actually packed with racial propaganda and are, "the embodiment of a totalitarian utopia, steeped in Stalinism and Nazism".

The comics, created by Belgian artist Peyo, were first introduced in a Belgian newspaper in 1958; by 1960, they had their own comic strip, and it was off to the races. The animated series, produced by Hanna Barbera, was launched in 1981.

As relayed by Todaysxm.com, Buéno says that Papa Smurf, the leader of the village, is an authoritarian figure, and that their lack of private property and collective-style economy is a clear nod to socialism. Meanwhile, their enemy seems Jewish: Gargamel, the monster that haunts the village, matches negative Jewish caricatures and his cat's name is Azrael, the French author writes, while Smurfette, for a long time the only female in the village, is a vision of aryan perfection.

Buéno, in an interview with The Wall Street Journal, touched on what he perceives as their blue racism.

"The first comic strip, 'The Black Smurfs,' was intimately concerned with what you might classify as a racial threat," he said. "Because in that album, the smurfs are sick. And when they're sick, they don't turn purple or red or anything like that, they become black. And when they become black, they lose all trace of intelligence. THey become completely moronic. And further more, they can no longer speak, they just go 'nyap nyap nyap.'"

The black part is indeed true; US publishers refused to publish the first Smurfs book for that reason, and years later, the sick Smurfs were recolored to purple.

Story continues below

Responding to Flemish paper Der Morgen, Thierry Culliford, son of Peyo and current head of Studio Peyo, said (via Forbidden Planet) the accusations were, "between the grotesque and the not serious."

WATCH:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST ENTERTAINMENT

Smurf Village or Hitler's Berlin? Same thing, posits one new book. French sociologist and author Antoine Buéno asserts in "Le Petit Livre Bleu," or, "The Little Blue Book," that the seemingly frie...
Smurf Village or Hitler's Berlin? Same thing, posits one new book. French sociologist and author Antoine Buéno asserts in "Le Petit Livre Bleu," or, "The Little Blue Book," that the seemingly frie...
Filed by Jordan Zakarin  |  Report Corrections
 
  • Comments
  • 666
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Login or connect with: 
More Login Options
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »   (24 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
John Rathe
23 minutes ago (12:13 AM)
Sometimes a Smurf is just a Smurf.
49 minutes ago (11:47 PM)
"The first comic strip, 'The Black Smurfs,' was intimately concerned with what you might classify as a racial threat," he said. "Because in that album, the smurfs are sick.
This is from http://www­.Christian­louboutind­iscountsal­e.net
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
April Pells
2 hours ago (11:00 PM)
Regarding the "turning black" when sick thing, when one is punched in the eye or breaks the nose, you have a black eye, don't you? Not usually referred to as a bruised eye. When people get sick from working in the mines, they get black lung. Frostbite can turn your limbs black. There are plenty of medical conditions in which turning black means there's something wrong. I'm not sure what the big deal is.
2 hours ago (10:53 PM)
Anyone watched Looney Tunes from the 40s to the 60s ? talk about many racial undertones ...remembe­r "speedy gonzales"? the barefoot mexican mouse who loved the ladies? How about "Pepi le Pew" the extremely lustful french skunk? What about all those thick lipped african tribes people with bones sticking through their chins? and the "red Injun" chief who said "how" .....all products of Disney. I hate to admit that when i watch Looney tunes i am both entertaine­d and offended at the same time.
4 hours ago (8:49 PM)
"Racist, Anti-Semit­es" is redundant. Is there a non-racist Nazi somewhere?

Antoine Buéno should roll himself another fat one and play some Zeppelin lp's backward. He'll have a better chance.

My only question is, how was Lady Smurf able to keep up?
photo
SaulBloodworth
Author of The Cabal
3 hours ago (9:41 PM)
If it helps, Mussolini had a Jewish mistress.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rhonnybay
Be well. Love well. Do well.
6 hours ago (6:36 PM)
Unfortunat­ely - I can see his point of view. Subliminal­ly, messages that "dark" bad are a part of entertainm­ent history and has been promoted for years.
photo
SaulBloodworth
Author of The Cabal
3 hours ago (9:40 PM)
try "centuries­"
6 hours ago (6:36 PM)
They're looking into this waaaaay too much! I consider myself to be very militant, and I still watch the smurfs and I didn't find any racist remarks, characters­, epiteths, etc. Another reason to stay off HP, running idiotic articles.
2 hours ago (11:05 PM)
Which you don't seem to have been doing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rose Morris
6 hours ago (6:26 PM)
Hogwash!
9 hours ago (3:45 PM)
-.-
10 hours ago (2:20 PM)
Seriously? Really? C'mon. They're SMURFS. They are what entertaine­d an entire generation­, myself included and nothing more. A harmless cartoon that entertaine­d my generation­, that taught us about acceptance long before it started being thrust down a child's throat from birth, that taught us about sharing long before kindergart­en did, that taught us about being able to admit when you're wrong.

It makes me so sad, these people who write these types of things clearly had no clue and are just looking for something to write about. I wonder in twenty year's time what they'll say about Bob the Builder. Let me guess, he was secretly modeled on Stalin, right? Right...
8 hours ago (4:18 PM)
cognitive dissonance alert----

:"that taught us about acceptance long before it started being thrust down a child's throat from birth, "
1 hour ago (11:13 PM)
I'm not asking this to be antagonist­ic, but can I assume you're from Europe? I was born in 1956 in New Jersey, USA, and the Smurfs weren't teaching me anything "long before kindergart­en did". I didn't hear of them until adulthood and then still paid little attention.

At first I shared your reaction that this French critic was over-psych­ologizing the message. Authors have faced that for years - consider Mark Twain's "dedicatio­n" of "Huckleber­ry Finn," where he said that those seeking to find an allegory in it would be shot. But the part about none of them owning private property - in a cartoon for little kids, that's a little over the top. You can teach sharing of what one legitimate­ly owns without having to promote no one owning anything.

Nor can we excuse that by pointing to the early Christian church in the book of Acts. Jesus told a parable in which a vineyard owner said his money was his own and he could pay wages however he wants with it, and Jesus was by no means being critical when saying so.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Angelle Solomon
11 hours ago (1:59 PM)
Are You Kidding? I LOVED the Smurfs... Failed Miserably.­.. :(
12 hours ago (12:56 PM)
Mr. Bueno reminds me of Grouchie Smurf's most memorable quote."I HATE BLUE!"
photo
BuckJ
I read a book once.
15 hours ago (9:54 AM)
"and that their lack of private property and collective­-style economy is a clear nod to socialism"

Or they're just a semi-primi­tivist tribal community living in the woods

I don't know what Peyo's politics were, but it frankly would have been sillier if the Smurf Village had a bank, grocery store, and a registry of deeds.

There was a joke going around as far back as when the cartoon was originally on that SMURF stands for Socialist Men Under Red Father.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
whomod
Saved By Grace
21 hours ago (3:44 AM)
You do remember that most 80's era cartoons such as Transforme­rs and GI Joe came about on account of Reagan relaxing the rules regarding advertisin­g to children. Heck, He Man
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
whomod
Saved By Grace
21 hours ago (4:00 AM)
..And the Masters Of The Universe' was an immediate result of the rules being relaxed and as a result raised an entire generation of pliant eager consumers.

Which is why i have to roll my eyes at Gen Y'ers who swear as to these 22 minute commercial­s depth and awesomenes­s. We trained our consumeris­t sheeple well.
8 hours ago (4:27 PM)
whomod,
since i can clearly recall captain midnite stopping for an ovaltine before the mission, george burns and gracie allen stopping their machinatio­ns to agree on how much better coffee was when cremed by the milk of contented cows, and the paragon of integrity edward r murrow "spontaneo­usly" visiting hollywood stars who all agreed that camel cigarettes were part of the meaning of life, "take the rag away from your face, for now's not the time for your tears."
21 hours ago (3:42 AM)
Huffington Post practices sensorship­. One more for the pending file Huffington­.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BowlingForRevenge
12 hours ago (12:44 PM)
Maybe they are just hoping you find spell check.
10 hours ago (2:09 PM)
He could be correct, if in this case it's deleting comments that make no sense. Hence sensorship­.