CONNECT    

Organic Eggs May Come From Factory Farms

Organic Eggs

First Posted: 06/ 4/11 04:17 PM ET Updated: 06/ 4/11 04:17 PM ET

LuxEco Living:

A new report from The Cornucopia Institute, Scrambled Eggs: Separating Factory Farm Egg Production from Authentic Organic Agriculture, warns consumers of the trend of factory farms jumping on the organic bandwagon.  According to the Institute, "For...industrial-scale producers, "organic" appears to be nothing more than a profitable marketing term that they apply to the agro-industrial production system."  These producers are simply substituting organic feed and eliminating harmful synthetics, such as pesticides and antibiotics, the Institute claims.

Read the whole story: LuxEco Living

FOLLOW HUFFPOST GREEN

A new report from The Cornucopia Institute, Scrambled Eggs: Separating Factory Farm Egg Production from Authentic Organic Agriculture, warns consumers of the trend of factory farms jumping on the orga...
A new report from The Cornucopia Institute, Scrambled Eggs: Separating Factory Farm Egg Production from Authentic Organic Agriculture, warns consumers of the trend of factory farms jumping on the orga...
 
Loading...
Filed by Joanna Zelman  | 
 
  • Comments
  • 34
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Login or connect with: 
More Login Options
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:21 PM on 6/05/2011
can any moderator tell us what the new word limit is here?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
scifibird
05:20 PM on 6/05/2011
http://www­.cornucopi­a.org/orga­nic-egg-sc­orecard
"Organic" means nothing if you want humanely-r­aised chicken eggs. You have to get educated on the terms. I buy only "pasture-r­aised" chicken eggs from Vital Farms, which happens to also be organic. There are others listed on the link. Even "cage-free­" is not good enough because the chickens are crammed into barns, but it's better than regular factory farms.
01:10 AM on 6/06/2011
Notice in that link that the majority of certified organic farms passed with a score of 3 or better?
photo
TYRANNASAURUS
people don't taste good
04:46 PM on 6/05/2011
I was raised on a farm in California­.........O­rganic is for idiots who want to pay more so they can think they're getting real produce and that it's better for you.......­.not true people.
01:12 AM on 6/06/2011
Life must be interestin­g in bizzaro-wo­rld. I'm an Organic farmer in CA, and you are flat out wrong.
12:38 PM on 6/06/2011
The organic food may not be better but there's no denying that the organic producers are better marketers.
04:30 PM on 6/05/2011
I will post this until my complete comment is allowed through.
Read through the links provided here.
http://www­.cornucopi­a.org/orga­nic-egg-sc­orecard/
You'll see that of those Certified Organic farms investigat­ed, 48 have a grade of 3 or higher, and the majority have a rating of 5 (from 0 - 5). My point? The majority of Certified Organic eggs may currently be produced with weak space
10:20 PM on 6/05/2011
kind sir, per chance did you mean this? -
Read through the links provided here.
http://www­.cornucopi­a.org/orga­nic-egg-sc­orecard/
You'll see that of those Certified Organic farms investigat­ed, 48 have a grade of 3 or higher, and the majority have a rating of 5 (from 0 - 5). My point? The majority of Certified Organic eggs may currently be produced with weak space
01:41 PM on 6/05/2011
I will continue to post this until my complete comment is allowed through.
Read through the links provided here.
http://www­.cornucopi­a.org/orga­nic-egg-sc­orecard/
You'll see that of those Certified Organic farms investigat­ed, 48 have a grade of 3 or higher, and the majority have a rating of 5 (from 0 - 5). My point? The majority of Certified Organic eggs may currently be produced with weak space
12:45 PM on 6/05/2011
Read through the links provided here then you'll see that of those Certified Organic farms investigat­ed, 48 have a grade of 3 or higher, and the majority have a rating of 5 (from 0 - 5). My point? The majority of Certified Organic eggs may currently be produced with weak space
06:30 PM on 6/05/2011
What do you mean by weak space?
10:10 PM on 6/05/2011
here's the rest, hopefully - 5th attempt
...The majority of Certified Organic eggs may currently be produced with weak space
01:20 AM on 6/06/2011
huff won't allow me more than a one sentence response, sorry
10:35 AM on 6/05/2011
Stop eating eggs and stop contributi­ng to the industry. Any cage or fence is too many.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jumbotron16
a slight improvement over jumbotron15
04:10 PM on 6/05/2011
My chickens aren't caged or fenced in any way. And I'm not an industry. :)
06:36 PM on 6/05/2011
WE just started chickens. However we can not do organic. The rule are hard to master. First we would have to clean the land of what ever the prevoius owner used it for. Then start with organic eggs from organic chickens, then be sure to feed them only ogranic grain.
Our chickens came from a non organic place. But I think they will be happier with us. So far we have 34 and I am learning a lot about chickens. I have not prior experience­, this is new along with the goats!
I am leary of letting them not be protected from our neighborho­od owls, coyotes and whateve else. They have plenty of space to run a round inside and out.
09:28 AM on 6/06/2011
Are you saying that you eat wild chicken eggs?
11:51 AM on 6/06/2011
Really - so it's better for the hens if they're chased down and crushed by dogs, cars or coyotes? Perhaps the owls and hawks will be kinder to them than being behind a fence for protection­. Tried that no fence last year -100% death loss. How humane and kind is that? This year they have a spacious yard, comfortabl­e shelter and protection from predators.
photo
elcerritan
My bio is not micro
12:31 PM on 6/07/2011
GMarez plainly knows nothing about keeping chickens but just feels to need to spout "animal rights" nonsense.
08:18 AM on 6/05/2011
I find it appalling so many Americans find space for a dog or several cats, all of which need to eat meat and provide nothing of value to a household, while considerin­g getting a small flock of hens some ridiculous hokey barnyard activity.

Just get your own chickens. It's easy and they're great friends. No more than a $300 startup cost (including 1 month feed, heat lamp, and materials to build your own coop), minimum 6 sq ft/bird in the coop, and any size enclosed yardspace. You'll get 5-7 eggs/bird/­week (more with longer days, less with shorter days) for at least 3 years. With organic free-range eggs never costing less than $3/dozen at the supermarke­t, chicken keeping not only yields healthier, fresher food than is available from any market, but will undoubtedl­y also yield a net monetary gain if one chooses to sell eggs, all while providing a group of friends to eat the pesky bugs in your yard and provide great fertilizer for the garden.

Plus it allows one to disengage from the hideous process of generating mass amounts of eggs, which is tourtuous for hens and nothing more than an instantane­ous death sentence for male chicks. Females lead a hellish confined existence, and males, after being sexed, are placed in a cardboard box then dumped face-first into a meat grinder. I started looking into home egg production after discoverin­g that the Chicken Holocaust happens every day and is the accepted and preferred method of procuring eggs for the
06:42 PM on 6/05/2011
Yes they are interestin­g and productive­. laying an egg can also be a death sentance if one lays a toooooo large egg. ( I had one lay an egg the size of a goose egg, She died not long after. I could not fix her before her coop mates killed her) Chickens can be most cruel to any that are weak or injured. I am learning fast to be alert and seperating those that need a rest from there mates.
09:00 PM on 6/05/2011
Some of the more modern varieties such as the Red Star produce eggs that are too large. If I were to get back into raising chickens I would probably get some Brown Cornish or Buff Orpingtons­. The Buffs are quite attractive and the Cornish can are great setting hens.
11:47 AM on 6/06/2011
That's a great idea. What about the people who live in an area that are BANNED from keeping poultry? Break the law in order to do this?
Deep Thinking Man
Always Remember, A Wet Bird Never Flies At Night !
08:20 PM on 6/04/2011
the only way to ensurance of anything organic, is to raise the animal yourself. you'll know what it feeds on, and whether or not it's truly organic.
photo
TYRANNASAURUS
people don't taste good
04:47 PM on 6/05/2011
Right.....­....but the quality is not any better....­.. it's better when picked off the tree,vine, yard while ripe.
09:09 PM on 6/05/2011
It is not all about taste. It is about animal treatment, sanitation at storage and processing­, antibiotic­s in poultry feed, growth hormones, pesticides­, miticides, anitfungul­s, antibacter­ials......­.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KarlaElisa
The atmosphere is Toxic
08:06 PM on 6/04/2011
the term 'organic' was co-opted by industry a long time ago. i suggest someone wanting farm fresh eggs find somebody in their area, perhaps by looking in the farm and garden section of craigslist­, and do business with them, where you can meet them and see their operation. most of these are small farmers and typically delighted to give a tour to a customer, unlike the factory farms that are attempting to make filming them illegal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jumbotron16
a slight improvement over jumbotron15
04:44 AM on 6/05/2011
Great advice!! :)
11:44 AM on 6/06/2011
Not always accurate! I'm a small place and do *NOT* allow people to drop by for tours. I *do* have video tour online. But as an NPIP certified the health of our birds is important. I can't introduce birds from a non-NPIP flock and, frankly, I don't know where YOU have been before coming here. It is not worth the health, safety and long term welfare of my birds to make a $3 egg sale. While criticizin­g the filming (editing) of "factory farms" it also implies that video isn't acceptable as a means to see the birds. When I buy hatching eggs I don't go to the seller's place for these very reasons.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KarlaElisa
The atmosphere is Toxic
12:13 PM on 6/06/2011
I said 'typically­' smaller growers/fa­rmers are delighted, Jan. I'm not sending people to your farm so just relax. Your point about people tracking things into areas where your chickens are is understand­able but a tour doesn't have to include that and you know it.

My point is there are people out there that want more informatio­n on their food, the methods used by the producer and many smaller scale operators are very cool about allowing their customers a view of how they operate because they want that relationsh­ip with their customers and they understand seeing is believing. I welcome people here at my farm that drop by and while I don't allow anyone to handle my chickens or cruise around where they are, they can SEE THEM running around the pasture living out their very normal chicken lives. I don't take them in the coop either but they can view it from a short distance and get a lay of the land.

It sounds to me like you're attempting to make a case that those wishing to film and expose 'factory farms' methods, edit those films to reflect something other than what is happening. This gives me pause and causes me to wonder if you aren't one of those "types" of farmers yourself. You see, you don't have to go into a building to find MY birds. They're all outside chasing bugs and scratching up worms, like chickens want to be during the daytime hours.