CONNECT    

Kati Marton

Kati Marton

GET UPDATES FROM Kati Marton
 

Facts Are a Dictator's Worst Enemy; and a Journalist's Best Friend

Posted: 06/ 6/11 12:52 PM ET

This post is derived from my remarks upon receiving the United Nations Association's Leo Nevas Prize.

This is a great honor -- and one I really am humbled to receive. All I can say is that I will use the Leo Nevas Prize -- and Leo's wonderful example of a life well lived in the service of Human Rights -- as a spur to do more.

We are living an exciting and dangerous moment in history. We are witnessing Arabs from Tunisia to Syria, and the nations in between, rise up and claim their human rights and dignity.

There has perhaps never been a time when we needed to speak truth not only to power, but to the millions of people who are connected in our wired world. That is the role of journalists -- my chosen field. I never regarded that role as morally neutral.

For a number of years I have fought for journalist's rights as the only real safeguard against demagogues and dictators. In 2000 I marched with the people of Belgrade against Milosevic. As a member of Human Rights Watch I have spoken and written against American use of so called "enhanced" interrogation. The argument cannot be about whether torture works or not. It is about who we are. Americans do not torture. It's that simple.

"Comment is free, but facts are sacred!" a great British editor, once said. That has never been more relevant and urgently true than today, as new technologies are making "citizen journalists" out of anybody with an iPhone. It is a powerful tool. In the wrong hands a dangerous one. The same dazzling technology is available to demagogues and extremists to spread their version of reality. Electronic narcissism is also an unappealing byproduct of the wired world. I did not become a journalist in order to share my every impulse with the world.

Let's not lose sight of the fact that it was not a million tweets, but a vegetable vendor named Mohamed Bouazizi who set himself on fire in protest against the confiscation of his cart and license -- his livelihood -- which set off the demonstrations in Tunis, which two weeks later, forced the demise of President Ben Ali, soon to be followed by President Mubarak... with perhaps more to come. It was, ironically enough, when the Egyptian government shut down the Internet that crowds poured into the streets of Cairo to get the news.

As a child I witnessed the Hungarian Revolution, which began as a small demonstration and within 24 hours exploded into a popular uprising. So my point is this: let's credit the basic human urge for dignity and human rights -- an urge that knows no boundaries nor cultures. Of course the technology helps. But it is the human impulse for a right to earn a decent living, have leaders who are accountable to us, not to themselves, to right to say what we like, and pray the way we like -- that is what it means to be human, and that is what we are witnessing today in the Middle East.

It is the bravest of the brave on whose behalf I make interventions through my work at the Committee to Protect Journalists. From Moscow to Teheran to Karachi -- they lay everything on the line, not by sharing with us their morning coffee choice, but to expose the corrupt and the cruel. I have sat with them in Turkish prisons, and in Russian hospitals, always in awe at their breathtaking courage. I do this partly because there was no such organization when the Hungarian Secret Police arrested my mother and father and sentenced them to long prison terms, merely for the crime of being good reporters. Then, as now, facts upset dictators. They can even upset countries whose self-image can clash with the truth. (Recall how as Americans we recoiled from the images of torture at American hands in Abu Ghraib). But facts are sacred.

Our growing ignorance of history -- even recent history -- also makes it easier for demagogues and fanatics to gain ground. People die. The past does not. Our duty is to understand it. If I have made a modest contribution to the cause Leo Nevas championed it has been in the choice of subjects to write about.

I try in my books to connect today's world with our recent past -- a past that should ring a warning bell, alerting us to the ever-present danger of intolerance. In my book on Raoul Wallenberg I focus on the difference one brave and stubborn man can make in standing up to murderous hate mongers. Wallenberg also stood up to those too cautious bureaucrats who -- in their way can also lead millions to their death, by blindly following inhuman policies. (in this instance during Nazi occupied Hungary, but also in our own State Department's blind refusal to help Jewish refugees).

In The Great Escape I chronicle the self-destructiveness of states that close their borders (and hearts) to minorities.

In my most recent work, Enemies of the People, I burrowed into the files of a police state to reveal how ordinary, decent people are forced to become tools of a terror state, by the most powerful weapon of all: fear.

Facts are the most potent of all weapons, and dictators know that. Look at how the Iranian demagogue Ahmadinejad freely distorts history, denies the Holocaust, and how devastating his lies would be, in the absence of documentation to prove he is a fabricator.

In closing, please allow me to say a few words about Richard Holbrooke, who would be so proud of this honor. A few lessons I learned in the 17 years I was lucky enough to share with him:

  • American leadership is still essential. And Richard did not mean just military leadership. Richard believed in the primary importance of American values as a force for good in the world. He joined American power to moral passion and decency.
  • He never let bureaucracies -- nor process -- hinder his goal.
  • He thought it was ok to step on some big toes if lives were at stake.
  • His brand of diplomacy had a human face -- it was built on trust and respect -- not assertion of might. But if that failed he was fearless about summoning power. You break down barriers by sitting across from your bitterest foe -- which is what Richard did in the Balkans. When he was given the Afpak assignment he insisted the Presidents of Afghanistan and Pakistan come to Washington together. Once you know your adversary sit down with him face to face -- it's much tougher to demonize him.


And he always put the responsibility to save lives, ahead of any other consideration -- even the responsibility to authority.

Thank you for this wonderful award -- which will spur me to follow the twin examples of Leo Nevas and Richard Holbrooke.

 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Login or connect with: 
More Login Options
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
1 hour ago (9:16 AM)
Refreshing rhetoric regarding 'facts' - we'll all be waiting with baited breath to see her printed words regarding the facts of the Israeli Occupation of Palestine.

The Arab Spring and the ending of the Apartheid Occupation of Palestine are two sides of the same coin - and the facts from which the Neoconserv­atives, Israeli Lobby, and Israel itself are running are beyond obfuscatio­n

Ms Marton was the 3rd wife of Richard Holbrooke - Mr Holbrooke being a Neoconserv­ative, and in many ways being instrument­al in 'Neocon Foreign' Policy in the Near and Middle East.

Holbrooke, like HIllary Clinton, is hook, line and sinker Israeli Lobby and Neocon foreign policy
2 hours ago (8:22 AM)
"speak truth"
See evil. Speak of evil. Let the world hear of evil deeds. The better to prevent them now and in the future?

"Americans do not torture".
with impunity?

"their version of reality"
The powers that be seem intent on spreading the story that the population is staging an armed insurrecti­on, and thus must be subject to forceful pacificati­on. However, they deny access to journalist­s willing to risk life and limb to witness the facts. So, how much gravitas do unverified assertions merit?

"facts are sacred"
And have a divinity worthy of worship.

"Look at how the Iranian demagogue Ahmadineja­d freely distorts history"
I suspect there no books relating to the Salem Witch Trials to be found in Iran. So as far as being tried for black magic goes. He may write his own history, as the last victim of that primitive belief system.
11 hours ago (11:50 PM)
Seems like the recipient is a selective advocate of human rights. Her concerns about human rights seem to vanish regarding offenses by the US or agents supported by the US.

In that regard she is very much like Richard Holbrooke.

Too bad.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce
Atheistic-agnostic Canadian polymath
13 hours ago (10:10 PM)
Facts are indeed powerful, but they need three things to be so:

1) People willing to tell them to the mass audience

2) A mass audience that can tell facts from fictions

3) A mass audience willing to change their attitudes based on the facts
Unfortunat­ely, the 'herds of independan­t news media' tend to behave like herds, meaning many facts (especiall­y facts that contradict carefully nutured beliefs) do not get a chance to become powerful because the mass audience never hears them. Others do get heard, but are up against fictions that are being told the audience with conviction by those who prefer the fictions, and because so many people lack the ability to tell the difference­, become no more powerful than the fictions. And the final thing is the most insidious, because it is an inately human thing to find ways to dismiss, diminish, and distort facts if that is what it takes to feel good about what one has done in the past, or to fit in with the crowd
13 hours ago (9:33 PM)
"In 2000 I marched with the people of Belgrade against Milosevic. As a member of Human Rights Watch I have spoken and written against American use of so called "enhanced" interrogat­ion."

Very nice, but all of which renders your news judgement suspect. Maybe you should consider a career in commentary and opinion rather than pretending to present facts in an even-hande­d manner?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Enock Zamora
Angels of Unconditional love.
14 hours ago (9:13 PM)
Apocalypse is a disclosure of something hidden from the majority of mankind in an era dominated by falsehood, i.e. the 'veil' to be lifted (Wiki). An example of this are all the books the Vatican banned during 'The Council of Laodicea' and changed the law's of God for example as is mandated in the 29th Canon and vacated the fourth-com­mandment. We are all journalist when we expose those that distort history and it is our duty to expose those that want to use us as slaves, and degrade our women and treat them as second hand citizen's or like s step-child­.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jim Pasterczyk
16 hours ago (7:05 PM)
Facts may be a journalist­'s best friends but they're hack politician­s' worst enemy, hence the creation of phony controvers­ies inter alia.
18 hours ago (5:06 PM)
"Facts are a journalist­'s best friend"?

Someone should tell that to the "journalis­ts" at faux news.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jim Pasterczyk
16 hours ago (7:04 PM)
"Journalis­ts"? Faux News? It's the mouthpiece of the business-c­an-do-no-w­rong GOP; occasional­ly it throws a bone to the social conservati­ves just to keep them voting in lockstep their way.
14 hours ago (8:43 PM)
Exactly. That's why I put "journalis­ts" in quotes.
19 hours ago (3:55 PM)
Truth in journalism was the paramount condition of employment at one time. Yet these days it seems that the ability to give the appearance of truth out weighs the giving of actual truth. If you can report some truth or take things out of context or lie real good and twist things so that what you are reporting on fits the Politicall­y Correct Agenda then you've got the job.
The body of the people these days have also gotten so ingrained with receiving gossip, half-truth­s, and lies that when the full truth does show up on important issues it is not believed and the one reporting it is called all kinds of names and accused of being some kind of phobic or a spreader of hate.
So how does a person tell that they are being lied to if they get their info from only a couple of sources and it turns out these sources are pushing a PC agenda? How do you get the truth through to a person who has only believed lies and the mind is closed to the truth?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jim Pasterczyk
16 hours ago (7:03 PM)
Journalism has become just another business, something to generate profits, especially the news department­s at the big three networks. What it should be is a sort of priesthood­, one to which people are called because of their personal integrity instead of their personal avarice.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
jeb50
Retired.
19 hours ago (3:33 PM)
Facts are a journalist­s best friend? Where were these 'journalis­ts' during bush and the gops reign of terror?
18 hours ago (5:09 PM)
Where were they? Completely ignoring the facts and doing the bidding of bush et al. And that's a very large part of why they were able to get away with so much.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
jeb50
Retired.
17 hours ago (5:53 PM)
Exactly! All the WH had to do was call their boss and they couldn't have gotten a job on a shopping guide. The days of Woodward, Bernstien and I think the editor Bradley all all but gone.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cynthia Rays
peace in the valley seeker
21 hours ago (1:56 PM)
Journalist­s play an incredibly important role. In the build up to the Iraq war they were missing in action. They were not willing to question US interventi­on and the 'weapons of mass destructio­n" and as a result we are still embattled in Iraq, with more soldiers killed everyday. In Cast Lead, the Israeli assault on Gaza, no outside journalist­s were allowed in Gaza. Israel was allowed to spin as much as it could with only the citizens of Gaza to try to report on what was happening there.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jim Pasterczyk
16 hours ago (6:59 PM)
That's why I have McClatchy bookmarked­; they were the one news org that actually got it right pre-invasi­on. Dubya and Fleischer were quite adept at manipulati­ng the media by denying access unless they'd write favorable stories. Of course now that the media aren't buying that anymore it's too late for them to hold Dubya accountabl­e so instead they've upped their scrutiny of Obama. But this is how they do it, in cycles so the scrutiny comes while they're out of office.
photo
OneFish
Various and assorted mutualistic microbial buddies
21 hours ago (1:55 PM)
I find the attempts by Palin supporters to alter the Wiki page on Paul Revere to be indicative of a declined electorate­. In this modern, wired world, facts and history are malleable, education and journalism are under attack.
21 hours ago (1:29 PM)
Facts Are a Dictator's Worst Enemy; and a Journalist­'s Best Friend?

Here's some facts a certain dictator may not want you to see.
http://ill­uminaticon­spiracy.bl­ogspot.com
21 hours ago (1:27 PM)
I congratula­te Kati Marton on a well deserved Prize. I agree that the American leadership is essential (one of the lesson you shared with the late Richard Holbrooke)­. I am saddened we haven't seen much US leadership in Libya and Syria. The Syrian and Libyan people deserve the full backing of the United States. In the case of Libya the US has refused to help Nato in getting rid of Ghaddafi the madman of Libya. As for Syria, the US has been very cautious and reluctant in condemning the tyrannical Assad regime. The least the US could do is to recall the Ambassador from Damascus and condemn the killing of unarmed civilians by the brutal Syrian security forces. World media and journalist­s are banned from reporting the facts from Syria. Can we look forward to a strong unequivoca­l declaratio­n from President Obama delegitimi­zing the Damascus regime.