Is Massive Rape a Tool of Al Qathafi - or of War Propagandists? 18/06/2011 13:22:00
ARTICLE SUMMARY: After all the other fake stories used to whip up public support for wars, you'd think we had learned something. Apparently not, judging from the media's unquestioning spreading of claims that Al Qathafi ordered Viagra-furled rapes - claims that, according to businessinsider.com look dubious under even a little scrutiny.
Is Muammar Al Qathafi trying to save his government - and his life - by encouraging mass rape? Does that make sense? Personally speaking, if I had the world already against me, and was hoping to retain whatever support I could among my own people, that would not be my preferred course of action, the website's opinion writer said.
He says it seems too crazy. Nevertheless, that's the infamy of the day against Al Qathafi.
After analysing what, in his opinion, are the true purposes behind the NATO bombing campaign, efforts to rally world opinion behind removing Al Qathafi from power, now, things are being ratcheted up, with the claim that it's not just one woman but hundreds have been raped - and that Al Qathafi is personally behind this.
Following is the rest of the article in which the writer expresses his personal views.
If true, (the accusation of massive rape) this would of course make Al Qathafi out to be even more of a monster than he is already perceived to be. It would likely play a tremendous role in persuading otherwise opposed members of the international public to support the NATO bombing campaign. And maybe even an overt expansion into what it actually is - a thinly disguised invasion/coup.
So, what are the particulars on the latest claims?
Here's the Washington Post's blog:
In March, a Libyan woman named Eman Al-Obeidi burst into a Tripoli hotel to tell journalists she had been raped at the hands of the militia of Libyan leader Muammar Al Qathafi
At that time, Blogpost reported that Libyan doctors who treated female rape survivors said they had found Viagra and condoms in the pockets of dead pro-Al Qathafi fighters.
Quick question: why are “doctors” who are treating rape survivors going through the pockets of fighters? Who are these doctors? Are the dead soldiers processed by the same doctors who see rape victims?
Let's continue with the Washington Post:
Amnesty International released a statement that said Libyan authorities must “immediately launch an independent and impartial investigation.”
Libyan officials did little to investigate, but the International Criminal Court did, and investigators now say they have evidence that Al Qathafi ordered mass rapes and bought containers of sex drugs to encourage troops to attack women, pan-Arab news site Al-Arabiya reported.
By the way, how readily available are large quantities of Viagra in Libya? Has anyone looked into this - or bulk purchases? Back to the Post:
Chief ICC prosecutor Luis Moreno-Ocampo said he may ask for a new charge of mass rape to be made against Al Qathafi, his intelligence chief, and one of his sons following the new evidence.
… “Now we are getting some information that Al Qathafi himself decided to rape, and this is new,” Moreno-Ocampo told reporters.
Moreno-Ocampo said hundreds of women had been raped and confirmed the doctor's statements about Viagra-type medicines.
“The rape is a new aspect of the repression,”the prosecutor said. “It was very bad - beyond the limits, I would say.”
Based on this, I went to look up the original Al Arabiya report, which as you can see was actually not an Al Arabiya report but from the following wire service:
By Agence-France-Presse - United Nations
Investigators have evidence that Libyan leader Muammar Al Qathafi ordered mass rapes and bought containers of sex drugs to encourage troops to attack women, the chief ICC prosecutor said.
Luis Moreno-Ocampo said he may ask for a new charge of mass rape to be made against the Libyan strongman following the new evidence.
The International Criminal Court's chief prosecutor is expecting a decision from judges within days on his request for charges of crimes against humanity to be laid against the Libyan leader, one of his sons and his intelligence chief.
“Now we are getting some information that Al Qathafi himself decided to rape and this is new,” Mr. Moreno-Ocampo told reporters.
He said there were reports of hundreds of women attacked in some areas of Libya, which is in the grip of a months-long internal rebellion.
There was evidence the Libyan authorities bought “Viagra-type” medicines and gave them to troops as part of the official rape policy, Mr. Moreno-Ocampo said.
“They were buying containers to enhance the possibility to rape women,” he said.
“It was never the pattern he used to control the population. The rape is a new aspect of the repression. That is why we had doubts at the beginning, but now we are more convinced that he decided to punish using rape,” the prosecutor said. “It was very bad - beyond the limits, I would say.”
Mr. Al Qathafi's regime had not previously been known for using rape as a weapon against political opponents and Mr. Moreno-Ocampo said he had to find evidence that the Libyan leader had given the order.
In March, a Libyan woman made international headlines when she entered a Tripoli hotel and said she had been raped by Al Qathafi troops.
Eman al-Obeidi was detained but managed to escape from Libya. She ended up in Qatar but was deported back from there to rebel-held Libya. She is now resting at a refugee centre in Romania.
Mr. Moreno-Ocampo issued arrest warrants last month against Mr. Al Qathafi, his son Seif al-Islam and intelligence chief Abdullah al-Sanussi. ICC judges are to announce in days whether they agree to the charges.
The Libyan government does not recognise the international court's jurisdiction. (end of AFP report)
Ok,so it's not, as the Washington Post made it seem to its readers, an original report from an Arabic language publication. It's simply them carrying a report from the European wire service Agence France-Press (France being one of the leading members of the coalition seeking to drive Al Qathafi out), which in turn was just dutifully reporting what Moreno-Ocampo said at his press conference at the UN. No indication that anyone expressed any healthy skepticism.
But look. Here's the very same news service Agence France-Press, as published in the Australian paper the Herald-Sun, the next day:
A UN human rights investigator has cast doubts over claims by the chief ICC prosecutor of evidence that Libyan leader Muammar Al Qathafi had ordered mass rapes.
The International Criminal Court's Luis Moreno-Ocampo had said today that there was evidence the Libyan authorities bought “Viagra-type” medicines and gave them to troops as part of the official rape policy.
But Cherif Bassiouni, who is leading a UN rights inquiry into the situation in Libya, suggested that the claim was part of a “massive hysteria”.
Mr Bassiouni told journalists that he had heard those claims when he visited rebel-held eastern Libya. But when he went to Tripoli, “the same story comes up”.
“This time it's the government people telling us, 'you know what? The opponents have a policy of rape, we have discovered that they are giving out contraceptives and Viagra pills',” he recounted.
…The investigator also cited the case of a woman who claimed to have sent out 70,000 questionnaires and received 60,000 responses, of which 259 reported sexual abuse.
However, when the investigators asked for these questionnaires, they never received them.
“But she's going around the world telling everybody about it … so now she got that information to Ocampo and Ocampo is convinced that here we have a potential 259 women who have responded to the fact that they have been sexually abused,” Mr Bassiouni said.
He also pointed out that it did not appear to be credible that the woman was able to send out 70,000 questionnaires in March when the postal service was not functioning.
Nevertheless, the investigator said his team will examine the claims.
“We're going to go back and we're going to look at it,” he said.
For the moment, the team has only heard of three cases.
…”For the moment the numbers are very limited, but they've had a tremendous socio-psychological impact on society. Everybody's talking about it. That's where we're at,” said the investigator. (end of report on Herald Tribune)
The original allegation got a lot of play. Not the doubts. Even though they came via the exact same news organisation. How 'bout that!
Control of information, including psychological operations and propaganda, has always been a central tool in war. The perennial failures of the Western media to do proper checking before spreading such stories (or after, even) helps explain why the public remains forever in the dark.
This article has ( 4 ) Comment(s)
Name: Thair El Heri
Date: 19/06/2011 17:35:05
Comment: I know that this war was started by CIA/Fench Inteligence, however Gaddafi fell into a trap and once his forces had killed demonstrators there was no going back. I do not have evidence that Rape was ordered but that amoung Gaddafi's forces were mercanaries whom without dought were not as dicaplined as they should have been and its quite realistic to think that they rapped. There were so many oppertunties to avoid this civil war by distributing the wealth that it really is the fault of Gaddafi. We all know that Gaddafi's role on paper is symbolic however if he is not head of state then who gives him permission to meet up with heads of states? I personally liked the revolution to get rid of Kings but now that Gaddafi calls himself the King of Africa. It is time for Gaddafi to go. The green book as many nice ideas that cannot be applied inreality. If Gaddafi went before atleast he could have been remembered with respect to a certain extent like the King of Morroco. Most of all we the Muslims are meant to be peacefull and have love for one another. Omar Bin Katub head of the law at the time of our Prophet PBUH had no body guards because he was so honest & just which is why the people loved him.
Date: 25/06/2011 17:53:08
brave leybian people. great Qadafi
Name: James Padgett
Date: 08/04/2011 06:53:57
Comment: THe US and NATO will dip to any depths of slime to depict Mr. Gaddafi's regime and forces as being immoral and corrupt. The truth is they are only motivated by a desire for better positioning with Libya's 46.4 billion barrels of oil. Humanitarain concern? Nonsense! Somalia cried out to NATO for 9 months to have a no-fly zone and naval barricade put in force to keep weapons and ammo from reaching Muslims extemists in the country. NATO did nothing! But in just 5 days it responded when asked by the rebels and placed a naval barricade and no-fly zone in place - in OIL RICH LIBYA! May God continue to come against NATO and its forces and give Mr. Gaddafi's regime and forces VICTORY. May NATO soon leave with its TAIL WAGGING BETWEEN ITS LEGS IN HUMILIATION and DEFEAT.
Name: Dr. James Padgett
Date: 08/09/2011 05:36:06
Comment: How shameful for Hillary Clinton to have picked up on the false accusations of Gaddafi troops committing mass rape before getting any kind of solid substantiation. In her ARROGANCE and FOOLISHNESS, she and Obama are doing ANYHING to cause world opinion to be in favor of removing Mr. Gaddafi from power. Their egos are involved, so they will not realize the utter wrongfulness of their intervention - which wwell over 60 percent (according to many polls) of the American people strongly dislike and resent and think should never have taken place! Many of believe Obama is the worst president the USA has ever had BY FAR and Hillary has only served as his mindless subservient lackey. May GOD stop this horrible intervention and bless the Gaddafi regime and forces to overcome and defeat NATO.
Gaza, Somalia: Humanity Lives On - By Ramzy Baroud I remember how exhilarated I felt when I was told I was old enough to fast for the month of Ramadan. My feelings had little to do with abstention from food and drink between dawn and sunset each day. For a child, there is little joy in that.