October 13, 2011 11:17 AM

Macho ads targeting men going too far?

This video frame grab provided by the Dr Pepper Snapple Group, shows the new Dr Pepper TEN beverage. It's not often that a major brand tries to block out an entire segment of the population, but that's exactly what Dr Pepper is doing with the launch of its latest product, Dr Pepper TEN.

This video frame grab provided by the Dr Pepper Snapple Group, shows the new Dr Pepper TEN beverage. It's not often that a major brand tries to block out an entire segment of the population, but that's exactly what Dr Pepper is doing with the launch of its latest product, Dr Pepper TEN. (AP Photo/Dr Pepper Snapple Group)

(CBS News) 

Dr. Pepper is facing criticism for a very pointed ad for a new 10-calorie soda. The ad says of the soda, "It's not for women."

It takes a new kind of commercial aimed at men to a new level.

Using humor to play into a man's ego, is a common device in a long line of recent ads showcasing hyper-masculinity to sell products, CBS News correspondent Betty Nguyen reported on "The Early Show."

The Old Spice man, for instance, challenged men to both smell good and look buff. The ploy worked. Last year, according to Adweek, sales for the body wash at one point had more than doubled.

Pepsi Max, another product geared toward men, has zero calories, but blatantly makes no mention of the word "diet" on its black can or in ads.

Clinical psychologist Dr. Jeffrey Gardere said, "They're really trying to push an idea that, in order to be a real man, a man's man, you can't be sensitive. You've gotta drink beer, you've gotta be into physicality. And if nothing else, you can't tap into that feminine side."

The message is "be macho" and, according to Gardere, it's striking a chord with men at a time when more women are finding professional success.

"(The ads say) if you haven't been able to keep up with them, this is a way that you can," Gardere said. "'Harken back to when a man was a man, forget about these women, they're not your competition. Now you can reclaim your territory and be the king of the jungle."'

Nguyen added it's a re-drawing of old battle lines -- and stereotypical roles between men and women.

On "The Early Show," Mary Lou Quinlan, chief executive officer of Just Ask A Woman, said the ads are funny, but some of them cross the line and are offensive to women.

When pressed about what's offensive, Quinlan said, "It's not the commercial, but if you look at their viral presence ... the commercial is fun, but if you go on to the Facebook page, which is not for women, women are excluded from the page, they have a shooting gallery where guys can shoot high heels; there's a lot of kind of insulting stuff happening."

For more with Quinlan on the macho advertising trend, check out the video below.

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.
Add a Comment
by Bloodywellright October 14, 2011 4:20 PM EDT
Ok, let me get this straight - THIS is offensive, but it's ok to paint your son's toenails and post it in a J. Crew catalog? How far is this "PC" crap going to go? What a whining, hypersensitive bunch we Yanks are becoming - No apologies - Climb out of your plastic bubble and get over all this sensitivity nonsense! Lighten up...
Reply to this comment
by amerilatino October 13, 2011 3:00 PM EDT
LOL, I may look like a Hispanic Shrek but in my youth I've been to a few places in Latinamerica where I flung with women many of these Madison Avenue hacks would never DREAM of meeting. Today my daughters tell my wife to keep an eye on me, because their friends tell them that they don't believe I'm old as I say, so I know there's NO ACCOUNTING FOR FEMALE TASTE. If these Madison Avenue wags want to sell me a mediocre soft drink and an after shave that smells like spiced rubbing alcohol by appealing to my male insecurity, they're sure as hell barking up the wrong tree. I'll take my Cuba Libre with a sprig of spearmint and diet cola, thank you.
Reply to this comment
by rwsmith29456 October 13, 2011 2:36 PM EDT
Well, they started controversy by appealing to insecurities. That is good advertising.
Reply to this comment
by amnda6 October 13, 2011 1:24 PM EDT
Who gives a crap? The commercial is funny, pull the panties out the crack and laugh for once without looking in so deep that it ruins all the fun. I am a woman and am far beyond being offended by something meant to be fun, yeah I know how gender roles are placed on kids, but whether there is a commercial or not the same pressures are going to be put on regardless. The answer to the problem isn't to complain about commercials or television it is to stop letting television parent the kids.
Reply to this comment
by Samlv October 13, 2011 12:49 PM EDT
I don't know. Does the AT&T ad portraying a man as an insecure henpecked husband incapable of choosing a contract option go too far? Do cartoons showing boys being corrected sternly by girls and cowering go too far?

Does PC/EEO go too far? So far that this article exists and gets comments about men being insecure?

Yes, I think so.
Reply to this comment
by Transatlantique October 13, 2011 11:43 AM EDT
This is another attempt to profit on the insecurity of men. If men and women were raised the same, then there would be no need for this nonsense. The masculine identity is just an illusion as is the feminine identity. We all have masculine and feminine traits, and its important for everyone to get in touch with the idea that neither is real or important. Of course this isn't what the destructive media or advertising world would want, because they print money from people's insecurities. However, they don't fool me, and I'm insulted by products aimed at men with the idea that I'm somehow insecure and in need of a "men's" product. I refuse to buy those products, especially when they are as unhealthy as a carbonated popular beverage. They should be stressing "real people" instead of "real men."
Reply to this comment
by Lifeson2112 October 13, 2011 12:09 PM EDT
You seem kind of lost.
by Forty-Four October 13, 2011 11:41 AM EDT
That's what I thought when I first saw it. Here comes all the "politically correct" people who are all offended by it. Personally, I don't like it, but I am not offended by it. That, and I am a guy
Reply to this comment
by Lifeson2112 October 13, 2011 11:33 AM EDT
Here's a neat idea ladies. Get over it!
Reply to this comment
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook