12 December 2011 Last updated at
EU veto: Cameron says he negotiated in 'good faith'
David Cameron: ''Satisfactory safeguards were not forthcoming and so I did not agree to the treaty''
David Cameron has said he "genuinely looked to reach an agreement" at the EU summit but vetoed treaty change because it was not in the national interest.
Mr Cameron told MPs he negotiated in "good faith" and his demands were "modest, reasonable and relevant".
The prime minister said he used the veto as he did not secure "sufficient safeguards" on financial regulation.
There is no sign of his pro-European Deputy PM Nick Clegg, who usually sits alongside the PM in the Commons.
Labour leader Ed Miliband questioned why Mr Clegg was not in the Commons, saying the PM could "not even persuade" his deputy of the merits of his actions.
BBC Political Editor Nick Robinson said he had been told Mr Clegg - who said on Sunday the result "was bad for Britain" - had decided that his presence in the Chamber would be a distraction.
The statement began with Labour MPs shouting "where's Clegg" - and later during the statement Tory backbencher Nadine Dorries accused the Lib Dem leader of "cowardice".
Giving an account of the decisions he took in Brussels in Friday, Mr Cameron insisted he had agreed his negotiating stance with his Lib Dem partners before the summit and the two parties had to "put aside differences" to work in the national interest.
Britain today has much more negotiating strength because they know they are dealing with a prime minister who will say no if he needs to”
During rowdy exchanges, Commons Speaker John Bercow has had to intervene on several occasions to restore order.
Explaining his decision to veto the treaty, Mr Cameron said it was "not an easy thing to do but it was the right thing to do".
He said he was faced with the "choice of a treaty without proper safeguards or no treaty at all".
He dismissed claims that he had demanded "an opt-out" for the City from EU directives on finance, seeking only proper regulations and a "level playing field" for British business in Europe.
"I went to Brussels with one objective - to protect Britain's national interest. And that is what I did."
He argued: "I do not believe there is a binary choice for Britain that we can either sacrifice the national interest on issue after issue or lose our influence at the heart of Europe's negotiating process.
"I am absolutely clear that it is possible to be a both a full, committed and influential member of the EU but to stay out of arrangements where they do not protect our interests."
But Ed Miliband said the PM had gained nothing from the negotiations, saying "it is not a veto when something goes ahead without you, that's called losing".
"He has come back with a bad deal for Britain," he told MPs. "Far from protecting our interests, he has left us without a voice."
Suggesting the outcome was a "diplomatic disaster" for the UK, Mr Miliband said the prime minister "did not want a deal as he could not deliver it through his party".
Mr Cameron repeatedly pressed his Labour counterpart on whether he would have signed the Treaty.
Ed Miliband said the prime minister ''could not persuade his own deputy'' that not signing the treaty was a good outcome
Although the Labour leader to did not directly reply, the BBC's Nick Robinson said Mr Miliband's aides later made it clear he would not have signed it as it stood - but would have stayed in the room and secured a better outcome.
Mr Cameron's efforts were applauded by a succession of eurosceptic Conservative MPs, one - John Redwood - saying he had shown "excellent statesmanship".
"Britain today has much more negotiating strength because they know they are dealing with a prime minister who will say no if he needs to," he said.
But Lib Dem MP Martin Horwood said international investors now needed reassurance that the UK remained "at the heart" of European decision-making while his colleague Jo Swinson accused the PM of "rushing for the exit" rather than trying to secure a consensus.
Plaid Cymru's leader in Westminster, Elfyn Llwyd, accused the PM of putting the interests of the City ahead of the national interest while the SNP's Stewart Hosie said Mr Cameron had not consulted with devolved administrations in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland before using his veto.
The treaty changes needed the support of all 27 EU members, including those not in the euro, such as the UK, to go ahead. It now looks likely that all 26 other members of the European Union will agree to a new "accord"
setting out tougher budget rules aimed at preventing a repeat of the current eurozone crisis.
The new accord will hold eurozone members to strict budgetary rules including:
a cap of 0.5% of GDP on countries' annual structural deficits
"automatic consequences" for countries whose public deficit exceeds 3% of GDP
a requirement to submit their national budgets to the European Commission, which will have the power to request that they be revised
French President Nicholas Sarkozy has suggested Friday's outcome signalled "there are now clearly two Europes".
However the deal still has to be agreed by a number of national parliaments, and the reaction of the financial markets suggests it has failed to bring a swift end to the euro crisis.
The BBC's Rob Cameron in Prague said: "Commentators here have taken a more cautious - and arguably more accurate - view, reflecting the fact that the Czechs haven't signed up to anything yet."
The current French presidential front-runner, Socialist Francois Hollande, said on Monday that if he was elected next May he would renegotiate the accord, saying: "This accord is not the right answer."
One of Chancellor Merkel's close aides in the German parliament told the BBC's Stephen Evans he does not see why "Britain should stay isolated".
CDU Chief Whip Peter Altmaier said: "Over the last years there has been very intensive cooperation between the UK and Germany and I'm deeply convinced that this will continue. It will last. We have so much in common and there are so few issues that divide us."
More on This Story
From other news sites
Trevor Kavanagh: Cam is a hero... but what next?
15 hrs ago
About these results
Related Internet links
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites
51 MINUTES AGO
Cameron has taken the right decision. The fact that Nick Clegg doesn't appear to back the PM shouldn't concern anyone. Clegg's own admission at this year's Lib Dem conference that he made the wrong call in backing us to join the euro only reinforces the idea that Nick Clegg's views should be treated with extreme caution. Probably best he wasn't sitting alongside Cameron in parliament today.
51 MINUTES AGO
Contrary to the vile ad-hominem aimed at Nick Clegg, I believe he should be commended for swallowing his pride and leading his party into doing whats right for the UK.
2 HOURS AGO
''The Euro will collapse.The Euro has collapsed''...Gosh I have been hearing about this imminent collapse ever since I was 15yo and now I am 25! Cameron has made the wrong decision.We are now isolated,marginalized and the bad guys! It is in our best interest to want a stronger central governance of the EU institutions that would help us be a part of truly strong and all mighty union.
Good to see the British prime minister using a bit of backbone,
Unlike some european ministers who promise a referendum then crumble before the eurocrats.
The United Kingdom needs it's Independance from this fiscal farce.
3 HOURS AGO
Cameron was right to veto the Eurozone Treaty. What was being voted for goes well beyond the purposes of a single 'trading' market. We're in the EU to aid & promote better trading relationships with other European countries and movement across borders. We're not in the EU for the purposes of having the sovereign right to control our own economic and budgetary policies undermined and dictated to us
Share this page
RBS nearly collapsed in 2008 because of poor management decisions and poor regulation, a report from its regulator says.
The US military's first Hindu chaplain
The Americans camping out at the London Stock Exchange
Mass protests put Vladimir Putin under pressure
Is America capable of intelligent debate?
Four professionals explain why relocating abroad for work can often mean moving mountains
Why business is soaring for Asia's airlines as Europe and the US face economic gloom