52 captures
30 Mar 2011 - 03 Feb 2021
About this capture
Member Login
HomeBlogsFrom the Potomac to the EuphratesHow Do You Say 1989 in Arabic?
Follow Us On  
STEVEN A. COOK
From the Potomac to the Euphrates
Cook examines developments in the Middle East and their resonance in Washington.
Subscribe to the Blog Feed Receive Blog Posts by Email
Previous Post Next Post
Print Email Share
How Do You Say 1989 in Arabic?
by Steven A. Cook
March 28, 2011
U.S. President Barack Obama leads a briefing on the current situation in Libya, with National Security Advisor Tom Donilon (L) aboard Air Force One, during a secure conference call on the flight from Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, to Santiago, Chile on March 21, 2011 (Ho New/Courtesy Reuters)
I have been surprised that President Obama has taken so much guff over the Libya situation and his handling of the Arab Spring, more generally. Ben Smith at Politico calls it the “narcissism of small differences.” He makes the point that the arguments and counter-arguments over the White House’s handling of the uprisings are more about tactics than strategy. The punditocracy and political folks tend to lose sight of the fact that the administration is confronting one of the hardest political challenges that any administration could face. Momentous change is happening in an important part of the world and Washington has little ability to influence the trajectory of events short of applying military force as it is doing in Libya.
It’s safe to say there is no playbook for the uprisings and revolutions roiling the Middle East. In the last few months, I have often been asked “Is this the Middle East’s 1989?” There is a temptation to make a connection between the fall of communism in Eastern and Central Europe and the cracking of regimes all over the Arab world. The speed at which the uprisings spread from Tunisia to Egypt to Libya and Bahrain and Yemen are, indeed, reminiscent of the fast forward changes that took place in the fall of 1989. Mu’ammar Qadhafi may very well be the Middle East’s Nicolae Ceausescu. Still, 1989 has nothing on the 2011 winter-spring of Arab discontent. President Obama and his team have few partners in the region to help them realize the peaceful and orderly transitions that the administration desires. There are no Arab analogues to Helmut Kohl, Margaret Thatcher, and Francois Mitterand with whom Obama can work to help bring about soft landings. King Abdallah of Jordan is facing his own domestic turmoil; Morocco’s Mohamed VI is in no position to help; Abdelaziz Bouteflika of Algeria is on the uprising/revolution watch list; the Qataris are influential, but not in the right way because Arab dictators under fire blame al Jazeera for their troubles; in Oman, Sultan Qaboos is dealing with the aftermath of unrest that broke out last month, and Saudi Arabia’s King Abdallah is working at cross purposes with the Obama administration, offering support for leaders confronted with mass demands for political change.
This is an extraordinarily tough political environment in which Washington’s influence and leverage is limited, at best. So when the talking heads get going this evening after President Obama’s address to the nation from National Defense University, keep in mind that they are engaged in the ultimate Monday-morning quarterbacking. With no precedent, no playbook, and no leverage to speak of, I am not sure anyone who was sitting in the White House would be doing any better.
Posted in U.S. Foreign Policy
Share
Post a Comment
1 Comment
Posted by Sybil
March 29, 2011 at 9:53 am
Could Israel be involved in some way in this situation in the arab word?
Post a Comment
Name *

Email (will not be published) *

Website
* Required
Comment *

About This Blog
On From the Potomac to the Euphrates, Cook provides a lens for viewing how debates about Mideast policy in Washington connect to the region, with a special focus on Egypt and Turkey.
About the Author
Steven A. Cook
Hasib J. Sabbagh Senior Fellow for Middle Eastern Studies
Follow via RSS
Follow via Twitter
@stevenacook:
Watching a Turkish soap opera. Suddenly, #Turkey is an inspiration for my own country. #Turkishmodel #Softpower
Looking fwd to stuffing myself w/kebab at Musa Ustam thanks to @​YigalSchleifer​#IstanbulEats
@WashingtonPoint The games ppl play. It's time for a full-on TGS and civilian leadership briefing @blakehounshell#Turkish #Syria
Follow Steven Cook on Twitter
Recent Posts
July 13th, 2012
Weekend Reading: Debating Abortion in Turkey, Lies About Syria, and a Lebanese Action Flick
Religious pluralism and abortion in Turkey. Maysaloon on the lies people tell about the Syrian revolution. A Lebanese action film…
July 12th, 2012
Turkey: Phantom Shoot-Down?
Istanbul, Turkey What really happened to the Turkish RF-4 Phantom jet that went missing over or near Syrian airspace on…
July 9th, 2012
Istanbul and Cairo
I will be traveling to, and blogging from, Istanbul and Cairo over the course of the next two weeks. Hope…
July 6th, 2012
Weekend Reading: Egyptians Getting Down to Business, Freedom of the Press in Morsy’s Egypt, and Libya’s Stalled Revolution
Issandr al-Amrani says Egypt’s new government can waste no more time getting down to business in solving the country’s exigent problems, after…
Categories
Algeria (2)
Bahrain (4)
Coups (4)
Defense/Homeland Security (1)
Democracy (39)
E.U. (2)
Egypt (122)
Elections (34)
Gaza (3)
GCC (3)
Hamas (2)
Human Rights (7)
Iran (8)
Iraq (4)
Israel (25)
Jordan (1)
Lebanon (6)
Libya (4)
NATO (2)
News (5)
North Africa (8)
Opposition Movements (9)
Palestinian Authority (8)
Protests (19)
Reform (32)
Saudi Arabia (10)
Succession (10)
Syria (30)
Terrorism (4)
Tunisia (2)
Turkey (42)
U.S. Foreign Policy (34)
Uncategorized (34)
United Arab Emirates (2)
Weekend Reading (47)
Yemen (9)
Archives
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
Blogroll
Abu Maqawama
Arabawy
Baheyya
Commentary Contentions
Coteret
Eighth Gate
IraqSlogger
Istanbul Calling
Jeffrey Goldberg
Jonathan Tepperman
Marc Lynch
MEI Blog
Middle East Channel
Ottomans and Zionists
Politico
Sandbox
Shadow Government
South Jerusalem
The Angry Arab
The Arabist
The Cable
The Moor Next Door
The Washington Note
Via Meadia
Zeinobia
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
YouTube
RSS Feeds
Podcasts
Enewsletters
Regions
Africa
Americas
Asia
Europe/Russia
Middle East
Polar Regions
Issues
Defense/
Homeland Security
Democracy & Human Rights
Economics
Energy/
Environment
Global Governance
Health, Science, & Technology
International Peace & Security
Proliferation
Terrorism
U.S. Strategy & Politics
Experts
Cyberconflict and Cybersecurity Initiative
Energy Security and Climate Change
Europe Program
Global Health Program
International Institutions and Global Governance Program
Latin America Studies Program
Maurice R. Greenberg Center for Geoeconomic Studies
Middle East Program
National Security Program
Renewing America
U.S. Foreign Policy Program
Women and Foreign Policy Program
Publications
All Publications
Foreign Affairs
Backgrounders
Op-Eds
Interviews
Interactives
Analysis Brief
Essential Docs
Must Reads
Blogs
About CFR
Contact Us
Current Openings
FAQs
Support CFR
Mission Statement
Annual Report
Membership
Officers and Directors
Staff
Resources
Business
Congress
Diplomats
Educators
Religious Community
State & Local Officials
Media Resources
Member Login
© Copyright 2012, Council on Foreign Relations. All Rights Reserved.
HomeRegionsAll RegionsAfricaAmericasAsiaEurope/RussiaMiddle EastPolar RegionsIssuesAll IssuesDefense / Homeland SecurityDemocracy & Human RightsEconomicsEnergy/EnvironmentGlobal GovernanceHealth, Science, & TechnologyInternational Peace, & SecurityProliferationTerrorismU.S. Strategy & PoliticsExpertsAll ExpertsAbout the Studies ProgramCenters, Programs, InitiativesResearch ProjectsPublicationsAll PublicationsForeign AffairsBackgroundersOp-EdsInterviewsInteractivesEssential DocsMust ReadsVideosBooksBlogsElliott AbramsEdward AldenJohn CampbellBlake ClaytonIsobel ColemanSteven A. CookRobert M. DaninElizabeth C. EconomyEd HusainJosh KurlantzickMichael A. LeviJames M. LindsayShannon K. O'NeilStewart M. PatrickAdam SegalSheila A. SmithScott A. SnyderMicah ZenkoAsia UnboundCampaign 2012Development ChannelGeo-GraphicsRenewing AmericaAll BlogsAbout CFRAbout CFRContact UsCurrent OpeningsFellowshipsFAQsSupport CFRMission StatementAnnual ReportMembershipOfficers and DirectorsStaff