Issue #2, Fall 2006

Letters to the Editors

Letters from our readers

Taking Exception

Michael Signer makes a lucid case for “exemplarism,” a model of American foreign policy that embraces our country’s impressive (and, in many respects, unique) power but also recognizes the growing role that global public opinion plays in constraining it [“City on a Hill,” Issue #1]. I would volunteer two criticisms, which, while tangential to his thesis, are, independently, important points of discussion.

First, although he does so only in a passing reference to Josef Joffe’s recent book, Signer internalizes the supposition that “anti-Americanism” and opposition to American foreign policy are synonymous. Yet they are not. The former phenomenon, literally interpreted, denotes a resentment of American values, culture, people, and achievements: in short, the very essence of our nation. Thankfully, as innumerable polls reveal, it is quite confined. However, these same surveys reveal the latter phenomenon to be pervasive. Our conduct abroad is an important manifestation of our national character, but, given its vagaries over the past two centuries, it is an inappropriate gauge of Americanism–hence the fallacy of interchanging the two aforementioned terms.

Second, while Signer criticizes contemporary progressives’ insufficient embrace of “U.S. primacy and power,” he agrees with the rationales that have led it to render such a judgment. In particular, deepening networks of interdependence decrease the utility of armed force because global civil society can increasingly counter military action via economic and political means. The aftermath of the United States’ invasion of Iraq amply affirms this assertion. Furthermore, mainstream progressives, with some exceptions, assent to the United States’ deployment of hard power in response to an unprovoked attack or as part of humanitarian efforts.

Globalization is not a zero-sum game. The United States stands to accrue great dividends from other countries’ progress, provided that it does not become complacent. Exemplarism or, for that matter, any prudent foreign policy paradigm will firmly root itself in this mindset.

Ali WyneWashington, D.C.

Punching Bag No More

As a conservative, I very much welcome your magazine. I agree with you that all of the good ideas are coming out of the conservatives. And that is bad. Our nation can only stay great if good opposing ideas are battling against each other to change and become great ideas. The right needs a sparring partner. In the last couple of decades it seems we have only had a punching bag.

Joseph Libson San Francisco, Calif.

Correction

Democratic Representative William Smith was from Virginia, not North Carolina [“The Fall of the House of Representatives,” Issue #1]. We regret the error.

Issue #2, Fall 2006
 

Post a Comment

Name

Email

Comments (you may use HTML tags for style)

Verification

Note: Several minutes will pass while the system is processing and posting your comment. Do not resubmit during this time or your comment will post multiple times.