21 captures
07 Feb 2011 - 25 Feb 2021
About this capture
Don’t expect sweeping reforms in Jordan, former ambassador cautions
By Sal Gentile
February 3, 2011
The tremors of Egypt’s popular uprising continued to ripple across the Arab world Thursday as King Abdullah II of Jordan met with leaders of the opposition there to discuss possible political reforms, two days after dismissing his cabinet and promising to “bolster democracy.”
Some observers, however, have warned not to expect wide-ranging reforms to Jordan’s political process, which disenfranchises large swaths of the population and acts mostly at the discretion of the king. Edward Gnehm, the former U.S. ambassador to Jordan from 2001 to 2003, warned in an interview this week that Jordan’s deep ethnic divisions and traditional power structure augured against the kinds of sweeping changes being demanded in the streets of nearby Arab capitals.
“The problem is, it’s really difficult for the king to agree to what they’re asking for,” said Gnehm, now a faculty member at George Washington University’s Elliott School of International Affairs. “I think there’s likely to be some change and some movement, but I don’t think there’s going to be any massive shift, at least not right away.”
The problem, Gnehm said, is the traditional rift between Jordan’s powerful East Bank tribes and the country’s large Palestinian population. The rural tribes have traditionally wielded most of the power in Jordan, including in the military and other elite professions, while the Palestinians have been confined to the poorer urban areas.
While both groups tend to agree on the need for a more robust economy and a cure for Jordan’s crippling unemployment, East Bank Jordanians remain skeptical of proposed electoral reforms that would give the Palestinians more political power. Voting in Jordan’s parliamentary system disproportionately favors tribal Jordanians from rural parts of the country, while under-representing urban Palestinians.
And East Bank Jordanians have long been suspicious of any sign that the Palestinians’ influence may be expanding. When Prime Minister Samir Rifai ordered all government offices to display photos of Jordan’s then-14-year-old heir apparent, Crown Prince Hussein bin Abdullah — who is part Palestinian — U.S. diplomats warned that the move “could potentially spark criticism among East Bank Jordanians that power is subtly shifting towards Jordanians of Palestinian origin,” according to a January 2010 cable obtained by WikiLeaks.
Human rights activists monitoring the protests in Amman, Jordan’s capital, say the throngs of demonstrators there comprise virtually all of the country’s ethnic and political enclaves, including the Palestinians and East Bank Jordanians, Islamists, Communists and trade unionists. Sameer Jarrah, a human rights lawyer and regional director for Freedom House, said in an interview from Amman this week that, to his surprise, the East Bank Jordanians, “who are known as very loyal tribes to the crown, to the government, they are participating.”
That may be true, Gnehm said, given the broad consensus among Jordanians on the need for far-reaching economic reforms. But most of the groups demanding a fairer and more robust electoral process, such as the Islamist parties and the trade unions, are dominated by Jordanians of Palestinian descent. And their demands, Gnehm cautioned, may well be outweighed by the political interests of the East Bank Jordanians in the country’s powerful military and bureaucracy.
“You cannot deny, simply can’t deny that what happened in Tunisia was a catalyst for what happened in Egypt and in Amman and in other places,” Gnehm said. “But in the Jordanian community, it represents a challenge in the minds and the eyes of the East Bankers, a challenge to their political supremacy.”
He added: “I just cannot imagine it going to the fullest extent.”
Last modified: February 3, 2011 at 4:05 pm
Tags: arab world, Egypt, Egypt protests, Egypt uprising, Hosni Mubarak, Islamic Action Front, Jordan, Jordan protests, King Abdullah, middle east, Muslim Brotherhood, Palestinians, Tunisia, WikiLeaks
  • F8lee
    My question about all of the protests in the middle east is just that – “what do the protesters expect to happen if they get their way?” That is, when we see people marching for gay rights or to reverse Roe vs Wade, whether one agrees with the sentiment or not one knows what the marchers want if they were to “win”.
    With the middle east fiasco, though, I have not heard any pundits or commentators say anything about what the net outcome of the revolts will be – will replacing the leadership magically create jobs and industries where there are few to none today? Are these leaders preventing the discovery of vast mines-full of rare earth metals that will create export income all of a sudden (since China is cutting back their exports by 75% this year)?
    I certainly do not claim any special knowledge of the situation there, but beyond rioting for rioting’s sake and getting the frustrations of high unemployment and apparently generally miserable living conditions out in the open, what is the protesters’ end game?
  • http://www.mapmonde.org Satellite maps
    Will you think about posting some more aspects concerning this subject in the future?
Historically speaking (11)
International desk (79)
Need to hear (10)
Need to learn (5)
Need to read (25)
Need to see (22)
Need to taste (6)
Need to watch (32)
Notes from the corner cubicle (9)
Photo of the day (212)
Politics and campaigns (23)
The sausage (2)
Around the web: Drone politics
In search of the college vote
Egypt in transition
Learn More
Providing Support for pbs.org
The dirty dozen and clean 15 of produce
A brief history of the birth control pill
Starting your own food truck
Just how easy is phone hacking?

Need to Know is a production of Creative News Group (CNG) in association with WNET. Marc Rosenwasser is Executive Producer. Need to Know is made possible by Bernard and Irene Schwartz, Mutual of America, Citi Foundation, John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Foundation, Margaret A. Cargill Foundation, The Corporation for Public Broadcasting and PBS.
© 2013 WNET.ORG. All rights reserved. pbs.org Terms of Use Privacy Policy
HOMEEPISODESNEWSTOPICSHealthEconomyImmigrationInfrastructureMilitaryCultureMoney & MedicineReligionOPINIONVIDEO