10 captures
16 Nov 2013 - 19 Jan 2016
About this capture
Edition: U.S. / Global
Search All NYTimes.com

News Analysis
Indentured Servitude in the Persian Gulf
Shawn Baldwin for The New York Times
Asian workers slept on the roof of a building in Doha, Qatar, in 2010.
Published: April 12, 2013
DOHA, Qatar
LAST year, Theresa M. Dantes signed a contract with an employment agency in the Philippines to come here to work as a housemaid for $400 a month, plus room and board. But when she arrived, her employer said he would pay her only $250. She acquiesced; her family back in Quezon City depended on her earnings.
Other surprises quickly followed. Ms. Dantes, 29, said she was fed one meal a day, leftovers from the family’s lunch: “If no leftovers, I didn’t eat.” She worked seven days a week. When she finished work in her employer’s house, she was forced to clean his mother-in-law’s house, and then his sister’s.
After eight months, Ms. Dantes tried to leave. Her boss laughed. “You can’t quit,” he told her.
Under kafala, the system that governs the working lives of every foreigner employed in Qatar, Ms. Dantes could not resign without her employer’s permission. She fled and joined 56 other women who had sought shelter at the Philippine Overseas Labor Office.
Some 1.2 million foreign workers — mostly poor Asians from India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal, Indonesia and the Philippines — make up 94 percent of the labor force in Qatar, an absolute monarchy roughly the size of Connecticut.
Developed in the late 1950s in sparsely populated Persian Gulf states that needed workers for their oil and gas industries, the system has expanded to the point where there are nearly five foreign workers for each Qatari citizen. Perhaps a million foreign workers are expected to arrive in the next few years to help build nine new stadiums and $20 billion in roads needed by 2022, when Qatar will host the World Cup.
Many of these workers will labor under near-feudal conditions that Human Rights Watch has likened to “forced labor.” Qatari employers assume legal responsibility for their employees in addition to providing them with a paid job, a work visa, housing and often food. In exchange, an employee agrees to work for an employer for a fixed length of time.
But a worker cannot change jobs, leave the country, get a driver’s license, rent a home or open a checking account without the permission of his or her employer-sponsor, or kafeel. And a kafeel also can withdraw sponsorship at almost any time and send the employee home.
It’s not just housemaids and other low-skilled workers who are the victims. An Arab-American businessman, Nasser Beydoun, said he spent 685 days as an “economic hostage” in Doha before he was released in October 2011. After he quit as chief executive of a local restaurant chain, his former employer denied him a permit to leave Qatar.
“Foreign workers in Qatar are modern-day slaves to their local employers,” Mr. Beydoun, who now lives in Detroit, told me. “The local Qatari owns you.”
Only about half of foreign blue-collar workers sign formal work contracts before coming to Qatar, according to a poll by the Social and Economic Survey Research Institute at Qatar University. The rest come with nothing more than a verbal agreement.
Even a formal contract offers inadequate protection. A quarter of the blue-collar workers who signed contracts said employers failed to fully honor the agreements, the poll found. That proportion increased to 42 percent among the third who made less than $275 a month.
Under pressure from human rights and labor advocates, the government has promised new protections. “Seven, eight years ago we didn’t have labor laws,” said Hussein al-Mulla, under secretary of the Labor Ministry. “It is better now than before. It will be better in the future.”
The  ministry has created a phone line for workers to anonymously report abuses, and a system of arbitrating labor disputes. Employers now must report paycheck details to the Labor Ministry. The country is finalizing a law setting occupational health and safety standards and a charter of workers’ rights.
But new laws are not enough. “The challenge is enforcement of these laws and establishing a new work culture,”  Andrew Gardner​, an anthropologist at the University of Puget Sound who studies gulf laborers, told me. “The scope of the problem is so large and the number of foreigners is growing so quickly.”
Next Page »
Richard Morin is a former polling editor at The Washington Post and a visiting scholar at the Social and Economic Survey Research Institute at Qatar University​.
A version of this news analysis appeared in print on April 14, 2013, on page SR4 of the New York edition with the headline: Indentured Servitude in the Persian Gulf.
Try unlimited access to NYTimes.com for just 99¢.  SEE OPTIONS »
Get Free E-mail Alerts on These Topics
QatarForeign Workers
Forced LaborHuman Rights Watch
What makes a great Shakespearean?


Inside NYTimes.com
Opinion »
Letters: Sudden Shifts on the Health Front
World »
Armed With Paint Within Earshot of Syrian War
N.Y. / Region »
His Roots in Italy, de Blasio Has Fans There
Opinion »
The Lesser of Two Evils?
Climate scientists see nuclear power as essential to phasing out fossil fuels. But, Room for Debate asks, is it dangerous?
Television »
We Interrupt This Generation ...
Travel »
Travel Guide: Chicago for Kids
Video Games »
Sizing Up the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One
Arts »
Going Beyond Blackness, Into the Starry Skies
Opinion »
The Stone: The School of Arthur Danto
Danto, a singular thinker and stylish writer, transformed the field of philosophical aesthetics.
Theater »
‘Little Miss Sunshine’ Opens at Second Stage
Opinion »
Op-Ed: Surrender, Oblivion, and Survival
Sports »
From Shortstop to Book Publisher