1 capture
23 Jan 2014
About this capture
In the News
Blimplike surveillance craft set to deploy over Maryland heighten privacy concerns
Raytheon - Two aerostats, which look like white blimps, are to be set aloft at Aberdeen Proving Ground about 45 miles northeast of Washington in Maryland, for a three-year test slated to start in October.
By Craig Timberg, E-mail the writer
They will look like two giant white blimps floating high above I-95 in Maryland, perhaps en route to a football game somewhere along the bustling Eastern Seaboard. But their mission will have nothing to do with sports and everything to do with war.
The aerostats — that is the term for lighter-than-air craft that are tethered to the ground — are to be set aloft on Army-owned land about 45 miles northeast of Washington, near Aberdeen Proving Ground, for a three-year test slated to start in October. From a vantage of 10,000 feet, they will cast a vast radar net from Raleigh, N.C., to Boston and out to Lake Erie, with the goal of detecting cruise missiles or enemy aircraft so they could be intercepted before reaching the capital.
Surveillance aircraft floating high above Maryland
The U.S. Army says the aerostats being deployed near Washington will not be equipped with cameras as ones in Afghanistan were. The Post's national technology reporter, Craig Timberg, explains how aerostats work and how powerful their radar and camera sensors can be.
Aerostats deployed by the military at U.S. bases in Iraq and Afghanistan typically carried powerful surveillance cameras as well, to track the movements of suspected insurgents and even U.S. soldiers. When Army Staff Sgt. Robert Bales murdered 16 civilians in Kandahar in March 2012, an aerostat above his base captured video of him returning from the slaughter in the early-morning darkness with a rifle in his hand and a shawl over his shoulders.
Defense contractor Raytheon last year touted an exercise in which it outfitted the aerostats planned for deployment in suburban Baltimore with one of the company’s most powerful high-altitude surveillance systems, capable of spotting individual people and vehicles from a distance of many miles.
The Army said it has “no current plans” to mount such cameras or infrared sensors on the aerostats or to share information with federal, state or local law enforcement, but it declined to rule out either possibility. The radar system that is planned for the aerostats will be capable of monitoring the movement of trains, boats and cars, the Army said.
The prospect of military-grade tracking technology floating above suburban Baltimore — along one of the East Coast’s busiest travel corridors — has sparked privacy concerns at a time of rising worry about the growth of government eavesdropping in the dozen years since the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks.
“That’s the kind of massive persistent surveillance we’ve always been concerned about with drones,” said Jay Stanley, a privacy expert for the American Civil Liberties Union. “It’s part of this trend we’ve seen since 9/11, which is the turning inward of all of these surveillance technologies.”
The Army played down such concerns in written responses to questions posed by The Washington Post, saying its goal is to test the ability of the aerostats to bolster the region’s missile-defense capability, especially against low-flying cruise missiles that can be hard for ground-based systems to detect in time to intercept them.
The Army determined it did not need to conduct a Privacy Impact Assessment, required for some government programs, because it was not going to collect any personally identifiable information, officials said in their written responses to The Post.
“The primary mission . . . is to track airborne objects,” the Army said. “Its secondary mission is to track surface moving objects such as vehicles or boats. The capability to track surface objects does not extend to individual people.”
Even the most powerful overhead surveillance systems, experts say, struggle to make out individual faces or other identifying features such as license plates because of the extreme angles when viewing an area from above.
But privacy advocates say location information can easily lead to the identification of individuals if collected on a mass scale and analyzed over time.
Researchers have found that people vary their movements little day to day, typically traveling from home to work and back while also regularly visiting a small number of other locations, such as stores, gyms or the homes of friends.
Aerostats’ range
The aerostats planned for Maryland will have radar capable of detecting airborne objects from up to 340 miles away and vehicles on the surface from up to 140 miles away — as far south as Richmond, as far west as Cumberland, Md., and as far north as Staten Island. The Army declined to say what size vehicles can be sensed from those distances.
“If it’s able to track vehicles, that is problematic,” said Jennifer Lynch of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a civil liberties group. “You could imagine a scenario in which the location information can reveal where you go to church, what doctor you’re going to, whether you’re cheating on your wife, all those types of details. . . . Once a surveillance technology is put up, it’s very tempting for law enforcement or the military to use it for reasons they did not originally disclose.”
Technologies developed for battlefields — weapons, vehicles, communications systems — long have flowed homeward as overseas conflicts have ended. The battles that followed the Sept. 11 attacks have produced major advances in surveillance equipment whose manufacturers increasingly are looking to expand their use within the United States.
Aerostats — basically big balloons on strings — grew popular in Iraq and Afghanistan and also are used by Israel to monitor the Gaza Strip and by the United States to eye movement along southern border areas. Even a rifle shot through an aerostat will not bring it down, because the pressure of the helium inside nearly matches the pressure of the air outside, preventing rapid deflation.
TCOM, a Columbia, Md.-based company that Raytheon hired to manufacture the aerostats planned for the upcoming deployment, said business is growing for smaller, tactical systems that can be used in sensitive border or harbor areas.
“When you need persistent surveillance in a particular area, there is no better solution than the aerostat because it’s there all the time,” said Ron Bendlin, TCOM’s president.
The Defense Department spent nearly $7 billion on 15 different lighter-than-air systems between 2007 and 2012, with several suffering from technical problems, delays and unexpectedly high costs, the Government Accountability Office found in an October 2012 report .
The system planned for Maryland is called JLENS, short for Joint Land Attack Cruise Missile Defense Elevated Netted Sensor System. The system has had setbacks, including rising costs and an accident in 2010 that damaged one of the aerostats at a facility in North Carolina.
A GAO report in March put the total development costs for JLENS at $2.7 billion. Once expected to provide 16 systems, each consisting of two aerostats and accompanying ground controls, only two of these systems have been built, the one scheduled to fly in Maryland and a second sitting in storage in Utah.
Raytheon, the prime contractor on the project, declined numerous interview requests about the JLENS system and, after requesting questions in writing, also declined to answer those.
The military has no concrete plans to build more JLENS systems, though supporters of the program have not given up hope of reviving support.
“They are bringing this to the East Coast, close to Washington, to get the Pentagon guys and Congress to say, ‘Whoa, we could really use this,’ ” said Daniel Goure of the Lexington Institute, a military think tank with ties to the defense industry. “This is re-purposing. You’ve already spent the money.”
Tests in Utah
The JLENS aerostats can stay in the air continuously for up to 30 days and have shown the ability in tests to track fast-moving objects in flight. The JLENS radar systems also can detect what security experts call “swarming boats,” the kind of small, agile watercraft that, when loaded with explosives, can threaten ships.
The aerostat system destined for use outside Baltimore has spent the past few years based at the Utah Test and Training Range, in the vast, parched salt flats west of Salt Lake City.
Residents of the area complained less about privacy issues than the militarization of the airspace. Testing of the JLENS involved small aircraft that raced through the sky, mimicking the flight of missiles. The radar systems were supposed to track them and help firing systems home in on the moving targets. The aerostats themselves were not armed.
The Army said similar tests will not be conducted while the aerostats are deployed in suburban Baltimore.
As the aerostats hover above the area, they will be visible — at least faintly — for dozens of miles in any direction. To fans seated in the stands behind home plate at Orioles games in Baltimore’s Inner Harbor, more than 15 miles away, they will probably appear as two white dots hovering in the sky beyond the historic brick warehouse at Camden Yards.
The JLENS system will require pilots to take precautions in flights through the area; the Federal Aviation Administration is creating a “special use airspace” for the three-year test period, the Army said.
There also will be “minor adverse impacts” on the bald eagle population in the vicinity of Aberdeen Proving Ground, which sits among the highest density of nests for the iconic birds in the Chesapeake Bay region, according to an Army environmental assessment.
One of the two base stations for the aerostats will breach a 500-meter perimeter established to protect a nest used by a pair of bald eagles. The environmental assessment says that if those eagles are disturbed or killed because of the proximity of the JLENS base station or related construction, it would qualify as a legally permissible “incidental take” of the species.
In a bid to demonstrate the long-term utility of JLENS to potential customers, Raytheon organized and paid for an exercise at a Utah test range in which it outfitted an aerostat with a spherical MTS-B sensor, often used by the Air Force and Customs and Border Protection to conduct overhead surveillance from drones. The exact capabilities of the MTS-B are classified, military officials said, but engineers familiar with the technology said its electro-optical and infrared sensors probably can detect individuals from more than 20 miles away.
For the Raytheon test, the MTS-B spotted a person pretending to be a terrorist planting an improvised roadside bomb, even though the view was obscured by smoke from a nearby forest fire, according to a Raytheon news release from January 2013. Operators could see live feeds of “trucks, trains and cars from dozens of miles away.”
The Army described the MTS-B test as “a contractor conducted demonstration” and said that only Raytheon could provide details. The company declined to do so, referring all questions to the Army.
Activists in Utah critical of the aerostat testing there said they were never alerted to the testing or to potential privacy issues for the test of Raytheon’s surveillance sensors.
“I’m positive that was never raised,” said Steve Erickson of the Citizens Education Project, based in Salt Lake City. “Privacy was just not an issue, in part because of the remoteness of the place.”
Follow The Post’s new tech blog, The Switch, where technology and policy connect.
Top Business Stories
Most Popular Videos
The Post Most: Business
10 startling facts about global wealth inequality
Economic mobility hasn't changed in a half-century in America, economists declare
China accuses hackers for Internet disruption; experts suspect censors
World Marketsfrom   
Other Market Datafrom   
Key Ratesfrom   
Post Newsletters & Alerts
Sign-up for e-mail newsletters and alerts and get the news you need delivered directly to your inbox.
Local Business Alerts
Economy & Business News Alerts
Technology News Alerts
Capital Business
Ezra Klein's Wonkbook
Personal Finance
TechNews Daily Report
More ways to get us
Newsletter & Alerts
Washington Post Live
Reprints & Permissions
Post Store
Contact Us
Help & Contact Info
Reader Representative
Digital Advertising
Newspaper Advertising
News Service & Syndicate
About Us
In the community
Newspaper in Education
Digital Publishing Guidelines
© 1996- The Washington Post
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Submissions and Discussion Policy
RSS Terms of Service
Ad Choices
Real EstateRentalsCarsToday's PaperGoing Out GuideFind&SaveService Alley
HomePostTVIn PostTVPoliticsIn PoliticsCongressCourts & LawThe Fed PageHealth CarePollingWhite HouseGovBeatMd. PoliticsVa. PoliticsD.C. PoliticsBlogs & Columnsaaron_blakeHalf of Americans fear terrorist attack in SochiPost Politics Aaron Blakejaime_fullerEverything you need to know about the Chris Christie investigationsThe Fix Jaime Fullernathaniel_persilyAmerican elections need help. Here’s how to make them better.The Monkey Cage Nathaniel Persilyniraj_chokshiA partial list of the things Florida lawmakers might make secretGovBeat Niraj Chokshijosh_hicksFederal employment projected to drop through 2022The Federal Eye Josh HicksOpinionsIn OpinionsToles Cartoons Telnaes AnimationsThe Post's ViewLetters to the EditorLocal OpinionsColumnist IndexFeatured Blogsalexandra_petriHappy National Hug Day, I guessComPost Alexandra Petrigreg_sargentHappy Hour RoundupThe Plum Line Greg Sargentjonathan_capehartBob and Maureen McDonnell weren’t cheap friendsPostPartisan Jonathan Capehartjennifer_rubinImmigration reform could happenRight Turn Jennifer RubinLocalIn LocalD.C. Maryland Virginia Crime Education Obituaries Transportation Weather Blogs & Columns Blogs & Columnsdavid_streitCold stranglehold eases a bit, maybe afternoon flurriesCapital Weather Gang David Streitmaura_judkisThis thing you should try: Right Proper’s ‘Chick Filet’Going Out Guide Maura Judkisrobert_thomsonMetro working on all lines this weekendDr. Gridlock Robert ThomsonSportsIn Sports Redskins/NFL Capitals/NHL Wizards/NBA Nationals/MLB D.C. United/Soccer Colleges AllMetSports Blogs & Columns Other SportsBlogs & Columnskatie_carreraFive thoughts on Caps-SensCapitals Insider Katie Carreradan_steinbergNick Sundberg goes at Roger Goodell on extra pointsDC Sports Bog Dan Steinbergmark_maskeWilliams might return to Redskins in front office job The Insider Mark Maskejames_wagnerNationals sign reliever Clay Hensley to minor league dealNationals Journal James WagnerNationalIn NationalEnergy & EnvironmentHealth & Science Education National Security InvestigationsInnovations Know MoreReligion On Giving CorrectionsBlogs & Columnsmatt_mcfarlandThe elevator that learns to read mindsInnovationsnia_malika_hendersonWomen seek to expand their numbers in the SenateShe The People Nia-Malika Hendersoneugene_volokhAbout our move to the Post, for those who missed the memoVolokh Conspiracy Eugene VolokhWorldIn WorldAfrica The AmericasAsia & Pacific Europe Middle East National Security War Zones Special Reports Columns & BlogsBlogs & Columnscaitlin_deweyWhy some Ukrainian protesters are wearing kitchen colandersWorldViews Caitlin Deweyanup_kaphlePhotographer follows doctors into Syrian refugee campsWorldViews Anup Kaphlemax_fisherWhy Sunnis and Shiites are fightingWorldViews Max Fishermax_fisherUkraine’s protests are back. Here’s why.WorldViews Max FisherBusinessIn Business Economy IndustriesMarketsPolicy & RegulationKnow More World BusinessCapital BusinessOn Leadership On Small Business On I.T. Blogs & Columnsmichelle_singletaryProtect your credit by freezing itThe Color of Money Michelle Singletaryezra_klein10 startling facts about global wealth inequalityWonkblog Ezra Kleinjena_mcgregorJust the right level of narcissism to be successfulOn Leadership Jena McGregorTechIn TechnologyInnovation Green Technology The Switch Photo Galleries Blogs & Columnshayley_tsukayamaEaston-Bell Sports reports data breach at online vendor Hayley Tsukayamabrian_fungNetflix’s secret weapon in the net neutrality fightThe Switch Brian Fungbrian_fungThe 16-year-old kid who’s helping to keep Snapchat honest.The Switch Brian Fungandrea_petersonJust by sitting on them, the government earned another $24 million from Silk Road’s bitcoinsThe Switch Andrea PetersonLifestyleIn LifestyleAdvice Carolyn Hax Food Express Home & Garden Style Travel Weddings Wellness Magazine KidsPost On Parenting Blogs & Columnsemily_yahrQuentin Tarantino dumps new project and spills the details; NBC quietly abandons ‘Murder, She Wrote’ rebootThe Style Blog Emily Yahremily_heilThe last all-male Alfalfa Dinner -- in 1993 (#TBT) The Reliable Source Emily HeilEntertainmentIn EntertainmentBooksComics Going Out GuideHoroscopes MoviesMuseums Music Puzzles & Games Theater & DanceTV Blogs & Columnsmichael_cavnaMLK DAY: Check out these books on Dr. King, civil rightsComic Riffs Michael Cavnamaura_judkisThis thing you should try: Right Proper’s ‘Chick Filet’Going Out Guide Maura JudkisJobsIn JobsMoreClassifiedsCarsDealsReal EstateRentalsPhotosBlogsDiscussionsFind&SaveObituariesArchivesTopicsWP Wine ClubWP BrandConnect
Robert McDonnellSochiUkraineRoe v. WadeRep. Steve Pearce
Floating aircraft raise privacy worriesCOLUMN | These Games have a dangerous ringVIDEO | How to fold the perfect dumplingQuick: Name this masterpiece