2 captures
06 Jun 2014 - 16 Jul 2014
About this capture
Trending Topics
Charles Krauthammer
Opinion Writer
Free him, then try him
(Uncredited/AP) - In this image taken from video obtained from Voice Of Jihad Website, which has been authenticated based on its contents and other AP reporting, Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, right, stands with a Taliban fighter in eastern Afghanistan. The Taliban on Wednesday, June 4, 2014, released a video showing the handover of Bergdahl to U.S. forces in eastern Afghanistan, touting the swap of the American soldier for five Taliban detainees from Guantanamo as a significant achievement for the insurgents. Bergdahl was freed on Saturday after five years in captivity, and exchanged for the five Guantanamo detainees who were flown to Qatar, a tiny Gulf Arab country which has served as a mediator in the negotiations for the swap. (AP Photo/Voice Of Jihad Website via AP video)
By Charles Krauthammer, E-mail the writer
What is it with Susan Rice and the Sunday morning talk shows? This time she said Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl had served in Afghanistan “with honor and distinction” — the biggest whopper since she insisted the Benghazi attack was caused by a video.
There is strong eyewitness evidence that Bergdahl deserted his unit and that the search for him endangered his fellow soldiers. If he had served with honor and distinction, there would be no national uproar over his ransom and some of the widely aired objections to the deal would be as muted as they are flimsy. For example:
Charles Krauthammer
Krauthammer writes a politics column that runs on Fridays.
You may also like...
Michael Gerson
Obama ditches his party
George F. Will
When a president goes rogue
1. America doesn’t negotiate with terrorists.
Nonsense. Of course we do. Everyone does, while pretending not to. The Israelis, by necessity the toughest of all anti-terror fighters, in 2011 gave up 1,027 prisoners, some with blood on their hands, for one captured staff sergeant.
2. The administration did not give Congress 30-day notice as required by law.
Of all the jurisdictional disputes between president and Congress, the president stands on the firmest ground as commander in chief. And commanders have the power to negotiate prisoner exchanges.
Moreover, from where did this sudden assertion of congressional prerogative spring? After five years of supine acquiescence to President Obama’s multiple usurpations, Congress suddenly becomes exercised over a war power — where its claim is weakest. Congress does nothing in the face of 23 executive alterations of the president’s own Affordable Care Act. It does nothing when Obama essentially enacts by executive order the Dream Act, which Congress had refused to enact. It does nothing when the Justice Department unilaterally rewrites drug laws. And now it rises indignantly on its hind legs because it didn’t get 30 days’ notice of a prisoner swap?
3. The Taliban release endangers national security.
Indeed it does. The five released detainees are unrepentant, militant and dangerous. They’re likely to go back into the field and resume their war against local and foreign infidels, especially us.
The administration pretense that we and the Qataris will monitor them is a joke. They can start planning against us tonight. And if they decide to leave Qatar tomorrow, who’s going to stop them?
The administration might have tried honesty here and said: Yes, we gave away five important combatants. But that’s what you do to redeem hostages. In such exchanges, the West always gives more than it gets for the simple reason that we value individual human life more than do the barbarians with whom we deal.
No shame here, merely a lamentable reality. So why does the Bergdahl deal rankle? Because of how he became captive in the first place. That’s the real issue. He appears to have deserted, perhaps even defected.
The distinction is important. If he’s a defector — joined the enemy to fight against his country — then he deserves no freeing. Indeed, he deserves killing, the way we kill other enemies in the field, the way we killed Anwar al-Awlaki, an American who had openly joined al-Qaeda. A U.S. passport does not entitle a traitor to any special protection. (Caveat: If a POW is turned, Stockholm-syndrome-like, after falling captive, these condemnatory considerations don’t apply.)
Assume, however — and we will find out soon enough — that Bergdahl was not a defector. Simply wanted out — a deserter who walked or wandered away from his duty and his comrades for reasons as yet unknown. Do you bargain for a deserter?
Two imperatives should guide the answer. Bergdahl remains a member of the U.S. military and therefore is (a) subject to military justice and (b) subject to the soldiers’ creed that we don’t leave anyone behind.
What to do? Free him, then try him. Make the swap and then, if the evidence is as strong as it now seems, court-martial him for desertion.
The swap itself remains, nonetheless, a very close call. I would fully respect a president who rejected the deal as simply too unbalanced. What is impossible to respect is a president who makes this heart-wrenching deal and then does a victory lap in the Rose Garden and has his senior officials declare it a cause for celebration. The ever dutiful, ever clueless Susan Rice hailed it as “an extraordinary day for America.”
Good God. This is no victory. This is a defeat, a concession to a miserable reality, a dirty deal, perhaps necessary as a matter of principle but to be carried out with regret, resignation, even revulsion.
The Rose Garden stunt wasn’t a messaging failure. It’s a category error. The president seems oblivious to the gravity, indeed the very nature, of what he has just done. Which is why a stunned and troubled people are asking themselves what kind of man they have twice chosen to lead them.
Read more from Charles Krauthammer’s archive, follow him on Twitter or subscribe to his updates on Facebook.
Read more about this topic:
Charles Lane: When soldiers walk off
George F. Will: The rogue president
Dana Milbank: Knowledge not required
Kathleen Parker: He had to make a deal
Ruth Marcus: Still one left behind
Top Opinions Stories
Most Popular Videos
The Post Most: Opinions
The top-read stories of the past four hours
Free him, then try him
Going for his legacy
The perils of leaning forward
Connect with PostOpinions
Facebook: Become a fan of Washington Post Opinions
Voice Your Opinions
Contact the reader representative
Have questions about Post content or practices?
Send a letter to the editor
Write a response to a piece in The Post.
Submit an op-ed
Make an argument about a topic in the news.
Is President Obama stripping American values out of his foreign policy?
Review your answers and share
Sign in to have your score recorded »
Join a Discussion
Earlier Today
More ways to get us
Newsletter & Alerts
Washington Post Live
Reprints & Permissions
Post Store
Photo Store
Contact Us
Help & Contact Info
Reader Representative
Digital Advertising
Newspaper Advertising
News Service & Syndicate
About Us
In the community
Newspaper in Education
Digital Publishing Guidelines
© 1996- The Washington Post
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Submissions and Discussion Policy
RSS Terms of Service
Ad Choices
Real EstateRentalsCarsToday's PaperGoing Out GuideFind&Save
HomePostTVIn PostTVPoliticsIn PoliticsCourts & LawThe Fed Page Health CarePollingWhite HouseGovBeatMd. PoliticsVa. PoliticsD.C. PoliticsBlogs & Columnssean_sullivanKoch brothers donate $25 million to United Negro College FundPost Politics Sean Sullivanaaron_blakeGay marriage opponents don’t have much fight in themThe Fix Aaron Blakesarah_krepsDo Americans really love drone strikes?The Monkey Cage Sarah Krepsniraj_chokshiColorado passes nation’s first law regulating uberX, LyftGovBeat Niraj Chokshijosh_hicksActing VA secretary promises to ‘make dust’ to fix problemsThe Federal Eye Josh HicksOpinionsIn OpinionsToles Cartoons Telnaes Animations The Post's ViewLetters to the EditorLocal Opinions Columnist Index Featured Blogsradley_balkoColorado’s poster boy for ‘stoned driving’ was drunk off his gourdThe Watchalexandra_petriAshamed of reading YA?ComPost Alexandra Petriradley_balkoMorning Links: NYPD conducts mass sweep of public housingThe Watch Radley Balkojennifer_rubinRick Perry’s comeback?Right Turn Jennifer Rubingreg_sargentMorning Plum: A gay rights milestoneThe Plum Line Greg SargentLocalIn LocalD.C. Maryland Virginia Crime Education Obituaries Transportation Weather Blogs & Columns Blogs & Columnsjason_samenowAtlanta’s amazing red sky double rainbow (PHOTOS)Capital Weather Gang Jason SamenowThe week’s best concerts: Kishi Bashi, Morrissey, Seun KutiGoing Out Guidejulie_zauzmerSewer leak closes lanes in ArlingtonDr. Gridlock Julie ZauzmerSportsIn SportsRedskins/NFLCapitals/NHLWizards/NBANationals/MLBWorld Cup 2014CollegesAllMetSportsBlogs & ColumnsOther SportsBlogs & Columnsalex_prewittCapitals out of Baltimore Hockey ClassicCapitals Insider Alex Prewittdan_steinbergThe Sports section, the day after D-DayDC Sports Bog Dan Steinbergmike_jonesGruden: Williams will help RGIII continue to matureThe Insider Mike Jonesjames_wagnerThe Nationals face a tough 10-day roadtripNationals Journal James WagnerNationalIn NationalEnergy & EnvironmentHealth & Science Education National Security InvestigationsInnovations Know More Religion On Giving CorrectionsBlogs & Columnsmatt_mcfarlandAre comments overrated?Innovations Matt McFarlandnia_malika_hendersonIowa Senate candidate likens his female opponent to a chickShe The People Nia-Malika Hendersonjonathan_h_adlerBADCC (Beware of acronyms in the D.C. Circuit)Volokh Conspiracy Jonathan H. Adlermark_bermanIt’s National Doughnut DayPost Nation Mark Bermanjoel_achenbachAnother day, another dyspeptic human spaceflight reviewAchenblog Joel Achenbachdan_lamotheRemembering the military secrecy and lies that made D-Day successfulCheckpoint Dan LamotheWorldIn WorldAfrica The AmericasAsia & Pacific Europe Middle East National Security Columns & BlogsBlogs & Columnsadam_taylorBritain hopes Lego will thwart Scotland’s independence bidWorldViewsabby_phillipFull Transcript: President Obama’s remarks at the 70th anniversary of D-DayWorldViews Abby Phillipishaan_tharoor20 World Cup goals that changed historyWorldViews Ishaan Tharoordan_lamotheRemembering the military secrecy and lies that made D-Day successfulCheckpoint Dan LamotheBusinessIn Business Economy IndustriesMarketsPolicy & RegulationKnow More World BusinessCapital BusinessOn Leadership On Small Business On I.T. Blogs & Columnsmichelle_singletaryOne final CliffsNotes for recent grads — on paying off debtThe Color of Money Michelle Singletarychristopher_ingrahamSchwarzenegger says he’s ‘pumped up’ for nationwide redistricting reformWonkblog Christopher Ingrahamjena_mcgregorWhat GM could do to change its cultureOn Leadership Jena McGregorjonathan_oconnellGeorgetown plots big Tenleytown expansion Digger Jonathan O'ConnellTechIn TechnologyInnovation The Switch Blogs & Columnsbrian_fung_andrea_peterson_and_hayley_tsukayamaSwitchback: Talking Techhayley_tsukayamaWe’re doing what Verizon and Netflix need to do: ChatThe Switch Hayley Tsukayamabrian_fung‘A soup of misery’: Over half say they’d abandon their cable firm, if only they couldThe Switch Brian Funghayley_tsukayamaThe Switchboard: Vodafone tips massive state surveillance program in new reportThe Switch Hayley TsukayamaLifestyleIn LifestyleAdvice Carolyn Hax Food Express Home & Garden Style Travel Weddings Wellness Magazine KidsPost On Parenting Blogs & Columnsemily_yahrTaye Diggs finally explains why he follows thousands of random people on TwitterThe Style Blog Emily Yahrhelena_andrewsActress Tea Leoni chokes up while recounting scenes from a refugee campThe Reliable Source Helena Andrewslenny_bernsteinPainful mosquito-borne virus has arrived in the U.S.To Your Health Lenny Bernsteincaitlin_deweyWhat was fake on the Internet this week: detached retinas, doodled passports, and a murder caught on Google StreetviewThe Intersect Caitlin DeweyEntertainmentIn EntertainmentBooksComics Going Out GuideHoroscopes MoviesMuseums Music Puzzles & Games Theater & DanceTV Blogs & Columnsmichael_cavnaANIMATION OF THE DAY: Line for line, PBS’s Philip Seymour Hoffman short is a poignant gemComic Riffs Michael CavnaThe week’s best concerts: Kishi Bashi, Morrissey, Seun KutiGoing Out GuideJobsIn JobsMoreClassifiedsCarsDealsReal EstateRentalsPhotosBlogsDiscussionsFind&SaveObituariesArchivesTopicsWP Wine ClubWP BrandConnectPublic Relations
KrauthammerBowe BergdahlMinimum wageSnowden
PHOTOS | D-Day at 70 The best veggies to eat PHOTOS | Over-the-top homes On Pride Day, a principal comes out