MAYJUNJUL
06
201320142015
2 captures
06 Jun 2014 - 06 Jun 2014
About this capture
OPINIONS
Trending Topics
David Ignatius
Opinion Writer
Edward Snowden took less than previously thought, says James Clapper
By David Ignatius, E-mail the writer
As the intelligence community continues its assessment of the damage caused by Edward Snowden’s leaks of secret programs, Director of National Intelligence James Clapper says it appears the impact may be less than once feared because “it doesn’t look like he [Snowden] took as much” as first thought.
“We’re still investigating, but we think that a lot of what he looked at, he couldn’t pull down,” Clapper said in a rare interview at his headquarters Tuesday. “Some things we thought he got he apparently didn’t.” Although somewhat less than expected, the damage is still “profound,” he said.
David Ignatius
Ignatius writes a twice-a-week foreign affairs column and contributes to the PostPartisan blog.
Archive
@IgnatiusPost
Facebook
RSS
Gallery
Edward Snowden: Traitor or public servant?: A roundup of politicians and opinion-makers and their take on the controversial whistleblower.
You may also like...
Anne Applebaum
Europe’s clash of values
Fareed Zakaria
The U.S. shouldn’t be simplistic
This assessment contrasts with the initial view in which officials, unsure of what Snowden had taken, assumed the worst — including the possibility that he had compromised the communications networks that make up the military’s command and control system. Officials now think that dire forecast may have been too extreme.
It’s impossible to assess independently the accuracy of what Clapper said, either about the damage Snowden allegedly caused or its mitigation. That’s one reason why a legal resolution of the case would be so valuable: It would establish the facts.
In the damage evaluation, the intelligence community has established three tiers of material: The first tier is the 300 or so documents that a senior intelligence official said news organizations in the United States or overseas have already published, often with redactions. The second is an additional 200,000 documents the United States believes Snowden or his associates gave to the media.
It’s a third tier of documents, which Snowden is assumed to have taken but whose current status isn’t known, for which officials have lowered the threat assessment. This batch of probably downloaded material is about 1.5 million documents, the senior official said. That’s below an earlier estimate of 1.77 million documents.
In the months immediately after June 2013, when Snowden began to reveal his cache of National Security Agency documents, U.S. officials said they couldn’t be sure what he had seen and downloaded. Now, by piecing together a replication of top-secret files at the time, they have a better idea of what Snowden may have taken.
In Snowden’s recent interview with NBC News’s Brian Williams, the former NSA contractor seemed eager to explore a deal that would allow him to return to the United States and face legal proceedings with some sort of negotiated plea agreement.
A senior intelligence official cautioned that any discussion of plea negotiations would be overseen by the Justice Department. He said the comment by NSA Deputy Director Rick Ledgett that there was “room for discussions” with Snowden reflected Ledgett’s personal views only.
“Plea negotiations are difficult if you start by saying you’re a hero and wanting a parade,” the senior official said, dismissing Snowden’s characterization of his actions during the NBC interview as patriotic and constitutional. The intelligence community sharply disagrees with that self-assessment.
But the door still appears to be open for Snowden to negotiate some process under which he would return to the United States from Russia and face charges. “If he came back and told everything he knows, then perhaps some accommodation could be reached,” the senior official said.
The official said that in the event there were plea discussions, there could be a wide range of potential outcomes depending on Snowden’s inclination to cooperate and share information.
Pressed to explain what damage Snowden’s revelations had done, the official was guarded, saying that there was “damage in foreign relations” and that the leaks had “poisoned [NSA’s] relations with commercial providers.” He also said that terrorist groups had carefully studied the disclosures, turning more to anonymizers, encryption and use of couriers to shield communications.
The senior official wouldn’t respond to repeated questions about whether the intelligence community has noted any changes in behavior by either the Russian or Chinese governments, in possible response to information they may have gleaned from Snowden’s revelations.
The official said the director of national intelligence is developing new procedures to make a future breach of secrecy less likely, including “continuous evaluation” of those with high security clearances that would monitor their use of social media and other online activity. But he said he worried that such a regime might be “oppressive” and that employees might decide it was “too hard to work with.”
Clapper’s interview illustrates one unlikely benefit of the Snowden affair, which is that officials have decided to be more transparent in discussing intelligence issues. That, at least, is a step forward.
Read more from David Ignatius’s archive, follow him on Twitter or subscribe to his updates on Facebook.
Read more:
Richard Cohen: Make a deal with Edward Snowden
Erik Wemple: What Michael Kinsley gets wrong about Glenn Greenwald
Peter Swire: Why technology companies and the NSA are split on Snowden
Charles Lane: The truth about government secrets
Reprints
Top Opinions Stories
Most Popular Videos
The Post Most: Opinions
The top-read stories of the past four hours
1
Free him, then try him
3
Going for his legacy
5
The perils of leaning forward
Connect with PostOpinions
Facebook: Become a fan of Washington Post Opinions
Voice Your Opinions
Contact the reader representative
Have questions about Post content or practices?
Send a letter to the editor
Write a response to a piece in The Post.
Submit an op-ed
Make an argument about a topic in the news.
TODAY’S OPINIONS POLL
Is President Obama stripping American values out of his foreign policy?
Yes
No
Submit
Next
Review your answers and share
Sign in to have your score recorded »
Join a Discussion
Earlier Today
SUBSCRIBE
PostTV
Politics
Opinions
Local
Sports
National
World
Business
Tech
Lifestyle
Entertainment
Jobs
More ways to get us
Newsletter & Alerts
Washington Post Live
Reprints & Permissions
Post Store
Photo Store
e-Replica
Twitter
Contact Us
Help & Contact Info
Reader Representative
Digital Advertising
Newspaper Advertising
News Service & Syndicate
About Us
In the community
Careers
PostPoints
Newspaper in Education
Digital Publishing Guidelines
Partners
washingtonpost.com
© 1996- The Washington Post
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Submissions and Discussion Policy
RSS Terms of Service
Ad Choices
Real EstateRentalsCarsToday's PaperGoing Out GuideFind&Save
HomePostTVIn PostTVPoliticsIn PoliticsCourts & LawThe Fed Page Health CarePollingWhite HouseGovBeatMd. PoliticsVa. PoliticsD.C. PoliticsBlogs & Columnssean_sullivanKoch brothers donate $25 million to United Negro College FundPost Politics Sean Sullivanaaron_blakeGay marriage opponents don’t have much fight in themThe Fix Aaron Blakesarah_krepsDo Americans really love drone strikes?The Monkey Cage Sarah Krepsniraj_chokshiColorado passes nation’s first law regulating uberX, LyftGovBeat Niraj Chokshijosh_hicksActing VA secretary promises to ‘make dust’ to fix problemsThe Federal Eye Josh HicksOpinionsIn OpinionsToles Cartoons Telnaes Animations The Post's ViewLetters to the EditorLocal Opinions Columnist Index Featured Blogsradley_balkoColorado’s poster boy for ‘stoned driving’ was drunk off his gourdThe Watchalexandra_petriAshamed of reading YA?ComPost Alexandra Petriradley_balkoMorning Links: NYPD conducts mass sweep of public housingThe Watch Radley Balkojennifer_rubinRick Perry’s comeback?Right Turn Jennifer Rubingreg_sargentMorning Plum: A gay rights milestoneThe Plum Line Greg SargentLocalIn LocalD.C. Maryland Virginia Crime Education Obituaries Transportation Weather Blogs & Columns Blogs & Columnsjason_samenowAtlanta’s amazing red sky double rainbow (PHOTOS)Capital Weather Gang Jason SamenowThe week’s best concerts: Kishi Bashi, Morrissey, Seun KutiGoing Out Guidejulie_zauzmerSewer leak closes lanes in ArlingtonDr. Gridlock Julie ZauzmerSportsIn SportsRedskins/NFLCapitals/NHLWizards/NBANationals/MLBWorld Cup 2014CollegesAllMetSportsBlogs & ColumnsOther SportsBlogs & Columnsalex_prewittCapitals out of Baltimore Hockey ClassicCapitals Insider Alex Prewittdan_steinbergThe Sports section, the day after D-DayDC Sports Bog Dan Steinbergmike_jonesGruden: Williams will help RGIII continue to matureThe Insider Mike Jonesjames_wagnerThe Nationals face a tough 10-day roadtripNationals Journal James WagnerNationalIn NationalEnergy & EnvironmentHealth & Science Education National Security InvestigationsInnovations Know More Religion On Giving CorrectionsBlogs & Columnsnia_malika_hendersonIowa Senate candidate likens his female opponent to a chickShe The People Nia-Malika Hendersonjonathan_h_adlerBADCC (Beware of acronyms in the D.C. Circuit)Volokh Conspiracy Jonathan H. Adlermark_bermanIt’s National Doughnut DayPost Nation Mark Bermanjoel_achenbachAnother day, another dyspeptic human spaceflight reviewAchenblog Joel Achenbachdan_lamotheRemembering the military secrecy and lies that made D-Day successfulCheckpoint Dan LamotheWorldIn WorldAfrica The AmericasAsia & Pacific Europe Middle East National Security Columns & BlogsBlogs & Columnsadam_taylorBritain hopes Lego will thwart Scotland’s independence bidWorldViewsabby_phillipFull Transcript: President Obama’s remarks at the 70th anniversary of D-DayWorldViews Abby Phillipishaan_tharoor20 World Cup goals that changed historyWorldViews Ishaan Tharoordan_lamotheRemembering the military secrecy and lies that made D-Day successfulCheckpoint Dan LamotheBusinessIn Business Economy IndustriesMarketsPolicy & RegulationKnow More World BusinessCapital BusinessOn Leadership On Small Business On I.T. Blogs & Columnsmichelle_singletaryOne final CliffsNotes for recent grads — on paying off debtThe Color of Money Michelle Singletarychristopher_ingrahamSchwarzenegger says he’s ‘pumped up’ for nationwide redistricting reformWonkblog Christopher Ingrahamjena_mcgregorWhat GM could do to change its cultureOn Leadership Jena McGregorjonathan_oconnellGeorgetown plots big Tenleytown expansion Digger Jonathan O'ConnellTechIn TechnologyInnovation The Switch Blogs & Columnsbrian_fung_andrea_peterson_and_hayley_tsukayamaSwitchback: Talking Techhayley_tsukayamaWe’re doing what Verizon and Netflix need to do: ChatThe Switch Hayley Tsukayamabrian_fung‘A soup of misery’: Over half say they’d abandon their cable firm, if only they couldThe Switch Brian Funghayley_tsukayamaThe Switchboard: Vodafone tips massive state surveillance program in new reportThe Switch Hayley TsukayamaLifestyleIn LifestyleAdvice Carolyn Hax Food Express Home & Garden Style Travel Weddings Wellness Magazine KidsPost On Parenting Blogs & Columnssteven_petrowCivilities Chat: ‘Why do so many lesbians wear men’s clothes?’The Style Blog Steven Petrowhelena_andrewsActress Tea Leoni chokes up while recounting scenes from a refugee campThe Reliable Source Helena Andrewslenny_bernsteinPainful mosquito-borne virus has arrived in the U.S.To Your Health Lenny Bernsteincaitlin_deweyWhat was fake on the Internet this week: detached retinas, doodled passports, and a murder caught on Google StreetviewThe Intersect Caitlin DeweyEntertainmentIn EntertainmentBooksComics Going Out GuideHoroscopes MoviesMuseums Music Puzzles & Games Theater & DanceTV Blogs & Columnsmichael_cavnaANIMATION OF THE DAY: Line for line, PBS’s Philip Seymour Hoffman short is a poignant gemComic Riffs Michael CavnaThe week’s best concerts: Kishi Bashi, Morrissey, Seun KutiGoing Out GuideJobsIn JobsMoreClassifiedsCarsDealsReal EstateRentalsPhotosBlogsDiscussionsFind&SaveObituariesArchivesTopicsWP Wine ClubWP BrandConnectPublic Relations
KrauthammerBowe BergdahlMinimum wageSnowden
PHOTOS | D-Day at 70 The best veggies to eat PHOTOS | Over-the-top homes On Pride Day, a principal comes out