206 captures
12 Mar 2014 - 13 Apr 2021
About this capture
Subscription Center
Subscribe to All Access »
Subscribe to Print »
Give a Gift »
View the Latest Issue »
Energy & Sustainability » Climatewire
Climate Change and Rising Food Prices Heightened Arab Spring
The effects of climate change on the food supply exacerbated the underlying tensions that have led to ongoing Middle East instability
March 4, 2013 |By Ines Perez and ClimateWire

Flickr/Nasser Nouri
If the Arab Spring taught us something, it is that the effects of climate change can serve as stressors, contributing to regional instability and conflict, experts said.
In a report published last week, researchers from the Center for American Progress, the Center for Climate and Security and the Stimson Center examined the role of climate change in the Middle East's upheaval during 2010 and 2011. Looking at long-term trends in rain, crops, food prices and migration, they were able to determine how these factors contributed to social instability in the region.
"The Arab Spring would likely have come one way or another, but the context in which it did is not inconsequential. Global warming may not have caused the Arab Spring, but it may have made it come earlier," the report says.
The Middle East and North Africa region is extremely vulnerable to fluctuations in food supplies and prices. According to the report, with little arable land and scarce water supplies, the region is one of the top food importers in the world.
In 2010, droughts in Russia, Ukraine, China and Argentina and torrential storms in Canada, Australia and Brazil -- all major wheat and grain producers -- considerably diminished global crops, driving commodity prices up. The region was already dealing with internal sociopolitical, economic and climatic tensions, and the 2010 global food crisis helped drive it over the edge.
But the issue here is much bigger. Because of globalization, regional climate events can have a global extent, the report says. What's more, scenarios where weather events unfold economic and political shifts are likely to be repeated as climate volatility, expanding populations and competition for resources disturb national stability, the report says.
National collapse becomes a security threat
According to Michael Werz, senior fellow at the Center for American Progress and one of the authors of the report, the argument here is that there are a number of symptoms -- such as food scarcity, water rationing, crops failure, migration and rapid urbanization -- squeezing the margins of what a society can deal with before exploding.
"This is pushing many societies, especially those with a weak state, to their limits," Werz said.
At the launch of the Arab Spring and climate change report, Werz and other foreign affairs experts discussed the challenges of climate change in global stability -- particularly in terms of food and water security and migration -- and how the United States needs to rethink its foreign policy to incorporate these borderless challenges.
"We've gone from a connected world to an interconnected world, and from an interconnected world to an interdependent world," said New York Times foreign affairs columnist Tom Friedman. "When the world is this interdependent, your rivals failing is much more dangerous than your rivals rising," he said.
According to Friedman, U.S. foreign policy is so caught up in the Cold War model -- of strategic competition between superpowers -- that it's missing the real security issue of the current world.
"We are not worried that Egypt is going to become an ally of the Soviet Union; we are worried that Egypt is going to collapse, which in an interdependent world is a threat," Friedman said.
In a 2011 article in The Atlantic, former Department of State Director of Policy Planning Anne-Marie Slaughter explained how the international environment had changed in the last century.
"The Cold War world was like chess. The 21st century world is more like tennis, where the wind, heat, possible rain delay and your opponent's relative health and form on any given day all affect the speed, trajectory and spin on the ball coming at you," she wrote.
Food shortage, drought, migration and human security are issues in a society that can later unfold to big issues between states, Slaughter said at the event. But unlike popular topics like Iran or Afghanistan, food security lacks two important qualities to be taken seriously in Washington, D.C., she added: "It's not immediate, and it's not sexy."
Security linkages often are often overlooked
Creating long-term, sustainable and stable countries in the world is much more beneficial for U.S. and global security than anything else, Werz said.
A new study by British think tank E3G warns that the spread in democracy that followed the Arab Spring could be reversed due to failure to address the threat of food and energy price shocks. According to the report, climate models consistently estimate that warming will occur faster in the Middle East-North Africa region, accentuating the growing scarcity of water. Yet existing government investment is more focused on providing incentives for continued democratic reforms than addressing other vital areas for stability.
"There's definitely been a shift," said Taylor Dimsdale, senior research associate with E3G, about the understanding of linkages between social strife, food prices and climate change. "We're sort of recognizing that there's a lack of a full appreciation and full recognition for that need."
Moreover, as climate change drives extreme weather events in producer countries, food price increases could become another ticking bomb in the region. "We see it as an ongoing risk," Dimsdale said.
Because of globalization and interdependence, the relationship between climate change, migration and security should become the "new normal" in international policy conversations, the panel said. "In climate sciences, the axiom I live by is 'We have to manage what's unavoidable and avoid what's unmanageable,'" Friedman noted.
In that sense, according to Friedman, it all comes down to building resilience. One way to do this would be to stimulate market-based solutions through regulations and prices to drive clean energy, clean water and clean power in America or anywhere else in the world, he said.
"We need to come up with long-term, sustainable solutions that current foreign policy doesn't allow us to even think about," Slaughter said.
But first, she said, the United States needs to rethink the way it engages with the world. "The normal way the State Department is organized is by region, and then by issue area," Slaughter said. But with this format, it's hard to figure out how things are interconnected and even harder to address things bottom-up, she added.
Reporter Tiffany Stecker contributed. Reprinted from Climatewire with permission from Environment & Energy Publishing, LLC. www.eenews.net, 202-628-6500
Share this Article:

You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.
More from Scientific American
Latest NewsMost Read
Lemur Latrine Trees Serve As Community Bulletin Boards
Track Cosmic Rays With Smartphone App
Dust Bowl Conditions Not Rivaled in 1000 Years
U.S. Tornadoes Form in Swarms
Did Jesus Save the Klingons?
Follow Us:
See what we're tweeting about
Scientific American Contributors
sciam Astronomer David Weintraub says #extraterrestrial contact may have profound effect on our religious sensibilities http://t.co/JulRBJrWeQ
1 hour ago · reply · retweet · favorite
KHCourage RT @joshdneufeld: With minor reservations, my days of offering free peer reviewing services for profit-driven journals are over.
4 hours ago · reply · retweet · favorite
sciam Mars Losing Parts of Itself http://t.co/h1asIVAJkc #MAVEN #mars​http://t.co/WMvWDdojcv
4 hours ago · reply · retweet · favorite
More »
Solve Innovation Challenges
NIH Single Cell Analysis Challenge: Follow That Cell
Deadline: Dec 15 2014
Reward: $100,000 USD
Many biological experiments are performed under the assumption that all cells of a particular “type” are identical. However, recent data
Pseudoephedrine #3:  Outsmarting Methamphetamine Producers
Deadline: Nov 20 2014
Reward: $100,000 USD
The Seeker desires a method for formulating pseudoephedrine products in such a way that it will be extremely difficult for clandestine c
More Challenges »
Powered By:
Latest from SA Blog Network
Terror skinks, social skinks, crocodile skinks, monkey-tailed skinks… it's about skinks (skinks part II)
Tetrapod Zoology|8 hours ago
The Return to Nepal: In Search of Soot
Expeditions|11 hours ago
#NABJ14 #HealthyNABY Recap: Cultivating Diversity in Science Communication
The Urban Scientist|12 hours ago
The Strange Medical Case of the Radioactive Landslide
History of Geology|14 hours ago
Of course a soda tax will work. Why else would the industry fight it so hard? (VIDEO)
Food Matters|17 hours ago
News From Our Partners

China to Punish Carmakers Who Fail to Meet Fuel Targets

Dust Bowl Conditions Not Rivaled in 1000 Years

Red Planet Spacecraft Prepare for Rare Comet Encounter

Natural Gas Offers Little Benefit in Fight against Global Warming
Science Jobs of the Week
PhD Position in Bioinformatic Analysis of Astrocyte Function
VIB Center for the Biology of Disease, K.U.Leuven
Postdoctoral Fellow Position - Human Decision Making in Risky, Dynamic and Complex Environments
ETH Zurich
Postdoctoral Fellow Position - Choice Architecture to Promote Resilience in Consumption Decisions
ETH Zurich
More jobs from Naturejobs.com »
YES! Send me a free issue of Scientific American with no obligation to continue the subscription. If I like it, I will be billed for the one-year subscription.
Subscribe Now
Scientific American is a trademark of Scientific American, Inc., used with permission

© 2014 Scientific American, a Division of Nature America, Inc.

All Rights Reserved.

SubscribeNews & FeaturesLatest StoriesAsk the ExpertsFact or FictionExtreme TechFeaturesForumIn-Depth ReportsInteractive FeaturesMind MattersNewsScience ImagesSlide showsTopicsEnergy & SustainabilityEvolutionHealthMind & BrainSpaceTechnologyMore ScienceBiologyChemistryPhysicsAll topicsBlogsStaff BlogsMIND Blog NetworkFrom Our NetworkVideos & PodcastsVideoSA's The Countdown60-Second Science Podcast60-Second Earth Podcast60-Second Health Podcast60-Second Mind Podcast60-Second Space Podcast60-Second Tech PodcastScience Talk PodcastEducationScience in Action AwardBring Science HomeCitizen ScienceDigital Education ReportProfessional Learning1,000 Scientists in 1,000 DaysSearch for Scientists/EducatorsScientist Sign UpEducator Sign UpParticipant DashboardEducation ResourcesCitizen ScienceWhale-Song ProjectSolve Innovation ChallengesSA Magazinecover imageSubscribeGive as a GiftBuy Single IssuesInside the Latest IssueFeaturesAdvances50, 100 & 150 Years AgoAnti GravityForumGraphic ScienceThe Science AgendaThe Science of HealthSkepticTechnoFilesRecommendedArchiveSpecial Editions Classics Briefings Mobile SA Mindcover imageSubscribeGive as a GiftBuy Single IssuesSA Mind Home PageSA Mind Blog NetworkInside the Latest IssueFeaturesHead LinesAsk the BrainsConsciousness ReduxFacts and Fictions in Mental HealthIllusionsMind in PicturesPerspectivesWe're Only HumanReviews and RecommendationsArchiveSpecial EditionsBooksSA/FSG BooksScientific American eBooks