By using this site, you agree we can set and use cookies. OK For more details of these cookies and how to disable them, see our cookie policy.x

OCTDECJAN
08
201420152016
130 captures
12 Mar 2015 - 01 May 2021
About this capture
Our website Main catalogue
Magna Carta
Britain's unwritten constitution
Article by: 
Robert Blackburn
Theme: 
Magna Carta today
Unlike most modern states, Britain does not have a codified constitution but an unwritten one formed of Acts of Parliament, court judgments and conventions. Professor Robert Blackburn explains this system, including Magna Carta’s place within it, and asks whether the UK should now have a written constitution.
For most people, especially abroad, the United Kingdom does not have a constitution at all in the sense most commonly used around the world — a document of fundamental importance setting out the structure of government and its relationship with its citizens. All modern states, saving only the UK, New Zealand and Israel, have adopted a documentary constitution of this kind, the first and most complete model being that of the United States of America in 1788. However, in Britain we certainly say that we have a constitution, but it is one that exists in an abstract sense, comprising a host of diverse laws, practices and conventions that have evolved over a long period of time. The key landmark is the Bill of Rights (1689), which established the supremacy of Parliament over the Crown following the forcible replacement of King James II (r.1685–88) by William III (r.1689–1702) and Mary (r.1689–94) in the Glorious Revolution (1688).
From a comparative perspective, we have what is known as an ‘unwritten constitution’, although some prefer to describe it as ‘uncodified’ on the basis that many of our laws of a constitutional nature are in fact written down in Acts of Parliament or law reports of court judgments. This aspect of the British constitution, its unwritten nature, is its most distinguishing characteristic.
The Bill of Rights
This declaration of 1689, known as the Bill of Rights, stated that it was illegal for the Crown to suspend or dispense with the law, and insisted on due process in criminal trials.
View images from this item  (3)
Copyright: © Parliamentary Archives, London HL/PO/JO/10/1/1430, membrs. 2–3
Features of Britain’s unwritten constitution
There are a number of associated characteristics of Britain’s unwritten constitution, a cardinal one being that in law Parliament is sovereign in the sense of being the supreme legislative body. Since there is no documentary constitution containing laws that are fundamental in status and superior to ordinary Acts of Parliament, the courts may only interpret parliamentary statutes. They may not overrule or declare them invalid for being contrary to the constitution and ‘unconstitutional’. So, too, there are no entrenched procedures (such as a special power of the House of Lords, or the requirement of a referendum) by which the unwritten constitution may be amended. The legislative process by which a constitutional law is repealed, amended or enacted, even one dealing with a matter of fundamental political importance, is similar in kind to any other Act of Parliament, however trivial its subject matter.
Another characteristic of the unwritten constitution is the special significance of political customs known as ‘conventions’, which oil the wheels of the relationship between the ancient institutions of state. These are unwritten rules of constitutional practice, vital to our politics, the workings of government, but not committed into law or any written form at all. The very existence of the office of Prime Minister, our head of government, is purely conventional. So is the rule upon which he or she is appointed, being whoever commands the confidence of the House of Commons (the majority party leader, or head of a coalition of parties).
The Monarchy is one of the three components of Parliament (shorthand for the Queen-in-Parliament) along with Commons and Lords. In legal theory, the Queen has absolute and judicially unchallengeable power to refuse her assent to a Bill passed by the two Houses of Parliament. However, convention dictates the precise opposite and in practice she automatically gives her assent to any government Bill that has been duly passed and agreed by Parliament. Another important convention is that government ministers must have a seat in Parliament (and, in the case of the Prime Minister and Chancellor of the Exchequer, specifically in the House of Commons) in order to hold office. This is a vital aspect of what is known as the ‘Westminster system of parliamentary government’, providing a direct form of executive responsibility and accountability to the legislature.
The written documents of our unwritten constitution
There is irony in the fact that the United Kingdom today does not have a written constitution, yet historically it has had a rich heritage of pioneering constitutional charters and documentation. First and foremost is Magna Carta (1215), the ‘Great Charter of the Liberties of England’. This established the principle that our rulers, at that time the king, could not do whatever they liked, but were subject to the law as agreed with the barons they governed. This simple concept laid the foundations for constitutional government and freedom under the law. Insofar as Magna Carta was ‘the first great public act of the nation’, it also established the direction of travel for our political system towards representative institutions and, much later, democracy itself.
Magna Carta 1215
One of the four surviving copies of the 1215 Magna Carta containing the famous clause ‘to no one will we sell, to no one deny or delay right or justice’.
View images from this item  (1)
Free from known copyright restrictions
In 1258, the Provisions of Oxford, sometimes referred to as the first ever written constitution, provided for a Council of twenty-four members through whom the King should govern, to be supervised by a Parliament. This was convened for the first time in 1264 by Simon de Montfort (d. 1265). During the constitutional conflicts of the 17th century, the Petition of Right (1628) relied on Magna Carta for its legal basis, setting out rights and liberties of the subject including freedom from arbitrary arrest and punishment. The Bill of Rights (1689) then settled the primacy of Parliament over the monarch’s prerogatives, providing for the regular meeting of Parliament, free elections to the Commons, free speech in parliamentary debates, and some basic human rights, most famously freedom from ‘cruel or unusual punishment’. This was shortly followed by the Act of Settlement (1701) which controlled succession to the Crown, and established the vital principle of judicial independence.
Image of the House of Commons, from True Platforme and Manner of the Sitting in the Lower House of Parliament
This is the earliest representation of the House of Commons. It is unlikely to be accurate in all its details, but it gives an impression of the tall, narrow and cramped chamber in which the House met.
View images from this item  (1)
Free from known copyright restrictions
The Petition of Right
The Commons asserted their interpretation of the law by presenting Charles with a ‘Petition of Right’, rather than a formal bill, implying that they were claiming the subject’s existing rights, rather than creating new ones.
View images from this item  (1)
Copyright: © Parliamentary Archives, London HL/PO/PU/1/1627/3c1n2
Over the past century there have been a number of Acts of Parliament on major constitutional subjects that, taken together, could be viewed as creating a tier of constitutional legislation, albeit patchy in their range and with no special status or priority in law. They include:
The Parliament Acts (1911–49) that regulate the respective powers of the two Houses of Parliament.
The Representation of the People Acts (1918) (as amended) providing for universal voting and other matters of political representation.
The European Communities Act (1972) making the UK a legal partner in the European Union.
The Scottish, Welsh and Northern Ireland devolution Acts of 1998 (as amended) creating an executive and legislature for each of those three nations in the UK.
The Human Rights Act (1998) establishing a bill of rights and freedoms actionable by individuals through the courts.
Recently, too, some conventions have been subject to an ad hoc codification, such as the principles of ministerial responsibilities in the Ministerial Code.
Human Rights Act 1998
The purpose of the Human Rights Act was to incorporate into UK law the rights and freedoms guaranteed under the European Convention on Human Rights (1953).
View images from this item  (1)
Open Government Licence
Should the UK have a written constitution?
The question then arises in this 800th anniversary year — should the UK now take steps to codify all its laws, rules and conventions governing the government of the country into one comprehensive document, ‘a new Magna Carta’? The case for a written UK constitution has been debated at our universities and by politicians of all parties for several decades and has been the subject of a House of Commons committee inquiry during the 2010–15 Parliament. If a written constitution for the future is to be prepared, it must be one that engages and involves everyone, especially young people, and not simply legal experts and parliamentarians. Some of the mystique and charm of our ancient constitution might be lost in the process, but a written constitution could bring government and the governed closer together, above all by making the rules by which our political democracy operates more accessible and intelligible to all.
Written by Robert Blackburn
Robert Blackburn (LLD, FRHistS) is Professor of Constitutional Law at King’s College London. He has published many books on political and constitutional affairs, among them The Electoral System in Britain (Macmillan, 1995), Fundamental Rights in Europe (OUP, 2001), Parliament (2nd ed., Sweet & Maxwell, 2002) and King and Country (Politico’s, 2006). He is a member of the Magna Carta 800th Anniversary Committee.
The text in this article is available under the Creative Commons License.
See also
MORE ARTICLES ON:
MAGNA CARTA TODAY
Magna Carta and human rights
Magna Carta and jury trial
Why Magna Carta still matters today
Magna Carta in the modern age
Human rights legislation
Related Collection Items
The Bill of Rights
Magna Carta 1215
Image of the House of Commons, from True Platforme and Manner of the Sitting in the Lower House of Parliament
The Petition of Right
Human Rights Act 1998
Related Teaching Resources
Should we remember Magna Carta?
Magna Carta, parliament and representation of the people
External links
The British Library is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites
Magna Carta: My Digital Rights
The Magna Carta Project
Share this page
Print this page
Please consider the environment before printing
British Library Newsletter
Subscribe to our free email newsletter for useful resources, latest news and events plus exclusive offers
Subscribe
Magna Carta
Themes
Articles
Collection items
Videos
People
Teaching resources
Supported by
Mobile site
Terms of use
About the British Library
Privacy
Cookies
Accessibility
Contact us

All text is © British Library Board and is available under a Creative Commons Attribution Licence, except where otherwise stated.
Skip to main content
Explore the British Library (56m items)BookbindingsBritish National BibliographyEnglish Short Title CatalogueIncunabula (early printing)Archives and manuscriptsIlluminated manuscriptsIndia Family HistoryPhotographically illustrated booksPhotographsSoundVictorian ephemeraFull list of cataloguesSubjectsMore about our collectionsDigitised British newspapersEndangered archivesFestival books (1475-1700)International Dunhuang ProjectManuscriptsSoundsThesesUK Web ArchiveManagement and business studiesSocial WelfareElectronic resourcesAmericas studiesAsian and African studiesEnglish and dramaInspired byMedieval manuscriptsSocial scienceSound and visionUntold livesFull list of blogsOnline Gallery overviewTurn the pages of our beautiful booksHighlights tourSacred textsTaking LibertiesGeoreferencer (maps)More online exhibitionsPersonal galleriesecardsCaxton’s ChaucerCodex SinaiticusGutenberg BibleMagna CartaShakespeare QuartosTurning the PagesDiscovering LiteratureLearning at the LibraryAccents and dialectsEnglish language/literatureHistoryThe VictoriansTimelinesWorld War One19th century books appUK SoundMapOur podcasts pageOur podcasts on iTunesVoices of ScienceOverviewOpening timesRegister for a Reader PassGuides to getting startedMy Reading Room requestsSt Pancras Reading RoomsBoston Spa Reading RoomBusiness & IP CentreConference CentreFood and drinkLearning programmeWiFiBrand licensingAudio transcriptionDocument supplyFine art printsImages Online (picture sales)Imaging servicesMetadata ServicesNewspaper Microfilm ServicesOnline ShopPermissionsPublishingBusiness & IPCollection careReference teamPublic Lending RightSt PancrasBoston SpaOpening timesWhat’s onExhibitionsEventsToursBox OfficeWorkshops for schoolsTeacher conferencesFamily activitiesOpening timesRegister for a Reader PassGuides to getting startedBusiness & IP CentreConference CentreFood and drinkWiFiOverviewQuick informationStrategy, policy, programmesAnnual reportGovernanceSupplying the LibraryFreedom of informationCorporate Social ResponsibilityContact usCareersWorking at the LibraryVacancies and how to applyFundraisingAdopt a BookSign up for our e-newslettersFull list of blogsFind us on FacebookFollow us on TwitterWatch our YouTube channelJoin us on Google+Find us on PinterestPress and policyPress releasesChinese - 中文Arabic - عربي French - FrançaisGerman - DeutschMoreAll researchersAuthorsEntrepreneursJournalistsLibrariansPeople in higher educationPublishers (legal deposit)ScientistsSocial ScientistsTeachers
Home Themes Articles Collection items Videos People Teaching resources