2017 Patrick Henry College ((Thomas Siu & Meridian Paulton)
Runner-up: United States Air Force Academy (Kevin Kim & Colleen Slein)
2016 Patrick Henry College (Caleb Engle & Chris Baldacci)
Runner-up: Patrick Henry College (Ashlyn Olson & Jacob Van Ness)
2015 Morehouse College (Emanuel Waddell & Rodje Malcome)
Runner-up: Patrick Henry College (Claire Rossell & Ben Williamson)
2014 Patrick Henry College (Kayla Griesemer & Blake Meadows)
Runner-up: California State University, Long Beach (Ashely Hall and Kyle Maury)
2013 Patrick Henry College (Andrew Ferguson & Katie Tipton)
Runner-up: The College of Wooster (Alexi Ehrlich and Amanda Collins)
2012 Patrick Henry College (Andrew Ferguson & J.C. Cartee)
Runner-up: The College of New Jersey (Andrew Wallach and Olaniyi Solebo)
2011 Patrick Henry College (Alex Harris and Brett Harris)
Runner-up: The College of Wooster (Rachel Shonebarger and Willem Daniel)
2010 Patrick Henry College (Rachel Heflin and Jenna Lorence)
Runner-up: Baylor University (Erik Baumann and Ray Panneton)
2009 Patrick Henry College (Rachel Heflin and Aidan Grano)
Runner-up: Patrick Henry College (Brianna Edelblut and Joseph Alma)
2008 The College of Wooster (Katharine McCarthy and Drew Glassroth)
Runner-up: Patrick Henry College (Will Glaser and Rebecca Reis)
2007 Armstrong Atlantic State University (Adam Morrison and Brian Dotson)
Runner-up: The College of Wooster (James Owens and Michael McMaster)
2006 Patrick Henry College (Brian Wright and Rachel Williams)
Runner-up: Patrick Henry College (Zachary Gappa and Benjamin Mills)
2005 Patrick Henry College (Peter Kamakawiwoole and Sara Wilson)
Runner-up: College of the Holy Cross (Elizabeth Letak and Erin Robert)
2004 University of Texas at Arlington (Andrew Stublefield and Mark Melton)
Runner-up: College of the Holy Cross (Elizabeth Letak and Erin Robert)
2003 California State University - Long Beach (Thomas Hartnett and Ja'Nene Hall)
Runner-up: Patrick Henry College (Rayel Papke and Matthew du Mee)
2002 Howard Payne University (Rob Welker and Lorianna Anderson)
Runner-up: University of North Texas (Leiza Dolghih and Joshua Godbey)
2001 Hardin Simmons College (Marta DeLeon and Sarah Horn)
Runner-up: Fitchburg State College (Beckett Augat and Michael O'Connell)