The Battle of the Best Savings Accounts

  • June 11, 2018
  • Advertiser Disclosure
  • Many of the products that appear on this site are from companies from which MyFinance receives compensation.

    The results of our research, product assessments, and reviews are based on objective quantitative and qualitative analysis of the products attributes and reputation.

    Compensation impacts which products we review and write about as well as, how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear).

    While we try to feature as many of the available options on on our site as we can maintain, we recognize that our site does not feature every possible choice for a given product category.

There are a few banks that pay 10x the interest of most others, but how do they stack up against each other? Continue reading to find out which one of them truly earns the title of best savings account.

The Battle of the Best Savings Accounts

There are a few banks that pay 10x the interest of most others, but how do they stack up against each other? Continue reading to find out which one of them truly earns the title of best savings account.

  • June 11, 2018
  • 5 min read
  • Advertiser Disclosure
  • Many of the products that appear on this site are from companies from which MyFinance receives compensation.

    The results of our research, product assessments, and reviews are based on objective quantitative and qualitative analysis of the products attributes and reputation.

    Compensation impacts which products we review and write about as well as, how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear).

    While we try to feature as many of the available options on on our site as we can maintain, we recognize that our site does not feature every possible choice for a given product category.

 

It's a well-known fact that interest rates on savings accounts are incredibly low. In fact, the average savings account is hovering around 0.06%.1 That's such a far cry from pre-crisis times, it's shocking.

At rates that low one might ask, "Why even have a savings account? Why don't I just place my hard-earned money under the mattress?" We can't blame you. However, if you did that you'd be leaving money on the table (or under the mattress). There are much better options out there; savings account options that earn fifteen times the average rate of 0.06%.

We've scoured high and low to find the best accounts. In our search, we've come across a few that stand above the rest. You'd be in good shape if you had any of these accounts, but after some thorough analysis, one of them truly earns the title of best savings account. Here they are at a glance:

We were just as taken aback when we first saw these numbers. {{ vm.accountsByApy[0].apy | percentage:2 }} and {{ vm.accountsByApy[1].apy | percentage:2 }}? Why didn't I hear of these accounts before I put my money in [large, untrustworthy bank X]? You might be saying to yourself, "{{ vm.accountsByApy[0].display_name }} is clearly the winner because their APY is slightly higher.""{{ vm.accountsByApy[0].company.name }} and {{ vm.accountsByApy[1].company.name }} have the same interest rate, so what's the difference?"

However, you can't jump to a conclusion as there are other important factors to consider when opening a savings account. So we've broken them each down, piece by piece.

Monthly Minimums

{{ vm.lowMinDepositAccounts[0].display_name }} doesn't require any fees either, but does require a {{ vm.lowMinDepositAccounts[0].min_balance_open | currency:"$":0 }} in order to open an account. {{ vm.lowMinDepositAccounts[0].min_balance_open | currency:"$":0 }} is still incredibly low compared to other major banks, which can require an opening deposit upwards of $300 just to get started.

Winner: {{ vm.lowMinDepositAccounts[0].display_name }}

Just because all of these banks have some type of monthly fee doesn't mean there isn't a good choice. {{ vm.lowMinBalanceAccounts[0].display_name }} only requires {{ vm.lowMinBalanceAccounts[0].min_balance_fee | currency:"$":0 }} in order to avoid a {{ vm.lowMinBalanceAccounts[0].monthly_fee | currency:"$":0 }} fee. {{ vm.lowMinBalanceAccounts[0].min_balance_fee | currency:"$":0 }} is still incredibly low compared ot major banks such as Bank of America, which requires a $300 balance to avoid the $5 fee.

Winner: {{ vm.lowMinBalanceAccounts[0].display_name }}

This one's pretty simple. {{ vm.noFeeAccounts[0].display_name }} has no monthly fees regardless of balance. To give you a little comparison, Bank of America requires $300 in your account to avoid a monthly charge. So if you're looking for a great "No Fee" bank, {{ vm.noFeeAccounts[0].display_name }} is a perfect option.

Winner: {{ vm.noFeeAccounts[0].display_name }}

are both "No Fee" banks, meaning neither of them charge a monthly maintenance fee, nor do they require a minimum balance in the account; while {{ vm.lowMinBalanceAccounts[0].display_name }} requires {{ vm.lowMinBalanceAccounts[0].min_balance_fee | currency:"$":0 }} in order to avoid a {{ vm.lowMinBalanceAccounts[0].monthly_fee | currency:"$":0 }} fee. {{ vm.lowMinBalanceAccounts[0].min_balance_fee | currency:"$":0 }} is still incredibly low compared to major banks such as Bank of America, which requires a $300 balance to avoid the $5 fee. That said, you can't beat the $0 minimum offered by .

are both "No Fee" banks, meaning neither of them charge a monthly maintence fee, nor do they require a minimum balance in the account. In fact, they don't even require a deposit to open an account!

{{ vm.lowMinDepositAccounts[0].display_name }} doesn't have any fees either, but does require a {{ vm.lowMinDepositAccounts[0].min_balance_open | currency:"$":0 }} deposit in order to open an account. {{ vm.lowMinDepositAccounts[0].min_balance_open | currency:"$":0 }} is still incredibly low compared to other major banks, which can require an opening deposit upwards of $300 just to get started. That said, you just can't beat the $0 minimum offered by .

are both "No Fee" banks, meaning neither of them charge a monthly maintence fee, nor do they require a minimum balance in the account. In fact, they don't even require a deposit to open an account!

are both "No Fee" banks, meaning neither of them charge a monthly maintence fee, nor do they require a minimum balance in the account. In fact, they don't even require a deposit to open an account!

Tie:

are all "No Fee" banks, meaning they don't charge a monthly maintenance fee and they do not require a minimum balance. In fact, not one of these banks even require a minimum deposit to open an account!

Winner: {{ vm.noFeeAccounts.length }} way tie

Bank Reputation

This might not have been very important to us before the financial crisis, but times have changed. We need to feel safe with where we put our hard-earned money. Each of these banks are backed by the maximum allowable FDIC guarantee of $250,000. This means if the bank defaults, the US Government would repay you every penny you had in the account, up to $250,000. Bank of America, Chase, etc. all have this same insurance.

More than just the FDIC insurance, we need reliability and value from our bank. So here is how the top banks fare in terms of reputation:

 
 

Winner: {{ vm.bankReputations[0].display_name }}

Customer Service and Ease of Use

These companies all have good customer service according to online reviews. 3 star reviews don't sound great for a restaurant, but for an industry that's really suffering from an image problem, 3 star ratings are some of the best ratings received. Comparatively, Bank of America had 1.6 stars, HSBC had 1.4 stars and Chase came in at 2.5 stars.

So how did we figure this one out? Members of our team personally opened an account in each and compared notes over a two-week period.

All of the banks' websites are state of the art and incredibly intuitive; and each has an "American English" speaking support team that is very attentive and easy to deal with.

 

Winner: {{ vm.customerServiceWinner.display_name }}

Interest Rate

This one is not as obvious as you may think.

If you are looking for the best interest rate, and not considering anything else, BAC Florida is a better option. However, there is a slight asterisk.

Barclays is a pure savings account meaning you have easy access to cash. BAC Florida on the other hand is a certificate of deposit which means if you withdraw the cash before the 12 months are up, you could lose the money you gained in interest.

Winner: {{ vm.accountsByApy[0].display_name }}

This one's easy. At {{ vm.accountsByApy[0].apy | percentage:2 }}, {{ vm.accountsByApy[0].display_name }}'s interest rate is slightly higher. Even though {{ vm.accountsByApy[0].display_name }}'s rate is slightly higher, really either of these accounts are huge improvements over what Chase, Bank of America, or Wells Fargo would pay you.

Winner: {{ vm.accountsByApy[0].display_name }}

{{ vm.accountsByApy[0].display_name }} and {{ vm.accountsByApy[1].display_name }} are both offering a {{ vm.accountsByApy[0].apy | percentage:2 }} interest rate. For this reason, we had to give them the tie.

Tie: {{ vm.accountsByApy[0].display_name }} and {{ vm.accountsByApy[1].display_name }}

Conclusion

 

Winner: {{ vm.overallWinner.display_name }}

Our Recommendation

{{ vm.overallWinner.open_account }} Account

{{ vm.overallWinner.open_account }} Account

THIS IS AN ADVERTORIAL AND NOT AN ACTUAL NEWS ARTICLE, BLOG, OR CONSUMER PROTECTION UPDATE

Disclaimer: This page compares financial institutions offering competing products.  While our assessment of each company's offering is the product of our research, our overall conclusion and recommendation is determined by compensation paid to us by each participating financial institution.  

MyFinance strives to keep its information accurate and up to date. This information may be different than what you see when you visit a financial institution, service provider or specific product’s site. All financial products, shopping products and services are presented without warranty. Additionally, this site is compensated through third party advertisers. 

Many of the offers appearing on this site are from advertisers who compensate us to be listed on our site. Compensation may impact which products we review and write about and how and where they appear on this site including, for example, the order in which they appear. 

Supporting Details:

  1. https://www.fdic.gov/regulations/resources/rates
  2. MONEY® Magazine's annual "The Best Banks in America" (November 2014)
  3. Kiplinger's Personal Finance magazine
  4. http://www.bankrate.com/brm/rate/rankings.asp