Winter Olympics: Kamila Valieva misses out on podium as she finishes fourth

Kamila Valieva's controversial Winter Olympics ended in tears with a fourth-place finish in the women's event after the 15-year-old fell multiple times in the free skate.

Valieva, in the spotlight after a court ruled she could compete in Beijing after a failed drugs test, sobbed while awaiting the score.

She had led going into the free skate.

Those who witnessed the events questioned the wisdom of allowing her to skate in the first place - the Court of Arbitration for Sport had said it would do "irreparable harm" to not allow it.

Many of those who witnessed it would say it may have done that by allowing it.

"I am slightly speechless for all the wrong reasons," said an emotional BBC commentator and 1980 gold medallist Robin Cousins.

"Someone thought having her do that was better than having her go home to her family and to wait and sort this out, knowing she could have two more Olympics ahead of her.

"To see the talent and the unquestionable quality of Valieva... To see it put into this arena in that way should never have happened."

• 'She became the face of a problem bigger than her' - anger & sympathy as Valieva breaks down under world's gaze

From asterisks to agony

Valieva landed her opening quadruple jump but then faltered on the next triple, triggering a series of errors that had the crowd gasping in disbelief at what they were seeing.

As the mistakes mounted and the falls came, the crowd cheered her on and applauded the moves she did complete.

She threw her hands up at the end before leaving the ice in tears - for a second time this week, having also burst into tears after the short programme as the tension of recent days told.

As she left the ice Russian-flag waving supporters stood and chanted "well done" in Russian.

The Russian has set several world records since making her senior debut in October, including for a free skate score, but Thursday's free skate score of 141.93 fell well short and was only the fifth best of the day.

The medal-winning skaters will get their medals at an official ceremony, with the International Olympic Committee having previously said there would be no ceremony if Valieva came in the top three while the doping investigation was still ongoing.

The medals for the team event, where Valieva helped the Russian Olympic Committee to victory, will not be handed out until the case is concluded.

The talk before Thursday's skate was about the IOC's decision that there would be an asterisk against the women's result until the doping case was over, but thoughts of that quickly evaporated during a performance where the mistakes came with agonising frequency.

• ROC would disagree with any Valieva asterisk

Why was Valieva allowed to compete?

Valieva was allowed to compete in the women's event after the Court of Arbitration for Sport (Cas) ruled against re-imposing a provisional suspension on her.

She discovered on 8 February that she had tested positive for angina drug trimetazidine but then successfully appealed against a Russian Anti-Doping Agency decision to impose a provisional suspension.

That decision was upheld by Cas after appeals by the IOC and others, with the court's ruling pointing to "exceptional circumstances" regarding her age and the timing of the test result, which came during the Games and nearly six weeks after the sample was taken.

There were mixed reactions from her fellow competitors, with some unhappy they were knowingly skating against someone who had failed a drugs test and others sorry that a child was caught up in a doping scandal.

A different Russian teen wins gold

The attention around the Valieva situation meant that most skaters had face questions about what they thought about her participation and potential for gold rather than their own performances.

Instead it was two other Russian teenagers in the top two spots on the podium.

Gold medallist Shcherbakova, who is also the world champion, said she "will not say anything about this situation" around Valieva.

Instead the 17-year-old was trying to able to enjoy own success, saying: "It's hard to say what I'm feeling right now. I still don't comprehend what has happened, I'm overwhelmed by happiness but I also feel an emptiness inside."

Silver medallist Trusova, meanwhile, was upset that her free skate, which earned the top score of the night and featured attempts at five quadruple jumps, had not won her the gold.

"Everyone has a gold medal, everyone, but not me," said the 17-year-old, who was in tears before the flower ceremony. "I hate skating. I hate it. I hate this sport. I will never skate again. Never."