Brazil women suffer in silence as COVID-19 sparks domestic terror

Brazil women suffer in silence as COVID-19 sparks domestic terror

Advertisement

During the early months of Brazil's COVID-19 pandemic, Rio de Janeiro police detective Fernanda Fernandes (pictured below) was certain that cases of domestic abuse were rising, but there was little she could do about it as few women came forward to file a report.

. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares
Fernandes at the police headquarters.

"Women (were) unable to escape their abusers while stuck at home," said Fernandes, who runs the Specialized Delegation for Support of Women (DEAM) in Rio's sprawling Duque de Caxias suburb. The number of complaints has, however, risen as the outbreak has ebbed, and more women have left their homes to lodge complaints with police, she said.

Around the world, police and prosecutors, victim support teams and women's movements, as well as the United Nations, have reported rising domestic violence during coronavirus-related lockdowns. The pandemic in Brazil has left many couples jobless, adding to domestic tensions, Fernandes said.

The economy slumped 4.1% last year and Brazil's recovery is likely to remain tepid as the country grapples with a brutal fresh wave of infections.

. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares
Vanessa Lima, 34, who says she was hit and psychologically abused by her husband, waits to be examined by a police officer. Lima's husband has been charged and is awaiting trial. Lima's husband will be subpoenaed to present his defense, according to court documents. A lawyer from the public defender's office has not yet been assigned to the case. Reuters was unable to verify the details of the aggression described by Lima.

Brazil recorded 649 femicides during the first half of 2020, according to figures from the Brazilian Forum for Public Safety, up 2% from the same period in 2019. But other crimes against women such as assault and rape, which usually require victims to file a police report, fell during that period, the Forum noted.

"The decrease in the registration of some crimes in this period is more a reflection of the difficulties and obstacles women encountered during the pandemic to report abuse, than a sign of a reduction in cases," it said in its latest October report.

. Rio De Janeiro, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares
Antunes holds drawings sent to her by her former partner showing a woman who looks like her being killed by a man holding a cleaver, at her home.

Fabiana Antunes, a shopkeeper, said that she finally gathered the courage to go to police in May after the latest attack by her abusive former partner, an illustrator whom she met five years ago.

A year into their relationship, he began to drink more, forbade her from seeing friends, and became violent, she said. She left him two years later, but they were still living under the same roof at the onset of the pandemic, when his mood soured.

"The pandemic - the fact of being stuck at home - made everything worse," she said.

In May, he struck her in the stomach during a fight, Antunes said, and she contacted the police. A judge issued a restraining order against Antunes' ex-partner, who moved out, according to Fernandes and court documents.

Yet Antunes still worries. Her ex-partner drew sketches which she showed to Reuters - of a woman who looks like her murdered by a man wielding a cleaver.

Aldefran Melo da Silva, her ex-partner, said Antunes had previously been proud to feature in his artistic work. He confirmed the restraining order had been issued but denied wrongdoing.

"We had normal marital discussions, but without any physical or verbal aggression," he said. "I never hit her."

. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares
Fernandes at the police headquarters.

Fernandes - whose team in Duque de Caixas handled 4,121 cases of domestic violence in 2019, the most of any DEAM team in Rio state - has held Facebook Live sessions to brief the local community on the need to report signs of domestic abuse.

Part of the challenge, she said, is convincing some women abuse is unacceptable. Others fail to grasp the danger of their situation as they do not believe their partners are capable of killing them.

. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares
Fernandes looks at photos on her phone of Taylaine Alves.

Taylaine Alves, a 19-year-old mother of two, was severely burned in a 2019 attack and later died in hospital from her injuries. Alves' boyfriend was charged and is in prison awaiting trial. His lawyer from the public defender's office declined to comment.

. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares
Jorge Luis Sampaio, the father of Taylaine Alves, looks at his daughter's body with his son Victor Hugo during Alves's funeral.

"We mothers never forget," said Jozilene Pereira Alves. "Life goes on, but a piece of me is dead."

Brazil introduced tough penalties for domestic abuse in 2006 with the Maria Da Penha law – named after a woman left paraplegic after being shot by her husband in her sleep.

. Rio De Janeiro, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares
Police officers from the Specialized Delegation for Support of Women (DEAM) unit detain a man suspected of having assaulted a woman.

However, it was not until 2015 that Brazil officially recognized femicide as a crime – years after most other countries in the region, including Colombia, Chile, Argentina and Mexico.

Paulo Cesar da Conceicao, who runs a rehabilitation center for men involved in domestic violence, called CR Homem, said most abusers struggle to accept their responsibility, blaming their victims for provoking them.

. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares
Paulo Cesar da Conceicao leads a group session.

Conceicao said that, in group sessions, his team guide conversations to help men to see their own responsibility for domestic abuse.

"The men arrive in the group very closed and resistant, and we try to break that down," he said.

. Boituva, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares
Gasparin said she lost her hand and suffered 11 stab wounds when her former partner attacked her with a knife on a bus. "When I came back from surgery ... many people came to congratulate me. They said I was a warrior, because it was a big battle for me to survive."

Daniela Gasparin, 38, says she lives in fear of her former partner, who was jailed after attacking her with a knife on a bus in the city of Boituva, in Sao Paulo state. Her ex-boyfriend was arrested and convicted in the case.

"Even if he is in jail, I'm still scared he will get out and come after me," said Gasparin. "This is a love I cannot understand. How can a person love and also try to kill?"

1 / 16

Slideshow

Gasparin laughs with her grandson Pyetro at her son's house.
. Boituva, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Gasparin laughs with her grandson Pyetro at her son's house.

Gasparin attends an evangelical service.
. Boituva, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Gasparin attends an evangelical service.

Gasparin leaves her home to go to church.
. Boituva, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Gasparin leaves her home to go to church.

Police military officer Daniel Deglmann, who is suspected of assaulting his wife Monique Goncalves, is escorted by officers as they arrive at the Specialized Delegation for Support of Women (DEAM) police unit. Deglmann has been charged and is awaiting trial. He denies the accusations against him. Deglmann's lawyer, Marcos Espinola, said he couldn't provide more details about the case because it is sealed but said his client would be found innocent.
. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Police military officer Daniel Deglmann, who is suspected of assaulting his wife Monique Goncalves, is escorted by officers as they arrive at the Specialized Delegation for Support of Women (DEAM) police unit. Deglmann has been charged and is awaiting trial. He denies the accusations against him. Deglmann's lawyer, Marcos Espinola, said he couldn't provide more details about the case because it is sealed but said his client would be found innocent.

Debora Goncalves Linhares, the mother of Monique Goncalves, 23, is accompanied by officers as she arrives at her daughter's former home to collect her belongings. Police arrested Monique's husband after she said she was imprisoned, drugged and tortured by him over several weeks. "When I saw my daughter in that way ... injured, with punch marks all over her body and psychologically abused, I thought I was going to lose her," Linhares said. Deglmann has been charged and is awaiting trial. He denies the accusations against him. Deglmann's lawyer, Marcos Espinola, said he couldn't provide more details about the case because it is sealed but said his client would be found innocent.
. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Debora Goncalves Linhares, the mother of Monique Goncalves, 23, is accompanied by officers as she arrives at her daughter's former home to collect her belongings. Police arrested Monique's husband after she said she was imprisoned, drugged and tortured by him over several weeks. "When I saw my daughter in that way ... injured, with punch marks all over her body and psychologically abused, I thought I was going to lose her," Linhares said. Deglmann has been charged and is awaiting trial. He denies the accusations against him. Deglmann's lawyer, Marcos Espinola, said he couldn't provide more details about the case because it is sealed but said his client would be found innocent.

Debora Goncalves Linhares is accompanied by officers as she collects belongings at her daughter's former home.
. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Debora Goncalves Linhares is accompanied by officers as she collects belongings at her daughter's former home.

Debora Goncalves Linhares comforts a friend at the entrance of the Specialized Delegation for Support of Women (DEAM) unit. "I became an activist after my daughter was almost a victim of femicide," said Linhares. Health workers often call Linhares when a victim arrives at the hospital. "I am doing my best, when a female victim of domestic violence appears. I immediately go with her to support her with anything she needs and sometimes take her to DEAM."
. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Debora Goncalves Linhares comforts a friend at the entrance of the Specialized Delegation for Support of Women (DEAM) unit. "I became an activist after my daughter was almost a victim of femicide," said Linhares. Health workers often call Linhares when a victim arrives at the hospital. "I am doing my best, when a female victim of domestic violence appears. I immediately go with her to support her with anything she needs and sometimes take her to DEAM."

Vanessa Lima, 34, who says she was hit and psychologically abused by her husband, waits to be examined by a police officer. Lima's husband has been charged and is awaiting trial. Lima's husband will be subpoenaed to present his defense, according to court documents. A lawyer from the public defender's office has not yet been assigned to the case. Reuters was unable to verify the details of the aggression described by Lima.
. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Vanessa Lima, 34, who says she was hit and psychologically abused by her husband, waits to be examined by a police officer. Lima's husband has been charged and is awaiting trial. Lima's husband will be subpoenaed to present his defense, according to court documents. A lawyer from the public defender's office has not yet been assigned to the case. Reuters was unable to verify the details of the aggression described by Lima.

Relatives of Taylaine Alves mourn during her funeral.
. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Relatives of Taylaine Alves mourn during her funeral.

Thais Alves, the sister of Taylaine Alves, shows a photo of Taylaine on her mobile phone during Taylaine's funeral.
. Rio De Janeiro, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Thais Alves, the sister of Taylaine Alves, shows a photo of Taylaine on her mobile phone during Taylaine's funeral.

X-ray images of a woman who said she was punched in the face and body by her ex-boyfriend, are pictured at Hospital Municipal Dr. Moacyr Rodrigues do Carmo. Reuters was unable to verify the details of the case.
. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

X-ray images of a woman who said she was punched in the face and body by her ex-boyfriend, are pictured at Hospital Municipal Dr. Moacyr Rodrigues do Carmo. Reuters was unable to verify the details of the case.

Jozilene Pereira Alves talks to a police officer about her daughter Taylaine Alves at the police station unit Specialized Delegation for Support of Women (DEAM).
. Rio De Janeiro, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Jozilene Pereira Alves talks to a police officer about her daughter Taylaine Alves at the police station unit Specialized Delegation for Support of Women (DEAM).

Jose Dias, a police officer from the Specialized Delegation for Support of Women (DEAM) unit, speaks to a woman reporting a case of domestic violence.
. Rio De Janeiro, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Jose Dias, a police officer from the Specialized Delegation for Support of Women (DEAM) unit, speaks to a woman reporting a case of domestic violence.

Densso Simoes dos Santos, 24, shows his tattoo for a photograph, after attending a group session at CR Homem, a rehabilitation center for men involved in domestic violence.
. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Densso Simoes dos Santos, 24, shows his tattoo for a photograph, after attending a group session at CR Homem, a rehabilitation center for men involved in domestic violence.

A police officer from the Specialized Delegation for Support of Women (DEAM) unit, attends an incident where a man is suspected of having assaulted a woman.
. Duque De Caxias, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

A police officer from the Specialized Delegation for Support of Women (DEAM) unit, attends an incident where a man is suspected of having assaulted a woman.

Favelas are seen in Duque de Caxias.
. Rio De Janeiro, BRAZIL. Reuters/Pilar Olivares

Favelas are seen in Duque de Caxias.