Brazil's indigenous rights hinge on one tribe's legal battle
Jose Boiteux,Brazil
Amanda Perobelli
Updated 27 September
26 images
Pushed into a degraded corner of their ancestral lands, the Xokleng people of southern Brazil anxiously await a Supreme Court ruling that could restore territory they lost decades ago.
Sitting by a wood stove, Xokleng elders recall the days when plentiful fish and game fed their families, before the bulk of their fertile lands were sold by the state to tobacco farmers in the 1950s.
People sit around a bonfire in Xokleng Laklano indigenous land in Jose Boiteux.
Now the Xokleng pray that Brazilian courts will fulfill a dying shaman's prophecy that they would one day win their lands back.
On Wednesday, the top court in Brasilia will decide whether the Santa Catarina state government has applied an overly narrow interpretation of indigenous rights by only recognizing tribal lands occupied by native communities at the time Brazil's constitution was ratified in 1988.
Indigenous Xokleng people pray for victory of their cause at a Supreme Court, during an evangelical church service.
The case was sparked when the state government used that interpretation to evict a group of Xokleng from a nature reserve in their ancestral lands. The decision was appealed by Brazil's indigenous affairs agency Funai on behalf of the Xokleng.
It was "another attempt to eliminate us," said Brasilio Pripra, a 63-year old community leader. "Our people have lived here for thousands of years."
Community leader Brasilio Pripra touches the document issued by Santa Catarina state office about indigenous land.
The state's solicitor general, Alisson de Bom de Souza, who will represent Santa Catarina in court on Wednesday, said he was seeking a decision that respects indigenous rights without hurting other constitutional rights of Brazilians.
The Xokleng were cleared off their traditional hunting grounds over a century ago to make room for European settlers, mostly Germans fleeing economic and political turmoil.
João Paté poses for a photograph.
At one point, the state rewarded the killing of indigenous people and mercenaries collected the ears of dead natives, a painful history documented by anthropologists and passed between generations.
"Before they killed us with guns, now they kill us with the stroke of a pen," said João Paté, a former 'cacique' or chief.
Xokleng indigenous people sing in their own language around a bonfire during a reunion.
Determined to keep their traditions alive, the Xokleng gather around bonfires at night to tell stories in their own language and keep up their rituals of dance and prayer, sometimes painting the faces of their young ones.
They still share their food in communal meals but the beef they roast is bought off the reservation, as they lack enough land to hunt or to raise cattle.
Vanda Kamlem sits surrounded by her grandchildren at her house.
"We cannot plant food living in this hole. They want to get rid of us. They don't like us," said Vanda Kamlem, 87, surrounded by her six grandchildren. A former midwife, Vanda remembers the days when she gathered pine nuts from the abundant Araucaria pines, known as monkey-puzzle trees.
Now, the forests have been cut down and fish have become scarce as the rivers turned cloudy, she said.
A sawmill on land which the Xokleng indigenous people claim as their territory in Vitor Meireles.
"The settlers moved in slowly, taking over. They built two sawmills and devastated the place," said Paté, a bespectacled evangelical pastor who leads services in the community church. He says the word of God saved the Xokleng from alcoholism that became widespread in the 1950s.
The Xokleng number some 3,000 people today, crowding into their 14,156 hectares of hilly territory, where landslides threaten homes and most land is too steep for agriculture.
A car passes by a tobacco plantation in Vitor Meireles.
They claim a further 24,000 hectares (9,300 square miles) of rich tobacco country that they say belonged to them for centuries before settlers moved in.
If the decision on Wednesday finds in favor of the Xokleng, over 800 families of smallholdings face "chaos" and "no future" said Tarcisio Boeing, 65, who farms 50 hectares that has been in his family of German descent for over a century.
"This land was bought and we have titles to it," said Chico Jeremias, 61, who says his German grandfather arrived a century ago and left him 27 hectares that he farms with his four sons.
"If the court decides to extend the indigenous land, where will these family farmers go? ...This will become a lawless land," he said.
Loreni Ngavem Pripra, 44, sits with Xokleng indigenous women as they chat after lunch.
Across Brazil, the Supreme Court ruling will affect hundreds of indigenous land claims, many of which offer a bulwark against deforestation in the Amazon rainforest.
A defeat in court for the Xokleng could set a precedent for the dramatic rollback of native rights which far-right President Jair Bolsonaro advocates. He says too few indigenous people live on too much land in Brazil, blocking agricultural expansion.
Powerful farming interests would have firmer legal ground to challenge indigenous land claims and Congress would have the green light to write a restrictive definition of indigenous lands into federal law.
Lazaro Kamlem, cacique of Palmeira village, and his daughter Ludmila, 10.
If they lose their case, the younger Xokleng say they will continue the fight. "We are here and we will resist to the end. This struggle will not be over," said Lázaro Kamlem, 47.
He is a descendent of Shaman Kamlem, the Xokleng medicine man who said on his deathbed in 1925 that they would lose their land to "white men," but would one day gain it back.
(Photo editing Marika Kochiashvili; Writing by Anthony Boadle; Text editing by Rosalba O'Brien; Layout Aisha Zia)
1 / 15

The portrait of Shaman Kamlem, the Xokleng medicine man who said on his deathbed in 1925 that they would lose their land to "white men," but would one day gain it back, hangs on a wall at his descendant Lazaro Kamlem's house.
More from
Amanda Perobelli
Subscribe to the week’s best stories
September 11 attacks fuse photographer and survivor in trauma
Editor’s choice
U.S. election year shaped by pandemic and Trump's defiance
Elon Musk's satellites beam internet into Chilean boy's life
More Stories
Nigeria's hyena men put maligned animals centre stage
"We are scared the country will become a desert," Yemen's forests are next casualty of war
Tokyo 2020 Olympics: From the sidelines
Senegalese plant circular gardens in Green Wall defence against desert
Boki Diawe
Grim aftermath of Ethiopian battle offers rare clues of brutal war
Editor’s choice
Reuters photographer Danish Siddiqui captured the people behind the story
Shah Porir Dwip
Editor’s choice
The Tenacious Unicorn Ranch made a transgender haven. Then the violent threats began
Editor’s choice
Volunteer undertakers bear the dead from Indonesian homes as COVID deaths rise
Scholar by day, street-sweeper by night, one Black man navigates Rio's racial divide
Belford Roxo
In a scarred Hong Kong, “beautiful things are gone”
Hong Kong
Postcards from Tokyo: light and shadow ahead of pandemic Olympics
Editor’s choice
In China's new Xinjiang: patriotic tourism, police and propaganda
Back to Top
We have updated our Privacy Statement. Before you continue, please read our new
Privacy Statement and familiarize yourself with the terms.
Follow UsLike UsFind Us Editor's Choice Interactive Behind the News Cultural Atlas Forces of Industry Living Planet Moment of History Perspective Shifting Society Tales of the Unexpected StoriesPhotographers Latest In a French migrant camp, a man sells sandwiches to raise smugglers' fee Recommended Chinese boxer trounces stereotypes to become 'Queen of the Ring' Follow UsLike UsFind UsSubscribeiPad AppAboutFAQsContactRSSBack to reuters.com