Mining tin from the sea
Toboali, Indonesia
Photography by
Willy Kurniawan.

Reporting by
Fransiska Nangoy.
Updated 28 July
28 images
From the shores of Indonesia's Bangka island, miners like Hendra head out by boat every day to scores of crudely built wooden pontoons dotted off the coast that are equipped to dredge the seabed for lucrative deposits of tin ore.
Indonesia is the world's biggest exporter of tin used in everything from food packaging to electronics and now green technologies.
A miner checks the sand of tin ore while working on a pontoon.
But deposits in the mining hub of Bangka-Belitung have been heavily exploited on land, leaving parts of the islands off the southeast coast of Sumatra island resembling a lunar landscape with vast craters and highly acidic, turquoise lakes.
Miners are instead turning to the sea.
Hendra monitors the mining operation.
"On land, our income is diminishing. There are no more reserves," said Hendra, 51, who shifted to work in offshore tin mining about a year ago after a decade in the industry.
"In the ocean, there are far more reserves."
Miners install a suction pipe on a pontoon.
Often grouped together around undersea tin seams, the ramshackle encampments of pontoons emit plumes of black smoke from diesel generators that rumble so loudly workers use hand gestures to communicate
Hendra, who like many Indonesians uses one name, operates six pontoons, each manned by three to four workers, with pipes that can be over 20 metres (66 feet) long to suck up sand from the seabed.
The pumped mixture of water and sand is run across a bed of plastic mats that trap the glittery black sand containing tin ore.
Hendra and other miners head to their pontoons.
Hendra is among scores of artisanal miners who partner with PT Timah to exploit the state miner's concessions.
The miners are paid about 70,000 to 80,000 rupiah ($4.90 to $5.60) per kg of tin sand they pump up, and a pontoon typically produces about 50 kg a day, Hendra said.
Amirudin, 43, a field supervisor of state's tin mining company PT Timah, rests on a makeshift hammock, on a tin pontoon.
Timah has been ramping up production from the sea. Company data shows its proven tin reserve on land was 16,399 tonnes last year, compared with 265,913 tonnes offshore.
The huge expansion, coupled with reports of illegal miners targeting offshore deposits, has heightened tension with fishermen, who say their catches have collapsed due to steady encroachment on their fishing grounds since 2014.
Apriadi, his son Avanza, 12, and his friend, collect their catches as they return from fishing.
Fisherman Apriadi Anwar said in the past his family earned enough to pay for his two younger siblings to go to university, but in recent years, they have barely scraped by.
"Never mind going to university, these days it's difficult to even buy food," said Apriadi, 45, who lives in Batu Perahu village.
A fisherman pours water out of a boat on Sampur beach in Pangkal Pinang.
Apriadi says fishing nets can get tangled up in offshore mining equipment, while trawling the seabed to find seams of ore has polluted once-pristine waters. "Fish are becoming scarce because the coral where they spawn is now covered with mud from the mining," he added.
Indonesian environmental group Walhi has been campaigning to stop mining at sea, especially on Bangka's western coast, where the mangroves are relatively well-preserved.
Jessix shows an area of offshore tin mining on the island of Bangka.
"The mangrove is an ecological fortress for the coastal area," said Jessix Amundian, executive director with Walhi Bangka Belitung.
In a statement, Timah said it communicates with fishing communities to improve their catch, adding it had built artificial reefs to help restock the sea in line with regulations.
A lake known as Kulong Biru (blue lake) in Koba.
Authorities have cracked down on the tin industry from time to time, particularly illegal mining, and remaining land reserves are often hard to access or require heavy machinery to exploit.
Unlicensed miners work in a tin mining area in Toboali.
Still, rising tin prices are an incentive to overcome these obstacles.
Amri, an unlicensed miner in Bangka, said he had restarted his land operations after a 14-month hiatus when tin prices rose due to tighter global supplies.
(Photo editing Marika Kochiashvili; Text editing Ed Davis and Karishma Singh; Layout Julia Dalrymple)
1 / 17

An aerial view shows wooden pontoons.
More from
Willy Kurniawan
Subscribe to the week’s best stories
Temptation everywhere: Mexican children struggle with obesity
Mexico City
Editor’s choice
Tsunami, 10 years on
Khao Lak
Witnessing COVID chaos in India’s hospitals, graveyards and crematoriums
New Delhi
More Stories
Editor’s choice
The Great Green Wall: China's farmers push back the desert one tree at a time
Meet the U.S. students confronting racism, injustice and a pandemic
'For fallen souls' - A survivor says Myanmar fight must go on
Editor’s choice
Death in the Himalayas: Poverty, fear, stretched resources propel India’s COVID crisis
Editor’s choice
Getting up close with cicadas to find climate change clues
Editor’s choice
Generation Crisis: young Syrians come of age in a decade of conflict
Editor’s choice
From the streets of Tokyo, 22 residents weigh up the Olympic Games
I'd rather die than go back, Moroccan migrant boy tells Spanish soldier
Editor’s choice
Gaza girl survives Israeli strike that shattered her family and home
Gaza City
Editor’s choice
Japanese boxing nurse has Olympic dream crushed by COVID
Editor’s choice
On the edge of Moroccan desert, surfers give kids a taste of waves and freedom
Editor’s choice
27 hours: a life-and-death shift with a young doctor in COVID-hit India
New Delhi
Back to Top
We have updated our Privacy Statement. Before you continue, please read our new
Privacy Statement and familiarize yourself with the terms.
Follow UsLike UsFind Us Editor's Choice Interactive Behind the News Cultural Atlas Forces of Industry Living Planet Moment of History Perspective Shifting Society Tales of the Unexpected StoriesPhotographers Latest In Haiti, festive wakes and Voodoo undertakers help mourners say their last goodbyes Recommended A Syrian field hospital in Douma Follow UsLike UsFind UsSubscribeiPad AppAboutFAQsContactRSSBack to reuters.com