Why Turkey wants to handle security at Kabul airport
Ankara’s willingness to deploy a military mission to secure Kabul’s airport raises questions about the risks it is prepared to take, what allies Turkish forces could have on the ground and what the US administration is prepared to offer in return. 
DOMINIQUE FAGET/AFP via Getty Images
Metin Gurcan
@Metin4020
June 17, 2021
Turkey’s offer to secure Kabul’s airport after the US-led NATO force completes its withdrawal from Afghanistan later this year is largely seen as an attempt by Ankara to win favor with Washington, but such a mission is fraught with risks and uncertainties that might bear on Turkey’s friendly ties with Afghanistan and bring it odds with regional players.
President Recep Tayyip Erdogan discussed the issue with his US counterpart Joe Biden in their first face-to-face meeting as presidents at the NATO summit last week. There was little indication of progress on the main disputes that have poisoned Turkish-US ties in recent years, but Erdogan signaled a possible consensus on Afghanistan. “If they do not want us to leave Afghanistan, if they want a certain [Turkish] support there, then the diplomatic and financial backing of the United States will be of importance,” he said. “I told [Biden] about our idea to collaborate with Pakistan and Hungary. There is currently a consensus. There is no problem on this,” he added. 
NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg, meanwhile, said no decision was made on who would run Kabul's international airport after the withdrawal of allied troops, but stressed Turkey would play a key role there. 
Turkey’s current military presence in Afghanistan is limited to a battalion of about 500 soldiers involved in non-combat missions. The number of Turkish troops has exceeded 2,000 during Turkey’s leadership stints in international missions in the past two decades. Turkish troops have been involved in guarding and running the military section of the Kabul airport. Yet, Turkey has never had a combat force in Afghanistan. Turkish soldiers have never engaged in an armed confrontation and never fired a bullet in the country.
The Hamid Karzai International Airport in Kabul — Afghanistan’s primary airport that doubles as a military base — serves as a vital link to the outside world in the mountainous landlocked country where road travel remains far from safe. Control of the airport amounts to control of Afghanistan’s gateway to the world.
The Afghan civil aviation authority requested the handover of the airport’s air traffic control from NATO in April as the alliance began the withdrawal of its mission in line with Biden’s decision to pull out all American troops from Afghanistan by Sept. 11.
The security of the airport and air travel is seen as a prerequisite for the operation of foreign diplomatic missions in Afghanistan, the US State Department stressed last week. Most recently, security fears prompted Australia to shutter its embassy in May. The safe functioning of the airport is also crucial for the delivery of humanitarian aid by international charity groups.
Yet the Taliban has sniffed at Turkey’s offer to take charge of the airport after the departure of the NATO mission, saying that the Turkish troops should go, too. “Turkey was part of NATO forces in the past 20 years, so as such, they should withdraw from Afghanistan on the basis of the agreement we signed with the United States on Feb. 29, 2020,” Suhail Shaheen, the Taliban spokesman in Doha, told Reuters June 11. “Otherwise, Turkey is a great Islamic country. Afghanistan has had historical relations with it. We hope to have close and good relations with them as a new Islamic government is established in the country in future,” he added.
How things wind up will depend largely on talks between Ankara and Kabul and the Kabul government’s contacts with the Taliban.
A scholar of Afghan security based in Turkey who recently traveled to Afghanistan described vividly how the Taliban has regained strength since the 2001 US-led invasion and the subsequent overthrow of the Taliban government. “Currently, from the far north to the far east of the country, the Taliban controls the main transitional areas. They have been ruling rural areas like a shadow government,” he told Al-Monitor on condition of anonymity. “A couple of months ago, while traveling from the capital to Takhar province, I witnessed Taliban patrols and checkpoints that collect taxes from every crossing vehicle, mainly from trucks loaded with goods and commodities,” he added.
The question for Turkey is how it could assume responsibility for the security of the airport, embassies and critical facilities in Kabul without conducting military policing and patrolling, which are clearly combat tasks. 
Combat missions would run contrary to Ankara’s hitherto vision in Afghanistan, which has been based on the notion that Turkey, the sole Muslim-majority member of NATO, is in Afghanistan to support stability and help the Afghan people as part of the historically close relationship between the two nations, including ethnic bonds.
Turkey’s military involvement has been through a coalition force that never directly engaged the Taliban or other militant groups on the battlefield. Drawing on its century-old friendship and religious affinity with Afghanistan, Ankara has enjoyed enormous political and social leverage among Afghans, especially groups with Turkic roots such as the Uzbeks, and its soldiers have generally received a warm popular reception in the country. Of note, Turkey has traditionally also had close ties with Pakistan, where Taliban leaders receive training and support. 
Now, Ankara seems to be counting on its soft power in Afghanistan to use it as a bargaining chip for a thaw with Washington. However, Erdogan’s ambitious plan to keep Turkish troops in Afghanistan could turn into a nightmare in the long run unless it is handled with the utmost caution and deftness.
Two key aspects need to be analyzed here. The first is the regional actors involved in Afghanistan.
Pakistan stands out as a crucial player whose interests are crystal clear. It has a border conflict with Afghanistan and a Pashtun population larger than the one in Afghanistan. Wary of the Afghan Pashtuns’ decades-long aspirations for an independent Pashtunistan, Pakistan has kept tight control over its own Pashtuns inhabiting areas along the Afghan border. And with the added weight of Islamabad’s economic interests and water disputes with Kabul, it is hard to imagine Pakistan as a reliable ally for Turkey in Afghanistan. Islamabad has often manipulated US administrations throughout the American involvement in Afghanistan, making it even harder to imagine a smooth Turkey-Pakistan coalition on the ground. Though Turkey's military involvement in Afghanistan might be preferable to Pakistan over the United States', Islamabad would rather hold the strings of a puppet Taliban regime than deal with a third party. 
As for Iran, it currently has a militant faction active in Afghanistan and friendly ties with the Taliban — a far cry from the political support that Tehran gave to the toppling of the Taliban in 2001. 
China appears as the only regional actor that might favor an active Turkish role in Afghanistan in the hope of advancing its ambitious Belt and Road Initiative. But overall, regional actors would prefer to deal with a domestic actor — the Taliban — rather than Turkey. 
The second aspect is the international actors. As a NATO member, Turkey does seem to be the best possible alternative after the United States and NATO withdrawal from Afghanistan. Such a role — if approved by the UN Security Council and backed by the international community — could buy Turkey a whole new level of regional and international attention and political leverage. If not, it could devolve into political turmoil that would shatter Turkey's good image in Afghanistan. Russia, for instance, might be reluctant to back Turkey as it has recently built close ties with Taliban leaders and would not be happy with the presence of a NATO member.
Also, domestic factors in Afghanistan such as religious and tribal affiliations, ethnic rifts and geographical divides are often underestimated or overlooked by the international community. The Taliban hail predominantly from Pashtun groups that have been extremely hostile to other ethnicities in Afghanistan. Turkey might face a dilemma on whether to align with non-Pashtun and Turkic groups or the dominant Pashtun groups. This may sound like a minor issue, but it was one of the essential causes of the US failure in Afghanistan. 
So, Ankara needs to think twice and be aware that Afghanistan is not Syria, Libya or Nagorno-Karabakh and is not called a “graveyard of empires” without reason.
MORE FROM METIN GURCAN
Afghan refugee influx stokes tensions in Turkey 
Metin Gurcan | Turkey | Jul 23, 2021
Turkish mobster claims AKP supporters secretly armed after putsch
Metin Gurcan | Turkey | Jul 14, 2021
Turkey's mixed record against Islamic State
Metin Gurcan | Turkey | Jun 30, 2021
POPULAR ARTICLES
4,000-year-old city discovered in Iraq
Adnan Abu Zeed | Iraq | Jul 9, 2021
Saudi Arabia’s race for Gulf economic leadership takes to the sky
Sebastian Castelier | Gulf | Jul 13, 2021
Ancient fossilized fish found in Egypt that survived in hot waters
Alaa Omran | Culture | Jun 16, 2021
Will Turkey use Syrian mercenaries in Kabul?
Fehim Tastekin | Turkey | Jul 12, 2021
Has Israel’s army become too small?
Ben Caspit | Israel | Jul 13, 2021
RECOMMENDED ARTICLES
Will Erdogan’s Afghan gambit pay off in Washington?
Semih Idiz | Turkey | Jul 30, 2021
Secular Turks mock government’s appropriation of care-free lifestyles in Istanbul promo video
Andrew Wilks | Turkey | Jul 29, 2021
License holder of coup-linked app faces 15-year jail term in Turkey
Diego Cupolo | Turkey | Jul 28, 2021
Amid Afghan influx, Turkey’s refugee policy gets tested with fire
Nazlan Ertan | Turkey | Jul 28, 2021
RECENT PODCASTS
Nile Dam talks may be ‘in a lot of trouble,’ says Samuel Ramani
NSO officials comment on Pegasus spyware affair: We are self-regulated on right for privacy, transparency  
Ali Hashem on what to expect from Ebrahim Raisi and the rise of the Hezbollahis in Iran
Major General Noam Tibon: IDF needs more boots on the ground 
South Asia security expert Ayesha Siddiqa says Turkey is a natural fit for Afghanistan 
NEWSLETTERS
Subscribe
© 2021 Al-Monitor, LLC. All rights reserved.