News|Border Disputes
India, China army talks to defuse border tensions fail
Both nations will keep troops in forward areas for a second freezing winter as 17-month standoff continues.
An Indian fighter plane flies over a mountain range in the Ladakh region [File: Danish Siddiqui/Reuters]
11 Oct 2021
Talks between Indian and Chinese army commanders to disengage troops from key friction areas along their border have ended in a stalemate and failed to ease a 17-month standoff that has sometimes led to deadly clashes, the two sides say.
The continuing standoff means the two nations will keep troops in the forward areas of Ladakh for a second consecutive winter in dangerously freezing temperatures.
India’s defence ministry, in a statement on Monday, said it gave “constructive suggestions” but the Chinese side was “not agreeable” and “could not provide any forward-looking proposals.”
A statement from a Chinese military spokesperson said “the Indian side sticks to unreasonable and unrealistic demands, adding difficulties to the negotiations”.
The commanders from both armies met for the talks on Sunday, after a gap of two months, at Moldo on the Chinese side in the Ladakh area.
Both countries have stationed tens of thousands of soldiers backed by artillery, tanks and fighter jets along the de facto border called the Line of Actual Control (LAC).
Since February, both India and China have withdrawn troops from some faceoff sites on the northern and southern banks of Pangong Tso, a glacial lake at 14,000 ft (4,270 metres), Gogra and Galwan Valley, but they continue to maintain extra troops as part of a multi-tier deployment.
Troops have been added at Demchok and Depsang Plains, Indian media reports say.
Sunday’s talks came amid frustration expressed by the Indian army chief at what he called the massive deployment of troops and weaponry by the Chinese side.
“Yes, it is a matter of concern that the large-scale buildup has occurred and continues to be in place, and to sustain that kind of a buildup, there has been an equal amount of infrastructure development on the Chinese side,” General M M Naravane said on Saturday.
“So, it means that they (China) are there to stay. We are keeping a close watch on all these developments, but if they are there to stay, we are there to stay, too,” he said.
The Chinese statement from Senior Colonel Long Shaohua of the Western Theater Command said “China’s determination to safeguard its sovereignty is unwavering, and China hopes India will not misjudge the situation”.
Temperatures in the forward areas in Ladakh drop to -30 Celsius (-22 Fahrenheit) around January. Troops from both sides used to retreat to their traditional summer holding positions but they have remained in place near the disputed border since the faceoff started in May 2020.
Last year, 20 Indian troops were killed in a clash with Chinese soldiers involving clubs, stones and fists along the disputed border. China said it lost four soldiers.
The LAC separates the Himalayan territories from Ladakh in the west to India’s eastern state of Arunachal Pradesh, which China claims in its entirety. India and China, whose frontier runs for 3,500km (2,200 miles), fought a deadly war over the border in 1962.
Since the standoff began last year, the Chinese have been building build dozens of large weather-proof structures along the LAC in eastern Ladakh for their troops to stay in during the winter. New helipads, widening of airstrips, new barracks, new surface-to-air missile sites and radar locations have also been reported by Indian media.
In­dia tells Chi­na bor­der troop pull­back need­ed for bet­ter ties
In­dia’s FM says re­la­tions will only de­vel­op when both coun­tries pull their troops back from dis­put­ed Hi­malayan bor­der.
17 Sep 2021
In­dia to Chi­na: ‘Uni­lat­er­al change of sta­tus quo not ac­cept­able’
In­dia, Chi­na agreed to ‘seek a mu­tu­al­ly ac­cept­able so­lu­tion’ to the bor­der prob­lem af­ter meet­ing of for­eign min­is­ters.
14 Jul 2021
In­dia’s Modi greets Dalai Lama on birth­day in rare phone call
In­di­an lead­ers have gen­er­al­ly been cir­cum­spect about pub­lic con­tact with Ti­betan leader to avoid up­set­ting Chi­na.
6 Jul 2021
Ladakh Bud­dhists who hailed In­dia’s Kash­mir move not so sure now
A year af­ter In­dia scrapped Kash­mir’s spe­cial sta­tus, anger and ap­pre­hen­sions in Ladakh over their fu­ture.
14 Oct 2020
Ukraine faces enormous military odds against Russia
Brent oil hits $91 a barrel as Ukraine worries persist
Tata regains Air India control after years of taxpayer bailouts
Ukraine crisis: From Belarus to Japan, where do countries stand?
A simple guide to the Ukraine-Russia crisis: 5 things to know
Soldier opens fire, kills five guards at Ukraine military plant
Ukraine backs US response to Russia’s security demands
Elon Musk space rocket on collision course with the Moon
Follow Al Jazeera English:
© 2022 Al Jazeera Media Network
You rely on Al Jazeera for truth and transparency
We understand that your online privacy is very important and consenting to our collection of some personal information takes great trust. We ask for this consent because it allows Al Jazeera to provide an experience that truly gives a voice to the voiceless. You have the option to decline the cookies we automatically place on your browser but allowing Al Jazeera and our trusted partners to use cookies or similar technologies helps us improve our content and offerings to you. You can change your privacy preferences at any time by selecting ‘Cookie preferences’ at the bottom of your screen.To learn more, please view our Cookie Policy.