Cookies on the BBC websiteWe use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies on the BBC website. However, if you would like to, you can change your cookie settings at any time.
Find out more
This page has been archived and is no longer updated.
Find out more about page archiving.
Is India sliding into a hereditary monarchy?
Soutik Biswas | 09:18 UK time, Tuesday, 18 January 2011

Is India sliding into a pseudo monarchy of sorts? In his splendid new book, India: A Portrait, historian Patrick French dredges up some startling data on the stranglehold of family and lineage on Indian politics.

The research finds that though less than a third of India's parliamentarians had a hereditary connection, things get worse with the younger MPs. Consider this:
Every MP in the Lok Sabha or the lower house of the Indian parliament under the age of 30 had inherited a seat.
More than two thirds of the 66 MPs aged 40 or under are hereditary MPs.
Every Congress MP under the age of 35 was a hereditary MP.
Nearly 40% of the 66 ministers who are members of the Lok Sabha were hereditary members.
Nearly 70% of the women MPs have family connections.
Interestingly, for MPs over 50, the proportion with a father or relative in politics was a rather modest 17.9%. But when you looked at those aged 50 or under, this increased by more than two and a half times to nearly half, or 47.2%.
Also most of the younger hereditary MPs - and ministers - have not made a mark and sometimes have been shockingly conservative in their actions. A young MP from feudal Haryana, for example, was seen to be cosying up to extra-constitutional village councils in the state which were punishing couples for marrying outside their caste and clan.

"If the trend continued," concludes French, "it was possible that most members of the Indian Parliament would be there by heredity alone, and the nation would be back to where it had started before the freedom struggle, with rule by a hereditary monarch and assorted Indian princelings." He also worries the next Lok Sabha will be a "house of dynasts".
Most agree that growing nepotistic and lineage-based power in the world's largest democracy is a matter of concern. "The idea of India," political scientist Mahesh Rangarajan told me, "is rent apart by these two contradictory impulses."
But nepotism is a part of India life; and politics mirrors society. Power, wealth, land and status have hinged to a large extent on who your parents were, what they owned and where they stood in society. Most Indian businesses continue to be owned and run by families though the new economy is throwing up more first generation entrepreneurs. Bollywood, India's thriving film industry, is dominated by sons and daughters of famous actors and producers. Three members of one family - Nehru-Gandhi - have held the post of prime minister. If the Congress party wins the next elections and PM Manmohan Singh steps down, there is a likelihood of the dynast Rahul Gandhi becoming India's next prime minister. (It is no surprise that 37% of the MPs - 78 of 208 - in Congress are hereditary compared to only 19% hereditary MPs - 22 of the 116 - in the main opposition BJP.)
Despite French's troubling data, all may not be lost. "Please remember," Dr Rangarajan told me, "the MPs have lineage as a huge plus, but the posts are not hereditary." In other words, if they fail to deliver, they will be voted out of power. Merit triumphed over dynasty in the recent elections in dirt-poor Bihar. So though lineage remains a key factor in politics, remind analysts, it can only give a headstart, and nothing more. Thank democracy for that.
Bookmark with: | Digg | Reddit - What's this?
Sign in
or register to comment.
Jump to more content from this blog
About this blog
I'm Soutik Biswas and I’m the online correspondent for BBC News in India. This blog is my take on life and times in the world’s largest democracy.
For the latest updates across BBC blogs,
visit the Blogs homepage.
Subscribe to Soutik Biswas's India
You can stay up to date with Soutik Biswas's India via these feeds.
Soutik Biswas's India Feed(RSS)
Soutik Biswas's India Feed(ATOM)
If you aren't sure what RSS is you'll find our beginner's guide to RSS useful.
Latest from BBC News blogs
Nick Robinson:
"Britain is standing by to give more money to the IMF so that it can, in turn, lend more money..."
Douglas Fraser:
"With a mighty thud, the Ledger has been slammed shut. Thanks for reading it. But it's not finished - far..."
Brian Taylor:
"Thank you for reading my blog. It has now moved to a new home, with a fresh format. Visit my..."
Betsan Powys:
"It was an inspired conversation. What shall we call a blog written by someone called Betsan? How about ... Betsan's..."
Richard Black:
"Thanks for having read my blog over the last few years. As of today, it is moving to a new..."
Jonathan Amos:
"Things are changing. The BBC's Spaceman has been assigned a new ship for his thoughts. So, as of today, this..."
Our blog about issues in News
Our blog about issues in Sport
Our blog about photos and News
Our freedom-of-information blog
BBC Internet Blog
Radio 4 Blog and 5 Live Blog
Magazine Monitor and See Also
More from this blog...
Topical posts on this blog
Past twelve months
May 2011 (1)
April 2011 (5)
March 2011 (6)
February 2011 (2)
January 2011 (3)
December 2010 (3)
November 2010 (5)
October 2010 (6)
September 2010 (6)
August 2010 (2)
July 2010 (5)
June 2010 (4)
complete archive
Northern Ireland
Full A-Z
Mobile site Terms of Use About the BBC
Privacy Accessibility Help
Cookies Contact the BBC
Parental Guidance
BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.
« PreviousMainNext »