Gaddafi death: The bloody birth of a new Libya
By Jeremy Bowen
BBC Middle East editor, Tripoli
22 October 2011
Gaddafi was captured alive and dragged along the ground in Sirte
The death of Muammar Gaddafi has removed a big problem for this country's transition rulers. It has also imbued the new Libya with original sin it may regret.
The leaders of the National Transitional Council (NTC) during the months of the fight against the colonel often spoke about building a country based on rights, not revenge.
But the iconic image of their moment of national liberation is of Col Gaddafi, a man who spilled oceans of other peoples' blood, not accounting for his crimes in a court, but being set upon by fighters who killed him.
One man here in Tripoli told me he thought Col Gaddafi should have been spared to make him face justice. But everyone else I have spoken to is just pleased he is dead, and they do not care how it happened.
But if the new Libya is going to be a country of rights, then it has some questions to answer.
The most pressing are about what appears to have been the summary executions of Col Gaddafi and his son Mutassim.
But black Africans have also been rounded up as alleged mercenaries, on little or no evidence, without being given access to a lawyer.
I saw several dozen of them today being driven through Tripoli, hands bound, blindfolded with cloths of Gaddafi green, in the back of trucks with welded-on anti-aircraft cannon and heavy machine guns.
Body quandary
Col Gaddafi was a cruel dictator who ordered appalling acts of murder. He built a system that ran on fear and brutality.
He deserved to face punishment. The one he received was summary justice - of the kind that his own henchmen had meted out for years.
States that have been through deep and violent change tend to do best later on if there is a process of national reconciliation. Old enemies need to learn how to work together.
Maybe dispatching Col Gaddafi and his son will make that easier - or it might make the NTC's promises of fairness and forgiveness harder to believe.
Right or wrong, killing him quickly solved a problem for the National Transitional Council. The arguments about what to do with the body and where to bury it have been difficult enough.
If he had lived, there would have been months of rows about his crimes, his trial and his punishment.
And there would have been the nagging fear that Col Gaddafi's existence, and his first public and no doubt defiant appearance in court, would be a focus for the old regime's loyalists, who are now quietly keeping their heads down.
Libyans have been celebrating without expressing qualms about the manner of Gaddafi's death
Head down
And the death of the colonel has changed the atmosphere in the capital. To get an idea of how profoundly, take a walk through Martyrs' Square in the old part of Tripoli. It was called Green Square in the Gaddafi years.
During the time in the spring and summer that Nato was bombing Libya, the square was the centre of the Gaddafi cult.
Most afternoons and evenings there were demonstrations, all with the same simple message - against Nato, and glorifying the colonel.
The rallies were not comfortable places to be. The crowd would work themselves up to a pitch of anger. On Fridays especially, thousands of bullets would get fired into the sky.
Ask someone a question and you would be surrounded by a jostling, yelling mass of people competing to condemn the West and express their love for Muammar Gaddafi.
As soon as the regime fell at the end of August, it started to change. The faces were different.
I had started recognising the noisiest regulars in the Gaddafi rallies. The new ones in what was soon renamed Martyr's Square often said they had not been to the Square for years.
As in all police states, the best thing to do was to keep your head down so as not to get noticed.
Weight lifted
Some things do not change. Libyans are never going to be quiet when they get into a crowd.
People celebrating the death of the Gaddafis, just like his supporters, enjoy driving overloaded cars around the city at speed, as they hang out of the windows and chant slogans.
And Libyan still have an alarming love of expressing their emotions by firing into the air, though I notice they aim the heavy guns out to sea now instead of straight up.
But I have never seen Tripoli so relaxed, which should not be surprising. A heavy weight has been lifted. While Col Gaddafi lived, many Libyans could not quite lose the fear that he might come back.
But now they have seen his body. Crowds in Misrata have even lined to view it and snap it where it lies in a cold store.
Tunisians and Egyptian revolutionaries have a growing fear that they got rid of the man at the top, while important parts of the old regime stay intact and powerful.
Libyans do not need to have that fear. Col Gaddafi's Libya has been smashed. It is, really, a new beginning.
That is why they need to get the fundamentals right from the very start.
Top Stories
US sends reinforcements for Afghan withdrawal
Joe Biden has set the withdrawal deadline for 11 September, but it comes amid escalating violence.
6 hours ago
Concern increases over India Covid variant in UK
5 hours ago
Tightrope walkers and orchestra in Colombia protests
13 hours ago
Features
Inside Myanmar's Spring Revolution
Covid: Indians abroad 'helpless and heartbroken'
Eurovision welcomes back fans despite pandemic
Why are vaccines going unused in Africa?
Quiz of the week: What's Meghan's children's book called?
Taking an invention from idea to the marketplace
The judo class that put a seven-year-old in a coma
BBC Culture: TV shows that reveal the real France
Who is young Republican rising star Elise Stefanik?
Elsewhere on the BBC
Football phrases
15 sayings from around the world
Most Read
Child shoots three at school in Idaho, police say1
Concern increases over India Covid variant in UK2
Twitter suspends account sharing Trump posts3
China emissions top all developed nations combined4
IBM claims next-gen chip breakthrough
5
Holiday costs to jump in summer, warns travel boss6
Chinese rocket debris could crash back onto Earth7
The judo class that put a seven-year-old in a coma8
US sends reinforcements for Afghan withdrawal9
Rio de Janeiro drugs raid shoot-out leaves 25 dead10
BBC News Services
On your mobile
On smart speakers
Get news alerts
Contact BBC News
Home
News
Sport
Reel
Worklife
Travel
Future
Culture
Music
TV
Weather
Sounds
Terms of Use
About the BBC
Privacy Policy
Cookies
Accessibility Help
Parental Guidance
Contact the BBC
Get Personalised Newsletters
Why you can trust the BBC
Advertise with us
AdChoices / Do Not Sell My Info
© 2021 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.
BBC HomepageSkip to contentAccessibility HelpSign inHomeNewsSportReelWorklifeTravelFutureCultureMenuSearchHomeNewsSportReelWorklifeTravelFutureCultureMusicTVWeatherSounds
MenuHomeCoronavirusVideoWorldUS & CanadaUKBusinessTechScienceStoriesEntertainment & ArtsMoreHealthIn PicturesReality CheckWorld News TVNewsbeatLong ReadsWorldAfricaAsiaAustraliaEuropeLatin AmericaMiddle East