Saif al-Islam will not get fair trial in Libya, says lawyer
6 July 2012
Lawyer Melinda Taylor says an impartial trial for Saif al-Islam in Libya is ''impossible''
The son of Muammar Gaddafi will not get a fair trial in Libya, an International Criminal Court lawyer who was detained in Libya has said.
Melinda Taylor made the comments days after she was released from detention after meeting Saif al-Islam in the town of Zintan.
She said it was impossible for the 40-year-old to be tried in an "independent and impartial manner" in Libya.
Saif al-Islam Gaddafi has been indicted by the ICC for crimes against humanity.
But Libyan authorities have insisted that he should be tried at home rather than in The Hague.
Ms Taylor was freed on Monday after being held for more than three weeks in Libya on suspicion of spying, along with three colleagues. The ICC has promised to investigate the Libyan claims.
'Irrevocably prejudiced'
Speaking at a news conference on Friday, Ms Taylor said that her actions in Libya were "consistent with my legal obligations" under ICC rules.
"Irrespective of any issues concerning my own personal conduct, the rights of my client, Mr Saif al-Islam, were irrevocably prejudiced during my visit," she said.
She said recent events had "completely underscored that it will be impossible for Mr Gaddafi to be tried in an independent and impartial manner in Libyan courts".
She added that Libyan officials had "deliberately misled the defence concerning whether the visit with Mr Gaddafi would be monitored", and also seized confidential documents.
Ms Taylor said she would submit a report later this week. ICC spokesman Fadi el-Abdallah said it had no comment to make on Ms Taylor's remarks, but said judges would consider the findings as they deliberate Libya's application to prosecute him.
Saif al-Islam, who was once expected to suceed his father, was arrested in November, three months after anti-government forces overran the capital, Tripoli.
ICC apology
Both the ICC and Libya want to put Saif al-Islam Gaddafi on trial for crimes under the former regime
Ms Taylor, an Australian, had been part of a team sent to prepare Saif al-Islam's defence when she was accused of passing Saif al-Islam coded documents, allegedly written by his former right-hand man.
She and her interpreter from Lebanon, Helen Assaf, were then formally detained by militia in Zintan on suspicion of endangering national security.
Their two other colleagues, Russian Alexander Khodakov and Spaniard Esteban Peralta Losilla, remained with them out of solidarity.
The announcement of their release was made during a visit to Libya last week by ICC president Sang-Hyun Song, who also offered an apology for any "difficulties" caused by the mission.
The ICC has also told Libya it will investigate the claims of wrongdoing.
Ms Taylor's team are also scheduled to appear before a court in Tripoli on 23 July for a final ruling on their case, a senior member of the Libyan attorney-general's office told the BBC.
Related Internet Links
International Criminal Court
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
Top Stories
US sends reinforcements for Afghan withdrawal
Joe Biden has set the withdrawal deadline for 11 September, but it comes amid escalating violence.
5 hours ago
Concern increases over India Covid variant in UK
5 hours ago
Tightrope walkers and orchestra in Colombia protests
12 hours ago
Features
Inside Myanmar's Spring Revolution
Covid: Indians abroad 'helpless and heartbroken'
Eurovision welcomes back fans despite pandemic
Why are vaccines going unused in Africa?
Quiz of the week: What's Meghan's children's book called?
Taking an invention from idea to the marketplace
The judo class that put a seven-year-old in a coma
BBC Culture: TV shows that reveal the real France
Who is young Republican rising star Elise Stefanik?
Elsewhere on the BBC
Football phrases
15 sayings from around the world
Most Read
Child shoots three at school in Idaho, police say1
Concern increases over India Covid variant in UK2
IBM claims next-gen chip breakthrough
3
Twitter suspends account sharing Trump posts4
US sends reinforcements for Afghan withdrawal5
Thousands enter lottery to kill Grand Canyon bison6
Rio de Janeiro drugs raid shoot-out leaves 25 dead7
Holiday costs to jump in summer, warns travel boss8
The judo class that put a seven-year-old in a coma9
Britain awaits results of bumper election day10
BBC News Services
On your mobile
On smart speakers
Get news alerts
Contact BBC News
Home
News
Sport
Reel
Worklife
Travel
Future
Culture
Music
TV
Weather
Sounds
Terms of Use
About the BBC
Privacy Policy
Cookies
Accessibility Help
Parental Guidance
Contact the BBC
Get Personalised Newsletters
Why you can trust the BBC
Advertise with us
AdChoices / Do Not Sell My Info
© 2021 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.
BBC HomepageSkip to contentAccessibility HelpSign inHomeNewsSportReelWorklifeTravelFutureCultureMenuSearchHomeNewsSportReelWorklifeTravelFutureCultureMusicTVWeatherSounds
MenuHomeCoronavirusVideoWorldUS & CanadaUKBusinessTechScienceStoriesEntertainment & ArtsMoreHealthIn PicturesReality CheckWorld News TVNewsbeatLong ReadsWorldAfricaAsiaAustraliaEuropeLatin AmericaMiddle East