Diese Webseite verwendet Cookies
Damit wollen wir unsere Webseiten benutzerfreundlicher gestalten und zum Nutzen unserer Besucher*innen stetig verbessern. Wenn Sie die Webseiten weiter besuchen, stimmen Sie dadurch der Verwendung von Cookies zu.
Wir verwenden Cookies, um die Zugriffe auf unsere Website zu analysieren. Außerdem geben wir Informationen zu Ihrer Verwendung unserer Website an unsere Partner für Analysen weiter. Unsere Partner führen diese Informationen möglicherweise mit weiteren Daten zusammen, die Sie ihnen bereitgestellt haben oder die sie im Rahmen Ihrer Nutzung der Dienste gesammelt haben. Sie geben Einwilligung zu unseren Cookies, wenn Sie unsere Webseite weiterhin nutzen.
Mehr Infos
Notwendig
Statistiken
Marketing
Auswahl bestätigenAlle Cookies zulassen
Home » Publikationen » Die aktuelle Kolumne
THE DECLARATION OF PRINCIPLES ON ETHIOPIA’S RENAISSANCE DAM: A BREAKTHROUGH OR ANOTHER UNFAIR DEAL?
Download PDF 115 KB
Tawfik, Rawia
Die aktuelle Kolumne (2015)

German Development Institute / Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE) (The Current Column of 25 March 2015)
Bonn, 25 March 2015. The Declaration of Principles on the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) signed by the three Eastern Nile countries (Egypt, Ethiopia and Sudan) on 23 March 2015 in Khartoum has sparked much controversy among experts and commentators in Egypt. Some consider it a breakthrough between Egypt and Ethiopia after four years of tensions. Others opine that Egypt is bound to lose from this declaration, because it does not include a clear reference to Egypt’s historical rights in the Nile waters and does not ensure any reduction of the huge storage capacity of the GERD. The declaration is a positive step towards reaching a compromise on the largest dam project in an upstream Nile country. However, only the translation of this declaration into balanced technical agreements can build the missing trust between Egypt and Ethiopia and pave the way for sharing the dam’s benefits and reducing its potential negative impacts on downstream countries.
A realistic compromise on a complex dilemma
The Declaration cannot be evaluated without taking into account the current political context and the historical relations in the Nile basin. During the last decade the balance of power in the Nile basin has been changing in favor of Ethiopia. After decades of Egyptian domination, Ethiopia has managed to combine the hydrological advantage of its position as an upstream country that controls 86 % of the Nile waters and the economic advantage of sustained economic growth. This comes at a time when Egypt, which depends on the Nile for more than 90 % of its water needs, is struggling to sustain its economy after four years of instability. Trapped by its domestic political instability and economic challenges, Egypt was forced to accept the GERD as a fact on the ground. Although the International Panel of Experts that examined the dam recommended conducting more comprehensive studies on the impact of the project on downstream countries, Ethiopia has rejected freezing the construction of the dam until these studies are finalized. Historical mistrust and threats of using force by both sides have raised tensions and brought a halt to technical negotiations.
In this context, the Declaration is a realistic compromise on a complex historical dilemma and a true reflection of the current balance of power. On its positive side, the declaration states that the three countries will cooperate to implement the recommendations of the International Panel of Experts, and to reach an agreement on the guidelines of filling and operating the dam. It sets a timeframe of 15 fifteen months from the start of preparing the required studies on the dam for the conclusion of this agreement. Ethiopia is committed, according to the declaration, to take the necessary steps to avoid causing a significant harm to Egypt and Sudan, to mitigate this harm in case it happens, and to discuss compensation “whenever convenient”. However, the Declaration includes no reference to historical agreements or to Egypt’s acquired share in the Nile waters. Furthermore, it did not commit Ethiopia to reconsider the size of the dam and the 74  billion cubic meters storage capacity of the reservoir, a size that several experts considered as technically unnecessary and economically irrational.
What next
Much effort and good will is needed to build trust between the three Eastern Nile countries, in particular between Egypt and Ethiopia. The implementation of the recommendations of the international consultancy firm, which will conduct the required studies on the dam, and the resulting technical agreements that will be reached in light of the Declaration will be a necessary step in this direction. Any financial support for the project by international donors and organizations should remain conditional on this implementation. Only these technical agreements and the political will to implement them will determine if the GERD will provide a new example of win-win projects on shared rivers or a quest for development in one riparian state at the expense of others.

Rawia Tawfik is currently Guest Researcher at the German Development Institut / Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE) and Lecturer at Cairo University.
Über die Autorin
Tawfik, Rawia
Politikwissenschaftlerin
Weitere Expert*innen zu diesem Thema
Dombrowsky, Ines
Ökonomin 
Herrfahrdt-Pähle, Elke
Volkswirtin 
Hornidge, Anna-Katharina
Entwicklungs- und Wissenssoziologin 
Schoderer, Mirja
Umweltwissenschaftlerin 
Subramanian, Saravanan
Geographie 
AKTUELLE PUBLIKATIONEN
Warum die deutsche Wasserstoffstrategie eine multilaterale Ergänzung braucht
Stamm, Andreas / Rita Strohmaier / Tilman Altenburg / Huri Ece Oyan / Katharina Thoms
Die aktuelle Kolumne, 22.09.2021
Refugees and local power dynamics: the case of Gambella Region of Ethiopia
Hagos, Samuel Zewdie
Discussion Paper 25/2021
Europa sollte die Zusammenarbeit mit dem Nahen Osten und Nordafrika stärker auf die Gesellschaftsverträge fokussieren
Furness, Mark / Markus Loewe
Analysen und Stellungnahmen 7/2021
Regional integrated assessment of climate change impacts on the rainfed farming system in Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh, India
Nedumaran, Swamikannu / Dakshina Murthy Kadiyala / Jyosthnaa Padmanabhan / Roberto O. Valdivia / Sonali McDermid / Srinivasa Reddy Srigiri / Geethalakshm, Vellingiri / Anthony Whitbread
Externe Publikationen, 21.09.2021
The transformative capacity of transnational and transdisciplinary networks and the potential of alumni work
Vogel, Johanna
Discussion Paper 24/2021
Social protection: a powerful tool – but not in the Middle East and North Africa
Loewe, Markus
Externe Publikationen, 20.09.2021
Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE)
Tulpenfeld 6
D-53113 Bonn
Telefon +49(0)22894927-0
Fax +49(0)22894927-130
DIE@die-gdi.de
Copyright © 2021 Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE), Bonn
Sitemap
Barrierefreiheit
Datenschutz
Impressum
Deutsches Institut für EntwicklungspolitikLeichte SpracheStellen & PraktikaKontaktNewsletterDas DIE bei TwitterDas DIE auf FacebookDas DIE auf YouTubeDas DIE bei LinkedInDer DIE RSS-FeedDas DIE bei FlickrDer DIE BlogSustainable Global Supply Chains PodcastDeutschEnglisch
ForschungForschendes DirektoriumInter- und transnationale ZusammenarbeitTransformation der Wirtschafts- und SozialsystemeUmwelt-GovernanceForschungsprogramm "Transformation politischer (Un-)Ordnung"QuerschnittsvorhabenRegionalexpertiseBeratungAusbildungPostgraduierten-ProgrammMGG AcademyAfrican-German Leadership AcademyPromovierenBerufsausbildungTeamBibliothekJahrbücherPublikationenDie aktuelle KolumneZweiseiterTwo PagerAnalysen und StellungnahmenBriefing PaperDiscussion PaperStudiesAufsätze und sonstige PublikationenBuchveröffentlichungenBlogOnline-DatenvisualisierungenVeranstaltungenPressePressekontakteDIE in den MedienNewsletter abonnierenInfo-Mailings abonnierenPressemitteilungenÜber das DIEMission StatementOrganigrammOrgane und GremienQualitätssicherungKorruptionspräventionBeruf und FamilieStellen & PraktikaKontakt & AnfahrtBarrierefreiheit