Jun 16, 2009,12:01am EDT
Don't Let My Brother's Death Be In Vain
This article is more than 10 years old.
More From Forbes
On May 21, 2009, my brother Fathi Eljahmi, Libya’s most prominent dissident, died. He had been imprisoned since March 26, 2004, just two weeks after President George W. Bush cited his release as a sign that Libya had changed. Ironically, this was a time when Libya presided over the U.N. Human Rights Commission.
Until his last two weeks, when, already comatose, he was flown to Jordan, Fathi spent most of his last five years in solitary confinement in a Libyan prison, where he experienced torture and abuse. As his condition deteriorated, Libya denied him regular medical care. There was seldom international pressure to do otherwise.
Bush paid lip service to Fathi’s case, but administration officials seldom followed up on the president’s promises. The State Department conveyed concern about Fathi’s case, but Assistant Secretary of State David Welch, who has since retired, often delegated the issue to junior officials. (Ironically, as an official at Bechtel Corporation, Welch now pursues business contracts in Libya.)
When Secretary of State Hillary Clinton welcomed Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi’s son to Foggy Bottom on April 21, 2009, she too did not raise Fathi’s case directly, but rather left the task to an aide. Had Clinton forcefully and personally raised the issue, Fathi might be alive today.
It’s not just politicians who should reflect on how they handled Fathi’s case. My brother’s death should give prominent human rights organizations pause. For nearly a year, both Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch hesitated to advocate publicly for Fathi’s case, because they feared their case workers might lose access to Libyan visas.
Only on the day of Fathi’s death did Human Rights Watch issue a press release that announced what we had known for two months: That Fathi appeared frail and emaciated, could barely speak and could not lift his arms or head. When the researchers asked him on April 25 and 26 if he was free to leave prison, he said no. When they asked him if he wanted to go home, he said yes.
Perhaps because they still fear antagonizing Gaddafi, in their May 21 statement Human Rights Watch didn’t call for an independent investigation and stopped short of holding the Libyan regime responsible for Fathi’s death.
Amnesty International also compromised. They moved an April 2009 demonstration originally slated to occur in front of Libya’s U.N. mission to the U.S. mission instead so as not to antagonize Gaddafi. For the same reason, they ignored pleas for a public statement about Fathi’s deterioration. While an Amnesty delegation was in Libya when Fathi died, the Libyan regime refused it permission to travel to Libya’s second largest city.
After learning of Fathi’s death, Amnesty declined to condemn Libya’s role and instead simply requested that Gaddafi’s regime inform the family of the conditions that led to his death. It is unfortunate that other than the American Islamic Congress no Muslim or Arab organization ever advocated for Fathi, even as he dedicated his own life to advancing human rights for Arabs and Muslims in one of the region’s most oppressive states.
Experience has shown me that country researchers in marquee human rights organizations are vulnerable to the regime’s manipulation. Sarah Leah Whitson is one of the Human Rights Watch researchers who last saw Fathi before he was rushed to Jordan. She wrote an article for Foreign Policy upon her return from Libya, where she described efforts by the Gaddafi Foundation for International Charities and Development, which is headed by the Libyan leader’s son, Saif al-Islam, as a “spring.” The organization is actively menacing my brother’s family. Some family members continue to endure interrogation, denial of citizenship papers and passports, round the clock surveillance and threats of rape and physical liquidation.
Not all organizations compromised their principles. Physicians for Human Rights didn’t compromise with the Gaddafi regime and called for an independent medical investigation after Fathi’s death. One day, when free media penetrates Libya, my brother’s friends and admirers will learn how the American Jewish Committee sought to rally world leaders to Fathi’s cause.
It is important that Fathi not die in vain. President Barack Obama, congressional leaders and the human rights community should demand an independent medical investigation of Fathi’s death. They must hold Gaddafi accountable. For the State Department and the marquee human rights organizations, his death may simply be an inconvenience removed, but this attitude is shortsighted. Should Gaddafi conclude that Fathi’s death passed with little more than a press release, any reform efforts will backslide, as his government concludes that it can liquidate opponents with impunity.
Mohamed Eljahmi is a Libyan/American activist based in Massachusetts.
Reprints & Permissions

© 2021 Forbes Media LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Statement
Do Not Sell My Info
Terms and Conditions
Contact Us
Report a Security Issue
Jobs At Forbes
Reprints & Permissions
Forbes Press Room
BillionairesAll BillionairesWorld's Billionaires Forbes 400 America's Richest Self-Made Women China's Richest India's Richest Indonesia's Richest Korea's Richest Thailand's Richest Japan's Richest Australia's Richest Taiwan's Richest Singapore's Richest Philippines' Richest Hong Kong's Richest Malaysia's Richest Money & Politics 2020 Money InnovationAll Innovation5G AI Big Data Cloud Cloud 100 Cognizant BrandVoice | Paid ProgramConsumer Tech Cybersecurity Enterprise Tech Future Of Work Games Health Innovation Rules Jumio BrandVoice | Paid ProgramSAP BrandVoice | Paid ProgramScience ServiceNow BrandVoice | Paid ProgramSocial Media SurveyMonkey BrandVoice | Paid ProgramSustainability T-Mobile for Business BrandVoice | Paid ProgramVenture Capital Wind River BrandVoice | Paid ProgramLeadershipAll LeadershipCareers CEO Network CFO Network CIO Network CMO Network CxO Deloitte BrandVoice | Paid ProgramDiversity, Equity & Inclusion Education Forbes EQ | Paid ProgramForbes The Culture ForbesWomen Google Cloud BrandVoice | Paid ProgramLeadership Strategy Splunk BrandVoice | Paid ProgramUnder 30 Working Remote Over 50 MoneyAll MoneyBanking & Insurance Crypto & Blockchain ETFs & Mutual Funds Fintech Hedge Funds & Private Equity Investing Markets Personal Finance Premium Investing Newsletters Retirement Taxes Top Advisor | SHOOK Wealth Management Election 2020 BusinessAll BusinessAerospace & Defense Alteryx BrandVoice | Paid ProgramEnergy Food & Drink Hollywood & Entertainment Honeywell BrandVoice | Paid ProgramManufacturing Media Policy Retail Ryder BrandVoice | Paid ProgramSportsMoney Tableau BrandVoice | Paid ProgramTransportation Small BusinessAll Small BusinessEntrepreneurs Franchises Office Depot OfficeMax BrandVoice | Paid ProgramSmall Business Strategy Square BrandVoice | Paid ProgramLifestyleAll LifestyleArts Boats & Planes Cars & Bikes Dining ForbesLife Forbes Travel Guide Spirits Style & Beauty Travel Vices Watches Real EstateAll Real EstateCommercial Real Estate Forbes Global Properties Residential Real Estate ShoppingAll ShoppingGear Health & Wellness Home & Kitchen Style Tech & Electronics CouponsAll CouponsPurple Squarespace Verizon Lululemon AT&T Lowe's Brooks Brothers Tory Burch Dr Martens Dell Chewy AdvisorAll AdvisorLife Insurance Best Life Insurance Companies Best Term Life Insurance The Best Credit Cards Of 2021 Best Balance Transfer Credit Cards Best Cash Back Credit Cards Best 0% APR Credit Cards Best Travel Credit Cards Best Business Credit Cards Best Travel Insurance Companies Pandemic Travel Insurance Best Car Insurance Companies Best Pet Insurance Best Personal Loans Best Student Loans Best Student Loan Refinance Best Tax Software For 2021 Best Project Management Software Forbes Advisor UK WheelsAll WheelsBest Sedans Best Luxury SUVs Best SUVs Best Pickups Best Performance Cars Best Family-Friendly Sedans Best SUVs & Crossovers Best Electric Cars Best Sports Cars ListsAll ListsVideoAll VideoCrypto Confidential Editorial Newsletters Investing Digest Premium Investing Newsletters Forbes MagazineAll Forbes MagazineForbes Asia Free Issue of Forbes Coronavirus Coverage Daily Cover Stories Dark Capital Editors' Picks Election 2020 Visual Web Stories 30 Under 30 2021 All Hands On Data - A Tableau Series | Paid ProgramAmerica's Top Women Wealth Advisors Atlassian BrandVoice | Paid ProgramCapital One BrandVoice | Paid ProgramChangemakers In Action Data Sharing In The Covid Era | Paid ProgramDNA Of Success Emotional EQuity | Paid ProgramForbes Insights with Capital One | Paid ProgramForbes Next 1000 2021 Hitachi ABB Power Grids BrandVoice | Paid ProgramOffice Depot OfficeMax BrandVoice | Paid ProgramSAP Concur BrandVoice | Paid ProgramSchneider Electric BrandVoice | Paid ProgramServiceNow BrandVoice | Paid ProgramSquare BrandVoice | Paid ProgramThe Leukemia & Lymphoma Society BrandVoice | Paid ProgramThe Next Step | Small Business Video Series World's Billionaires List Advertise with ForbesReport a Security IssueSite FeedbackContact UsCareers at ForbesTipsCorrectionsPrivacyDo Not Sell My InfoTermsAdChoicesReprints & PermissionsSubscribe